Share

Canada Orders US War Resister (and New Mother) Deported

by: Ann Wright, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Iraq war resister Kimberly Rivera faces a military court-martial once deported from Canada back to the US. (Photo: Courage to Resist)

    The Canadian government has ordered the deportation of Kimberly Rivera, the first US woman Iraq war veteran resister to go to Canada, and four other US war resisters. Rivera, her husband and three children, including a newborn daughter, must depart Canada by January 27 or be deported. Rivera now lives in Toronto with her husband Mario, son Christian (six years), daughter Rebecca (four years), and newborn Canadian daughter Katie (six weeks).

    Rivera served in the US Army in Iraq in 2006, but refused a second tour in Iraq in 2007 and instead took her family to Canada. Her first tour in Iraq convinced Rivera that the war was immoral and that she could not participate in it.

    Rivera's Pre-Removal Risk assessment application and request to stay in Canada on humanitarian and compassionate grounds were denied by the conservative Stephen Harper government, although the Canadian government refused to join the Bush coalition of the willing and join in on the war in Iraq. The Canadian military's participation in the war in Afghanistan has been controversial as Canadian casualties rise.

    The War Resisters Support Campaign in Canada believes the Canadian Immigration Minister's decision to deport Rivera and four other US war resisters is based on the need to have the deportations completed before the Canadian Parliament returns in late January. The Parliament adopted a resolution in June 2008 that recommended to the Harper government that "conscientious objectors" to wars that are not authorized by the United Nations be allowed to apply for permanent residence status in Canada.

    Immigration Minister Jason Kenney has said that the refugee claims of war resisters are "bogus" and that he "has no sympathy for them." Kenney has made it clear that his government intends to go against the will of Parliament and the will of Canadians.

    If Rivera and the other US war resisters are deported to the United States or return voluntarily, they will face a military court-martial. Robin Long, the only other US soldier to be deported from Canada, was court-martialed in 2008 at Fort Carson, Colorado, and received a 15-month prison sentence and a dishonorable discharge, the longest sentence given to a war resister during the Iraq war.

    Other US war resisters in Canada face deportation even earlier than Rivera. Chris Teske has a deportation date of January 20, Patrick Hart, his wife Jill and their son on January 29 and Dean Walcott on January 30.

    Several other war resisters in Canada are appealing negative decisions in Canadian Federal Court. The court has stayed the removal orders of war resisters Corey Glass, Jeremy Hinzman and Matt Lowell. The Hart family faces deportation January 29 and will ask the court for a similar stay.

    Corey Glass has since been granted a new application to stay on Humanitarian & Compassionate grounds. Jeremy Hinzman's appeal date for his negative decision has been set for February 10 and Matt Lowell is waiting to hear whether his appeal will be heard.

    There are several Canadian groups actively opposing the government's actions. For further information on those efforts, contact the War Resisters Support Campaign.

  

»


Ann Wright is a 29-year US Army Reserves veteran who retired as a colonel. She was a US diplomat, who served in Nicaragua, Grenada, Somali, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Sierra Leone, Micronesia, Mongolia and Afghanistan, where she helped reopen the US Embassy in December 2001. She has traveled to Gaza twice in the past three months and will make her third trip in May 2009. She is the co-author of "Dissent: Voices of Conscience."

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

As a Vietnam draft resistor,

As a Vietnam draft resistor, Canadian immigrant(1967) and subsequently Canadian citizen of long-standing, I hate to see Canada lose its status as a sanctuary for those who oppose illegal and unrecognized wars. The quality of people migrating to Canada for this reason is extremely high. War resistors are moral, conscientious and often spiritually attached. They are politically active and help guide democracies in the pursuit of peace and diplomacy. Refusing to shelter these resistors is the same as approving and supporting an unjust, unnecessary and illegal war. Shame on you Canada.

the harper gov. does not

the harper gov. does not speak for the majority of canadians, who stand against the illegal wars of that criminal bush. that is why harper had to suspend the gov., because the people and their reps have no confidence and want him stopped.

So it sounds like Canada has

So it sounds like Canada has their own version of Bush.

There was a time when I

There was a time when I admired Canada.

How we are dragged down

How we are dragged down since the days of Pearson & Trudeau. Harpokkkrates is a warmonger, a betrayer of us all.

Don't you mean "shame on

Don't you mean "shame on _us_", Vietnam draft resistor? US deserters didn't fare better under the Liberal government for the same reason they aren't being welcomed by today's Conservative government: they volunteered, and refusing to serve at present isn't honourable. The US owes Iraq. The US should never have invaded Iraq in the first place but it now has a duty to see Iraq through to a better time. Shame on anyone who thinks it's okay for the US to abandon Iraq once again after having made such a mess of it.

Me too, Fr Tothus. Any idea

Me too, Fr Tothus. Any idea why such decent people don't get rid of their Bush clone? Our Constitution (plus of course invertebrate legislators) sticks us with a President for four years. But the Canadians, with a much more sensible parliamentary system, have no legal impediment to dumping their arrogant, sleazy PM. Say it ain't so, Canadians!