Truthout Original

Facebook DIGG

The Monstrosity of War

by: Dahr Jamail, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Civilian deaths increase as Israel moves deeper into Gaza. (Photo: Abid Katib / Getty Images Europe)

"Foreseen for so many years: these evils, this monstrous violence, these massive agonies: no easier to bear."
-Robinson Jeffers, American poet


    Agence France-Presse reports that the first person killed when the Israeli military began to enter Gaza on Saturday was a Palestinian child.

    On Sunday, a Palestinian woman and her four children were blown to pieces when Israeli warplanes bombed their home. They are among the 521 victims (at the time of this writing) of the ongoing air and ground assault on the Gaza Strip by a 9,000 strong force, which the Israeli government has launched on one of the most densely populated tracts of land in the world, home to 1.5 million Palestinians, half of them under 17 years of age.

    "The ground invasion was preceded by large scale artillery shelling from around 4 P.M., intended to 'soften' the targets as artillery batteries deployed along the Strip in recent days began bombarding Hamas targets and open areas near the border," Israel's Haaretz newspaper wrote of the onslaught. "Hundreds of shells were fired, including cluster bombs aimed at open areas."

    Israel began the military assault on Gaza on November 4, breaking the truce that Hamas had observed for many months. It went on to block food supplies to be delivered into Gaza by the UN Relief Works and World Food Program. The next casualty was the crucial fuel delivery service used to run Gaza's power plant. Finally, Israel banned journalists and aid workers from entering Gaza.

    It is important to note that in mid-December, during a visit to Israel, UN Human Rights Investigator Richard Falk called the Israeli blockade of Gaza "a crime against humanity" and a "flagrant and massive violation of international law."

    Falk, a professor emeritus of international law at Princeton University and United Nations special rapporteur on human rights in the Palestinian territories, urged the UN to invoke "the agreed norm of a responsibility to protect a civilian population being collectively punished by policies that amount to a Crime Against Humanity." Falk also called for an International Criminal Court investigation of Israeli military and civilian officials for potential prosecution.

    For this, he was detained at Tel Aviv's Ben Gurion Airport for 20 hours before being expelled from Israel.

    As Israeli tanks and ground troops pour into Gaza to engage in the worst kind of combat (should we even measure types of warfare against one another?), urban warfare, the atrocities on both sides continue, and one may assume that the situation will only worsen with time, as it inevitably does in progressive stages of war.

    "Operation Cast Lead" as Israel's latest offensive is named, has claimed, since December 27, over 520 Palestinian lives. Gaza medical officials put the number of wounded at over 2,400, most of them civilians.

    Hamas rockets have killed five Israelis, one of them a soldier and four of them civilians. As with Israeli attacks that kill and wound Palestinian civilians are a war crime, Hamas firing their grossly inaccurate rockets into Israel, which then wound and kill Israeli civilians, is also a war crime.

    According to KPFA radio correspondent Sameh Habeeb, "Around 17 people [from the Al-Atatra family] were killed in Bait Lahia town north of Gaza. Amongst them were several children, two brothers, 20-year-olds and many old men who were all killed by one rocket." Habeeb also reports of Israeli war planes striking water plants, dozens of houses, the use of white phosphorous incendiary weapons and of at least 15 mosques having been bombed. Dozens of people have been killed in the attacks against the mosques. Israeli Foreign Minister Ms. Tzipi Livni explains patiently, "But a war is a war; these things can happen. This is not our intention, but we cannot avoid completely any kind of civilian casualties. But the responsibility for this lies on Hamas' shoulders." The slaughter only compounds the hardships that Palestinians have suffered due to the severe shortages of food and medical supplies accruing from the two-year-old economic blockade imposed upon Gaza by Israel.

    In 2006, Dov Weisglass, an adviser to the Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, said of the blockade: "The idea is to put the Palestinians on a diet, but not to make them die of hunger."

    The UN has warned that there are "critical gaps" in aid reaching Gaza, despite claims from Livni that aid was getting through.

    Christopher Gunness, the UN Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) spokesman, dismisses the claim that there is no humanitarian crisis as an absurdity. He informs us, "The organization for which I work, UNRWA - has approximately 9 to 10,000 workers on the ground. They are speaking with the ordinary civilians in Gaza ... People are suffering. A quarter of all those being killed now are civilians [the majority of the over 2,400 wounded are civilians]. So when I hear people say we're doing our best to avoid civilian casualties that rings very hollow indeed."

    > From Iraq, I had reported on how the US military regularly blockaded cities during military operations, disconnecting power, food, water and medical supplies. Let us not forget the March 2003 US invasion of Iraq followed 12 and a half years of genocidal sanctions against that country, which claimed the lives of half a million children. The people of Iraq, like the people of Gaza, had been placed on a "diet."

    Back in Gaza, the International Committee for the Red Cross said on Sunday its medical emergency team had been prevented by the Israeli military for a third day from entering the territory. Here again, is an uncanny similarity with the situation in Iraq, particularly during the two US sieges of Fallujah during 2004, when medical and aid teams were not allowed into the city, and teams already inside were regularly targeted by the military when they attempted to rescue the wounded.

    KPFA correspondent Habeeb has reported of Israeli tanks preventing ambulances from reaching the wounded and of three paramedics and ambulance staff having been killed by the Israeli military while trying to rescue a family. Oxfam aid agency also reported on the incident. Journalist activist Ewa Jasiewicz reported, "On 31st December, around 2 am, two emergency medical services personnel were targeted by an Israeli missile as they attempted to reach injured in the Jabaliya region, northern Gaza. The first died immediately, the second soon after of complications from his internal injuries. Two days later, two more medics were injured in the area east of Gaza, again in the line of duty, again trying to reach the injured. Under the Geneva Conventions, Israel is obliged to allow and ensure safe passage to medical personnel to the injured. Instead, Israel routinely targets them."

    I am aware that for those who have not experienced war firsthand, an accusation against a supposedly civilized government of the deliberate targeting of medical personnel, who are, in theory, protected by international law, is unbelievable and shocking. But there are others like me who have witnessed such tactics firsthand on several occasions. I saw it being used by the Israeli military during their assault on southern Lebanon during summer 2006, just as I had seen the US military doing in Fallujah in 2004.

    Such is the madness of war.

    Veteran journalist Robert Fisk describes war as "the total failure of the human spirit."

    How can anyone expect the wide-scale butchering in Gaza to be any different when the dogs of war have been let loose? Psychosis, mental illness, the specious "logic" of it all: The fundamental assumption that war can ever solve a crisis is false. Has this not been apparent from the beginning of history?

"These events of war were performed not by atavistic savages following the code of archaic rituals, but usually by trained troops from societies boasting civilized values, humane laws, moral education, and aesthetic culture. Nor were these acts specific to one nation - typically Japanese, typically American, or German or Serbian ... Nor were they confined to exceptional psychopathic criminals among the troops. No: this is what wars do, what battles are; conventions of rampage on both a monstrous collective and monstrous individual scale, implacable archetypal behaviors, behaviors of an archetype, governed by, possessed by, commanded by Mars."

-James Hillman, Jungian psychologist, from "A Terrible Love of War"

    At this point, it simply must be stopped. No human, no matter what their race, religion or nationality, should ever have to endure the effects of war.

    Yet, impotent governments across the world remain unwilling to intervene, some conniving proactively to aggravate the distress of the targeted populations. Egypt has completely closed the Rafah crossing, effectively cutting off aid supplies to the hapless surviving residents of Gaza.

    It is the United Nations, however, that must be granted the undisputed crowning glory of impotence. In a move tried and tested for years now, last Saturday evening, the United States, yet again wielding its veto power to protect the actions of Israel, blocked approval of a UN Security Council statement expressing concern at the escalation of violence between Israel and Hamas and calling for an immediate cease-fire in the Gaza Strip and southern Israel. Perhaps, there is consolation in the fact that this was no great loss because, had the statement been approved, it would still have remained an empty gesture unable to check the violence.

    Frustrated by the untenable nature of the crisis and obviously angered by the veto power of the United States in the UN, president of the UN General Assembly, Miguel d'Escoto Brockman of Nicaragua, blasted the Israeli action, and said, "I think it's a monstrosity; there's no other way to name it ... Once again, the world is watching in dismay the dysfunctionality of the Security Council."

    Professor Falk, in a recent article titled "Understanding the Gaza Catastrophe," writes, "The people of Gaza are victims of geopolitics at its inhumane worst: producing what Israel itself calls a 'total war' against an essentially defenseless society that lacks any defensive military capability whatsoever and is completely vulnerable to Israeli attacks mounted by F-16 bombers and Apache helicopters. What this also means is that the flagrant violation of international humanitarian law, as set forth in the Geneva Conventions, is quietly set aside while the carnage continues and the bodies pile up. It additionally means that the UN is once more revealed to be impotent when its main members deprive it of the political will to protect a people subject to unlawful uses of force on a large scale. Finally, this means that the public can shriek and march all over the world, but that the killing will go on as if nothing is happening. The picture being painted day by day in Gaza is one that begs for renewed commitment to international law and the authority of the UN Charter, starting here in the United States, especially with a new leadership that promised its citizens change, including a less militarist approach to diplomatic leadership."

    "And where two raging fires meet together, they do consume the thing that feeds their fury...," said Shakespeare in "The Taming of the Shrew." But one of the worst conflict conditions in the world indicates otherwise. The fury and the fire rage unabated.

»


Dahr Jamail, an independent journalist, is the author of "Beyond the Green Zone: Dispatches From an Unembedded Journalist in Occupied Iraq," (Haymarket Books, 2007). Jamail reported from occupied Iraq for eight months as well as from Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Turkey over the last four years.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Where is Obama while this is

Where is Obama while this is going on? We know that Bush and Co. aid and abet Israel, but those of us who voted for Obama expect better. Come to think of it, though, he has R. Emmanuel as a Chief of Staff designate and Hillary Clinton as SOS designate. Does this tell us something? Alas, all the hope that things will be better with a new administration may be an exercise in futility. Palestinians probably had high hopes for some justice. Now, they have only despair.

Israel is behaving like

Israel is behaving like their enemy, they do not value human life. Israel has the power to accomplish their goals without such brute force. The power dynamic is lopsided. The entire world is negligent for letting this come to be. Chaos is the nature of the politics and death and carnage to innocents is the result. Why is the world like this? If you are not depressed, you are not paying attention.

Hamas revels in the world

Hamas revels in the world attention of pain and suffering of their own people. This is the most heinous crime of all; setting up your own women and children to be in the line of fire. The photo on your "Monstrosity of War" should read "Hamas; Monsters of War".

Where is the outrage when

Where is the outrage when Palestinians bomb Israeli schools? Don't misunderstand, I think that the fighting needs to stop. But BOTH sides need to come to the table of peace. As long as either side speaks with violence the other side will only hear with violence.

If you can look at the

If you can look at the pictures from Gaza and feel they represent a warranted sense of justice... your value system is broken. It may be a very complicated political situation, but that only makes it more important that our influence be carefully and thoughtfully spent on a peaceful course of action. War isn't the answer, or the solution; it is, by every time-tested example, a crime against all of humanity. Lest you believe otherwise, to justify any, there has never been a "good war." The Gaza Strip is comparable to the size of the SF Bay Area. Rockets, air raids, and soldiers bombard people who have very little food or water, very few medical supplies, and no where to hide. They are denied the opportunity to cross borders to seek safety. Outrage may be all these people have left.

israeli Foreign Minister Ms.

israeli Foreign Minister Ms. Tzipi Livni explains patiently, "But a war is a war; these things can happen. This is not our intention, but we cannot avoid completely any kind of civilian casualties. But the responsibility for this lies on hamas' shoulders."....WHAT?...seriously....how can she say that? Was it not israel who broke the cease fire? It only makes sense that those who have been persecuted for thousands of years would turn around and do the same to others. Having said that, israelis as well as american jews no longer have the right to hold the holocaust as some sacred event which justifies all their callous actions. AND I AM NOT AN ANTI-SEMITE...just a logical non partisan human being.

The people in Gaza chose to

The people in Gaza chose to live under Hamas who in turn used them, their schools, mosques, hospitals as shelters for their fighters, rocket launching into Israel and whose broadcasts, like those of Hezbollah called for the destruction of Israel and incidentally, the Jewish people. Now comes the payoff. Please stop the bleeding heart routine. There were no tears when Hizbollah rocketed Israeli towns and cities. The Israeli terms are reasonable: Stop the rockets, disarm, etc.. and if you have spread some blame around, there isn't an Arab regime that has given the people of Gaza anything but talk.

Israel has bomb shelters for

Israel has bomb shelters for their citizens. Hamas does not. Need I say more?

This article is filled with

This article is filled with blatant lies and I am sorely disappointed at Truthout for such biased covered. The article states that Israel broke the truce with Hamas on Nov. 4th - which is a HUGE failure of truth! Hamas started launching rockets into Israel in June 2006 - killing seven israeli civilian - most children relaxing at a beach! http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/5066768.stm Truthout is going to lose a lot of readers - not to mention my (and many many others) financial support by their clearly biased and falsified coverage of Israel's right to defend herself. Israel is not perfect and the treatment of Palestinians has been controversial at best, but they also do it to themselves. Any political group (i.e. Hamas) that uses television to recruit children into killing themselves is reprehensible. Obviously, anyone who is against Israel in this current invasion has not seen the Hamas television shows that show Jews killing a mickey mouse character called Farfour and calling on palestinian children to take up arms. Obviously, they have not watched these shows that show a CHILD killing George Bush and turning the White House into a mosque to inspire palestinian children to take up arms and be a hero for Islam! (I am not a Bush fan, but this particular video made me nauseous). I only wish Americans would travel beyond our borders and take the time to really understand what is happening!

Nothing hurts more than a

Nothing hurts more than a picture like that. Nothing. Both Israel and and the U.S. (read--the Bush administration and its supporters) know the consequences of what they are doing. This is Israeli politics playing itself out once again with U.S. support. It's a shame and a crime. Hopefully there is justice for this somewhere, but probably not in this world.

Whenever innocent lives are

Whenever innocent lives are lost, it is tragic. I recommend that Hamas come out from behind its women and children and fight like men. How brave to cry to the world community about the indecency of a war that is provoked by the people who end up suffering most. The solution is simple. Elect a government that cares more for its people than it cares for sustaining hatred. Israel is here to stay. Israel will not yield its right to live in safety. So get used to it. Make a decision. Do not cry into your teacups anymore.

It is beyond ludicrous to

It is beyond ludicrous to compare Hamas' handful of outdated, inaccurate rockets with the modern Israeli war machine. In answer to the question of where is the outrage when Palestinians bomb Israeli schools, I say, all over the biased American media. The question should be, where is the outrage over Israeli theft of land, water, energy, blockades of food and medical supplies? Israel has a homeland and the most powerful benefactor in the world; does not Palestine deserve the same? These actions by any other country besides Israel would be condemned as terrorism as the Hamas attacks quite properly are, but the issue is always, always framed as they attack we defend when we all know that 540 Palestinian deaths does not equal 5 Israeli deaths. Frankly, one is too many. The problem in the Middle East stems from the fact that the US armed and supported one side and stands idly by as the pretense of self defense continues.

2 WRONGS DO NOT = 1 RIGHT.

2 WRONGS DO NOT = 1 RIGHT.

Response to:" This article

Response to:" This article is filled with" (above) The actual BBC article you cite reports the killing of GAZAN civilians and children with NO ISRAELI DEATHS.

This is Palestinian

This is Palestinian propaganda.

Some of the people who

Some of the people who demonstrated on behalf of Hamas in Europe were demonstrating against terrorists when they planted bombs in their own countries. Take Spain, for example. So I have to wonder at the double-standard of those who think their own nations have a right to live, unattacked, but question the right of the Jewish people of Israel to have normal lives. I hope and pray for a speedy resolution, including sanity to the elected leaders of Palestine to stop putting their citizens in this suicidal position. That they recognize the reality of their political position, stop trying to make Israel the bad guy, recognize Israel, stop firing rockets, and get on with their lives.

"This is Palestinian

"This is Palestinian propaganda." Right the mother saw a bomb falling from a USA supplied jet and ran out with her child so he could be injured and provide a PR opportunity for the Palestinians. What gall. And if this child grows up and decides 30 years from now when Gaza is still being run like a Israeli version of Ghetto under Nazi rule, to become a suicide bomber and blow up Israeli civilians he will be called a terrorist.

The Israeli's have been

The Israeli's have been crying victim for a long time. The Palestinians are an "existential threat," they rocket us, they hide their guns in UN Shelters, they use infants as shields, they don't fight fairly... First off, Israel has the 4th strongest military in the world, (Jane's) with 200 nuclear bombs, the latest in US supplied jets and helicopters--it is hardly a helpless victim fighting giants with slingshots. Secondly, if anyone is existentially threatened, it is the Palestinians. Gaza is an open air prison, no one is let in or out. Essentials of life are turned off at a moment's notice by the wardens (Israel) . Israel has no real solution to the plight of the Palestinians--other than they hope they go away and if they won’t go away they are--killed, threatened, bombed out and denied sustenance. This is similar to America's policy toward its indigenous Indians. It worked in the USA (the Indians were all killed or corralled into reservations) but is not working in Gaza because Israel lives in a sea of Arabs. Short of killing all the Arabs, a solution is needed. Some adult needs to tell the Israeli's to stop. A neutral military force needs to be placed between the fighters forces. No rockets, blockades or settlers allowed. Go back to the '67 armistice lines, and deliver the 2 state solution preached by all but practiced by few. It's in Israel’s favor never to solve the crisis--that allows them to have their settlers create "facts on the ground." Adults need to say no to this.

How can you crazy people on

How can you crazy people on this blog sit there and justify these atrocities. US citizens need to stop trying to buddy up with Israel when they're doing wrong. We need to condemn unprovoked attacks and stop providing the weapons for destruction of innocent Palestinian civilians just like we do with innocent Israeli civilians. Please write to Obama, Clinton and your congressperson and tell them to stop supporting this country until they START SUPPORTING A PEACEFUL COEXISTENCE!

This is genocide. Ironic

This is genocide. Ironic since the Jews were almost exterminated themselves in WWII. Has Israel become the WWII Germany of the Middle East? Its beginning to look that way. I'm tired of the bullying of the lobbies in our country who say that anyone who protests the actions of Israel is antisemitic. No, the actions of Israel in Gaza today are barbaric and no country should be allowed to carry out such injustice. What hypocrisy! What happened to "never again". Any government that condones or stands silently by during this kind of aggression and carnage should be roundly criticized. Americans need to loudly protest our governments support of these actions. It's immoral.

The presence of militants

The presence of militants within a civilian population does not, under international law, deprive that population of their protected status, and hence any assault upon that population under the guise of targeting militants is, in fact, a war crime.

"So I have to wonder at the

"So I have to wonder at the double-standard of those who think their own nations have a right to live, unattacked, but question the right of the Jewish people of Israel to have normal lives." That goes, too, for so-called American peace activists who vigorously defend the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, but can't see the logic of defending Israel.

Good grief. Despit e the

Good grief. Despit e the monstrous nature of the military actions by Israel, there are still people who insist on blaming the victim and dismissing any and all Palestinian claims as 'propaganda' This..despite overwhelming proof to the contrary. Israel certainly does have the right to protect itself..but so too do the people of Israeli occupied Palestine. Israel is engaged in the wholesale slaughter of the Palestinian people ...plain and simple..and yet there are still those who continue to justify these horrific actions that have resulted in the slaughter of innocent children... as we have seen today. As for the poster questioning Obama's whereabouts, he is not yet occupying the office of president. That said..no one can realistically expect him to change the policies of decades of unconditional support for Israel by the US. Meanwhile..the slaughter continues unabated..and the US presents their brand new American embassy in American occupied Iraq. And we wonder why Muslims and Arabs have no faith in western governments and so-called peace initiatives.

to "It is bey0nd ludicrous:"

to "It is bey0nd ludicrous:" Dear Anonymous, you say "The question should be, where is the outrage over Israeli theft of land, water, energy, blockades of food and medical supplies?" Maybe you have your facts wrong? Israel did NOT steal any land - Palestine was a huge territory of the Ottoman Empire (approx. 1300-1918) including what is today Jordan, parts of Syria,and parts of Iraq. At the end of World War I the Ottoman Empire was dissolved and Turkey is the only autonomous survivor. The rest of the lands were divided between the French (Syria and Lebanon) and the British got a Mandate over Palestine. Mind you, a mandate is a trust - these lands did not BELONG to the British - yet Mr. Churchill, never one to bother with such trifles as International Law, gave, magnanimously what is today Jordan to the Hashemite Abdullah, and amalgamated Kurds, Sunnies and Shiites into one "country," without the slightest regards to the wishes or cultures of the peoples who lived there, and installed Feisal as "prince" over Iraq. There were Arab beduins and Jews living in the area which is now under contention. The United Nations decided that Jews and Arabs should each have their own country. The jews accepted the partition and proceeded to build a society, complete with agriculture, industry and intellectual and artistic endeavors. The Arabs chose not to accept their portion of the area in question and instead to concentrate their energies and most of the millions of petro-dollars they received mostly from the Saudis to the destruction of the Jewish state. They have CHOSEN THE STATE OF AFFAIRS that now exists. Many say "innocents" are dying. In the same breath Arabs point out that Hamas was "democratically" elected. Those who chose to vote for Hamas, knowing the agenda of Hamas was warfare against the state of Israel have also brought their fate on themselves. Of course it is tragic, and don't think for a moment that I am insensitive to the suffering of ANY human being. But we have to come to the recognition - at some time - that actions and choices we make have consequences. That recognition is called "taking responsibility."

Anonymous writes: "Where is

Anonymous writes: "Where is Obama while this is going on? We know that Bush and Co. aid and abet Israel, but those of us who voted for Obama expect better. Come to think of it, though, he has R. Emmanuel as a Chief of Staff designate and Hillary Clinton as SOS designate. Does this tell us something? " Yes, it does. So does his most recent choice of Adm. Dennis Blair as Director of National Intelligence tell us something--Blair, a shadowy puppet master behind the slaughter of thousands in East Timor. http://easttimorlegal.blogspot.com/2008/12/obama-pick-for-national-intelligence.html Obama has stacked his cabinet with masters of war--and don't forget Joe Biden, a self-proclaimed Zionist. This spells disaster for the world in years to come. Nothing new there, of course. But the realization grows ever more starkly clear that the USA is the world's most dangerous terrorist state. That growing realization, not the election of Barack Obama as president, is perhaps our greatest hope for real change.

No, thank YOU, religion.

No, thank YOU, religion. Really, you did it all this time, I deserve none of the credit. No, no! Stand up, take your applause, they're gonna want an encore.

Please, for a website

Please, for a website entitled "truthout" i was expecting an unbiased, and above all truthful account of the conflict. However, the blatant distortion of facts, and seemingly thoughtless, baseless claims did not do your namesake justice. Now, believe me, i do not think that Israel is an innocent victim in the current atrocities, but claiming that Israel's actions are unequivocally without aggravation is a blatant untruth. This article, especially under the facade of a title as ironic as "truthout", does nothing other than spread lies that catalyze hate and poison our world. Have we really become so blind to the world that we cannot see that the hate that each of us carry in our heart, or even worse publicize merely accentuates the ruthless killings. Or do we understand the possible consequences, yet still have such a self-righteous image of ourselves and believe so deeply in our words that we are willing to hold ourselves responsible for the murder of hundreds. Hate cannot drive out hate. if we choose to spread lies in order to provoke reactions and foster hatred we only feed a horrible cycle of vengeance and death. With great power, which undoubtedly falls into the hand of the media, comes great responsibility. I hope that we can recognize that we have created a society that is filled with unnecessary mass murder, all committed in the name of truth and righteousness, which is just hatred in disguise.

Re "Ludicrous". Well

Re "Ludicrous". Well Signoret your history may well be right but you are pursuing the blame game which goes on for ever, think of N Ireland and all similar conflicts. Tell that to the kids who are getting blown to bits in the name of rivalries in which they have no part, no understanding. What matters today is what is happening today not what was done by whom and to whom a hundred years ago . . . read the Norwegian doctor's account in www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=11636 today, and weep . . . for all of the innocents

Testosterone and religion

Testosterone and religion – a recipe for hatred, war and death.

Ladies and Gentlemen. All

Ladies and Gentlemen. All of those who take polarized stands either for or against Israel or the Palestinians with regards to this conflict are playing directly into the hands of those forces outside of either Israel or the Palestinian enclaves who lurk in the shadows and pull the strings behind the scenes. These forces have no interest in resolution of this conflict, and in fact their goal is to perpetuate it. These forces are located in the US as well as in a number of Sunni Arab countries and Iran. There can be hope of ending this conflict only if these outside parties cease pursuing their secret (or not so secret) agenda. Anyone who wants to be a part of the resolution needs to dig down much deeper into the history of the region and into the motivations and aims of all involved parties.

An eye for an eye makes the

An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind

The article is important for

The article is important for reminding us of the war crimes and crimes against humanity committed by the U.S. in Iraq and their direct parallel in the actions of our international partner in crime, Israel. People in Fallujah, Iraq called the U.S. 82nd Airborne "murderous maniacs". The Palestinians in Gaza are facing similarly murderous Israeli "maniacs". Israel is employing a policy of total warfare which does not exclude any possible actions, including the starvation of a population, direct attacks upon civilians, international propaganda, use of banned weapons, attacks upon hospitals and schools, etc. Israel is writing its own history before the court of international opinion. So be it. History marches on. And people continue to resist imperialist aggressors. The fact that governments and international institutions fail to act out of the their cowardice and fear of U.S. and Israeli retribution is no longer a surprise. However, the voices of people around the world are being heard. Miguel D'Escoto's courageous voice can serve as a model.

Former Israeli prime

Former Israeli prime minister Ariel Sharon in his own words: Leibowitz is right, we are Judeo-Nazis, and why not?...now don't be shocked, if they (Israel's founders) instead had killed six million Arabs here or even one million, what would have happened? Sure, two or three nasty pages would have been written in the history books, we would have been called all sorts of names, but we could be here today as a people of 25 million... Even today I am willing to volunteer to do the dirty work for Israel, to kill as many Arabs as necessary, to deport them, to expel and burn them, to have everyone hate us, to pull the rug from underneath the feet of the Diaspora Jews, so that they will be forced to run to us crying. Even if it means blowing up one or two synagogues here and there, I don't care. And I don't mind if after the job is done you put me in front of a Nuremberg Trial and then jail me for life. Hang me if you want, as a war criminal. Then you can spruce up your Jewish conscience and enter the respectable club of civilised nations, nations that are large and healthy. What you lot don't understand is that the dirty work of Zionism is not finished yet, far from it. ...Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon as quoted by prominent Israeli journalist, Amos Oz. (Les voix d'Israel, Calmann-Levy, Paris, 1982 - translated by Guy Seniak. The interview is on pages 79-91.)

The Palestinians do not have

The Palestinians do not have any other recourse but to turn to God. His is the power to change people's hearts and their state. May God change the state of hardship for ease, and help you with the wind of victory. May He contain the evil among those who asked for it. Overturn what they desire and make their efforts fail. @ Fernpatriot. If what you quoted is true; then, I am not surprise that Ariel Sharon is in the state he is in now. May we see what little justice as it is.

Let us recall that just

Let us recall that just after the creation of the State of Israel, in 1948, Arab nations attacked the new nations in an attempt to undo that creation. The Israelis easily defeated them and then went on to annex land which they had conquered by force of arms. Fair enough. In subsequent hostilities Israel seized more land, most notably in a major expansion in 1967. The world has condemned that Israeli expansionism. I'm uncertain about the geography, but may it not be the case that Hamas is firing rockets at occupiers of Arab land, which has become Israel only by conquest, and has, therefore, no legitimacy. Until Israel complies with UN Resolutions calling for withdrawal to the 1967 borders, we can expect that these attacks, by Hamas and other groups are going to continue and all the grotesque responses by Israel will do nothing to stop that. In Europe, under Nazi occupation, the Germans had a policy of killing ten people for any and every one of their occupying soldiers assassinated by partisans. The Israelis have clearly adopted such a policy and multiplied it about forty-fold. Yes, it is a bad idea for Hamas to fire rockets at civilians, but it is an infinitely worse idea to respond with wholesale slaughter of innocent people. The U.S. can help solve this dilemma by cutting aid to Israel unless and until Israel agrees to honor the U.N Resolutions and withdraw back to the boundaries of the originally sanctioned Israeli State. Might does not make right even for "good friends" of the U.S. It is no secret that many Israelis, including Israeli leaders favor expansion of their state to the limits of Eretz (original) Israel, which some define as stretching as far as the Euphrates, a policy the world cannot expect Arab nations, some of whom are in the way of that, to wholeheartedly endorse

In response to those who

In response to those who insist the brutalities visited on the people of Gaza by Israel are nothing more than 'Palestinian propaganda'...for heavens's sake PLEASE EDUCATE YOURSELVES. Uninformed responses such as these to the ongoing slaughter of innocent Palestinians by one of the most well-equipped, powerful (thanks to the USA) militaries in the world..add insult to injury. Despite the alarming prevelance of American/Israeli rhetoric posing as reality concerning the long and bloody 'conflict' between Israel and the people of occupied Palestine, there are still those who bravely and selflessly report the truth, despite all efforts made to curtail and control it. With a little bit of effort, you can learn to differentiate truth from fiction. It really is not all that difficult.

It would be nice if the

It would be nice if the outrage against Israel would also be used against another country that likes to go to war, namely the USA. We have this gigantic budget problem but cheerfully spent a fortune on foreign adventures. Eisenhower should see the military industrial complex now. We criticize everybody else but he who sits in a glasshouse should not throw stones.

So what do the Jews want?

So what do the Jews want? They want to depopulate the Occupied Territories of Palestinians and resettle with Jews? That's it?! Why would Israel have nukes? Not to defend themselves but to actualize the Zionist Dream of Israel From the Nile to the Euphrates. In Gaza, they have made the world passively, complicit in the genocide. Guilt is an objective force.I feel it. Its part of the plan to demoralize the populace, as we eat rice and wait for the next nuclear shoe to drop.

Israel has nukes, the other

Israel has nukes, the other neighboring countries don't, and therefore Israel has the upper hand militarily. They have the biggest, albeit injured, military power in the world (USA) supporting them nearly 100%. Until this dynamic changes, like Iran getting a nuke (and that's not likely), this isn't going to change, and Israel isn't about to give up its nukes. Israel isn't concerned much with what Syria, Egypt, Turkey, or Jordan might do as a check on Israel's overwhelming responses to any Palestinian guerilla action. If some Syrian jets came into Israel's air space and attacked a military objective, I have no doubt Israel would counter attack swiftly and possibly with a low-level nuclear weapon. All out war in the Middle East similar to the 1967 War would in this case be much more devastating to Israel's neighbors. Israel didn't have nukes then!

A shame that truthout should

A shame that truthout should fail so miserably in their reporting of the tragedy unfolding in Gaza. Clearly Hamas is no match for a modern military force but they have managed to launch over 6000 rockets into Israel. While the the loss of Israeli lives has been small. Living under the constant threat of bombardment, the daily exodus to air raid shelters and the destruction of property has pushed the Israeli's to employ leverage to stop this threat. Apparently Hamas found these measures, in spite of the toll they took on civilians a reasonable price to pay for the opportunity to bomb their neighbors.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.