Opinion

Facebook DIGG

A Wake-Up Call for Science Education

by: Alan I. Leshner  |  Visit article original @ The Boston Globe

photo
A study by Trends in International Mathematics and Science finds that the US is behind many industrialized countries in preparing students in math and science. The US is not even represented in the top ten nations for education in math and science. (Photo: Anthony S. Bush / The Capital-Journal)

    President-elect Barack Obama has named Harvard and Woods Hole physicist John P. Holdren to serve as assistant to the president for science and technology and director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy. Three other renowned scientists - Jane Lubchenco, Eric Lander, and Harold Varmus - also were tapped by Obama to fill key roles.

    Holdren's appointment, announced weeks before the inauguration, took place earlier than that of any other science adviser in modern times. Even so, the reinvigoration of US science advice cannot happen soon enough.

    The latest alarm bell just rang and it's official. The United States is once again missing from the list of top-10 science and math education countries. A new Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study confirmed that America lags behind many other industrialized countries at the task of preparing tomorrow's labor force. Long-term economic growth depends on a fully competent talent pool, including workers who can excel in a technology-based economy. But young people in many less-developed countries now outperform their American counterparts in both science and math.

    Interestingly, eighth-graders in Massachusetts actually tied for first place worldwide in science, while the state's fourth-graders ranked second among nearly 60 other nations. Clearly, the United States is capable of sustaining high-quality K-12 science and math programs. We simply are not providing equal educational opportunities for all of America's children. Now is the time to tackle the science education problem if we want long-term, stable improvements in our national economy and quality of life.

    We learned about US students' stagnant science scores while also, not coincidentally, confronting the largest number of job losses since 1945.

    Science and technology have been powerful engines of prosperity since World War II, but, sadly, science education and the versatility of the American workforce are both in decline. In 2006, the respected Programme for International Student Assessment reported that 15-year-olds in the United States ranked 17th on science tests and 24th on math tests, compared with teens from 29 other wealthy nations. The United States is failing to address the problems of science education for tomorrow's workforce.

    The problem demands a multifaceted response. Competitive pay for teachers should be our top priority. If we want to recruit and retain the best teachers, we need to reward them. Obama has proposed providing scholarships for those who teach in schools with the greatest needs, while training thousands of science and math teachers and boosting early-childhood education. He also has said he wants to help "ensure that state assessments measure higher-order thinking skills."

    Such plans demonstrate a commendable vision. We hope that US policy-makers, guided by Holdren and colleagues, also can find a way to send a clear signal that science generally and science education specifically are highly valued, respected, and essential for all children, not just those in magnet schools or in Massachusetts. That means increasing funding for science education at all levels, as well as federal research and development more broadly. Federal research and development has declined, in real terms, for the past four years.

    Uniform national science-learning standards will be critical, too. Currently, students' science-learning goals vary from state to state, and thus a child who excels in one region may fail elsewhere. This disparity across the country can create unacceptable inequalities in the opportunities provided to the next generation of Americans.

    Sputnik, the world's first satellite, ignited America's will to win the innovation race with the Soviet Union. Congress and President Dwight Eisenhower responded in 1957 by quadrupling funds for the National Science Foundation and launching the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. That decision triggered decades of breathtaking achievements, from the first man on the moon to the information superhighway and the decoding of life's genetic blueprint - the human genome.

    Today's economic crisis should similarly ignite America's will to ensure that our children's future is at least as good as our own. New jobs and prosperity require investment in science, technology, and science education now.

    -------

    Alan I. Leshner is chief executive officer of the American Association for the Advancement of Science and executive publisher of the journal Science.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

single parent homes where

single parent homes where mom has to leave the kids to fend for themselves because she can't afford child care, drugs more readily available than ever, sexual education available on network tv, children taught oral sex is not sex, video games instead of homework, todays children and young people are soooooooooo challenged to put their brain to use. We are too conditioned to NOT think so we will follow the politicos without questions. Just do it (nike). We are a pathetic nation of whiners and spoiled rotten babies.

One of the characteristics

One of the characteristics that marked the rise of the Asian economic tigers, Taiwan, China, South Korea, Singapore, etc., is that prior to their emergence, they installed excellent science and math education in their schools. The USA used to have a much lower trade deficit mainly because we exported a lot of high tech stuff. We no longer do that because other countries have passed us in the ability to do and think scientifically. Instead, thanks in large part to the anti-intellectualism that is being preached by the right wing christianists, we now have a national mindset that focuses more on "magic." People no longer believe that things happen for a reason, basic cause and effect. Now they think everything is some sort of unexplainable phenomenon done by some sort of supernatural force that is unknowable. As long as this attitude influences public policy, the country will continue its present journey down the crapper. Talking to you, McElroy.

" Science and technology

" Science and technology have been powerful engines of prosperity since World War II, but, sadly, science education and the versatility of the American workforce are both in decline. " I couldn't agree more. However, funding levels, at least for most disciplines in the field of medical research, are approximately one-third of what they were at the end of the Clinton era. This begs the question, who in their right mind would risk a grant dependent career on the whims of those elected to office? This question has not been lost to those searching for career opportunities, especially when witnessing the carnage of thousands of established labs closing their doors every year of this administration. Science is a powerful engine for prosperity, but if I were young enough to have the choice to do it over again, I would look elsewhere. It is under-appreciated by government officials, and is not even a side-show relative to the vast military industrial complex. Science is also an easy target for cuts as opposed to cutting of other services that you might more readily notice. Being a, if not the, leading nation in the world is not a birthright. Since WWII, and until as recently as the '70s, the US has been dominant in science, and education as a whole. However, other industrialized nations such as those in Europe, as well as China, India, etc, have not only caught up, but offer free education through college. Our edge is vanishing unless we take our heads out of the sand.

We have become an incredibly

We have become an incredibly arrogant and ignorant nation at the adult level and then fault children for bad living situations and poor schools. Republicans take pride in voting against programs that provide meals at schools or that provide medical care for children and push for charter schools so their children can attend better schools with better teachers and to hell with everyone else. It has become popular to bash teachers and children for a situation that is the product of a very selfish society and a government with representatives that spend more money on tanks and bombs and wars and occupying foreign countries which kill thousands of children, than it is willing to spend on education, and yet we are surprised that children in the USA today are not able to overcome this handicap. What is amazing is the colossal ignorance and lack of critical thinking demonstrated by the adults of this country voting by the millions for Bush not only in 2000 when it appeared he was a dry drunk and mentally incompetent, and again in 2004 when it was clearly established that he was in addition a liar and barely coherent on his best days.

One of the things that hurts

One of the things that hurts science education so much in the US is christian fundamentalism, religion that is anti science, and therefore prevents the proper teaching of evolution, all of the biological sciences, and the history of our planet. Other countries do not have to deal with such lunacy.

Texas Aggie notes that right

Texas Aggie notes that right wing Christians are part of a national anti-scientific push, but we must also look within the ranks of the left on this issue. How much of the left thinks that a good mathematics background is not essential to critical thinking and analysis? Anti-intellectualism is within our camp too. It would be considered inconceivable among left wing intellectuals to have a poor grasp of history, but having little or no mathematical sophistication is par for the course. The anti-mathematical attitude is far bigger and more insidious than just the right wing.

This is going to be an

This is going to be an uphill battle. Americans, by and large, have little respect for science. For instance, 70% of Republicans and 30% of Democrats in Congress say they don't believe in evolution. Most Americans purchase worthless remedies and supplements, in direct rejection of scientific studies that prove conclusively that they are worthless. The most popular television shows are those that promote pseudoscience and superstition. Virtually every newspaper carries an astrology column. Most Americans believe Uri Geller can bend spoons with his mind. Most Americans believe in visitations by aliens from other worlds. And scariest of all: 95% of Americans say they believe in a personal god, despite the complete absence of empirical evidence. In short, Americans believe what they want to believe - science be damned! It all begins in the schools. Teachers truly qualified to teach science are rare, because they, themselves, were poorly educated in science. Not long ago, the Dean of the medical research arm of Harvard University was asked by Charley Rose how many of his roughly 200 researchers were educated in the United States. He answered, "None!" Enough said.

A good start on science

A good start on science education would be to educate law enforcement that the substances and equipment used in a chemistry lab have other uses besides creating drugs or bombs! We've just heard that here in Canada, a brilliant high school science student with a clean record has been charged by police because some clerk in a plant store turned him in for buying some gardening chemical out of season (if it was so bad why was she selling it out of season?) and, the charges have stuck! So, this "chemistry is evil" mentality seems to have struck here too.

As a small child I was taken

As a small child I was taken outside at night to see Sputnik. It fired my imagination and led older kids to catch up in science. They built a rocket in the back of our mentor's shack. The rocket went up and left a crater about 40 feet deep and forty yards in diameter. All the jazzed effort of the previous generation had faded by my high school years. Even so, Washington is only one of eight states requiring biology, the only science requirement, to graduate. While living in the East I found Indians and Asians have had the scientific jump on us for so long we will have to light a Sputnik fire under our young. P.S. The first American, "one small step..." was boringly scripted and can't hold a candle to Yuri Gorigan's extemporaneous, "I felt as if I were dancing". Good thing this administration is concerned with the ability to think. Ronny Reagan read cue cards and the current prize idiot can't read, "See Spot run."

For a start, how about we

For a start, how about we let math and science be taught by people who know the subjects, and get the educational theorists off our backs. Second, how about we stop trying to force-feed the poor kids, and give them a chance to understand the basics first. California's new algebra-in-eighth-grade requirement is an atrocity. The best-prepared kids are ready for algebra in ninth grade. Shoving everybody into algebra in eighth grade is a waste of a year they should be spending preparing for algebra. A lot of those kids will be repeating their high school math in community college; a lot already do. Big ideas in education breed disaster.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.