Share

Tom Daschle and the Populist Revolt

by: Robert Reich  |  Robert Reich's Blog

photo
US Sen. Tom Daschle (D-South Dakota) withdrew Tuesday from the nomination of secretary of Health and Human Services. (Photo: Reuters )

    Tom Daschle's surprise withdrawal today shocked most Washington insiders - after all, Daschle had been a key figure in the Senate, was Obama's pick for a major role in the new administration, would very likely have done a superb job getting a new health-insurance system enacted, and, probably could have mustered enough votes to be confirmed. So what happened? My guess is that official Washington underestimated the public's pique at what appeared to be the old ways of Washington. Hill staffers tell me that many offices have been inundated with telephone calls, emails, letters and faxes expressing concern (to put it mildly) about Daschle - not only his failure to pay back taxes but his relationships with major players in the health care industry and rich consulting contracts with the private sector since leaving the Senate, and even the fact that he was given a car and driver by one of them.

    What's going on here? Maybe official Washington, much like most of Wall Street, is still not quite getting it.

    Typical Americans are hurting very badly right now. They resent people who appear to be living high off a system dominated by insiders with the right connections. They've become increasingly suspicious of the conflicts of interest, cozy relationships, and payoffs that seem to pervade not only official Washington but our biggest banks and corporations. In short, many Americans who have worked hard, saved as much as they can, bought a home, obeyed the law, and paid every cent of taxes that were due are beginning to feel like chumps. Their jobs are disappearing, their savings are disappearing, their homes are worth far less than they thought they were, their tax bills are as high as ever if not higher.

    Meanwhile, people at the top seem to be living far different lives in a different universe. They're the executives and traders on Wall Street who have lived like kings for years off a bubble of their own making while ripping off small investors, the financial louts who are now taking hundreds of billions of taxpayer bailout money while awarding themselves huge bonuses and throwing lavish parties, the corporate CEOs who are earning seven figures while laying off thousands of workers, the billionaire hedge-fund and private-equity managers who are paying a marginal tax rate of 15 percent on what they say are capital gains while people who earn a fraction of that are paying a higher rate, and, not the least, the Washington insiders who have served on the Hill or in an administration and then gone on to pocket millions as lobbyists for the same companies they once regulated or subsidized. To the American who's outside the power centers - the places of entitlement and I'll-scratch-your-back-while-you-scratch-mine deal making - the entire system seems rotten.

    I'm sorry Tom Daschle won't be in the Obama administration. He would have served the public well and with distinction. But the public wants change, real change, big change. There's no tolerance any longer for the way things used to be done.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.

  

»


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

Things are changing... a few

Things are changing... a few weeks ago Daschle's nomination would have been excused, forgiven and accepted. It gives me hope and that is something that has been lacking for me for a long time. Ann, Lincoln City

I am not sorry to see him

I am not sorry to see him go. Unfortunately, Tom Daschle has come to symbolize everything that is wrong with the Democratic party, from living the high life himself, to accepting money from questionable sources, to failing to stand up to the Bush administration. The man is a disgrace to his constituents, his party, and his nation.

It's great to have president

It's great to have president who knows where in the hell he's going for a change. The little bump in the road represented by Daschle should be considered old news already in light of the crucial goals at hand. It's almost laughable that some leap upon this as an example of a corrupt Democratic party. My God! Look at the Republican trail of slime over the past 8 years. Meanwhile, FOX news, Rush Limbaugh and Lou Dobbs are welcoming this opportunity to smear the Obama administration in a totally unreasonable way.

I was very tired of being

I was very tired of being harassed by the IRS for not filing when I owed nothing because I live on Disability (under poverty level). When I brought up the fact that the IRS should be trying to get what the rich are not paying and the IRS dismissed me. I filed and owed NOTHING so I am tired of the rich getting away with not paying taxes. Tom Daschle should have known better. No sympathy here. He needed to pay his portion.

I'm not sorry to see him go,

I'm not sorry to see him go, either. I want to see someone like Howard Dean, MD, (a REAL DOCTOR), in this position. Dean should have been the first choice of the Obama Administration. Daschle is a joke and a lobbyist for the medical industry!!! It is time for Obama to finally keep his word. Another one I want to see go, is Judd Gregg. He is a right-wing zealot who doesn't believe in the Commerce Department, but who believes in free trade. He also wants to take "reform" our Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. I don't trust him as far as I can throw him. Obama should remember that the Democrats won in November. I don't want any more RIGHT-WINGERS in my government! I AM SICK TO DEATH OF THEM!!!

Ditto and amen. Washington:

Ditto and amen. Washington: Get a clue.

Who was the party who

Who was the party who supplied Daschle with a car and a driver? That is the important part of this game. All this might have been going on for along time, but, under Bubba Clinton and the Bush family it'a become one big Scam..The outsourcing of our industrial base to China under both these past presidents has yet to be fully explained. Obama has fallen into the game and he does not have a clue. His inexperience is showing by the fact that he doesn't seem to know anyone except the good-ole-boy clubhouse in the Senate. His embrace of the Clinton and Bush Families leaves much to be desired. All this Financial destruction has happened under both the Clintons and the Bushees. The latest developments, including the statement from Chris Dodd re the One Payer Health system, Dodd said,"It will never happen". This must be "The Word" among the elite in Congress. It's time for Obama to get straight with the public, his choices so far are turning the public against him. Large and Small businesses are closing shop all over the country and we have lost millions more jobs, yet the Congress is fiddling around playing games like children playing Kick the Can. They don't seem to take the conditions of the country very seriously.We deserve a better explanation as to why Bubba Clinton has recieved more than $500,000,000 dollars from Foreign countries lately. The proof of the fallen economy is proof that Clinton was never qualified to run the country, and he is no expert on anyting except how to milk the system for himself. Rid us of the Clinton and Bush Machine. The latest developments seem to qualify that the zionists are behind much of this new game.

In Oregon we are hopeful

In Oregon we are hopeful John Kitzhaber will get a place at the table. He fought the insurance companies here in an effort to establish a formulary of the safest and most effective medications for particular issues. The system has to be made less harmful before more money is poured into it. Iatrogenic (doctor-caused) adverse outcomes have to be better dealt with or we won't get the better outcomes we seek. Modes of healing thousands of years old must be included without intimidation against the healers or those who seek those forms of healing. If people choose expensive procedures with side effects over lifestyle changes with side benefits, I guess that can't easily be changed. Discriminating against less invasive and dangerous change hurts us all, nonetheless. It's time for a careful examination of what works for whom.

Daschle is a disappointing

Daschle is a disappointing failure. He failed to stand up to Bush's disastrous plan for attacking Iraq, making one of the greatest political and moral miscalculations of recent times. And then he capitalized on his well-earned electoral defeat and left office to take millions from the health industry pirates who have been pillaging our country. It saddens me that Obama is filling some (many? most?) of his top appointments with people whose careers embody the very things that need changing in our country.

Howard Dean for HHS

Howard Dean for HHS Secretary. More balls, less baggage. Gov. Dean, a M.D., would have been my first choice regardless of Sen. Daschle's availability.

It's important to remember

It's important to remember that big pharma has most of the medical establishment in its collective pocket. We must not assume that MDs are more acceptable than Daschle. As a personal example and a general rule, there is at least one pharmaceutical representative in my GP's waiting room. Let's face it: the entire medical system is broken, and we need an altogether different sort of "doctor" to fix it.

One wonders why Obama

One wonders why Obama appointed Judd Gregg, who tried to abolish the department he now heads. I will agree with the person who has written that Obama knows few people outside the senate who could serve in the government. There are many. He might have asked some senators if he didn't know of any. Let's see some reformers, some community organizers, some people who have shown leadership abilities

Wrong! Mr. Daschle would not

Wrong! Mr. Daschle would not do the right thing-moving to a single-payer system; folding together Medicare and all the state programs into one coherent system, maximizing on the economics of scale necessary to bring down overall costs. Daschle is the archetype, establishment insider. Let's not even get into his wife's connections to the military-industrial-media establishment. Foget about it! This man and his wife ARE THE PROBLEM. They view their positions as vehicles to enrichment. They are disgusting! And to think that at one time (my earlier clueless days) I thought this corporate operative was a nice guy and a defender of the working guy. Ha! What did I know. Good riddance Tommy. You're old news.

Hey, Obama and Co asked us

Hey, Obama and Co asked us to be vigilant, to take the power. So when the very able but rather greedy fellow in the art director glasses screwed up he screwed Obama and he screwed us. Obama didn't get mad. We did. I wrote to Feinstein and said she should advise the secretary manque to bag it and clean up the playing field as he left. He did the right thing. The weepublicans would have kept this going, former senator or no. They would have reminded the administration for weeks about the double standard. Hey, nobody is irreplaceable. Even the magnificent George Bush has been replaced. Yrs, McD

It smells to me as if we're

It smells to me as if we're encountering an instance of representation without taxation here. As a lifelong museum quality democrat (to use Garrison Keillor's turn of phrase) it makes me very sad!

Pelosi is scum too. They

Pelosi is scum too. They all are. Obama should get on TV one Sunday and say he has come up against a wall and needs voters to take action. He would then introduce the solution: Only humans over 18 can give money to any candidate or iniatiative, and only under $99 Obama would urge voters to call their senator and house rep to support this because no new reforms for energy, heathcare, or banking can proceed until this most important reform kicks the money out of washington.

I'm with "tomvan" - the

I'm with "tomvan" - the snake oil Daschle (and Obama!) are peddling would benefit the insurance companies, not the people. Single payer, by contrast, would be a genuine step forward. I'd rather see, however, "30,000 payer": Divide the country into 30,000 health care districts, each administered by a locally elected board of 50 or 60 members, each given one-30,000th of the pie, and each charged with the health care of the 10,000 people in the district. Initially, they'd buy group health plans. In time, they'd build out-patient clinics, and provide health care directly.

I agree with all those that

I agree with all those that are delighted that Daschle is gone. The criteria for a position like HHS should not be who is best friends with congress or who is "owed" a position, but who understands healthcare from the perspective of primary care doctors and patients.Bill Bradley whose name has been floated was (maybe still is) beholden to pharma. Ny vote is for Dean - a Family Physician with Washington experience who understands the problems and is not afraid to fight the entrenched interests.

Daschele is tainted like so

Daschele is tainted like so many other established 'democrats'. It would be like putting a fox in the henhouse. I know why he stepped down. It is his best chance of avoiding further damaging scrutiny. Some of Obama's cabinet picks seem odd, but I think that he like FDR, wants to have a few insiders who know (and he expects them to tell) what has been and is going on. It's a good way to keep an eye on your secret enemies. Ms. Clinton is included. With the public apparently waking up and both lib and neocon propagandists falling on deaf ears, the dem party faces sweeping changes too. Obama knows that the Senate is still a cesspool even after this last election. It will hopefully be only 2 years before the public can clean out the remains of the worst congress in history, both dems and repigs.

I am glad to see Daschle go.

I am glad to see Daschle go. I have not forgotten that he voted for Bush's war in Iraq. As the leader of the Senate, he caved. So lets see if Howard Dean would accept Sec. HHS. He has already stated that his purpose now--in private life-- is to get national health insurance. And my belief is that the 50 state strategy must not be scuttled as the powers to be in the democratic party are doing. That 50 state strategy needs to be in place to help get us the legislation that we need passed, as well as electing members of the Senate and Congress

Nice turn of Phrase, Dr. Jay

Nice turn of Phrase, Dr. Jay -- representation without taxation. Unfortunate, but the process moves on, improved.I also agree with others that there is no reason why we cannot at least have the single-payer discussion. If not now, when? All in all, though, it is a relief to have Mr. O'Bama at the helm (okay, so I'm Irish).

It may not be okay that Tom

It may not be okay that Tom Daschle had not paid his taxes but he has his good points as well. He was actually very helpful to the people of South Dakota until Rove came in there and spread his lies about Daschle. Daschle was not the only one who voted for the war - many Democratic senators and congress persons were given a pack of lies that made them vote for the possibility but it doesn't mean that they were gung ho for the war if there weren't weapons. You will never get me to believe that that guy they pinned with sending the anthrax was the one. When Daschle was senator in South Dakota he went out of his way to help people. I am sure there are untold numbers of Republican public servants who have weaseled out of paying a LOT more than Tom Daschle owed here. I am not saying its right just that I think that instead of dismissing him as if he has no value as disenchanted Dems seem to want to do that it would be much fairer to give him credit for the good things he has done.