Share

Inauguration Day Is Time to Move On

by: Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Philadelphia - President-elect Barack Obama, cheered by onlookers along the train route Abraham Lincoln took on his journey from Illinois to Washington nearly a century and a half earlier. He will be inaugurated Tuesday. (Photo: Reuters)

    As Barack Obama prepares to be sworn in, I recall an old National Lampoon record album - record albums, remember those? - from the final weeks of the Watergate scandal that comically suggested that President Richard Nixon be given a "swearing OUT" ceremony. There followed a series of blistering curses and calumnies directed at the soon-to-be departed and disgraced chief executive, delivered by someone impersonating the Rev. Billy Graham.

    You have to wonder if amidst all the fanfare and hoopla Barack Obama isn't quietly swearing a bit beneath his breath as he beholds what his about-to-be-predecessor has left for him. Hercules mucking out the Augean stables is as nothing to the heaps of bungle and botch confronting the next commander-in-chief.

    Not that there's anything new about freshly inaugurated presidents inheriting a mess. George Washington, who took the oath of office on the balcony of Federal Hall in New York, at the corner of Broad and Wall Streets, was taking over a newly independent, penniless collection of squabbling states that couldn't even pay the soldiers who had won the Revolution. Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton had to negotiate a bailout from the Banks of New York and North America just to cover the salaries of the president and Congress.

    When Abraham Lincoln was sworn in on March 4, 1861, his hand on the same Bible Barack Obama will be using, the union was dissolving into Civil War. Jefferson Davis already had been inaugurated as president of the Confederacy just two weeks earlier. Lincoln's predecessor, James Buchanan, whose inert and inept presidency had done nothing to prevent the union's imminent collapse, told him, "If you are as happy on entering the White House as I am on leaving, you are a very happy man indeed," then skipped town to his country estate near Lancaster, Pennsylvania. (A little more than four years later, he would drive his carriage to the Lancaster depot and stand in silent tribute as Lincoln's funeral train passed.)

    Franklin Delano Roosevelt, of course, became president as the country was shivering and starving through the fourth winter of the Great Depression. Twenty-five percent of us were unemployed, stocks had plunged seventy-five percent after the Crash of '29 and new investment and industrial production were nonexistent.

    So it has been throughout America's stormy past: two steps back for every three forward, periods of boundless optimism countered by times of fear and desperation, a government alternately depended upon or despised. The crises Barack Obama faces may not seem as overpowering as those confronted by Lincoln or FDR, but perhaps no other president has taken over a government in such total and complete disrepair. For the last eight years, George Bush has ruled over a government the very concept of which he and his cronies loathed.

    As right-winger Grover Norquist - once described by The Wall Street Journal as the Grand Central Station of conservatism - infamously opined in 2001, "I don't want to abolish government. I simply want to reduce it to the size where I can drag it into the bathroom and drown it in the bathtub." This, apparently, was the Bush team's fantasy, although rather than reduction, they seemed to have favored a strategy of malign neglect and abuse to get the job done.

    It's not just the financial meltdown and Katrina and Iraq and Afghanistan and alleged violations of civil liberties and the Constitution - although especially chilling was this week's Bob Woodward interview in The Washington Post with retired judge Susan J. Crawford, convening authority of military commissions - the woman in charge of determining which Guantanamo detainees should be brought to trial.

    She told Woodward the military tortured Mohammed al-Qahtani, a Saudi who allegedly was planning to be the 20th hijacker on 9/11. "I sympathize with the intelligence gatherers in those days after 9/11, not knowing what was coming next and trying to gain information to keep us safe," she said. "But there still has to be a line that we should not cross. And unfortunately what this has done, I think, has tainted everything going forward."

    A few weeks ago, the nonpartisan investigative Center for Public Integrity released an in-depth report titled "Broken Government," a chronicling of more than 125 of what the center calls "systematic failures across the breadth of federal government," from the Securities and Exchange Commission to the Federal Labor Relations Authority to NASA. You can read it at: http://www.publicintegrity.org/investigations/broken_government/.

    "Many of the failures are rooted in recurring themes," the Center reports. "Agency appointees selected primarily for ideology and loyalty, rather than competence; agency heads who overruled staff experts and suppressed reports that did not coincide with administration philosophy; agency-industry collusion; a bedrock belief in the wisdom of deregulation; extensive private outsourcing of public functions; a general failure to exercise government's oversight responsibilities; and severely slashed budgets at understaffed agencies that often left them unable to execute basic administrative functions." Whew.

    In its defense, the White House has turned out three tomes of its own, all of which may be read at http://www.whitehouse.gov/infocus/bushrecord/index.html. One of them is titled, "100 Things Americans May Not Know about the Bush Administration Record." The 100th thing is, "Directed Unprecedented Preparations for a Smooth Presidential Transition." Not a moment too soon, some would say. Time to move on.

  

»


Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program Bill Moyers Journal, which airs Friday nights on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Smooth transition to a new

Smooth transition to a new administration? With all those "midnight" administrative changes in existing environmental safeguards? Even "smooth preparation" for transition is a charade.

There's a fundamental

There's a fundamental difference here, which must not be swept under the proverbial rug: Buchanan and Hoover were dense and obstinate, but not criminal. Bush and his enablers are criminal as well. They must be brought to justice under the Constitution they undermined, if only to restore that Constitution.

I 100% agree with Regina and

I 100% agree with Regina and "Anonymous". Regina, if you are a lawyer, please apply to the DOJ, via change.gov We need to re-establish justice and I hope Eric Holder will lead that

"systematic failures across

"systematic failures across the breadth of federal government," I would point out that it was the systemic failures of the POLITICAL APPOINTEES that managed (to abuse the term managed) the federal government, NOT the career civil service staff who failed, who abused and distorted the federal government. Lay blame where it belongs, not at the feet of the civil service, but rather the political appointees, that abused it.

Millions of people were

Millions of people were killed and injured by the Bush government based on lies and greed. Where is the justice in moving on without holding these criminals accountable?

We move on at our peril

We move on at our peril unless, as many US citizens have come to understand, that the litany of criminal activities be fully investigated and their perps punished.

Move on? Sweep it all under

Move on? Sweep it all under the rug? So we can "heal"? This little meme is exactly what those criminals would have us believe. Very convenient for them. Don't buy into it.

Any president who appoints

Any president who appoints as Secretary of the Treasury a person who has 'forgotten', to the tune of $35,000, to enter his taxes correctly is making an inexcusable error of judgment. Politicians may be scabrous and dishonest fools. We, the people, aren't. An appalling way to start a new presidency. Innocent mistake? Why in hell would Obama, and the scurvy politicians who back him, try to put that one over? I'm a democrat. Time to make a clean sweep. Geithner, Summers and the unspeakable Rubin should be sent out to do an honest day's work somewhere. They are a scourge. Have been for years. Obama will have to do better than that to make up for 8 years of hell.

TIME TO MOVE ON? Am I

TIME TO MOVE ON? Am I getting that right? Maybe you should try that line out on everybody on BOTH sides of our twin invasions that are missing limbs. Maybe you should tell that to the people that lost their homes, jobs or retirements so that the vile fraternity at the top could rake in still more money than they could possibly ever need. I want to live in a nation of laws, not cronyism, and that means accountability to those laws. It means punishment that fits the crime, not punishment without PROOF of crime. Our Constitution is in tatters, Lady Liberty has been gang-raped by varying degrees of gangsters for eight long evil years, and you, Mr. Winship, have the temerity to suggest that it's already TIME TO MOVE ON? The far-right-wing upper-class rodents wreck this country in every conceivable way, and we're going to stroll away from it? NOT WHILE I LIVE. You want me to move on? -Then it will have to be on a road paved with the severed heads of our Most Royal criminals.

Sorry, Jack, I mean Michael.

Sorry, Jack, I mean Michael. No moving on. When he comes to town, our town, any town, many towns. We will be waiting with signs and shoes and body counts. Sorry, Michael, not moving on until he is charged, tried, convicted and jailed.

The great question is: who

The great question is: who was the worst president or person claiming to be president in American history, James Buchanan or George W Bush? But I think this answers the question: if Obama, God forbid, were assassinated, would Bush stand at the station as the funeral train passed? Of course not. He is the worst person, morally as well as substantively, to ever occupy the White House. And, yes, I remember Richard Nixon.

I declare the term "move on"

I declare the term "move on" to be at last irrelevant and undescriptive of what we need to do. The original "move on" was intended to move the country past the political hanging of Bill Clinton after his fling with Monica Lewinsky. It's use now does not fit the current context. We need a new term such as "restore" or "renew", that refers to our government, our mindset, our focus, our watchfulness, our lives. We need much more than to "move on", we need accountability. IMO Regina at 21:36 has it correct: Bush and many of his cabinet must be independently investigated under suspicion of committing war crimes, and other high crimes, and put on trial. Let's stop this farce of "at long last he's gone so we can return to normal" because that won't happen until justice is served.

We definitely should

We definitely should prosecute officials who committed crimes, and very serious crimes were committed. However, the worst thing Bush did was not even against the law. He did everything he could to stall action on global warming, and now it may even be too late to save the human race. This alone makes the state of the country (and world) much worse than ever before. Everything else mentioned makes the situation even worse.

Agreed, tis NOT the time for

Agreed, tis NOT the time for moving on. Guess what? We can -- and must -- "move forward" but in tandem hold these rascals accountable, even to war crimes. We're a clever, persistant lot. Our republic is also based on the "rule of law". At the same time, we need to support the handful of our Congressional leaders who are thinking straight, such as Senator John Kerry, who voices his reservations of our 'plans' for Afghanistan (see YouTube, etc.), says it's beginning to look alot like Afghanistan -- and he should know. Fortunately for us, he's NOT a member of the administration, but Chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee -- and capable of standing up to conventinoal thinking when he chooses. Let's cover his back and support him in his DISSENT.

Israel to Palestinians: time

Israel to Palestinians: time to move on. Mugabe to the Zimbabwean people: time to move on. US to the 2 million+ dead and wounded in Iraq and Afghanistan: time to move on. The Fed to the tens of thousands of US military personnel suffering from Gulf War Syndrome: time to move on. Same to you, former and current residents of New Orleans: move on already, it's time. Madoff victims: that's right, time to move on. Or, how about - get over it? Or: whatever, dude...

Of course we are all angry

Of course we are all angry and want to "get even", BUT we do not have time for that crap. We need to get busy putting this dilapidated country back together and becoming the world leader we all think we are or should be in all the positive stuff, not in the vindictive "witch hunt" that you head hunters are screaming for right now. Maybe there will be some good verdicts. Maybe not. The best verdict is a reducing unemployment rate, restoration of civil right for all of old and young and improved access to the terrific health care that some of us, like me and my civil technical management retirees have access to right now. EVERYONE should have the same coverage all the time. It world in too many other places and damn the stockholders and their earnings ratios. Paul Fako Forward Thinker.

President Obama must be

President Obama must be reminded of his pledge that no man is above the law. An independent commissioner should be appointed in due time to conduct a methodical inquiry into what has happened to America in the last eight years. A prosecutor could be appointed after the commission finishes its work. Another measure would be the make the USA a spons0r of the International Criminal Court. Messieurs Bush, Rumsfeld , Cheney and Libby would probably allow their passports to expire.

Prosecute, Prosecute,

Prosecute, Prosecute, Prosecute.... Nothing is more important.

Prosecute, prosecute,

Prosecute, prosecute, prosccute is right. There's more, too... Let's take action in the streets, in the courts, in the woods, at civic functions, in our daily lives. It's time for justice and a new day.

Post-inaugural address, this

Post-inaugural address, this reads differently: no mention of "war on terror" bemoans Foxy 'News', alternative news notes a possible stepping down on Afghan 'surge' -- and new emphasis on RESPONSIBILITY. Given that Obama's change.org registered the MOST enthusiasm for Holding Bushies Accountable Under the Law -- check it out -- I'd say issue of move on vs. prosecute has already been resolved. Let's face it: the political landscape looks radically different -- now that Bush is safely contained in Crawford.