Share

An Unnecessary War

by: Jimmy Carter  |  The Washington Post

photo
A Palestinian confronts Israeli soldiers during a protest Thursday in the West Bank. Thousands of demonstrators gathered in Ramallah to demand an immediate halt to Israeli attacks. (Photo: Eric Gaillard / Reuters)

    I know from personal involvement that the devastating invasion of Gaza by Israel could easily have been avoided.

    After visiting Sderot last April and seeing the serious psychological damage caused by the rockets that had fallen in that area, my wife, Rosalynn, and I declared their launching from Gaza to be inexcusable and an act of terrorism. Although casualties were rare (three deaths in seven years), the town was traumatized by the unpredictable explosions. About 3,000 residents had moved to other communities, and the streets, playgrounds and shopping centers were almost empty. Mayor Eli Moyal assembled a group of citizens in his office to meet us and complained that the government of Israel was not stopping the rockets, either through diplomacy or military action.

    Knowing that we would soon be seeing Hamas leaders from Gaza and also in Damascus, we promised to assess prospects for a cease-fire. From Egyptian intelligence chief Omar Suleiman, who was negotiating between the Israelis and Hamas, we learned that there was a fundamental difference between the two sides. Hamas wanted a comprehensive cease-fire in both the West Bank and Gaza, and the Israelis refused to discuss anything other than Gaza.

    We knew that the 1.5 million inhabitants of Gaza were being starved, as the U.N. special rapporteur on the right to food had found that acute malnutrition in Gaza was on the same scale as in the poorest nations in the southern Sahara, with more than half of all Palestinian families eating only one meal a day.

    Palestinian leaders from Gaza were noncommittal on all issues, claiming that rockets were the only way to respond to their imprisonment and to dramatize their humanitarian plight. The top Hamas leaders in Damascus, however, agreed to consider a cease-fire in Gaza only, provided Israel would not attack Gaza and would permit normal humanitarian supplies to be delivered to Palestinian citizens.

    After extended discussions with those from Gaza, these Hamas leaders also agreed to accept any peace agreement that might be negotiated between the Israelis and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, who also heads the PLO, provided it was approved by a majority vote of Palestinians in a referendum or by an elected unity government.

    Since we were only observers, and not negotiators, we relayed this information to the Egyptians, and they pursued the cease-fire proposal. After about a month, the Egyptians and Hamas informed us that all military action by both sides and all rocket firing would stop on June 19, for a period of six months, and that humanitarian supplies would be restored to the normal level that had existed before Israel's withdrawal in 2005 (about 700 trucks daily).

    We were unable to confirm this in Jerusalem because of Israel's unwillingness to admit to any negotiations with Hamas, but rocket firing was soon stopped and there was an increase in supplies of food, water, medicine and fuel. Yet the increase was to an average of about 20 percent of normal levels. And this fragile truce was partially broken on Nov. 4, when Israel launched an attack in Gaza to destroy a defensive tunnel being dug by Hamas inside the wall that encloses Gaza.

    On another visit to Syria in mid-December, I made an effort for the impending six-month deadline to be extended. It was clear that the preeminent issue was opening the crossings into Gaza. Representatives from the Carter Center visited Jerusalem, met with Israeli officials and asked if this was possible in exchange for a cessation of rocket fire. The Israeli government informally proposed that 15 percent of normal supplies might be possible if Hamas first stopped all rocket fire for 48 hours. This was unacceptable to Hamas, and hostilities erupted.

    After 12 days of "combat," the Israeli Defense Forces reported that more than 1,000 targets were shelled or bombed. During that time, Israel rejected international efforts to obtain a cease-fire, with full support from Washington. Seventeen mosques, the American International School, many private homes and much of the basic infrastructure of the small but heavily populated area have been destroyed. This includes the systems that provide water, electricity and sanitation. Heavy civilian casualties are being reported by courageous medical volunteers from many nations, as the fortunate ones operate on the wounded by light from diesel-powered generators.

    The hope is that when further hostilities are no longer productive, Israel, Hamas and the United States will accept another cease-fire, at which time the rockets will again stop and an adequate level of humanitarian supplies will be permitted to the surviving Palestinians, with the publicized agreement monitored by the international community. The next possible step: a permanent and comprehensive peace.

    -------

    The writer was president from 1977 to 1981. He founded the Carter Center, a nongovernmental organization advancing peace and health worldwide, in 1982.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Israel has no real solution

Israel has no real solution to the plight of the Palestinians--other than they hope they go away and if they won’t go away there is their slow, creeping erasure. This is similar to America's policy toward its indigenous Indians. It worked in the USA (the Indians were all killed or corralled into reservations) but is not working in Gaza because Israel lives in a sea of Arabs. Short of killing all the Arabs, a solution is needed. Some adult needs to tell the Israeli's to stop. A neutral military force needs to be placed between the two peoples. No rockets, blockades or settlers allowed. Go back to the '67 armistice lines, and deliver the two state solution preached by all but practiced by few. It's in Israel’s favor never to solve the crisis--that allows them to have their settlers create "facts on the ground." Adults need to say no to this.

I found the statement that,

I found the statement that, at one point, having achieved an informal ceasefire between both sides, Israel refused to confirm this verbally. In other words, it was a real ceasefire, acted upon by Israel, but Israel simultaneously would not verbally substantiate this phenomenon. Is this about Israel's wounded ego? Is this pride underlying this whole issue, about who looks like a coward by cooperating openly in a ceasefire, about who loses face or looks weaker? Which brings me to an interesting point; that the psychological age of the people running the Israeli government is quite adolescent.

Simply unbelievable! The

Simply unbelievable! The horror and murder that is being inflicted upon the Palestinians and the destruction of schools and infrastructure are all crimes against humanity. The murder of well over a hundred children!!!! For God's sake can no one in the international community stand up to the Us and Israel and finally declare them to be the most aggressive terrorist organizations in the world today! What must we all do to get these monsters to stop their crimes?! Perhaps if all the worlds citizens imagined in a very visual way that it is their children that are being blown to pieces , or maimed for life, that this would help us to come to terms with all of our responsibility to help in any way that we can to motivate them to stop these horrendous crimes against humanity! I am a white christian Canadian. So many of my friends and acquaintances have been saying the same kinds of things as what I have stated above. Our government and media, on the other hand, has fallen to the lowest moral level ever and has been backing the US and Israel and as such puts us into the position of being complicit in terrorist activity of huge proportions!

It seems like I can only

It seems like I can only wait for the day Jerusalem is surrounded by troops as the Lamb said would come. Though only to scare the living hell out of the Jews. Right now it seems America is the only thing holding that back from happening.

It looks like a holocaust in

It looks like a holocaust in the making, this time with the Palestinians the clear victim of this vicious cycle.

The Israelis government are

The Israelis government are authoritarian fascists in their approach to Gaza. Bombing densely populated area of Gaza is an excuse for genocide. I thought the Jewish people were better than this considering what happened in Europe all but one generation ago. the West Bank should be an integrated zone and respectably Israel and Gaza both the respective countries. I suggest that since our economy is in such serious trouble that we stop all funding of Israel and pull our bases out of the Middle East and close several of them around the World. The Cold War is over and as history has shown us empires die.

After seeing this stupidity

After seeing this stupidity march on for as long as I can remember -- I'm 44 and I became aware of the ongoing conflict at around the age of 10 or so -- I find it hard to believe that the powers that be really want to find a solution. I watched Arafat as he "never missed an opportunity to miss an opportunity," and I've seen the Israelis either violate terms of an agreement or find a reason to break a truce. Inasmuch as I think this current conflict is at all distinct from the rest (not much, honestly), I see Hamas' rockets as a taunt inviting Israel's current, and inevitable, response. It is a very complicated situation, one that requires more space than I have here, not to mention more expertise than I have here (pointing to my head). But, like so many unfortunate conflicts, whether they be (inter)national, domestic, family, etc., it is always the children who suffer (metaphorically and literally).

Fascinating indeed. "ONLY 3

Fascinating indeed. "ONLY 3 PEOPLE WERE KILLED." WOULD THE GOOD CARTER FEEL SO CASUAL IF THE TRHREE WERE HIS WIFE, DAUGHTER AND ANOTHER RELATIVE. SHOULD A PEOPLE BE FORCED TO LIVE IN PERPETUAL FEAR OF A MISSLE, HAVE TO RACE FOR SHELTERS AT ALL TIMES OF DAY OR NIGHT. SHOULD THOSE NOBLE PEOPLE EVER LEARN TO SHOOT STRAIGHT ---WHAT THEN. WILL CARTER THAN SAY ONLY 10 THEN 100 THE 1000 ETC??? UGH!

This is another Holocaust? I

This is another Holocaust? I don't recall Jewish shopkeepers in 1940 in Poland launching rockets into the towns of innocent Germans.

Let's get some facts on the

Let's get some facts on the table: in 2008, 4000 rockets were fired at Israel. How many rockets hit the US before it invaded Iraq? During the "truce", 360 rockets hit Israel. The government did not respond, and suffered harsh criticism. The Hamas is a terrorist organization, supported by the Iranian, which took over Gaza and would not cooperate with the moderate Palestinians and the legal government, nor would it cooperate with Egypt. No wonder Egypt kept the crossing closed. They knew well that the Hamas leaders don't care about civilian supplies and are only interested in guns and weapons. How can you ask Israel to open it gates, when an Arab country is keeping them closed?? And, what is a defensive tunnel? Gaza is crossed by 1000s of tunnels, that were and are used to smuggle guns and weapons, hide explosives and attack Israel. The world can keep closing it eyes and pretend that Iran and the extremest are peace seekers- they are not. When they will, they will find out that the US, Israel and Europe are open and willing to talk. I am not ignoring the horrible pain of the simple man in Gaza, but we must all remember that this simple man elected a known terrorist group as a leader. Just like Hitler inflicted pain on the same people that elected him, Hamas is inflicting pain on their own population. I just hope and pray it would not take a decade to figure it out!

I feel deeply indebted to

I feel deeply indebted to Jimmy Carter for doing so much to promote rational and compassionate dialogue between the combatants. That said, there is no end to a conflict when extremists - both Arab and Jewish extremists - can fan the flames of revenge whenever the conflict appears to subside. The current attack on Gaza appears to be timed with the approaching elections in Israel in mind. Bibi and friends need to prove that they are King Kong. I think we do need a demilitarized zone between the two sides, where ever the border might be defined. That can only come from a US president - one who is in office. Let's encourage Obama to do the right thing.

Dear Mr. President: "Hope"

Dear Mr. President: "Hope" is now meaningless. The gang rape of Gaza will continue until the Israelis are spent. Take that anyway you'd like. This little fiasco undertaken by Israel, will neither give Israel peace nor security. This "fool's errand" will give Israel more insecurity and violence. Hizbollah, Hamas, and Israel's archenemy Iran, will only gain. That is the inevitable outcome of brutish militarism. The innocent of Israel will suffer as have the innocent of Gaza and the West Bank. That is the truth of political hypocrisy. As you very well know Mr. President, one reaps what one sows. The chains can never be broken and the violence will only escalate. Cynical? Yup. Mr. President, you know the truth and you know the moral ramifications of what Israel has undertaken. As America's last and only "moral" president, you know better than anyone. America MUST divest itself from the Israeli insanity and Israel must stand alone and be judged by international standards. Let the chips of justice fall wherever they may. respectfully, skulz fontaine Gaza Strip, Utah/Nevada

I cannot believe that the

I cannot believe that the Israeli's actually want this... the deaths of hundreds of Hamas and Palestinian people. That makes no sense. But for Hamas to tell Carter they wanted condition on the West Bank, too, was a simple political move for power on the part of Hamas... unacceptable. So, who'll be the "winner" here? Hamas will believe it will come out as Hezbolah did in the north a winner and defender of the country, East and West! That's the only real answer to the reason for this new war...the violence of Hamas.

I love that any claims that

I love that any claims that Israel might be in the wrong are considered anti-Semitic. True, the Pals broke the cease fire with the rockets. Israel however did jump in with both feet....and landed on innocent people as well as UN relief workers. Bravo. I guess Israel wasn't wrong in denying aid to those in Gaza in the first place, either?

That's because Jewish

That's because Jewish shopkeepers hadn't already been living in a concentration camp for 60 years, as the Palestinians have. It is one thing to be ostracized, bullied and robbed - it is something entirely different to be routinely bombarded by a modern war machine, starved and killed (and have it all blamed on you!).

It is a sad fact that Jimmy

It is a sad fact that Jimmy Carter is about the only national figure with the guts to stand up to the racist, apartheid Jewish state of Israel. The USA could stop this carnage in a heartbeat with a little "tough love" by demanding that Israel be content with its 78% of Palestine, giving back the 22% that is overrun by Jewish radicals, and allowing Palestinians their own state and basic human rights. The Israeli military occupation of the Palestinian people must end.

Israel controls the area and

Israel controls the area and will use any means at their disposal to achieve their goals. With our help, Israel have the military, economic and political power to do whatever they feel, even the violations of UNSC resolutions. Didn't we went into Iraq (one of many excuses) because Saddam Hussein did not comply with Security Council resolutions? As of this writing, more than 700 innocent killed, and more than 2000 injured; I wonder if the radical Zionists already forgotten what their Shoa?

Why is the whole world

Why is the whole world calling this a war? On one side we have a 40 billion dollar military and on the other we have some guys making their weapons in the kitchen. No, this is not a war, this is genocide, this is premeditated ethnic cleansing, banning the press first should have been a dead giveaway. So far Israel has killed over 700 people, mainly women and children, they’ve bombed UN schools, stopped relief and used white phosphorus, all in an area that they’ve already fenced off like a cage in the desert and stopped anyone from watching. No this is not a war it is genocide.

First and formost one cannot

First and formost one cannot but continually restate the fact that the Governments of Israêl and the Hamas are two very distinct entities from the Israëli 'Ehud six-pack' or 'Mohammet tea-drinker'. It's like for us : the Bushies are NOT the American people and their policies are often ( if not always) against the welfare of the population. This can be said to a certain degree about every country but these two (Israël and PalAuthority) get kudos in this area. There are people on BOTH sides who are trying, even as we speak, to get the ball rolling in the direction of peace and accomodation. But on one side you have a well oiled propaganda machine that equates everything said against its goals as anti-sremetic.And on the other side you have a well oiled propaganda machine that yells western cultural and religious bias against anything that dares to insinuate a possible different goal. None of this would bother me too much except that the oil in these machineries comes from the blood of innocent civilians. And maybe soon my (our) blood so much of this area being the powder keg that if it goes off into 'insanity land' will most likely lead to a major conflagration. So I guess this will be the crux the crucible that will reveal the extent of insight our new president Obama possesses : can he make the peace against all this religion based political fanaticism? Can,as another post said, a grown-up step up and please just point the way to the God-brats who are playing with everybody's health? I sure hope he has it in him!

This IS another holocaust,

This IS another holocaust, complete with concentration camps, starvation, intimidation, and ethnic cleansing. And the United States has the power to end it by simply cutting off the funds being used to perpetrate the criminality, and dedicate them to the rebuilding of the Palestinian Homeland. Let's not be taken in by the current PR effort to make us feel sorry for the poor, beleaguered Israelis. Let's demand that Israel and its big brother moneybagger, the US, stop the genocidal war and do what is right. Give up the stolen Golan Heights. Live within your boundaries instead of constantly stealing more land and alienating those from whom you steal it, under the guise of self-defense.

It is not genocide and it is

It is not genocide and it is not a holocaust. It is a war between the Palestinians and the Israeli's. It is an unfortunate war that started in 1947 when the UN decided to give the Israelis their original homeland back. 62 years later they are still fighting this war. Neither side will accept what the other wants and it doesn't look like they ever will. Each side must be convinced they are going in the wrong direction through international diplomacy which is totally lacking.

For those you who might

For those you who might actually want to know how the horrors going on in Gaza came to be, I strongly reccommend Helen Thomas' article "War is Hell" and even more Steven Nivas' "War of Choice", both available at commondreams.org. It is obvious to me that most of the pro-Israel voices here are unlikely to avail themselves of these resources. They like the neocons have a direct line to the Truth so cannot be bothered with mere facts. But I suspect that others of you will be in a better position to counter the outrageous pro-Isreal propaganda filling the MSM. I agree with @fempatriot, dr wu, and David Spaethe that it is long past time to apply some tough love to that seriously spoiled brat we've helped raise. We could start by cutting off the $3+billion allowance we've been shelling out. (don't pardon the pun, it was intentional)

this seesm to be the problem

this seesm to be the problem that faces the US with regards to Israel http://www.aipac.org/ its ful of lies and at best its a insult to peoples intelligence.

The suffering of the people

The suffering of the people in Gaza is indeed horrible. Too bad Hamas does not seem to really care! Lobbing 4000 rockets on Israeli CHILDREN (and families) is not likely to get the sympathy of those who are being attacked every day. [Did Iraq send missiles onto L.A., or N.Y., or Washington, D.C. before the US invaded on a Rovian pretext?] That the situation is deplorable , all can agree. That it is a"Zionist plot", or all Israel's fault, or another 'holocaust', [ deliberate, thoughtless provocatively stupid and inaccurate anti-Jewish terminology by the way] or an appropriate response to Palestinian isolation in Gaza, completely ignores real history --- of Arafat's never missing an opportunity to miss an opportunity, of Hamas' self-aggrandizing and self-promoting schemes regardless of the effect on ordinary Palestinians, of the Arab countries' perfidy and disinterest in helping the Palestinian people, or the Jordanian (remember CIS-JORDAN?) usurpation of what was supposed to be a separate country for the Palestinians. All admittedlya result of the callous British indifference to either the Arabs or Jews of the area... and just a way for them to wash their blood-drenched 'Christian' hands of another uncomfortable,unfortunate , but for them irrelevant colonial situation.

The United States is the

The United States is the world's largest arms dealer. Unless Pres. Obama's call for national unity through rebuilding the nation's infrastructure pulls workers away from the factories creating the defensive & offensive weaponry used globally for slaughter, the US will remain top distributor of death. Talk about beating swords into plowshares! How can we talk of peace when we give Israel all this destructive power? Ambassador Carter (that sounds about right) should be deputized by President Obama to lead the cause for peace and goodwill in the Middle East. Namaste- -+ IconDaemon +-

In Gaza we are witnessing

In Gaza we are witnessing re-enactments of Guernica and the uprising in the Warsaw Ghetto, but irony is lost on those Israelis who, in their pursuit Zionist dreams, visit the same harms on Palestinians as historically befell their own people. Perhaps the most naked irony is that because Hamas has thus far refused to accept Israel's right to exist, the Israeli government has set out to make Hamas cease to exist.

B"H Hamas's charter calls

B"H Hamas's charter calls for destruction of Israel and claims that Jewish civilians wherever they are found worldwide are legitimate targets. Is this a potential peace partner? Israel withdrew from the Gaza and received thousands of rockets from Gaza in return. Maybe if Hamas put their energy into building instead of destroying, they could build up the infrastructure of Gaza and provide for their own people instead of inviting misery upon themselves. What country in the world would allow itself to be bombarded on a daily basis by missles? It's time the Palestinians stop the hatred, bigotry, and violence and direct their energies into something peaceful and beneficial for themselves.STOP BEING APOLOGISTS FOR FANATICS AND TERRORISTS.. Stop the blame game and accept responsibility for inciting and inviting Israeli retaliation. This NO HOLOCAUST, Palestinians are not targeted for genocide. This is a WAR and tragically, death and heartbreak is the outcome for all sides.

Sorry, Mr. Carter, neither

Sorry, Mr. Carter, neither unnecessary nor a "war". As the late comedian Bill Hicks observed about the first Gulf War, "A war is when _two_ armies are fighting." Give the Palestinians a few hundred nukes, an air force, small arms, training, and a mountain of armored vehicles at American taxpayer expense, and then you can call it a "war". This is exactly like what we did in Iraq - an _invasion_ followed by an _insurgency_. And weirdly enough, in both cases, the insurgents, for some reason, don't love their invaders for stealing or destroying everything they had! Isn't that just impossible to fathom? -And after all, there's that religious / historical excuse to justify it! I mean, don't you think that the Isrealis would just go along with it if Italy, backed by China and Russia, were to invade Israel on the pretext that it used to be part of the Roman Empire? Face it, Mr. Carter, religious people see exactly what they want to see in their God. And until the "Big 3" of the Jehovan faiths dump all that vile, brutal, judgmental, genocidal crap in the Old Testament, they will ALWAYS have a "holy" excuse for behaving like killer apes. When both sides of a conflict share similar delusions concerning the righteousness of their own religious hatred, war will always be, in their minds, "necessary".

This is not a war..This is a

This is not a war..This is a massacre. How sad...yet appropriate somehow.. that it is a former American President who is willing to take a stand against the apartheid murderous actions of Israel. President Carter is not new to this cause...He had the distinct honour of being the only American President in recent history with the guts to go against the 'pro-Israel at any costs stance' favoured by the US..when he dared to formally criticize the apartheid actions of Israel not that long ago. Not only was that just NOT done...but it developed into a gigantic scandal...which resulted in this very honourable of men suffering undeserved character assassination. No one..and I do mean NO ONE gets away with criticising Israel..no matter how obnoxious Israel's actions..and horrific her crimes against humanity. George W. could not be expected to behave any differenty than he has. After all...lets not forget this is the same American president who lied his country into an illegal immoral war against an innocent sovereign nation... for profit. When it comes to crimes against humanity...G.W. Bush is right up there with present and former leaders of Israel. As long as people refuse to see the truth about the racist policies of Israel and the horrors perpetuated against the people she so brutally occupies... and kills at will. Israel will continue to use the tired but effective 'right to defend herself' and good old guilt as rationale for any and all behaviour..no matter how heinous. This will continue until people challenge the right of one people to humiliate, enslave, and attempt to exterminate another. Meanwhile...innocent Palestinians continue to die most horribly..while Israel tries to play victim.

Where is the U.N.? Weren't

Where is the U.N.? Weren't they created to intervene in situations just like this? What else are they for?

For centuries most leaders

For centuries most leaders have accepted the heresy that violence leads to redemption. This is now inbred in our culture and even most of our religious traditions (even though the original teachers said otherwise). Give the Palestinians a choice between electing ineffective and corrupt leaders in the PA or honest and militaristic leaders in Hamas--this is like so many of our own elections, choosing the "lesser of two evils". After elections we insisted on, the USA becomes a churlish bully and refuses to accept the democratic voice of the electorate!!! Then an economic, commercial, and in most ways total blockade of the people. Not wise; not Christian; not democratic; and not conducive for peace. After Israel withdrew from Gaza, they maintained control over the international border with Egypt; official crossings there had Israeli personnel controlling and largely blocking crossings. Gaza was made into a large open-air prison, has been starved into a ghetto condition, and is now being destroyed acre-by-acre just as Warsaw was.

wise old Arab proverb:

wise old Arab proverb: vinegar destroys its vessel.This is true of all & any.

The result of millennia of

The result of millennia of religious/ethnic hypnosis. The problem is so genetically ingrained that neither side has any actual leadership - the chain of command reaches back to forefathers long decomposed under the desert sands. This conflict isn't between the living, but between ghosts.

@ David Spaethe - You're

@ David Spaethe - You're right, the psychological age of all the leaders involved is quite adolescent. Then again, the whole conflict is quite adolescent. "We don't like you so we're not going to recognize your right to exist" answered by "Oh yeah? Well, our bombs are bigger than your bombs! We'll MAKE you recognize us, or you won't exist!" Follow that with a few punches, bombs going off, missiles landing on both sides, and both sides are complaining that they've been hurt but won't do anything to end the conflict.

And to think we all cheered

And to think we all cheered so loudly in 1948!

To the poster who asks.."

To the poster who asks.." where is the UN"...the answer is simple. The UN has tried over the years to introduce a multitude of resolutions to curtail the violence of Israel both in occupied Palestine and in Lebanon: however, the US..the world's only remaining superpower and unconditional supporter of Israel..always and I do mean ALWAYS... vetoes ANY AND ALL attempts to curtail Israeli aggression. Consequently..this is where we remain today..as Israel..with the full support of the US... slaughters the people of Gaza with a show of military strength far beyond the scope and abilities of the Gazans to protect themselves or escape the slaughter. Israel has nothing to be proud of in this..the latest in a series of attempts to control, and finally, destroy the indiginous peoples of occupied Palestine. Shame on all of us. Israel is allowed to bomb and as such slaughter the people of Gaza..and no one is willing/able to challenge the US and Israel..to stop the slaughter.

Thank you -- finally -- for

Thank you -- finally -- for letting the true expert and Nobel Peace prizewinner, former President Jimmy Carter, speak on Palestine. He, after all, has been there, oversaw the Int'l-monitored democratic election of Hamas in Gaza, and has a plan. I agree with those above who state the obvious: why isn't this honorab le man our envoy to the Middle East, diplomat to Palestine? We've got US warmongers calling the shots, ignorant statements from SOS Rice re excusing IDF for massacring Gazan citizens because "it's diffiicult to avoid" given the dense population. One way to avoid it is NOT to shoot into Gaza at all. How about diplomacy, Condi?

It's amazing how anyone

It's amazing how anyone would listen to Carter. He's off his rocker. He is a terrorist sympathizer. Hell, how is he going to accomplish anything when he gave everything away when he was president. This guy is a joke. Please go away and leave running the government to competent people. Israel has all rights to defend itself from these terrorists lobbing bombs into Israel. They were warned and now they'll pay to play. It's a war with Israel they wanted and it's what they've got. Go Israel, don't listen to this dribble of an ex-unpopular president. The same president who gave away the Panama Canal and Taiwan to China. If there was ever a pro communist/terrorist it would definitely go to Carter. You will never have peace in the Middle East as long as you have all these terrorist clans. Just stating the common sense things that you've never seemed to get. Go back to building you houses and get out of the government, you couldn't do it back then and you aren't needed now.

Whose interest is served by

Whose interest is served by keeping the Middle East a powder Keg? We should make weapons manufacture unprofitable. No Nukes for Israel or anyone.Hurry into a Green Economy so we can stop killing for oil/gas.Better yet,Lets make a Rule:"Thou Shalt not Kill".

Israel says that Hamas is to

Israel says that Hamas is to blame for Civilian Palestinian deaths, because Hamas fires their rockets from Civilian areas. If two terrorists fired at our Police from within a crowd of American women and children, would we think it OK if the Police killed the entire crowd of women and children in order to kill the Terrorists?

We can talk until we blue in

We can talk until we blue in the face, however, unless the people of America are ready to come together and push for a discontinuation of the $3 billion plus dollars of U.S. taxpayer money we ship off to these genocidal maniacs; intent on destroying the Palestinians we are simply whistling in the wind. Sticks and stone may break their bones but talk will never hurt them. But then again, we didn't take any real action to impeach the war criminal GW Bush, what could we possibly do to Israel? And long as the American public continue to respond like sheep toward the actions of the wolves, more of the same is expected.