Share

Obama Urged to Create Special Detainee Commission

by: Pamela Hess  |  The Associated Press

photo
Barack Obama after signing executive order to close the military prison in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. (Photo: AFP / Getty Images)

    Washington - The former general who investigated abuses at Iraq's Abu Ghraib prison is joining an ex-FBI director and others in seeking a presidential commission to investigate the Bush administration's treatment of terror detainees.

    They want President Barack Obama to create a nonpartisan, independent panel that would review policies such as harsh interrogations and "extraordinary renditions," the forced movement of suspected terrorists.

    Obama has appointed a task force to recommend new policies for handling terror suspects who are detained in the future and to decide where they would be housed once the prison at Guantanamo Bay closes.

    But the president has resisted calls for a review of President George W. Bush's record. "I'm more interested in looking forward than I am in looking backward," Obama said Feb. 9.

    The new push comes from a group that includes retired Army Maj. Gen. Anthony Taguba, former FBI Director William Sessions and former Undersecretary of State Thomas Pickering. It was Taguba's internal report on abuse of prisoners by Army military guards at Abu Ghraib that led to various investigations.

    Others involved in the commission effort are Juan E. Mendez, former special adviser to the U.N. secretary-general on the prevention of genocide, and Rev. John H. Thomas, president of the United Church of Christ.

    Also supporting the idea are 18 human rights groups, from Amnesty International to the National Institute of Military Justice.

    The commission would develop a comprehensive report on the detention, treatment and transfer of detainees since the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.

    "We need to understand what happened and how to prevent any illegal actions from taking place in the future," Sessions said in a written statement.

    The chairmen of the House and Senate Judiciary committees also are pushing for wide-ranging investigations into detainee issues, warrantless wiretapping and political hires by the Justice Department during the Bush years.

    More than 700 prisoners have been held at the Guantanamo Bay Naval Base in Cuba, most for several years. Only a few were charged with a crime.

    The CIA took fewer than 100 prisoners and used harsh interrogation tactics on about one-third of them, including three subjected to waterboarding, a harsh technique that makes the prisoner feel he is in danger of drowning.

    An undisclosed number of the CIA prisoners were part of the rendition program that handed them over to other countries for questioning. Some prisoners claim they were tortured, but proving that in court has proved difficult.

    The commission proposal came the same day a U.S. appeals court blocked a plan to free in the U.S. 17 detainees " - Turkic-speaking Muslims from western China - now held at Guantanamo.

    There is no evidence they plotted or fought against the U.S., so the government has no authority to hold them. But finding a country where they can be released has proved difficult. The U.S. will not release them to their home for fear they will be tortured.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Inconceivable violence. It

Inconceivable violence. It is ridiculously reductive to only call torture a “crime”. We cannot grasp its circumstances, its effect, its consequences, or its aftermath. It is a crime nonetheless - of inconceivable violence. What we can conceive is that torture unmistakably violates the Articles of the Bill of Rights thwarting the very intention of democracy and the US Constitution. We can understand that torture is the ultimate corruption of power. We can also deeply sense, therefore, that torture is treason to democratic government and Rule of Law. Yet, if you can be made to blink or shrug off torture as in any way acceptable in democratic society, sooner or later our voice to protest such matters will be irrelevant, and the camps will be here among us.

Our Constitution promises

Our Constitution promises justice - that justice should apply to all people. Renditions, secret prisons, and all the other illegal behavior of the Bush Administration needs to be made visible and actions taken to correct these horrendous and immoral activities. We are a nation of laws and we need to act like congruently. The moralist Bush was an immoral leader.

As much as I think Obama is

As much as I think Obama is right to think forward, I cannot reconcile that I was taught that we have laws, and to have justice, these laws must be obeyed, and not swept under a rug. Obama doesn't have to get involved, but he should not stand in the way of justice. It has nothing to do with how he runs the country, it has to do with our integrity as a nation. I personally believe there were many horrendous acts committed in the name of the United States. This is a can of worms that must be opened if we ever want to hold our heads high in dignity. It will not go away, and if we as a nation do not absorb completely these injustices with a relative outcome, they will haunt us for decades to come.