Truthout Original

Facebook DIGG

The Invisible Injuries of the Invisible Ranks

by: Carissa S. Picard, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Carissa S. Picard stands at the entrance to Fort Hood, Texas. Picard is the founder and president of Military Spouses for Change. (Photo: Erich Schlegel / Dallas Morning News)

    Expectations

    I never expected it to be so damn windy in Texas. I expected it to be still, dry and hot - something like Arizona, maybe. Of course, nothing is really what I expected it to be when I married Caynan.

    I never expected to feel so lonely, so isolated, so out-of-place and out of sorts all the time, always in that in-between place of neither here nor there, neither this nor that. As an Army wife (excuse me, as six percent are male, Army "spouse"), you are no longer a civilian, but you are not a soldier either.

    I don't know what military life was like before 9/11, but I can tell you what it is like now: and it isn't quirky and wacky and "just like civilian life but different." There is a reason Sarah Smiley (a female Dave Barry) is a Navy wife and Jenny (the cartoon) is an airman's wife: Army and Marine wives have less to laugh about.

    In March 2008, The Associated Press reported that 72 percent of Iraq deaths were Army, 24 percent were Marine, two percent were Navy and one percent was Air Force. These percentages obviously reflect who is being deployed the most; i.e., who is being exposed to combat and who isn't. However, there is not a huge difference in the overall size of each individual branch; e.g., the Army has a little more than 500,000 active duty soldiers, the Marines have nearly 195,000 troops, and the Navy and the Air Force each have approximately 330,000 service members.

    Consequently, there is a disproportionate burden for this "global war on terror" being placed upon the Army and the Marines. Not to mention the repeated 12- to 15-month tours with no guaranteed dwell time for soldiers, whereas rumor has it (as well as news reports) that Marines at least serve six- to seven-month tours at a time.

    Casualties of War

    My ex-husband called me the other day and asked me what a "Blue Star wife" was. I explained that it was a wife whose husband was serving in combat.

    Then I asked him if he knew what a Gold Star wife was. Of course he didn't.

    "That's a wife whose husband has died in combat."

    "Wow," he replied, "that's, uh, kind of sick, isn't it?"

    I laughed. I knew what he meant. The "Gold Star" comes across as a quasi-cultural "WAY TO GO!" for the surviving family member (as the term technically applies to the entire family). And let us not forget the "Silver Star" for the family of a service member wounded in a war!

    There is no star for a lifetime of sacrificing one's own career and/or educational aspirations to support a service member. In times of peace, as well as war, the military demands that family comes second to the military. ("Army needs come first!") The household moves are frequent (every two to three years). The inability of the service member-parent to participate in parenting brings tremendous challenges to working in an era where two-income households are the norm for maintaining a decent standard of living. The lack of family, friends and community makes loneliness an expectation, not just a fear.

    What color star should a spouse get for years of living like this?

    These designations are all "unofficial," of course. Everything pertaining to the familial appendages known as the spouse and children of the service member is unofficial.

    As for Army spouses (like myself), we exist in this in-between world. We are no longer civilians, yet we are not "soldiers" either. We are expected to live the military life without being seen, heard, prepared, paid, or recognized for our service. We are called "the silent ranks," but really, we are invisible too. The "new" Army likes to say it "recruits the soldier but retains the family," but the reality of "if the Army wanted you to have a family it would have issued you one" remains.

    We are outsiders living inside an institution that doesn't want to see or hear us. Civilians and lawmakers lack interest in our experiences with the military as well as with the wars - yet our experiences with these are second only to those of the service member. There aren't any star-studded galas for our service and sacrifice or public service announcements and national dialogues about how war affects us (and/or our children).

    Veterans' rights advocates talk to the "signature" wounds of the Afghanistan and Iraq wars, traumatic brain injury (TBI) and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Both are "invisible." Both are hard to diagnose. Both fundamentally alter the service member in ways that are complex and confusing - to the afflicted and the non-afflicted alike.

    Also unseen, however, are the injuries of those who love the service member, whose own changes, traumas and afflictions frequently go unidentified and untreated. We call our returning warriors with invisible injuries the "walking wounded;" I include military spouses and children in that definition.

    Consider the 19-year-old bride who witnessed her husband's suicide on webcam in Iraq. Or the (very young) children who watched their father wrestle their large family dog to the living room floor and break its neck, followed by threats to do the same to them if provoked. Or loving one person for seven years, waiting for him for a year, and being abused by a stranger when he returns.

    You don't have to wear a uniform to be wounded by these wars - but no one outside of those of us impacted seem to know this.

    There are many things that I may not be able to tell you about actual combat, but this much I know is true: by the time this deployment is over, my husband will not be the only veteran in this marriage.

    A Call to Arms

    Nothing prepares you for war. There is no training center for spouses. You are either going to make it or you won't.

    My husband Caynan is a helicopter pilot for the Army. A few nights before he left, we went over all the materials the families were given by the unit in preparation for their departure: the handy flip chart with emergency information about my husband's unit, how to get a Red Cross message to him in case of a family emergency here (as if they would let him leave the combat zone for it anyway), information about communication black outs, who will contact me if something happens to him, etc..

    What really had me in stitches were the leave dates and the return dates - those were hysterical.

    They're Not Waving, They're Drowning

    In June, the parade of terribles begins. News from the front: soldiers being electrocuted in the showers, self-inflicted gunshot wounds, 10-year-old suicide bombers, sexual assaults on female soldiers.

    I am learning not to worry about that which I cannot control (i.e., the life or death of the father of my children), although much of your time will be spent listening and validating the feelings and experiences of others: your soldier-spouse, your warrior-children.

    As for your own feelings, questions, and pain: Who has time for those? Civilian friends don't understand and your army spouse girlfriends run hot and cold' AWOL half the time, coping with their own dramas and lashing out at you as often as you, unfortunately, perhaps, lash out at them. Moreover, since we are NOT soldiers, there are no 24-hour mental health clinics for us on installations, no "rest and resiliency clinics," no pre- or post-deployment mental health assessments for us or our children. Even our pain and our coping are "unofficial."

    Some days I can't decide which is worse, the breaking spirit of your soldier or the breaking hearts of your children. These are invisible injuries that no one has names for, no one tabulates, no one keeps track of ... no one but the mother/spouse/father/sibling/family member who witnesses it and knows that some people will become stronger and some people will simply break.

    For example, when a soldier deploys to combat, those of us at home eventually get "the call."

    The call comes when his (or her) veneer of strength has cracked. When something really bad has happened; when he (or she) has witnessed (or done) something that he/she was not prepared for or expecting to be upset by; when the surreal becomes real and that reality comes crashing down upon them with crushing force.

    Nothing prepares you for this call, and you will usually hang up hurting and feeling totally useless.

    Over the next few months, you will get emails, calls and/or letters, referring to incidents giving you glimpses into a world where "humanity" has been turned on its head consistently and violently. Your soldier will ask a lot of rhetorical questions that will make your heart hurt. All the while your children will be asking a lot of real questions that will make your heart break. You live in fear that you will handle their struggles poorly and long-term emotional or psychological damage will occur and of course, it will be your fault. It is illogical, but it is your fear nonetheless.

    Caynan's call came a few weeks after he left us and two days after he started flying real medevac missions in Iraq. Unfortunately for him, even when combat missions settled down for our troops as we were handing security for large areas of the country over to the Iraqis, our medevac helicopters still go in and pick up injured Iraqis as well as wounded Americans; i.e., there is little reprieve from the carnage.

    The first soldier to die in Caynan's Blackhawk did so with his legs lying on his chest, having been completely blown off by an IED blast to the Bradley he was driving.

    Caynan, in broken sentences, tries his best to tell about "the look, baby, the look when the spirit leaves the body, the body changes, the eyes are different, everything is different, you know before the machines know, he's dead, he's just dead." But that wasn't the worst of that mission. When they landed at the Baghdad CSH and unloaded this dead soldier, the aircraft's rotor wash blew one of his disembodied legs off his chest. A crew chief had to chase the leg as it rolled across the dusty landing zone to return it to this 26-year-old soldier who would never use it again.

    "It's so surreal. You're watching this happening but it's like a movie ... It just doesn't seem real. How is this happening? How am I sitting in this helicopter watching this dead man's leg roll across the tarmac like this? It just doesn't seem real baby. This can't be real ..."

    Silently I listened. Silently I cried. Because it was real and we both knew it.

    The next call came at 4 AM. Caynan sounded like he might actually have been crying. In bits and pieces I got the story, but mainly he repeated, "The screaming, my God, the screaming."

    Apparently, two men were picked up. A US soldier and an Iraqi interpreter were hit by an IED. While they made it to the CSH alive, there was an "ungodly amount" of blood. Caynan "never knew blood could smell like that." But it wasn't the blood that disturbed Caynan; it was the screaming. He said he couldn't get the interpreter's screaming out of his head.

    "I've never heard anything like that before, Carissa. I can't his screams out of my head."

    I had nothing to say. All I could do was remind him that he got them to the CSH alive. But getting them to the CSH alive doesn't erase those screams and I know that. And I worry about him. I wonder how long those screams will haunt him.

    Jennifer told me that Stephen called her once, just once, when he was in charge of viewing all the Apache videos when we lent air support on a ground attack in 2008, and all he could say to her, over and over, was "you're my normal. You and the kids, you're my normal. THIS, THIS IS NOT NORMAL."

    What Stephen was referring to was our Apache pilots using Hellfire missiles on apparently unarmed Iraqis and laughing about it. In case you are wondering, Hellfire missiles are NOT supposed to be used on human targets, period.

    Nonetheless, it is my youngest son, Connor, who leaves me feeling helpless and hurting most of the time. Three months into this tour, a failed webcam attempt led to our first nightmare. I was awakened by Connor crying out, repetitively, "Mommy, I want Daddy. I want Daddy, Mommy. I want Daddy, Mommy, I want Daddy."

    I did the only thing that I could do: I held him tight, rocked him back and forth, and told him (repeatedly) that I knew he missed his Daddy.

    Two broken records painfully breaking the silence of night until Connor fell asleep in my arms, his tears still wet on his face and - having soaked through my shirt - my shoulder.

    Imagine my surprise when two months later Connor sees a picture that Caynan sent us (from Iraq) of himself in the cockpit of the Blackhawk and asks me, "Is that your friend, Mommy?"

    "No, baby, that's your Daddy in Iraq," I respond - probably an octave higher than I should have. He didn't seriously NOT recognize his own father? When did THIS happen?

    I pick up the photo to talk to Connor about what Caynan is doing in Iraq (again) but Connor has walked away and is playing with Legos, clearly not interested. I have to find out where to get one of those "daddy" dolls made ...

    After getting Connor to bed, and letting Caleb watch a movie in my bedroom because of course I have no idea how to force him to go to sleep, I go outside to sit on the front steps to smoke a cigarette and ponder what Connor will be like when he sees his dad again. Add that to my list of mommy failures; I have had to start taking Caleb to therapy at Darnall Army Medical Center, since apparently he wishes Connor was dead and has started drawing pictures of himself dying horrible deaths.

    To my left I see the spouse who drinks every night, with her cigarettes and a beer. I wave. To my right lives the Mormon spouse who doesn't drink or smoke but is addicted to Percocet, so she never leaves her house. No one to wave to there.

    A 2008 RAND study reports that at least one in five soldiers are returning from war with PTSD. When are they going to do a study on the spouses and children left behind in these wars? The ones who self-medicate or are prescribed anti-depressants (parent and child alike), who can never look at the world or the Army or themselves the same way again? What have we lost in service to this country?

    We are only a third of the way through my husband's deployment and I can already identify our wounded. Am I the only one paying attention?

    If this country wants to maintain an all-volunteer force, then the Department of Defense and Congress need to start recognizing the service of military families in actions and not just words. An investment in the family IS an investment in the service member. Fortify and strengthen the family and you fortify and strengthen your forces.

    Taking care of military families is not just a moral imperative - it is a troop multiplier.

»


Carissa S. Picard is the wife of an active duty Army pilot, an attorney, the founder and president of Military Spouses for Change, and a freelance writer whose work can be found on Military.com and Bloggernews.net.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

This is a heartbreaking

This is a heartbreaking article. I want to have compassion for this woman and her family -- yet I have to wonder if the madness cannot be stopped just by getting out of the military, or (here's an idea) never getting into the military in the first place. It's hard to know if the choices we make are really choices, or are foisted upon us. Why does this woman expect the military to put her family first when she has clearly made the choice to put the military first?

Thank you, I think. I'm

Thank you, I think. I'm ashamed that I've hardly given a thought to all the collateral damage that didn't occur in Iraq. Your piece made me understand how remiss I have been. I hope for the best for you and yours, and for all the still silent ones in your situation.

Peace, Not War. I'm sorry,

Peace, Not War. I'm sorry, but I don't buy into any sympathy or support for volunteer warriors. Choosing to be a member of the US military is choosing to be part of an imperial force, a foot soldier of the wealthy elite, an agent of hegemony. Huge amounts of money are spent giving massive benefits to military families. For those of us who believe that war is immoral, and the the US military is not used to DEFEND the US but is used to implement US empire, there is no way to feel that the "troops" are doing something righteous that deserves lots of money and other rewards. I suggest that Mrs. Picard, instead of advocating for more money for soldiers, become a pacifist, as was Gandhi, Martin Luther KIng, Jesus and many other heroic people, have her husband leave the military, and repair her karma. If you make a living dropping bombs on people, invading people's countries, "following orders" when the orders are illegal, do you really deserve subsidies and respect from the American people?

Perhaps her husband, a

Perhaps her husband, a medevac pilot, joined to save lives and she didn't know what she was getting into. Many families don't realize what they are getting into. And now with this economy, they can't afford to get out. Moreover, why do people feel so little compassion for the military yet not the police or firefighters and their hardships? Those in the military have volunteered to literally stand between an enemy's bullet and you and your family. They didn't realize that they could possibly be misused and lied to and sent away for years at a time for what would turn out to be an illegal or immoral war. What they did do was commit to die to protect American lives. For every person who volunteers to do this, one less person is at risk of being drafted.

Thank you for getting

Thank you for getting involved, speaking out, and telling the truth. War is senseless and the hurt goes way beyond what many people imagine. 20% come home with PTSSD? I'll bet its closer to 80%.

I am the daughter of a sole

I am the daughter of a sole surviving son who lost both his brother and brother-in-law in WWII. His brother was MIA for almost a year before they found out that he had died. Long story there. My heart goes out to the author and all other family members of soldiers. She is 1000% right in her premise that the families need all the help they can get as well as the returning soldiers. I have some hope here. Eric Shinseki will be the new head of the VA and he has a fantastic reputation. I'm hoping that he also knows this side of the equation.

strong stuff! now magnify

strong stuff! now magnify these feelings if you are the spouse of a gay American serving in the armed forces. even sending a letter can get your partner thrown out. career destroyed. no emails home, no videos. it's too dangerous. and even for people from the few states where gay marriage is legal. sure they are married, but they'd better not mention it. or else. and actually, there are a lot of official supports, groups and organizations for the straight husbands and wives of those serving, and zero for the gay ones. time to repeal DADT. luckily, i'm in Canada where we don't have those sorts of heart-breaking, career-killing and discriminatory restrictions.

This article hits home.

This article hits home. Though I did not get my TBI from the Iraq war nonetheless I associate myself with the victims having received a TBI and the emotional trauma associated this injury. The truly sad issue is that having “given” one’s self for a war that should have never happened, then to not realize that these men and women, not unlike some one who looses their limbs, a TBI robs an individual of something that is as equally significant; their ability to be whole; who they were before the incident that caused their TBI. And readers to help you put into perspective, everything that we are, and that we have learned in our life is stored in our Grey Matter. Think of the brain being like the hard drive in the computer, where all the information stored, then the hard drive becomes corrupted and the information is lost. Damage the brain and everything changes in one’s life. It becomes a life long struggle to re-learn almost everything including the simplest aspects of being a human being all over in one’s life. It becomes the re-birthing of ones entire life all over again, which takes time. The story about the tragic killing of one’s pet is so real. Not that I did that, but I did strike my 6-year-old chocolate lab for the stupidest reasons about a year ago. She is such a dear part of my empty life now. I hug her, even today, hoping that my daily hugs will cover the sin of my past indiscretion. So, for our military to sent these men and women out in the world, which they faithfully served, without the understanding that so many will not be able to live normal lives ever again, is more then tragic, it’s irresponsible.

I am the daughter,

I am the daughter, granddaughter, niece and cousin of military officers and have lived the profoundly harmful effects of dislocation, war and death on a family. I feel that the only way to stop the madness of war is to go back to conscription. When every son and daughter of every American (except the proverbial Senators' sons) stands a good chance of being put in harms way "for our freedom" (as they put it this time around) perhaps the fake patriotism and jingoistic calls to war will stop. And perhaps when warriors who did not choose to kill are put behind the gunsights the laughing will stop. Only when a large swathe of the America people begin to experience the trauma of having a beloved family member in combat will these illegal, immoral wars begin to end.

If only recruiters would

If only recruiters would help prepare the families for what they are about to endure. I plan to include this article in the "truth in recruitment" materials we take to our high schools. Thank you, Ms. Picard, for opening our eyes.

Thank you so much for

Thank you so much for writing this invaluable, heartbreaking, and essential piece. It is so important for "non military" people to understand this part of the war machine. Keep speaking out!

I'm feeling some lack of

I'm feeling some lack of sympathy here as well. My heart breaks for the children, but after Gulf War I, was anybody really unaware of what happens to soldiers & their families in a war? I don't buy that they didn't know what they were getting into. The only military service in my family was a peacetime stint by my father, and yet I KNOW the military and possible war is not a life I would want for myself or my children. These are educated people, how could they not know? Then again, I can imagine what Texas is like, but I've never lived there. As for the money angle, the author is an attorney, could they have survived on one income?

Those of you who say you

Those of you who say you have difficulty finding compassion for this woman and her family are merely revealing a lack of understanding (or lack of humanity) on your own part. Militaristic societies invest enormous resources in propagandizing their populations, from birth. Because some are able, either through their upbringing, their education, or their own experience and judgment, to largely free themselves of such inculcation does not mean everyone will or that everyone should be expected to. Everyone who suffers so deserves our compassion, whether we believe they should have known better, or whether we believe the situation is in some sense of their own making or not. Further, anyone who can claim they have never made a significant misjudgment, have never been fooled by high-sounding ideals or rhetoric, have never trusted the wrong person or institution, or have never gotten in over their heads is either lying, not human, self-deluded, or has not lived authentically.

We all have blood on our

We all have blood on our hands! Over 80% of Americans were for the Iraq war and the others didn't protest loud enough (as it would have mattered anyhow....) Patriotism is the egg out of which wars are hatched or hypocrisy in religion where everybody goes to church and bible studies and ignores the 10 commandments on a daily basis. Yes, P-E Obama is right in recognizing that the sentiment, that makes wars possible, has to change! I doubt it will ever happen as long as American Idol is more important than an education...

Although Carissa paints a

Although Carissa paints a picture of despair and confusion, what lies beneath is much more poignant. She puts on "The Face" while counseling Soldiers with PTSD as to not convey her pain to them, for they must feel confidence in the compassion and wisdom they need to possibly live as normal a life as humanly possible. She may help them in a small way that she can, but does she help herself in the process? Never having been married while on Active Duty I can not give a first hand description of the needs of a spouse in such circumstances, but I know many that can and have. It's a thankless job to those that live outside "The Box", only understood by those that live, eat and breathe it day in and day out, night in and night out, over and over... A Warriors function within the scope of any given conflict is often lost on the spouse as they have not been introduced or had their "Baptism by Fire" as a fully functioning member of "'The Club." Said club being Boot Camp, MOS Training, and the bond that exists within the brethren of the Warrior Class and it's Ethos. It's not usually meant to exclude them, but more of an unconscious lack of understanding of their need to be part of that club, part of those brethren, and part of the understanding of what it is to be one of the Warrior Class. This they need to survive, both physically and mentally, to keep their families on an even keel when their spouse is deployed, especially to a Combat Zone. The so-called support provided by any one branch is most certainly substandard, so they must form bonds with the others that suffer the same fate, waiting for their Warrior to come home, hopefully with all parts and pieces intact, but at least alive. It becomes drastically harder when one feels that the conflict in which their loved one fights is an unjust, and illegal one. They must dig deep for the understanding of why they, their family and their Warrior must suffer the horrors of War while maintaining their sanity and fulfilling their daily duties as the Mother, Father, Chef, Housekeeper, Coach, Teacher, Scout Leader, Comforter, and the list goes on…while maintaining the level of Love and Compassion that her family and Warrior so badly need. All need to look at the very essence of what it is to be a Military Spouse to understand that there’s more than one in harms way. Thanx…

+INSULT TO INJURY [what they

+INSULT TO INJURY [what they do not know yet]: if a divorce does occur, the USAGovernment will take the Disabled Veteran portion from the divorced spouse's retirement share, INSTEAD OF ITS OWN FUNDS--AS IF THE SPOUSE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR HIS SERVICE-INCURRED DISABILITY AND SENT HIM IN HARMS WAY!!! And the divorced spouse 's will find herself with less and less over the years. The USA's final THANK YOU TO HER FOR HER SUPPORT AND SERVICE. Legislation is needed to correct this.

When our son went to

When our son went to Afghanistan i did not sleep a full night the whole tour. But when he came home with PTSD, I realized that the hard part was just beginning. The VA in Oregon has been very helpful and has a seven week PTSD class for family members. But it is not enough. We need to get our warriors home and keep them there! Military solutions should be the absolute last resort, precisely because the ripples change and damage so many of us.

Thank you so very much for

Thank you so very much for this hard-hitting and powerful article. I feel so helpless; my son was blinded in this insanity, which I was totally opposed to, and how I have hated these evil unfeeling men who thought up the great idea to gain power & money. It's not only the wives and children who suffer, it extends far beyond. AS to no sympathy, how could you even say such a horrible thing? The country is a war-mongering one, glorifying war - and just tell me where else many of these people could be employed??? I agree that conscription is a good idea, taking from the families of those in the top 1% income bracket of the country first, no exceptions. Boom, no more war. My son was National Guard - and he joined to get a few extra bucks a month & college for his kids. He loved helping out the State of AZ in times of crisis but I don't believe he ever, once, thought he would wind up at war. It's the freaking NATIONAL guard for God's sake. Getting benefits was the fight of our lives, went on for over a year. And what his wife and daughter have gone through is too hard to bear, but this lovely Japanese girl has stuck with him.

So why are they in Iraq and

So why are they in Iraq and Afghanistan? Who sent them there? Any interest in politics, lady? Want to see change? Then stop this military bullshit, stop saying these people have our "support", when in reality it's feeding the poor, the stupid and/or misguided into the blender. Thank Bush and Co., thank the "defense" contractors who push war, the banks who finance war, the churches preaching war, the teachers who teach acquiescence and the parents who evidently don't give a shit about their children - who let them join the ranks so they can sport a new bumper sticker boasting of their "patriotism". Change, anyone?

I have been anti-war all my

I have been anti-war all my life. I came of age during Viet Nam. My father refused to fight in World War II because his dying father was a pacifist. Yet I can feel compassion for Carissa and her family. I don't agree that bringing back the draft is necessarily a good solution, but I think it is tragic that those Americans who don't have immediate family in the War have been so apathetic. That is why the current peace movement has not been as mainstream as it was during Viet Nam. Those who are "unsympathetic" to Carissa--have you never heard of the "economic draft"? Welfare cuts (of which Clinton was guilty) and other cuts have left some young people (particularly blacks) with no option but to join the armed forces--then they couldn't just leave once the war started! I'm a Canadian and I'm ashamed that my country is not welcoming those who desert for reasons of conscience. Anyway, those who stand in self-righteous judgment of a woman with the courage to speak out--get over yourselves!

Mrs. Pickard should be

Mrs. Pickard should be commended for her work and her compassion, for without compassion neither this war nor any other war will ever end. More to the point of her article, without compassion, especially on the part of the highest echelons of the military, no help will ever come to the families who suffer the fears and terrors of military life – and not just in wartime, but in peace time, too. Mrs. Pickard writes that she “never expected to feel so lonely, so isolated, so out-of-place and out of sorts all the time, always in that in-between place of neither here nor there, neither this nor that.” The same words and feelings could be applied to the children of service men and women everywhere as well, at any time – never mind wartime. This is the limbo, the dimension of the lost and homeless, to which the military consigns so many of its dependents; and it’s about time service men and women stopped making excuses for a system that is so harmful to them, and their children. It’s about time they found a voice, and a program, to alleviate a way of life that is traumatic enough even without the horrors of war. Much could be done to improve the lives of military families, if only a compassionate intelligence would be brought to bear on an emotionally crippling way of life.

Ms. Picard's article

Ms. Picard's article well illustrates the hideous truth that ALL WAR WASTES ALL THINGS. There is nothing at all good in it. It is a waste of human lives and money and materials that could easily be spent and used to some constructive purpose. Since the Reagan Presidency, every President has HAD to have a War to cement his legacy and demand respect and honor for their term in office. Where I live, in this small town, hundreds of us knew that we were being lied to in the runup to Iraq. We marched in the streets to protest the perversion of human existence that the Republicans were so self-righteously shouting about. Now 4300 or so of our young are dead, 30.000 or so are badly wounded, many families are broken or ruined, many billions of dollars are spent or stolen, and we are not one whit better off. STOP ALL WAR!

Jenna's comment is so very

Jenna's comment is so very correct. A draft, equally applied to all young men within the United States, is the ONLY thing that will get us thinking and doing something to end this madness. I want to puke with I see statements by Cheney that he had other priorities than the war and thus received so many deferments. Why is it that so many sissies are in control of sending our youth to war?

@Anonymous 12:28: read Jenna

@Anonymous 12:28: read Jenna again--she calls for a draft of "every son and DAUGHTER of every American", not just sons. @Eilish adds the nice condition that conscription should start with "the families of those in the top 1% income bracket of the country first, no exceptions." I'd like to see required universal service with the military as one option, but know that's a fantasy. But ain't no way even Jenna's and Eilish's more limited ideas will be realized. Reason? Vietnam taught the warmongers a lesson: use conscripts in a lousy war and you won't have no war. As for those with a compassion deficit, consider why folks join the military. Some are sociopaths a step ahead of jail whom the military welcomes with every lowering standards. Some are decent folks who truly believe, thanks to incessant propaganda, that military service is a way to act on their deep felt love for their country. Most are economic conscripts who turn to the military as the only path available to them to penury the impersonal system that always works for the moneyed has condemned them to. The last group soon finds they’ve been conned from the get go and that they are merely bodies to be thrown at the latest scheme of the rich and powerful for more, more, more. But at least they learn. The middle group are perhaps the saddest of all, since they will live out the rest of their lives clinging to a delusion. Carissa’s spouse is doing one of the most, maybe only, honorable jobs in the military: saving the lives of those used and abused for others’ pockets and egos. Nevertheless, she is right that the families of those conned one way or another deserve not only our compassion but also our help.

An apt service award for the

An apt service award for the invisible ranks: THE BLACK & BLUE HEART

My father in law dropped

My father in law dropped bombs on Japanese warships in the 'good war' and was one of the first to use napalm on Korean civilians in the 'forgotten war'. We are STILL living with the ramifications of that today. What we need to realize is that there really is no 'this war' or 'that war'. There is only THE WAR which is variously engaged in various locations at either a chronic or acute level ALL THE TIME. Why ? That doesn't matter so much as Who Benefits ? When that question is actually addressed, then THE WAR will begin to be over. Truly, there is something fundamentally insane about men dressing up in different colored costumes and inventing various devices ranging from the very primitive to the utmostly sophisticated, all designed for the purpose of putting lethal holes in each other at the expense of the women and children in their lives. (Not to mention the devastation of the real estate they are performing this activity on). Again, Who Benefits ?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.