Share

To Support and Defend: A Message to US Senators and Representatives

by: Phillip Butler, Ph.D., t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
(Photo: flickr/nj_dodge)

    "I, Phillip Neal Butler, having been appointed a Midshipman in the United States Navy, do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign or domestic, and to bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion, and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office upon which I am about to enter, so help me God." (Oath of Office, July 1, 1957.)

    Upon graduation from the United States Naval Academy in 1961, I had the honor of repeating this oath to be commissioned an ensign in the United States Navy. I served 20 years as an active duty commissioned officer. During that time, I became a naval aviator, flew combat in Vietnam, was downed over North Vietnam on April 20, 1965, and became a prisoner of war. I was repatriated on February 12, 1973, having served 2,855 days and nights as a POW - just short of eight years. The Vietnamese were not signatories to any international treaties on treatment of prisoners. They pronounced us "criminals" and freely used torture, harassment, malnutrition, isolation, lack of medical care, and other degradations during our captivity. I was tortured dozens of times during my captivity. But I often thought of our Constitution and the higher purpose we served - a purpose that helped me resist beyond what I thought I'd ever be capable of. Ironically, we POWs often reminded each other "that our country would never stoop to torture and the low level of treatment we were experiencing at the hands of our captors."

    This Oath of Office, the same one sworn to by all officers, government officials, presidential cabinet members, senators and representatives of our nation, has had a powerful effect on me. It has given me an over-arching purpose in life: to serve the greatest and most influential legal document ever written. The only different oath is specified for the president of the United States in Constitution Article II, Section 1 (8.) It mandates that he or she will "preserve, protect and defend the Constitution."

    So, what in the world has happened during the past eight years of the George W. Bush administration? The only defensible answer is that he and his subordinates have trampled our precious Constitution and the rule of law into the ground, while our elected members of Congress have stood idly and complicitly by. Our highest elected officials have utterly failed in their duty of greatest responsibility.

    During these years, we have seen gross attempts to institutionalize torture. Our Constitution, Article VI, (2), commonly known as the "Supremacy" clause, clearly states that treaties made shall become "the supreme law of the land," thus elevating them to the level of constitutional law.

    The Geneva Convention Relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War, ratified in 1949, states in Article 17, "No physical or mental torture, nor any other form of coercion may be inflicted on prisoners of war to secure from them information of any kind whatever. Prisoners of war who refuse to answer may not be threatened, insulted, or exposed to any unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment of any kind." This and numerous other ratified treaties clearly stipulate that "prisoners" is an inclusive term that is not limited to any nation's uniformed combatants.

    Other gross Bush administration crimes, in addition to authorizing torture, of general and constitutional law include: 1) the use of "signing statements" to illegally refrain from complying with laws, 2) authorization of the illegal suspension of Habeas Corpus, 3) authorization of wire tapping and other intrusive methods to illegally spy on American citizens, 4) unilateral declaration and pre-emptive conduct of war in violation of US Constitution Article I, Section 8 (11).

    These violations of our Constitution and rule of law have resulted in reducing our nation to the level of international pariah. Our beacon of liberty and justice no longer shines throughout the world. We no longer set the example for other nations to follow. We no longer stand on a firm foundation. We have lost our national, moral gyro.

    I despair when I think of the personal sacrifices made by so many in US wars and conflicts since 1776. If our forefathers were here to see, they would surely be angry and disappointed. And I think they would issue a clarion call for redress and setting an example for the world by punishing those who are guilty. The only way our nation can right itself is for Congress to prosecute the perpetrators of these crimes.

    I, therefore, call on my elected representatives in the Senate and House of Representatives to bring criminal charges against President George Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney, former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, legal counsel William J. Haynes, former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, former legal counsel David Addington, and potentially other high officials and uniformed officers. There is no other option if you are to carry out your responsibilities. Citizens of the United States and of the world are watching you. Do your duty. Support and defend the Constitution of the United States.

    ---------

    Note: This article was written for and at the request of Sen. John Kerry, to use as leverage with his Senate colleagues.

  

»


Phillip Butler, Ph.D., commander, USN (ret.). Phillip Butler is a graduate of the United States Naval Academy and a former light-attack, carrier pilot. In 1965, he was shot down over North Vietnam, where he spent eight years as a prisoner of war. He was awarded two Silver Stars, two Legion of Merits, two Bronze Stars and two Purple Heart medals. After his repatriation in 1973, he earned a Ph.D. in sociology from the University of California at San Diego, and completed his Navy career in 1981. He then founded and owned a management consulting and professional speaking business. Today, he mentors business and organization leaders and is a community activist. Contact information: Phillip Butler, 1330 Castro Court, Monterey, CA 93940, phone: 831-649-1336.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Dear Dr. Butler, I swore

Dear Dr. Butler, I swore the same oath, standing before George Herbert Walker Bush on May 29th, 1985. The oath has had a profound effect on my life ever since. While, thankfully, I was never put to such a severe test as you were, I did graduate from SERE school, based in part on your experiences. For four years I had the precepts of the Geneva Conventions drilled into my head, as well as all the very good reasons that we were a signatory to them. Until seven years ago, I would never imagine that my country would abandon those principles, and ignore those reasons. I agree wholeheartedly with your call to prosecute the violators of this law (because Treaties signed by our Senate are indeed the Law of the Land), and I agree that everyone you named should be charged. Unfortunately, there are a great number of other people who should be charged...namely most of both houses of Congress. Which is why it will probably never happen. Your article brings tears to my eyes. Tears brought by anger that this has gone on these last several years, and tears of joy that SOMEBODY understands, and is willing to put it down so clearly and without equivocation. Thank You for that. I hope to see your call brought to action, and will do whatever I can to see it carried to fruition.

Where do I sign the

Where do I sign the petition? How do we get this put into the form of a special referendum? Who can I write to in the Hague?

Restoring The Rule of Law in

Restoring The Rule of Law in this country should be at the very top of Obama's list. He needs listen closely to the many people who are DEMANDING that the Bush Administration be held accountable for ALL (I repeat ALL) their crimes. Only then can our country move forward from that disgraceful period. (Others out there do some research at www.journalof911studies.com. The PHD's and scientists at that site have much to tell us about what actually happened on that pivotal day during the Bush Administration.)

I found this an important

I found this an important statement of principle and likewise feel that punishment for the crimes against our Constitution should be punished. Perhaps such punishment should come from international bodies instead of our own Congress and courts who are, in some degree, complicit in these violations. I recently re-read much of the Constitution based on a discussion of its contents with a friend. It is a shame that it has been so violated... and also misinterpreted as far as I can tell. As a marine biologist, I have no legal training. However much of it seems pretty easy to properly decipher. My thanks to Phillip Butler for writing this.

I'm in complete agreement

I'm in complete agreement with Jen. I bet hundreds of thousands of us would want to sign such a referendum or petition.

Not only do I think these

Not only do I think these criminals should be jailed, t I think it will best serve justice that they serve time in a regular old fashioned federal prison, Leavenworth for example, and without privilege.

I took the oath in 1966. My

I took the oath in 1966. My son did likewise 30 years later. It was the flagrant violation of both oath and Constitution by the Bush administration that has infuriated me for the past eight years. President Obama has made it clear that things will change, let us hope so. As for prosecution of those flagrant violators, I wholeheartedly agree, but see it as improbable given the media outrage that would occur to support, defend, and protect said violators.

As a person who worked in

As a person who worked in the electronic intelligence field, having had the sanctity of American citizens' communications privacy drilled into my head, I too have spent the last seven years horrified by the crimes of the Bush Administration and the near-silence of Congress. Torture, warrant-less wire-tapping, imprisonment without trial or attorney, even murder have gone on right in front of our eyes and only a few sad sacks with a few stripes have been punished. We're all breathing a sigh of relief that we have a new administration and holding our breath wondering what, if anything, the Congress and Justice Department will do about past crimes. Fortunately, former President Bush didn't pre-pardon everyone!

crystal clear and 100%

crystal clear and 100% AGREED!!! may our country find the strength and fortitude to investigate and prosecute those who have so shamelessly brought us all so low. thank you Phillip Butler; so well said and SO TRUE!

I served our country in the

I served our country in the Army from 1968 to 1971 and our training included study of the Geneva Conventions. President Bush and his Administration should face the consequences of their actions. Charges should be brought against them and they should face prosecution to show that no one is above the laws of our constitution. Our nation's prison population exceeds that of all other countries. They are filled with minorities and the poor while the rich such as Bernard Maddoff steal Billions and wait at home committing more crimes as they await trial.

I am the daughter of an

I am the daughter of an ex-prisoner of war from WWII. I have argued and argued with others since the Guantanamo Bay incarcerations began, saying that the Geneva Convention once kept my father alive, that it was a piece of very important international legislation that we must not throw away. Time and again I was told that "it's not as important as U.S. security" but then I began to hear others say, "Yes, you are right." Today, I hear almost no voices shouting me down. Instead, I hear people tell me that our children and the world are all at risk because of this terrible policy. I not only call on all the Congress to announce to the world that WE do respect the Geneva Convention regulations but that we also respect OTHER peoples' rights to the same protection. Additionally, I believe that if the U.S. Congress does not have the stomach to go further and find a way to censure those who wielded power illegally in the last 8 years, at the very least the Am. Bar Association should throw out anyone whose legal opinions have led us into the flaunting of the Constitution and international law. Take away the prestige and licenses of these pseudo-lawyers. Let them get a different job. One that cannot ruin more lives.

Simply put... So right, Dr.

Simply put... So right, Dr. Butler!!!!!

I TOOK MY OATH IN1962 and

I TOOK MY OATH IN1962 and spent 6 years in the USAF. On the extreme side I say hang the bastards in a public square for treason and crimes against humanity. On the kinder, more gentle side, they should at least be tried, and if convicted, spend some time, at least 8 years (in honor of Dr. Butler), in a real prison before having their sentences suspended.

I've been wondering when

I've been wondering when this would occur. It is way past time to punish those responsible for the degradation of the US Constitution. When it was going on, I kept thinking that something should be done about it - but for some reason it seemed like nothing could be.

Dr. Butler, my heartfelt

Dr. Butler, my heartfelt thanks to you for your service to our country and for standing up and proclaiming what many of us feel, that our government has shamed us and let us down these past eight years. I keep a copy of the Constitution next to my desk and refer to it often. It is the most important and sacred text of the United States of America. That shining beacon on the hill that so many people in this world look up to is our Constitution. Everyone needs to get a copy and read it, and dedicate our lives to supporting and defending it against all enemies, foreign and domestic - even presidents.

Couldn't agree more, and

Couldn't agree more, and thank you for your letter Dr. Butler. Without an independent investigation and subsequent trial, our Constitution will remain damaged, and waiting for the next would-be tyrants to abuse it further, perhaps destroying it altogether. While I'm not a lawyer, I believe there is no more urgent action required by Americans than bringing the Bush administration to justice. It does not matter one whit who opposes it, because our freedoms depend upon it. If everyone understood that, millions of people would be demanding justice right now. But the people have been lied to so often, many don't know what's right and what's wrong at this point. Who will stand up and make this happen?

I have written the same

I have written the same things to congresspersons for years, but my words repeatedly fell on deaf ears. I hope that these statements, written and supported by those more prominent, will finally be taken to heart by those we elected to serve us. If not, then we must conclude that they no longer serve us and the Constitution by which we agree to live together.

Works for me! Never any

Works for me! Never any question in my mind that Bush/Cheney, Rice, Powell, Yoo, Feith, et al actions were a violation of international law & should be prosecuted as such. Too bad a majority of Congress also refused to comply with a logical interpretation of the Constitution & destroyed two federal court efforts to stop the crazy "I am dictator" theory of the Chief Executive power of Bush/Cheney, Inc. by passing additional legislation (Military Commissions Act, for one). I'd say that there should be a number of members of Congress from 2000 to 2008 who also should be prosecuted. They also knew & did nothing to stop it.

I was so grateful to read

I was so grateful to read this article. It expresses so clearly what I have been arguing with friends, relatives and others. The one argument against bringing these criminals to justice was that it would become an ongoing thing. Republicans impeached Clinton, we are after Bush, the next time it will be the Republicans after another Democratic president. I think this line of reasoning makes no sense whatsoever. What the Republicans did hunting down Clinton for a repulsive, yet minor error, does not even compare with demanding the rule of law concerning the actions of the Bush administration. We have to do this for ourselves and our constitution and for the rest of the world. We are nothing but hypocrites if we don't.

Now I offer my name to a

Now I offer my name to a fifth call for an investigation of Bush Administration officials for Crimes Against Humanity and the United States Constitution to be conducted and the perpetrators to be charged and face trial. To "put the past behind us" and "move on" requires that justice be served and that NO ONE is above the law. It is hypocritical to wage war upon other nations to demand their government follow the rule of law, only for the aggressor to trample upon that very rule of law it claims to be fighting for. Thanks for speaking out, Dr. Butler. Demanding justice, whether for the people or against criminals, should not require political action, but it often does. So, I ask that others write to their congressional representatives and to the White House to demand investigations into these allegations for the sake of our children to not face the pain and disgrace the Bush Administration has been to eager to spit upon us.

Thank you for your

Thank you for your sacrifices. W spent his time in uniform AWOL, from what I hear. Treason should be rewarded with hanging

Sign the petition to

Sign the petition to Attorney General, Eric Holder, here: http://www.democrats.com/special-prosecutor-for-bush-war-crimes

We owe these men a gratitude

We owe these men a gratitude that is so immense that it can hardly be articulated. The "enemy" from outside or WITHIN. It seems to me that, in general, the people that find it easiest to ignore their oath are the ones that "pretend" to be warriors and have never had to face the true dangers that real warriors faced. Ms. Pelosi and Mr. Reed should take a lesson from these truly great men represented by Dr. Butler. Just because they are no longer in office, they should not be beyond the reach of our laws and the agreements and treaties those laws have come to embody. If everyone would just put pressure on their representatives to press this issue, we may have some action, especially if their re-election depended on it.

Thank you Commander Butler!

Thank you Commander Butler! Now, who else among military veterans and the American electorate is going to step up?

America did a shameful act

America did a shameful act in flippantly loosening these thugs on the rest of the world totally unchecked(and we call Al Qaeda a "terrorist" organization!!). Currently the USA IS, and remains, an outlaw rogue nation despite Obama's intent to just "move on" with a new lawful order. The big thing here is that if we knowingly allow these war criminals to go unpunished, then WE, as a country, are just as guilty as they were. And the next Republithug administration WILL continue where Bush, Cheney, et al. left off. Not a threat; a certainty.

Preeminent and essential.

Preeminent and essential. Dr. Butler's paper is the clearest and most concise articulation of what the National discussion should have been over the last eight years. This hopefully will lead to thoughtful consideration of how the citizens of the United States could be blinded by the Bush Administration. How could we have been steered so far from our democratic foundations and a true course toward the common good? We need to ask the question and demand that it be asked by our "Representatives" as well.

I hope the rat pack is put

I hope the rat pack is put in jail and I pray this happens. I also hope everyone knows we the people is only the elite. Whoever has the most money runs the country. Let us change the Constitution as well and let freedom really ring.

If Bush isn't prosecuted for

If Bush isn't prosecuted for torture, American soldiers will be legitimately tortured for centuries to come.

I fully support Dr. Butler's

I fully support Dr. Butler's call for bringing criminal charges against Bush, Cheney and other high officials for crimes against humanity and for egrigious violations of the constitution which they swore to uphold. I too took the oath in 1962 and served in the Air Force until 1968. Unless Congress and the Justice Department, and all of us collectively, hold the Bush administration accountable for its criminal behaviour, we dishonor all those who served and sacrificed to uphold the principles upon which this country was founded.

I concur. The despicable

I concur. The despicable Congress, of both corrupt parties, does not. This is a kleptocracy, for sale to the highest bidders. Obama will do nothing to "change" that. A legal argument to prosecute the Bush gang for high treason.

I copied and pasted this

I copied and pasted this article and sent it to my congressperson and both senators with my name and address attached with my demand that action be taken against Bush, Cheney, et.al. I hope everyone else will do the same.

Thank you for your

Thank you for your observations and call to justice. I have sent the following message to my Senator: "Dear Senator Leahy, Now that we have ended the nightmare 8 years of the Bush administration, I am wondering what happened to your call for contempt of congress charges against Karl Rove, Harriet Meiers, and Josh Bolten. I assume their refusal to testify remains in effect, but with the new session of Congress, perhaps they have waited out the expiration of such a call for contempt citations. In reading the words of Dr. Philip Butler, published at the behest of John Kerry on the Truthout.org site, I hope that you too will seek action to remedy the actions of an Executive branch out of control, and will support as he asks: 'criminal charges against President George Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney, former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, legal counsel William J. Haynes, former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, former legal counsel David Addington, and potentially other high officials and uniformed officers.' I will look forward to your action to bring these officials to justice. " May the Senators and Congresspeople of this session act to move us forward toward renewed support for our Constitution and its guarantees of justice and liberty.

Notwithstanding Dr Butler's

Notwithstanding Dr Butler's strength of feeling regarding the trashing of the U.S. Constitution by the last Chief Executive and some of his key associates, It is imperative we keep our eye on the ball regarding two matters flowing from what he has raised but not addressed. FIRST -- Vietnam not having been a party at the time to various conventions sanctioning torture was not liable to prosecution for violating said conventions. I should have thought, however, that greater consideration might be given to the reality that U.S. troops were invading a country that was in no position to return the [dis]favour. Before damning Vietnamese torture of mass-murdering uninnocent marauding invaders, I would have expected greater circumspection from Dr Butler and others who shared his fate. SECOND -- it appears that behind the hoopla surrounding the long-anticipated final sinking of waterboarding, Gitmo torture chambers and CIA-run prisons in foreign countries, the U.S. may be rolling out its very own Obama-lag of special tribunals [and ultimately special "detention" facilities] in the United States for persons accused and convicted of being "illegal combatants" or otherwise involved in other terrorist crimes deemed a threat to the state. This is a judicial arena based entirely on reverse onus [guilty til proven innocent] and other Star Chamber-like practices, modulated by some limited respect for habeas corpus but otherwise retaining the entire corrupt and rotten protection for "secret evidence". FEMA already has the trailer camps ready in which to warehouse suspects under indictment.

Yes, yes, yes!!! If Pelosi

Yes, yes, yes!!! If Pelosi and Reid are afraid to exercise leadership, get rid of them and elect leaders who WILL show the courage and intelligence to do what is right. The men and women who broke their oaths to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution should be brought to justice, with all the same rigor that they want used in bringing marijuana users and military war protesters and, in a very few cases, Enron-type felons to justice. If we are to be a country of laws, let's be a country of laws. If "three times and you're out" applies to everyone else, it ought to apply equally to the people who PUBLICLY SWEAR to uphold the laws.

I am aware of the rising

I am aware of the rising voices for the prosecution of those responsible for the many laws broken over the past eight years. It is difficult to accept the fact that our Congress has been complicit, that it has failed to defend the Constitution, as dictated by their oath. So, what now? Whom do we turn to?? Fortunately, we have this medium, which is tailor-made for the kind of organizing which is necessary. What we need is a locus, a point from which we can combine our strength in numbers. Think MoveOn, only this would have to be a one-issue organization. Comments?

Thank you for speaking out.

Thank you for speaking out. If Bush & Co. are not prosecuted for war crimes and turned over to the Hague, we have lost our battle for the constitution, and there will be no example for future fascists who attempt to take control of this country, as he and his cohorts did. The best example we can give to the rest of the world is that democracy works--peacefully. And that means holding those who attempt to overthrow it with treasonous crimes criminally accountable

After reading about how NAS

After reading about how NAS has tapped into all of our home phones, computers, cell phones and faxes including our representatives( can anyone say BLACKMAIL?)

Lets get the united Nations

Lets get the united Nations to do it. It doesn't look like DC has the guts. Maybe because they are so sold out to other powers.

DISTRIBUTE THIS ARTICLE. I

DISTRIBUTE THIS ARTICLE. I will copy it and send it to my "Representatives" demanding action. I shudder to think that citizens of the United States were only one Supreme Court Justice's vote away from OUR GOVERNMENT, being able to disappear people! Had Justice Kennedy not been the deciding vote to reinstate habeas corpus we would be in that terrible position.

I also hope ways can be

I also hope ways can be found to get back some of the profits that were made in no-bid contracts. This would send a new message. Perhaps the persons most harmed by the former regime can launch a class-action lawsuit for damages. We need a U.S. Truth and Reconciliation program where the perpetrators cannot avoid facing the harm they have caused. We need to make whole the whistleblowers and to bring to light the stories that were suppressed. Since many of the bureaucracies have been infected with drilled-in barnacles of corruption, we need to figure this out as well. Sunsetting some bureaucracies may be necessary. A pretense of protecting the public is worse than an admission that the public must do due diligence on our own. There is so much work to be done.

ABSOLUTELY. Bush and

ABSOLUTELY. Bush and cronies should not be allowed to simply walk away with a "nevermind" response from the world. People who torture others and cause death are subject to the death penalty -- note that 8 people died after being tortured by our Administration, with Bush and Cheney leading the way. The Rule of Law should apply here, one would think...

When I think about the

When I think about the misbehavior of this Bush/Cheney presidency, my thoughts eventually find their way to Guantanamo... to the infliction of misery & terror, & the deprivation of personal freedom done to those incarcerated there. It requires someone, like Dr. Butler, who has experienced the miseries & the feelings of hopeless deprivation borne by those in captivity, to address what has taken place IN THE NAME OF THE AMERICAN PEOPLE. Then, it requires all of us to read that part of the Constitution of the United States which is OUR LAW concerning these actions. "In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence." If this isn't OUR LAW anymore, then all these detainees should have been sent on to The Hague- or some other appropriate venue- where our charges can be brought against them. Leaving ANYONE to simply rot in a cell is also "Torture" of a particularly gross & inhuman kind. That it should continue FOR YEARS is... heart-rending. ^..^

I certainly agree with the

I certainly agree with the sentiment but, all the comments in support notwithstanding, this is a controversial proposal. Obama needs to bring the country to a point where it will see the necessity for such an action. The first step is to release previously-secret information about what has been happening for the last eight years. This he has begun to do. The next step is an official truth commission, and then trials. Most matters could end with the truth commission but torture, and official authorization, encouragement and toleration of torture, must be punished.

This should be read by every

This should be read by every one in government office - every one. And those that don't honor our constitution should be brought to trial.

If I am not mistaken, no one

If I am not mistaken, no one having willingly taken an oath of allegiance to the Constitution of the United States has ever been released from it. Semper Fidelis

Nancy Pelosi and her fellow

Nancy Pelosi and her fellow gutless Reid need to be replaced. She said impeachment is off the table, that she never be so. There are many members of Congress especially R party that are very guilty for allowing all of this to happen and just rubber stamping whatever Bush wanted to ram thru legal or not. Thank you Dr. Butler for the wonderful, important article.

What we need here is a good

What we need here is a good rallying cry. "Yes, we can!" worked so well in the election; it's positive, easy to remember, and has a good cadence. I think a slight modification of this great slogan perfectly sums the main argument treading through these posts (which delight me no end!) that prosecution of these criminals is necessary, and actually required of those who currently hold office under the oath. In this vein I'm going to suggest "Yes, we must!" as a good catchy slogan that may not be lost on current office holders. Should we prosecute those who violate their oath of office to preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution? I say: "Yes, we must!"

It's telling, isn't it, that

It's telling, isn't it, that I'm afraid to use my real name and my e-mail address to comment here? Comments that I once felt completely free to make because I once had an assurance of freedom of speech? I think it is imperative that the members of the Bush administration responsible for these crimes be tried as war criminals, if not for treason. If there are no repercussions, if they go unpunished, we will have set a dangerous precedent for future administrations armed with signing statements and sycophantic legal teams to again break the law and ignore the Constitution with impunity.

as a disabled American

as a disabled American veteran, I feel dirtied by the last 8 years of misadministration. Cheney and Bush make me want to take a bath.

Remind me again what the red

Remind me again what the red eyed Republicans and their lap dog red dog Democrats in Congress tried to impeach the oversexed Bill Clinton for? Was it for lying under oath about a single tacky sexual encounter with a consenting adult? Was that it? The majority of the incumbent men and women in Congress must be put out of public office and the lobby industry in the next two or three election cycles. Or we Americans are risking, or will have in the very near future, a corporate military police state based upon the false flag attacks which give the rational for the "War on Terror" a war on ourselves that will never, ever end.

Hear Hear, finally, someone

Hear Hear, finally, someone with enough credibility and clarity of speech to bring forth the message that needs to said. Every American Citizen needs to read this. I will definitly copy/print this and move it down the line, and encourage everyone else to do likewise. While I agree wholeheartedly with the opinions expressed, I feel that the time for rhetoric is over, and it's definitly time to take a more positve action on our own. Remember, man created government, so government can never be greater than man. THESE PEOPLE WORK FOR US. They only have the power over us that they have because we voluntarily give it to them. It's time to stand up and hold these people accountable. The system isn't as powerful as people have been propogandized to believe. Remember, the Great Oz was only smoke and mirrors. Mohammad Ali knew this, he refused draft induction. "I never heard no North Vietnamese call me niggar." Did he go to prison? NO. He refused to VOLUNTEER for the system. You can too. The entire system is fraudulent, the gov't knows this, and they hide it in the UCC, or Uniform Commercial Code, with Code being an operitve word, as in codified so that the common man cannot understand the law and how it pertains to him. The time to stand up and take proactive action is NOW. It's upon every man, woman, and child to stand up and stop what's going on, to reestablish the natural order man under God, gov't under man, and corporation under gov't. We are sovereign, and we need to start acting like it.

Accountability, when there

Accountability, when there is corruption at the top it filters through those in power through out the government and the corporations that finance them. We are now living those results.

Thank you for putting this

Thank you for putting this in writing. As the spouse of a 20+ naval officer, and the daughter of a long line of military members - including my mother! I have felt that the Bush administration's total disrespect for the military has been overlooked. Not only in starting a war based on lies, but then putting future military members in danger through our treatment of prisoners of war and other's we've held throughout the last 7 years. If a crime has been committed, it's our obligation to get the facts and punish those responsible. It's not a choice - and I will be writing my members of Congress and reminding them of that as well. Thank you again for your service! ~Robin

YES WE WILL CAN perhaps a

YES WE WILL CAN perhaps a new rallying cry, "Yes we will can those bastards, lock them up, put them away and make restitution to their victims." The indefensible position that Bush's choices were made in the nations security interests DEMAND an open review before the courts. I'd LOVE to see Kenneth Starr ferreting the sordid details of this one. If he and the Republican members need a lascivious angle, they will certainly find it in the PORNOGRAPHIC voyeurism of Abu Ghraib detainee humiliation/torture videos that Bush/Rumsfeld gleefully viewed during their "Morning Briefing". We saw Bush pay feeble mention to his own scapegoat down to the last word where he stated that a disappointment of his was that friends mislead him. This is a veiled cover story that he didn't know anything and that Cheney was the mastermind. Fine. Bring them all up on charges. From Plame to OTA these knowingly criminal "evildoers" are seconded only by Stalin. We'd better do it now before Bush retreats to Uruguay on the hundreds of thousands of acres ranch his family now owns there. Federal Prison is too good for them but I'd love to see him shackled to Mr. Noriega, his newly Christianized brethren. We (yes you and I) owe a substantial apology to the people of Iraq, Afghanistan and the world and unless something is done now, must forever hold our heads in shame. Fortunately however, there is no Statute of Limitations on War Crimes so as of now, every country in the world has the solemn duty to arrest each one of these malicious and sadistic nincompoops.

From England an enthusiastic

From England an enthusiastic endorsement -YES YOU MUST. And we here should do likewise with his puppets, Blair and co.

Thank you for having the

Thank you for having the courage to write this very thoughtful document. We have just endured the most disgraceful administration in the history of our marvelous country. We must make sure that this could never ever happen again -- it is a terrible shame that the educated citizens of the US sat idly by and allowed the fraudulent election of GW Bush to occur. I am a war veteran myself and have always been very proud to have been able to serve my country. It was my duty and it was an honor. Bush and Cheney and Rumsfeld indeed have created criminal acts against the rest of the world and have disgraced the proun name of the United States of America. They should be brought to justice like all other war criminals who create heinous acts against mankind

Powerful statement. The rule

Powerful statement. The rule of law is critically important today. War crimes cannot go unpunished. Those with the sworn obligation to govern by the Constitution cannot overlook war crimes at the risk of being an accessory after the fact. I'd like to ask Mr. Butler, "When did you finally realized you were fighting in an illegal war that even the Sec. of Defense admitted was unwinable and wrong?" Korea was a crime, Viet Nam was a crime, 9-11 was a crime, the invasion and occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan is a crime. We fight crime by committing crimes. How many of the emotionally damaged veterans of the Iraq/Afghan War and Vietnam are struggling with having followed orders, knowing at the time, that doing so was criminal?"

I took my oath in October

I took my oath in October 1968 before going to Aviation Officer Candidate School in Pensacola FL. An odd beginning for a guy that ended up as a naval intelligence officer. But that choice turned out to be a serendipitous event. Five years later I had the honor and privilege of meeting Phil Butler as he disembarked from an Operation Homecoming C-141 at Clark AFB in the Philippines. I was Phil's "debriefer" but, more importanly, we became friends over the nine months we spent together. Phil, unlike many, was not a bitter man. Rather, he is a deep thinker who did not "toe the party line". He is a man of conviction and I applaud him for standing up to the injustice done to our beloved Constitution. I am reminded of a 1945 speech given by Frederick Vinson at Arlington National Cemetery. In that speech, Vinson declared "Wars are not acts of God. They are caused by man, by man-made institutions, by the way in which man has organized his society. What man has made, man can change." God bless you Phil and may your words not fall on deaf ears.