Share

Let Us Now Set Aside Childish Things

by: George Packer  |  The New Yorker

photo
Obama signs his first official document as the 44th president of the United States. (Photo: Molly Riley / Reuters)

    There were echoes of Jefferson, Lincoln, and Roosevelt, but President Obama uttered no words today that will be quoted in a hundred years. He has never been a real stem-winder or a coiner of unforgettable phrases; what he's always been is a great explainer, who pays the rest of us the highest compliment-the appeal to reason. Today he explained why Americans need to grow up, and the tone and vision of his speech-sober, realistic, clear-minded, undaunted-were absolutely equal to the occasion and the times, down to his requisite scriptural passage: "The time has come to set aside childish things." (This nonbeliever was also pleased to be included, for once, in the roll call of faiths-especially after Rick Warren's utterly sectarian invocation.)

    The speech was, among other things, and in spite of the gracious gesture at its opening, a devastating repudiation of ex-President Bush, who seemed to be shrinking physically as well as historically whenever the camera found him, until, by the end, his unimportance was almost bewildering. Now he is gone.

    The rest of the world was listening, too, and Obama saved his most eloquent words for them: "Because we have tasted the bitter swill of civil war and segregation and emerged from that dark chapter stronger and more united, we cannot help but believe that the old hatreds shall someday pass; that the lines of tribe shall soon dissolve; that as the world grows smaller, our common humanity shall reveal itself; and that America must play its role in ushering in a new era of peace." He also set for his goals in America's two ongoing wars a responsible withdrawal from Iraq and a "hard-earned peace" in Afghanistan-not victory. Here, too, Obama showed that he won't allow tempting rhetoric to undermine what's possible, what's real, which is part of his call to a "new era of responsibility." But no lines were more passionately delivered by this restrained and conciliatory man than these: "We will not apologize for our way of life nor will we waver in its defense. And for those who seek to advance their aims by inducing terror and slaughtering innocents, we say to you now that our spirit is stronger and cannot be broken. You cannot outlast us, and we will defeat you."

    He delivered something better than rhetorical excitement-he spoke the truth, which makes its own history and carries its own poetry. As for the poet who had the impossible job of immediately following the new President, I'll leave it to you to judge.

    The most reassuring thought on this Inauguration Day is that we Americans always get the President we deserve.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Pundits were nearly

Pundits were nearly unanimous in their disappointment that President Obama's speech had no convenient sound-bites. They conveyed their disappointment so well that one might believe the speech to have been an utter failure for this lack of simplistic sloganeering. We never seem to get enough of slogans, though, so when someone offers intelligent exposition in more than one simple sentence, we are challenged. Thank goodness for a President who wants to elevate the discourse and the level of intellect among the populace.

OK- SIT DOWN, SHUT UP, AND

OK- SIT DOWN, SHUT UP, AND GET TO WORK !

Now let's just hope

Now let's just hope Democrats were using a poker face when they stifled any discussion of justice being brought against bushco. Now we'll finally know if they were actually listening all along. We'll see.

I'll bet these lines will be

I'll bet these lines will be quoted in 100 years: "Because we have tasted the bitter swill of civil war and segregation and emerged from that dark chapter stronger and more united, we cannot help but believe that the old hatreds shall someday pass; that the lines of tribe shall soon dissolve; that as the world grows smaller, our common humanity shall reveal itself; and that America must play its role in ushering in a new era of peace."

Agree with seeing "put away

Agree with seeing "put away childish things" as the center of the speech. It remains to be seen how our country will change, since there are endemic and deep rooted issues - such as the cycle of repression and relief in relation to poor people, which has been described by Frances Fox Piven. This is related to the seeming unsustainability over the long term of endless growth, which is the engine of capitalist economy. Many of us remain excluded in various ways, and the hard work necessary to remedy these exclusions is not going to happen just by transparency and open door events for the public. On change.gov and now on the whitehouse.gov website my main impression is information overload.

Sad headline and scriptural

Sad headline and scriptural choice. Without regard to the text, the words "childish things " conjured up images of the government's dismissal of the brutally killed children and babies in Gaza.

I am excited to see Bush

I am excited to see Bush leave, but this family is concerned about some of "Team Obama's" inaugural steps. Picking Rick Warren to give the inaugural prayer (a very Christian inaugural prayer for a country nominally secular) was an insult to my family. But Team Obama really showed their colors with the deletion of the Bishop Robinson's prayer from the pre-inaugural broadcast. What does it say about getting past "childish things" when the new President will not be seen on national television associating with a gay bishop? What do I tell my near 3-year old son? "President Obama does not want to be associated with your family". Or, "President Obama asks a man to pray who thinks that your 2 dads are incestuous, pedophiles"? It is still Politics over People. Change? Was that a childish hope?

I noticed that there were

I noticed that there were only a few breaks for applause. Instead, people seemed to be really listening, thinking, taking it in, much like I expect they did for The Gettysburg Address. It was a wonderful speech and will be quoted in paragraphs and its entirety.

I disagree. This twenty

I disagree. This twenty minutes will hold junior-high civics students spell-bound for generations to come. From the all-too-contemporary references, to the underlying message, President Barack Hussein Obama took a nation about ready to throw in the towel, and told us, "Yes, it will be hard. But together, yes, WE can."

We didn't deserve the wartime-deserter and his snarling puppet-master -- they were illegally appointed through acts of high treason. And Obama didn't deserve to inherit the disaster that he fought to be the man to try to change. So now it's up to US, to ALL of us, to take off our Clark Kent shirts, and live up to the people that we need to be -- that we CAN be.

Re this comment: "Picking

Re this comment: "Picking Rick Warren to give the inaugural prayer (a very Christian inaugural prayer for a country nominally secular) was an insult to my family.." Let me speak for my family, then. 1: While I am not gay, I find Warren's views on sexual orientation medieval and appalling. 2: But I have a 6 year old son, and the thought of him growing up in this world if nothing is done to address climate change fills me with terror and despair. We can survive stupid wars and bigotry--societies always have. It is not at all clear that we can survive the damage that we are doing to the earth. Climate change is our truly existential threat; it dwarfs all other issues. 3: I make it a point to listen to right-wing radio frequently. At this point, climate change seems to be the primary focus of these troglodytes. There is a drumbeat about how the science is bogus, and that it is all a plot to impose a leftist dictatorship. We are in for a huge battle to get something meaningful done on this issue. 4: Rick Warren is on the right side of this issue, and a crucial ally. We desperately need to splinter the right wing in its opposition if we have any hope of really doing something about climate change. 5: Our President clearly understands this, and like FDR, is willing to find his allies where he can, even if they believe appalling things. And I am more thankful for this than I can say.

Β«...but President Obama

Β«...but President Obama uttered no words today that will be quoted in a hundred years.Β» What is this obsession with Down-South people (I'm from Canada) with "unforgettable phrasesΒ» ? Did you not just live with a President who was and still is famous for his own version of "unforgettable phrases" ? Barak Obama is not my President. I'm stuck with a lackluster Conservative Prime Minister who has been pedalling backward ever since his recent reelection and is a bit of a shame for my country. Yet I have listened to most of President Obama's speeches since his departure from Chicago last Sunday and they were remarquable, all, in realism, in heart-felt images and references, combining brilliance and honesty to a degree long forgotten in Presidential garb. Who the hell needs "unforgettable phrases" but people so exposed to Madison Avenue 10 seconds clips that they may well have forgotten that sentences can be longer and more complex than a sound-bite, and actually mean something. Just keep the man alive is all we should ask. The rest will come in due time. Stupidity and greed has left the White House and has been replaced by an exceptional individual. Calm down, "unforgattable phrases" addicts, and listen. It will make a difference.

"We will not apologize for

"We will not apologize for our way of life nor will we waver in its defense." Meaning we'll keep that oil flowing, regardless of the cost? What if the rest of the world wants some of the 25% of the resources we're consuming or wants some of the billions we so casually lavish on Wall Street and Halliburton and Lockheed?

The childish things I hear

The childish things I hear in many responses are those that cannot put aside their discord still. Some people are so cynical and narrow minded they insert irrational meanings into events and assume the future is predetermined. Making snap judgments about Obama and his cabinet upon its very beginning makes no sense, is indeed childish - a mere continuation of our legitimate response to the traumas foisted upon us by the past administration is out of place at this time - get a grip

'The most reassuring thought

'The most reassuring thought on this Inauguration Day is that we Americans always get the President we deserve." Did we (or the rest of the world) really deserve Bush/Cheney? If so, what did we do, and how can we avoid doing that in the future? President Obama: "We will not apologize for our way of life nor will we waver in its defense. And for those who seek to advance their aims by inducing terror and slaughtering innocents, we say to you now that our spirit is stronger and cannot be broken. You cannot outlast us, and we will defeat you." Are we not guilty of the slaughter of innocents, and inducing terror ourselves, as a nation? And are those action NOT a direct consequence of our way of life? Have we NOT supported others who are guilty of the same actions? Do we NOT continue to do so? They were moving words, but not coming from a position of complete honesty. In fact they were somewhat contradictory. Part of "setting aside childish things" is the letting go of the illusion that we are not just as guilty of the actions we persecute others for. Instead we must look at ourselves in the mirror, realize and accept that we as a nation and our way of life have played major roles in our problems culturally, economically, ecologically; and that we do indeed have a LOT to answer for. We will grow up as a nation when we can admit our own faults, look at them honestly and deal with them responsibly. That means apology and remedy. Only when we show ourselves that kind of respect and honestly will others be motivated to do so.

I do not approve of mixing

I do not approve of mixing church and State, but I have to admit it was gratifying to hear anyone, but particularly our new President, use a biblical quote, namely, "Let Us Now Set Aside Childish Things" to spur us on to greater heights of character and achievement rather than to try to legitimize yet another arrogant and brutal act of inhumanity.

I see "putting away childish

I see "putting away childish things" as moving beyond the lazy thinking of American exceptionalism. I see no sign that not apologizing for our way of life has anything to do with keeping the oil flowing. From everything else Obama said, it has much more to do with our basic ideals of freedom and equality, which unlike Bush, he doesn't see being spread by the barrel of a gun. We can no longer take our basic principles for granted. We need to work for them again. Hence, the numerous history lessons throughout the speech.

I was thoroughly upset with

I was thoroughly upset with Obama for inviting Warren to participate in our Inaugural. I have a crush on Obama but I thought he went too far in allowing this in the name of reciprocity. Also, having prays at Inaugurals is a fairly recent blaspheme against Separation of church and State that will pass as we grow up. However, Warren was so inane in comparison to the other two ministers that he pretty well looked like what he exactly is--a bit of flotsam.

Not all the pundits. Chris

Not all the pundits. Chris Matthews and, surprisingly, Pat Buchanan were agog over the speech, and Matthews found this segment to be the core departure from the last eight years: As for our common defense, we reject as false the choice between our safety and our ideals. Our founding fathers ... our found fathers, faced with perils we can scarcely imagine, drafted a charter to assure the rule of law and the rights of man, a charter expanded by the blood of generations. Those ideals still light the world, and we will not give them up for expedience's sake.

I think the exclusion of

I think the exclusion of Bishop Robinson had more to do with Team HBO than with Team Obama...

The character and content of

The character and content of this entire, brilliant, day of pomp and circumstance, of celebration and of tears of joy ought not to take account of such particulars as speeches and photographic moments, but celebrate it in its entirety instead. As such, it conforms doubtlessly to the ancient legal maxim: "res ipse loquitur". That means "the matter speaks for itself" So, we need to let is stand as a whole, rather than the sum of its particular parts.

Some of you were close but

Some of you were close but no cigar. "Putting away childish things", was meant to tell people that the age of leisure, over consumption and partying with no end - is at an end. Roll up your sleeves and get to work is the message. We must get our collective heads out of the clouds and focus on the path ahead. A hard uphill path at that. Living beyond one's means is now becoming history as well as living off the fat of the land. The land has no more fat. This will be a slap in the face for a lot of folks.

The expectations, the

The expectations, the crowds, the leading up to the inauguration, the knowledge that the RUBBUSH and his Hannibal Lector in a wheel chair would be gone were such intense feelings that by the time PRESIDENT OBAMA gave his speech we expected the earth to move. Even when I was listening for the first time, I THOUGHT IT WAS GREAT from beginning to end. I loved that he included "non-believer" in his trajectory. I know people have to analyze to death these things, but really PRESIDENT OBAMA was as eloquent as ever, the only thing more I wish he had said and done was to point to BUSH and tell him was a failure he has been, other than that, someone counted 51 references of possible admonitions directed at his administration, so I'm happy.

I agree with "Pat in

I agree with "Pat in Colorado"s comments about the citizens listening to our President's speech rather than interrupting with fawning applause. This is heartening. We are ready to take responsibility for the direction our country is going and we now have a President who with his intelligence shows us respect with this speech of truth and encouragement. He cannot put our feet on the constructive path but he lights the way by his example.

So I guess they'll be

So I guess they'll be repealing the so-called "PATRIOT" ACT, first thing, so they can show us how much they believe in that Constitution and the RULE OF LAW? I suppose they'll be hauling the outgoing administration UP ON CHARGES? -And I guess they'll be coming down like a ton of bricks on anybody that gave the orders to cluster-bomb children on the other side of the planet, so they can show us how much they hate terrorism in all its forms. -NO??? -Come on, folks. Calm down. I figure it's going to be a kinder, gentler, Military-Industrial, Big Brother Nation, until they PROVE OTHERWISE. To all of you "cult of Obama" types, you should maybe stop sounding like Bush's sycophants from 5-7 years ago. Anyone can make a speech. I'm waiting to see what this administration is going to DO, and I am primed to start yelling if it's more business as usual. I'd like also to point out to all you people mooning over the elevated discourse, that they invited the bigoted preacher first, and only got the gay bishop as an afterthought, and then pushed him into a corner. So tell me again how this sort of bronze-age, religious closed-mindedness is a sign of elevated discourse and great intellect??? Looks like another eight years of God-bully lawyers, coming up. Is that shiny new coat of CHANGE peeling around the edges, or is it just me?

well said George. It is

well said George. It is odd, but the evening following the inauguration I posted a quote from the speech and it was the same as your title. teny

IMHO, "Let us now set aside

IMHO, "Let us now set aside childish things," from the presumed writing of the Apostle Paul, was a call to seek and embrace spiritual maturity. This is a daunting call, and yet true to our being; to do less is to deprive ourselves of the full joy of existence. However, I don't think it is a call for the reliance upon military force for a accomplishment of national objectives. Instead, I think it is a call to each and all of us to awaken to the Oneness of humankind and to live compassionately, with a trust that all peoples are ultimately "Children of the Divine." This is different than being naive about the dangers of the world. But it does point us to a new set of priorities beyond the use of military force.

When it is all said and

When it is all said and done, it was awfully nice to be spoken to as if we are all reasonable, intelligent and thoughtful adults and not children to be amused while the grown-ups get on with running things.

hey! replying to another

hey! replying to another peasant, give him a chance will you? You are trashing him already. Let's be a little optimistic.