Truthout Original

Facebook DIGG

Hamas Should Stop

by: Marc Ash, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
A Palestinian man carries the lifeless body of his son killed in an Israeli raid. (Photo: Mohammed Saber / EPA)

    With multiple diplomatic efforts to stop the violence in Gaza urgently under way, Hamas could greatly speed and aid those efforts by ceasing the rocket attacks on Israeli towns. The international community has long sought reform of Israeli military and social policy towards Palestinian lands. While it is true that some Israelis are resistant to any reform that would empower Palestinian residents, such reform would become inexorable absent deliberate provocation of Israel's military wrath.

    There is a false and misguided notion that the rocket attacks or other random acts of violence are not really that significant to Israeli citizens. Nothing could be farther from the truth. These attacks, all attacks, on Israeli targets, both military and civilian, are viewed by the Israelis in the most serious light.

    Israel must understand that its Arab neighbors see Israel as a clear and present danger to their way of life. They fight for that reason, not for any abstract hatred of Judaism. Israel must find a way to be seen as less threatening to the region. Israelis have failed utterly to become a part of the fabric of life in the Mideast. Without such a coming to terms with the place in which it lives, Israel can never realize permanence.

    Militarists, all militarists, take great comfort in the covenant of "peace through strength." The time has come for a realization that peace can also lead to strength. Hamas, like their right-wing Israeli counterparts, see armed conflict as holding a promise of a better future. Both groups fail their communities by holding fast to this false and failed notion.

    Hamas has long ascribed to a strategy of actions that would assure Israeli military action. The firing of rockets into southern Israel guarantees a large-scale military response. This empowers right-wing Israelis, and weakens all those who would pursue diplomatic or social solutions.

    Every diplomat who has ever tried to achieve lasting peace in the Israeli-Palestinian theater has ultimately been forced to confront the realization that their best efforts can be undone by small violent groups, who take actions that cannot be ignored.

    Hamas, in fact, does have the popular support of the Palestinian people. Even more so now. Will Hamas continue to provoke Israeli military reprisal to further elevate its status with Palestinian residents? Will Israel's right wing continue to choose war over peace as it clings to political power?

    Hamas's current strategy of firing rockets into southern Israel is not just "fighting back" against an oppressor; it is a step that Hamas knew full well would provoke a major Israeli military response. This plays in turn to the interests of the Israeli right wing.

    Israel can be moved to a cease-fire, but never with Hamas rockets incoming.

»


You can send comments to Truthout Executive Director Marc Ash at: director@truthout.org.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Thank you Marc, for a sober

Thank you Marc, for a sober analysis. I believe Israel wants peace, and politics by Hamas is stopping peace. It is irrational. It is the politics of national hatred and will never allow for peace and growth. They want to remain stuck in despair. I do believe Israel should try a less aggressive offensive such as a blockade that doesn't allow rockets and weapons, and allows for the Palestinians to get on with their lives. Hamas has to learn to get along.

israel is committing

israel is committing genocide...shooting fish in a barrel..palestinians in a cage..using my tax money. shame....any american who had to live for one day in either gaza or west bank would be lobbing anything they could in to the land of the occupier.oppressor..but americans aren't allowed to know about the Palestinian experience..are they?

Well, truthout and Mr Ash

Well, truthout and Mr Ash seem to have reached a new low with this piece, which even outdoes the mainstream media's tendency to lie on this issue. According to Norwegian Dr. Mads Gilbert, speaking on The Early Show on CBS, what we are witnessing is "an all-out war on the civilian population in Gaza." Dr Gilbert says his emergency medical facility sees about one Gazan fighter for every several hundred casualties (dead and wounded). To be far outdone by CBS in allowing the truth out is quite an accomplishment, Mr Ash. This massacre has nothing to do with those silly rockets, and you know it. To say "Hamas should stop" when we are witnessing a slaughter of proportions unusual even for the IDF is beneath contempt. Shame on you.

" The international

" The international community has long sought reform of Israeli military and social policy towards Palestinian lands. While it is true that some Israelis are resistant to any reform that would empower Palestinian residents, such reform would become inexorable absent deliberate provocation of Israel's military wrath. " Ya right. How has this "sought" thing played out in practice? Sternly Worded Letters (TM) perhaps? And how many is "some" Israelis? The majority of Jewish members of Knesset are among them. Palestinians have actually been sitting pretty quietly most of the time since early 2005. Hamas itself held true to the first 4 months of cease-fire. What did it give them? (diclaimer: no Hamas fan. Just too familiar with reality to fall for this crap.)

Does anyone really know 100%

Does anyone really know 100% who is firing the rockets?

Tell you what--let's end US

Tell you what--let's end US taxpayer funding of Israel's war machine. Let's take the west bank and gaza and call it Palestine. Let's take the pre-'67 borders and call it Israel. Let's have a dmz in the middle staffed by Middle Eastern peacekeeping forces. Then there'd be peace faster than you can say Jack Robinson.

Get along? Didn't Hamas

Get along? Didn't Hamas participate in a six month cease fire with the expectation that Israel would lift the almost total blockade on Gaza? While there were violations on both sides (including the continuation of settlement expansion on the West Bank) the cease fire held until early November. And, Israel did not lift the blockade. To the contrary by all reports over the last 18 months its troops were engaging in 18 mock urban warfare in preparation for an invasion of Gaza.

There is a lot of fear and

There is a lot of fear and as someone who has many friends and relatives in the Middle East, I wonder how that cycle can be broken when each side refuses to accept the other. And people's lives are disrupted, scarred, and permanently damaged through violence - so much violence. The tragedy is that both sides (as if there are only two, with Hamas, Hezballah, the PA, Arab states as well as the Likud, Kadimah, Meretz, the Religious Israeli parties, etc.) continue to bait the other and see the other as a separate "illegitimate other". I think eventually it will be like the Monty Python movie where the two medieval knights are fighting and one of them keeps losing an arm, and then a leg, and then another leg, but he still keeps fighting with his blood spurting and his spirit undiminished. Heroism or stupidity?

Marc, you are missing

Marc, you are missing something big. Whenever things are calm, they are calm for Israel, and Palestinians continue to suffer. When the last truce was in effect, Hamas respected it. Israel did not: 1) the economic blockade wasn't lifted as it was supposed to be, and 2) Israel bombed gaza on november 4th. This is well documented, and the numbers are even cited on Israel's mfa website! It's nowehre to be found in any mass media. It just goes to show how very very very short the memory of journalists are. Far from me to suggest that Hamas are being wise, but the notion that if they were, things would be different is complete nonsense. The Israeli fanatics are at least as equally responsible for triggering hostilities. It is however revealing that most journalists and leaders are appealing to Hamas rather than to Israel for a de-escalation. Could it be that Hamas is more likely to be reasonable?! :-)

Let me just finish this

Let me just finish this paragraph. "Thank you Marc, for a sober analysis. I believe Israel wants peace, and politics by Hamas is stopping peace. It is irrational. It is the politics of national hatred and will never allow for peace and growth. They want to remain stuck in despair. I do believe Israel should try a less aggressive offensive such as a blockade that doesn't allow rockets and weapons, and allows for the Palestinians to get on with their lives. Hamas has to learn to get along." WITH THE FOREIGN INVADERS THAT STOLE THEIR LAND AND PUSHED THEM INTO REFUGEE CAMPS. There, that looks better now.

The Palestinians surely

The Palestinians surely realize, after forty years, that the "international community" is not riding to their rescue, no matter what they do. The "international community" has given Israel a blank check. The Palestinians are on their own. Their choice is to accept the role of untermenchen in Greater Israel, or to fight, however feeble their means. I don't think we're in a position to criticize their choice.

Are you two high on

Are you two high on something? Israel wants peace.. Please research the facts on the ground before making such a statement. Israel has had countless oppurtunies for Peace, and never ever came through on its agreements for the sole purpose of taking more land. Read reports from Human rights groups, UN Reports, Eye-witness reports etc... then make that statement!

Israel's idea of peace is

Israel's idea of peace is Gaza to the West Bank with any needed genocide applied. It has never been anything else.

Israel wants peace!!?? Are

Israel wants peace!!?? Are you guys kidding me. Come on lets get real. Israel wants peace like the US wants peace; at the barrel of a gun or bombing raids. Made in the USA guns and bombs at that, the only thing that America can manufacture anymore are weapons of mass destruction. Israel is wrong pure and simple and America needs to finally stand up to the powerful Israel lobby in this country and say so. Why are we so afraid to critize Israel in this country? Oh I know why, because anyone who does gets crucified. Just ask Jimmy Carter. I thought only Republicans blamed the victims for their plight!

What would be your advice to

What would be your advice to a woman being raped? I assume you would say that she should just submit, so that her attacker will stop beating her up. After all, she is going to get raped whether she resists or not.

It is not Hamas that is

It is not Hamas that is slaughtering hundreds including women and children. It is not Hamas that is bombing schools, homes, and mosques. And it is not Hamas that broke the truce. On Nov. 4 Israel did, and Marc Ash should educate himself on this. See http://bbsnews.net/article.php/20090101212318310 I do not justify Hamas firing rockets, but it is like throwing firecrackers when the other side drops 2000 pound bombs. Marc Ash, where is your outrage at the mass killing of Palestinians, who are being killed at a 100:1 rate over Israelis?

Hatred? Irrational? No,

Hatred? Irrational? No, these days you have to fire home-made rockets to get anyone's attention. If the Palestinians didn't resort to that, they would be ignored for another 40 years and into oblivion. Give them their land back, tear down the Apartheit Wall and put the Zealot settlers on trial for disturbing global peace.

I disagree on one thing: it

I disagree on one thing: it IS an abstract hatred of Judaism on the part of Islam. Just look at the demonstrations around the world. Pro-Israel signs call for Israel's right to exist. Arab signs say "Kill all the Jews." In fact, many mullahs have urged Muslims to murder Jews and Americans anywhere and everywhere. That's why you see non-Israeli Jews being attacked in far-flung places like India.

Within the sick way our

Within the sick way our society is now working to stomp on the victims and bordered by the psychopathic killer ways and means of the Israeli genocidal machine, Marc does a very good job at asking the few extremists (of which IDF is killing few or none) to stop behaving like tantrumized babies - they are banging their heads on the floor but the Palestinian people are getting the bruises! Thanks, Marc!

We are always reacting to

We are always reacting to the immediate situation. The problem is that we still have not addressed the larger issue of rights to land that was taken from Palestinians, either by force or by harrassment leading to forced sale. The Zionist ethnic cleansing of Palestinian villages - "tihur"- begun in the Plan Delat initially in the 1940's; from Mispaarayim to "bi'ur ham etz" ) has left a deep and unrecognized crime. No state can find legitimacy ultimately without facing this crime and finding a way to make amends. I believe there are people of conscience on both sides of this horrific reality for whom killing of any kind is crime whether by rockets, bullets or denial of rights of livelihood. It is this larger reality we all must come to terms with and redress with fairness and justice.

Ah yes, the good old "stop

Ah yes, the good old "stop hitting yourself!" remark raises its ugly head again; a timeless classic used by bullies since Cain used it on Abel. If the Palestinians would only stop their lame useless attempts at defending themselves and just let the Israeli army pound them to dust the international community would finally be SO appalled that it would guilt-trip Israel into just giving the Palestinians territory back. Palestinians have played the victim card but it's just not as effective if you're still TRYING to fight back. So there you go Palestinians, stop hitting yourself and the Israelis will let up as soon as you say "uncle". In my school-yard days you had to say "uncle sam" and "aunt sally" before they let up on you, so consider yourselves lucky.

I heartily second the above!

I heartily second the above! Marc's analysis was both sober and pragmatic! The vast majority of both Israelis and Palestinians desperately want an end to the violence. Hamas ignores their desires for peace in order to promote its own narrow sectarian agenda, the destruction of Israel, which is clearly stated in its Charter! The Hamas Charter can be Googled and found online. If the level of violence directed at Israel by Hamas is reduced then Israel would reduce the aggressive level of its response! The international community and the U.N. need to put in place an internationally monitored and enforced bilateral cease-fire. Until that measure is put in place, Palestinian civilian residents of Gaza will continue to make up the vast majority of victims of Hamas' policy of violence!

Marc Ash is way of base on

Marc Ash is way of base on this! I didn't expect Mr Ash to be making such comments and putting the blame squarely on the Hamas. How has he forgotten that Hamas was a creation of Israel and the US as a counter to the Fatah and PLO! The continuous embargo and blockade of Gaza had been going on during the so-called ceasefire and Hamas' authority in the Gaza was systematically undermined by the Israeli govt.

This is all Israel's fault.

This is all Israel's fault. They are supposed to be a responsible nation. The Palestinians have as much a right to exist as you or I. There are 1.3 billion that follow the Islamic faith too. Time to make peace now instead of this.

With all the sympathy in the

With all the sympathy in the world for the Palestinians for the injustices done to them, it is difficult not to wonder at the motivation of leaders who are reportedly claiming victory over Israel. No rational person can doubt the cruelty done to Palestinian Arabs by Zionists and their backers over nearly a century. But responsible leaders don't keep urging their people to do collective suicide, much less from a sense that they're winning this battle. It is always painful to watch Palestinian and Arab spokespersons argue their case in public.

Truthout -- really? While

Truthout -- really? While Mr. Ash makes a few good points, it seems all too apparent that there far less "truth" getting out here, far too little Murrow-esque speaking truth-to-power.... The subject after-all is Israel, and in US politics, and in the media, (and all too sad in truthout), there is little stomach or "independence" left. Profoundly disappointing. Truth remains largely suppressed -- and not "out." (except I should add, in the many telling comments by informed readers -- who otherwise appreciate truthout -- on other issues)

While the article was

While the article was rational from a certain point of view, it didn't actually explain some of the facts on the ground. Hamas had observed a truce, but Israel continued its oppression of the Palestinians in the Gaza. The Palestinians of all stripes, not just Hamas, have tried to accomodate Israeli demands on numerous occasions, but to no avail. Abbas has practically prostituted himself, but the Israelis continue building illegal settlements on the West Bank and continue with their control of movement by the Palestinians in their own territory. Granted that firing rockets doesn't do any good, but it is an excuse, not a reason for the attack. There is no question that the Israelis would have found some sort of pretext or other to attack the Gaza, just like Bush would have found some excuse to attack Iraq, since this offensive was planned long ago. They are doing it now while Bush is still lameducking because they know that they have US support that will be missing under the next administration. The rocket fire is irrelevant. My question is why does Marc think that acceding to Israeli demands is going to induce the Israelis to play nicely when it has never done so before?

After reading this

After reading this simplistic, insensitive analysis and its implied endorsement of Israeli butchery, I have decided to remove my Truthout bookmark.

Wow, I never thought I'd see

Wow, I never thought I'd see Marc Ash write in defense of Israel! Maybe he's Jewish? However, there are many of the Jewish faith that are as outraged as I am at what Israel is doing and has done to the Palestinians since day one. I am not saying its OK for Hamas to lob rockets, but what else do you do when you are starving and dying in a refugee camp? If Israel would just take a few diplomatic steps that should be made by any decent democratic, wealthy country then I believe Hamas would agree and there would be peace. Honestly, who doesn't want peace??

This piece, though offered

This piece, though offered as Mr. Ash's "opinion" is greatly offensive. After reading his insensitive, simplistic "analysis" with its obvious bias in favor of the Israeli perspective, I have decided to remove the Truthout bookmark from my browser.

I'm sorry, but this is utter

I'm sorry, but this is utter nonsense. It is the abuer's perspective" "Stop making me beat you!" Here is the reality: In the West Bank Israel and the US have everything they have demanded from the Palestinians. A weak, docile leader loyal to foreign interests, no rocket attacks, only limited Palestinian resistance and yet, yet ... the targeted killings continue, the raids continue, the closures continue, the theft of land continues, the humiliations continue, the settlements grow and Jewish only roads continue to be built, and there is no peace. In other words, all that the Israelis really demand from Palestinians is that they disappear quietly. The focus should not be on the victim but the aggressor: Israel.

Hamas should Stop? Stop

Hamas should Stop? Stop what? Defending itself? Isreal is the one who has all the power and the made in the USA bombs - they have an obligation to stop their terrorism of the Palestinian people. No Justice, No Peace. Thats the reality, like it or not.

More of the same. What does

More of the same. What does Marc want Israel to give up or quit doing? Israel has treated the Arabs like dogs but the dogs are not to bite back.

Check the 'useby .......'

Check the 'useby .......' dates on the weapons that the Israelis and the arms merchants are using to murder children.

Israel's government and the

Israel's government and the vast majority of it's people want the Palestinians to have an independent country. Hamas and a large percentage of Palestinians (Gazan's, overwhelmingly, voted for Hamas) do not want a 2 state solution and are dedicated to the destruction of Israel. Israel wants a permanent peace with a Palestinian state. Hamas wants peace only after Israel is destroyed or commits suicide. They attacked Israel from almost day one after Israel, unilaterally, left Gaza. They broke the cease fire consistently and only thought of the cease fire in terms of arming themselves so that they could destroy Israel. They spent their resources, in that time of "quiet," on long range missiles rather then helping their people. They have blocked every peace initiative by targeting and killing Israeli citizens. I agree, that Israel is not faultless in the wider issue of producing a 2 state solution. Their settlement activity has been a deeply flawed and immoral activity. But it is correct in protecting it's citizens by "taking on" Hamas.

I think many of the negative

I think many of the negative comments on this piece miss the point. i.e., that militarism doesnt work, whether practiced by Hamas or by Israel. And Hamas militarism alienates Palestinians in Gaza from much potential support in the rest of the world including the US. The depth of Israel's bad faith in this process will be only become clear if it is met with a more pacifistic response. Palestinians may have a responsibility to defend themselves against Israel's aggression but rockets directed at civilians cannot be construed as self defence. However much we understand the frustration and pain that fuels these rockets, they are only playing into Israel's hands.

Zionist Spin So, it's all

Zionist Spin So, it's all Hamas' fault? False. Israel broke the cease fire on November 4, the US election day, when the world was looking elsewhere. The provocations, as usual, came from the Israeli side according to plans long held and deliberately crafted so that the uninformed would automatically blame the victims (Palestine) for the latest round of Israeli state terrorism. This is a long and despicable pattern. American Jews "should stop" their mindless parroting of Israeli lies. Hamas should start targeting their rockets on military targets. What they are doing is useless militarily, and morally. Why lower yourself to the standards employed by the Israelis? Like indiscrminate bombing and terrorism? "The international community has long sought reform of Israeli military and social policy towards Palestinian lands." Yeah sure. That's very comforting when you're starving in the cold due to a military siege, and randomly bombed from the air. Israel should be isolated and cut off from all military and financial aid. Period. Their policies are no different than the Nazis, and very reminiscent of the liquidation of the Warsaw Ghetto.

The problem is, so many of

The problem is, so many of us are analyzing the situation without really having a lot of information. I just finished reading a number of articles in the Asia Times (on line) which pointed out how extraordinarily complex the insurgent movement in the Mideast has become since we invaded Iraq. I suggest other readers go to that site, as often their reporters have access to news from the 'other side'. Since our invasion, a mushrooming of insurgent groups have spread from there in to Gaza via neighboring countries. We've all been led to believe that it is Hamas alone who is shooting rockets in to Israel. That might not be the case at all. One group in particular, vaguely related to Bin Laden,which has already infiltrated in to Gaza, plans on attacking within Israel, as well as from Gaza. It has no political or philosophical connection with Hamas. As an aside, another article mentioned most of the tunnels in Gaza are solely set up to bring in food, clothing, medical supplies, etc. from Egypt - for the survival of the Palestinian civilians. We have to be honest - the Israeli government has created a pogrom environment within Gaza, and the Palestinians have needed to create 'lifelines' in order to survive. Apparently, the Hamas' tunnels for their weapons are separate. Right now, the Isrealis' are bombing tunnels - which ones do you think they are hitting?

Here is a diary entry of

Here is a diary entry of 1940, written by Yosef Weitz, former head of the Jewish Settlement Agency: "Between ourselves, it must be clear that there is no room in this country for both peoples....The only solution is Eretz Israel, at least the Western Israel, without Arabs, and there is no other way but to transfer the Arabs from here to the neigboring countries - to transfer them all - not one village, not one tribe should be left." Excerpted from Chomsky, "Middle East Illusions".

I'm responding to the

I'm responding to the anonymous critic who wrote, "Thanks Marc for making me regret my past donations. I won't make the same mistake in the future." What the hell is that supposed to mean? Do you disapprove of Marc for being too pro-Israel, like some others writers who are no longer "bookmarking" Truthout? Or do you hate Marc for being insufficiently anti-Hamas? Seems to me that Marc is trying not to "halve the difference" but to acknowledge that there are some truths that both sides are saying. My own personal feeling is that it's too late -- that Israel, like the Crusader states almost a millenium ago, has been identified by its neighbors as a form of western European imperialism. And, like the Crusader states, it has done nothing to help it fit into the neighborhood, and now it's just too late. But I'd be delighted if wiser politicians came to prominence in the US and Israel and the Arab states and created a modus vivendi where now there seems to be none. It'll never happen, though, if people trying to be fair-minded, like Marc, are met with a knee-jerk "fuck you."

Imaginal exercise: The

Imaginal exercise: The Palestinians send no rockets or mortars or suicide bombers for five years so that it is indeed apparent they have decided to not use violence. What do you think Israel will do? or Hamas recognizes the right of Israel to exist, Israel evacuates settlements, accepts no right of return and compensation instead for loss of land and assets and agrees to two state solution along 67 borders? What do you think Israel will do? hint 1/3 of Israel's water supply comes from the aquifer beneath the West bank so that technically morally legally said water belongs to the Palestinians. So do you think Israel wants peace and hence would withdraw from the settlements and risk Jewish terrorism? or do you think Israel actually requires violence from Palestinians so they can continue to fulfil God's will by regaining control of all of Judea Samaria for only then will the Messiah come? Meanwhile, fundamentalist American creationists can't wait for the Jews to regain Judea-Samaria for only then will Jesus return a second time. And they say Islamic fundamentalists are crazy.....

I found this to be a really

I found this to be a really reasonable and genuine invocation to peace by Ash. The history of willful provocation by hard-liners on both sides to be encapsulated by any pithy comments. Likud's insistence on invasive settlement's was always a provocation, as is the "right of return (by destruction of Israel)" given lip-service by (let's face it) most Palestinian political factions... But wow, the commenters on here are pretty terrifying group of "blame-Israel-always" and "every-Palestinian-rocket-is-a-resistance-lollipop" reactionaries. I'm getting a little weary of reading about how all Israelis (sometimes casually expanded to all Jews) are "pogrom-causing Nazis." It's not only disgusting; its massively ill-informed.

the first, and easiest,

the first, and easiest, thing to be done to save lives, is for Hamas to stop locating themselves among innocent citizens. whatever else is done or not done, why are they not being called to account for that? btw, the code used to determine whether the poster is human or a machine is UNREADABLE!

Unbelievable that Hamas

Unbelievable that Hamas whose rockets are responsible for 4 deaths should stop so that Israel won't kill another 500 plus people? Blame the victim mythology lives during a time of racial genocide.

I'm thrilled that Paul, the

I'm thrilled that Paul, the writer of the "Imaginal exercise" comment is clairvoyant enough to tell us how Israel will still behave exactly the same when others take the minor step of "recognizing its right to exist" (explicitly admitting that such a basic recognition has not yet been proffered).

What would happen if Iran

What would happen if Iran and the Arab countries would stop sending the Palestineans weapons and help them to set up an industrial base instead?

Wars are caused by fear.

Wars are caused by fear. Israeli wars are caused by fear of losing advantage. Israeli paranoia and megalomania are the leading breeders of anti-semitism.

Marc Ashe, I am in complete

Marc Ashe, I am in complete disagreement with you on this issue. It is the Zionist Jews in Israel that are the instigators of this latest attack on the Palestinians in Gaza...and has nothing to do with whether 'Hamas' actually lobbed any rockets at the Unoccupied areas of Israel. What proof do you have that the Israelis did not sneak over the Border just long enough to lob those rockets to make it appear as though it were Hamas doing the deed ? I suspect it is just another Reichstag used for the same purpose as the 'attack' on the World Trade Center....to have a 'legitimate' excuse to further the aims of the Zionists in world conquest. How can anyone actually believe that a mosquito on the ass of an elephant would really make any difference to that elephant. That is the same category I place this trumped-up military assault on Gaza by the Israeli Army. Think, Ashe, and see what a laughable idea you are trying to cause people with even half a brain to believe. Hamas are not that Stupid !

The Palestinian resistance,

The Palestinian resistance, including Hamas, did stop, and for prolonged periods, many times since before there was Hamas and after, only to see the blockade intensify, and so the assassinations, demolitions, land seizures, road blocks, the apartheid wall, the deliberate and systematic undermining of all that can be used to sustain life for the Palestinian people as people and on the level of individuals. Apologists for Israel as a racist state can always call on the victims to die peacefully, but alas: even animals refuse to do so, and the resistance continues. If history teaches anything, it is that Israel has either to exterminate the Palestinians and the rest of the Arabs as the Europeans did to the natives in our America and in Australia, or face its end as a colonial, racist state, as South Africa did. Choose you side.

Marc, I'm reading over these

Marc, I'm reading over these comments and I can only conclude that you have really upset the beehive, here. We all have to find a way to smile on our brothers. It doesn't help to assign blame or criticize, even when blame and criticism are so richly deserved by everyone involved. Especially then, in fact. Desmond Tutu's approach might work: first we acknowledge truth, then reconciliation becomes possible. People who are looking to avoid blame will *never* reconcile. People who are willing to face truth can hope for peace.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.