Share

The Laugher Curve

by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t | Columnist

photo
House Republican Leader John Boehner (R-Ohio). (Photo: Getty Images)

    Some weeks ago, I penned an article titled "Dump the GOP," which argued in part, "President Obama can work with the Democratic congressional majorities to pass future legislation, perhaps making sure to get one GOP vote in the Senate to thwart a filibuster. If no such vote is forthcoming, he can dump any quixotic quest for one or any GOP votes and dare the GOP to filibuster widely popular bills. He's not going to get GOP support for anything, so why bother trying? Let them keep it up and lose every time, and let them try to stand on that record for the 2010 midterms."

    It appears my advice in this matter was a tad premature. President Obama does not have to dump the GOP, for it appears quite evident they are doing just fine dumping themselves without any help from the administration. As it turns out, this has not been a sudden thing, but a long and drawn-out event now entering its third year. The Republican Party's descent from total domination of the entire federal government to a state of utter disorder has come to pass after a clearly identifiable arc of events we will call, for the purposes of explanation and with tongue firmly in cheek, "The Laugher Curve."

    On Monday, November 6, 2006, the Republican Party was enjoying the fruits it had gained after three victorious election cycles in a row, two presidential and one congressional. Republicans had been in control of the White House for six years, and barring a slight hiccup when James Jeffords woke up on the left side of the bed, they had also held sway over Congress for twelve years. The Executive Branch under Bush so thoroughly dominated the agenda of the Legislative Branch that the two were essentially transformed into that Unitary entity long desired by the likes of Vice President Cheney.

    That Monday, as it turns out, was the GOP's high-water mark. On Tuesday, November 7, 2006, the Democratic Party took back the House and Senate, and for all practical purposes, the presidential administration of George W. Bush was politically finished, and the power of the Republican Party began to collapse. The writing had been on the wall all year; a multitude of congressional sex-and-bribery scandals had riddled the GOP, a mudfight over immigration had split their coalition, and party leader George W. Bush was garnering the lowest presidential approval ratings in recorded history. The Democrats did not run a particularly sharp or effective campaign to retake Congress in 2006, but the GOP did so good a job at damaging itself that such a campaign was not actually needed.

    Flash forward to the presidential campaign of 2008, when the chaos that has so overtaken the Republican Party truly began to sink in. Candidates Romney and Giuliani found themselves crippled by the Huckabee campaign's overwhelming popularity with the GOP base. In primary after primary, neither was able earn enough base votes to survive, but Huckabee could not gain enough non-base votes to prevail, either. In the end, all three campaigns annihilated each other, and only John McCain remained.

    The GOP base, however, reviled McCain's positions on immigration, campaign finance reform, the environment and Bush's tax cuts. McCain had no hope of winning without those base voters, so his campaign spent the entire general election season trying to back its way into the good graces of the GOP base, going so far as to tap Alaska governor and base darling Sarah Palin to join McCain on the ticket. Already burdened by so much bad GOP baggage, the disastrous Palin nomination struck the McCain campaign - and indeed the entire Republican party - like an Exocet missile below the waterline. The whole lot of them have been sinking ever since.

    Today, the Democratic Party controls both the Legislative and Executive Branches. President Obama, through masterfully delivered public addresses and carefully articulated policy initiatives, now dominates the high ground of American politics. Meanwhile, the GOP has been defending policies only popular within its base to hold what it still has, which marginalizes the party even further. The entire Republican Party, it seems, has spent the last week bending a knee to Rush Limbaugh, whose far-right grandstanding is leading the GOP even further into darkness.

    Sooner or later the party will re-emerge, for that is the way of things in American politics. In the meantime, however ... hoo, boy, what a glorious mess this is.

    Dump the GOP? No need; the GOP is doing just fine dumping itself, and neither the Obama administration nor the Democrats need to lift a finger. They are obeying a very old maxim of Chicago politics: never get in the way of a perfectly good train wreck.

  

»


William Rivers Pitt is a New York Times and internationally bestselling author of two books: "War on Iraq: What Team Bush Doesn't Want You to Know" and "The Greatest Sedition Is Silence." His newest book, "House of Ill Repute: Reflections on War, Lies, and America's Ravaged Reputation," is now available from PoliPointPress.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

We in the GOP shot our

We in the GOP shot our selves in the foot by spending way too much money and a foolish intervention in nations who were neither our enemies or friends. Then came the election and the only candidate the republicans had who refused to kow-tow to the stupidity of the Bush administration was actively shut out of debates - delegates denied seating - primaries and straw polls jury rigged to exclude Ron Paul - yet his campaign has what the republican party so desporately lacks - a young innovative base (ron paul gold coins, Money bombs, blimp) that is firmly gounded in individual rights, fiscal sanity and the constitution. McCain signed his political death warrant when he supported the bail-out. Now the democrats are magnifying everything wrong the republicans did...

Why did the party fall

Why did the party fall apart? Because the Republican Party was a weird amalgam of three elements: 1) the plutocrats, 2)the Christian Right and 3)the far-right crazies, (There are two subgroups in 3) the racists and the Randists) The plutocrats brought in the Xtians with the Southern Strategy, but never really reconciled the two groups--and of course despised the crazies while manipulating them. All these three had in common was that they hated liberals. But after eight years, the Xtians hadn't got their abortion ban or, well, anything--and maybe they suspected that their born-again president was just a plutocrat wastrel who never went to church. When they no longer had power to hold them together and had to fall back on ideology, it was--what ideology? Was it fundamentalism or atheist Objeectivism? Were we to be a global empire or an isolationist country with closed borders? Was Hollywood the Scarlet Woman of Babylon or a profit center for Republicans? This unholy alliance is falling apart. They still all hate liberals. But the Christians are beginning to realize they hate the plutocrats too, and the crazies are realizing that (big surprise) they hate everybody else in the alliance, including the other crazies. It's fun to watch it happen.

The Republican Party doesn't

The Republican Party doesn't have to "re-emerge". It can go the way of the Whigs and the Anti Masonics. Fresh new parties such as the Greens are ready to take the vacant role of Loyal Opposition. Punitive methods of keeping us off of the ballot must be scrapped in the states where it remains difficult to impossible to get on the ballot. In the meantime, Greens are running counties, school boards and small towns across the country, reinventing honest government and trying to make up for declines in all of the environments.

Thanks Mr. Pitt for your

Thanks Mr. Pitt for your confidence in suggesting that the horror of this train wreck is on its way out with the Republicans boiling in their self made stew and the CPAC is now run by Limbaugh. However, if we really wish to correct future train wrecks, we must remember and recount the ways and just exactly who was driving this ill fated train. What I hold in the recesses of my darker vision of this world and nation is the rise of Christian Nationalism in the face of increasing Republican fall out. The Conservative right didn't die in the wreck, just the engineers. There is every reason to believe in their manipulation of the media that they will continue to dismantle the Obama freedom train. Until the CPAC and others like them are finished I can't rest.

I have been enjoying

I have been enjoying watching the GOP train wreck on Countdown and Rachel's show, and at Truthout and Think Progress. I fear the inevitable GOP comeback. Nobody except Pitt has acknowledged that they will right themselves and be back. Of course they will. Maybe it's just that as a recovering Catholic I can't truly enjoy the beauty of the moment. Stil, it is fun to watch!

Yes indeed. The GOP is

Yes indeed. The GOP is running around like the proverbial chicken with it's head cut off. Just deserts. Let there be no misunderstanding, it was planned this way. The disasterous and almost laughable antics of the GOP during the presidential campaign were a well orchestrated plan to loose the election. Bush, and all that he represented, (obvious totalitarianism), had to be stripped from power. But only on the surface. The same bankers, the CFR, Trilateral Commission and Builderberg Group - continue to pull the strings. President Obama will dance to their tune weather he likes it or not. Bill Clinton who is a member of all the above mentioned groups and gets his marching orders from them has and will continue to pile his old buddies, recommended by them, on Obama. This is the plan. Each of these groups believes the only future for this world is to exist under a one world government, one military force and one financial system, (the world bank). Who resides in the White House is irrelevant. But for the time, their control of governments and politicians has to remain out of sight. The election of Obama is the opiate that is necessary to dull the senses of the masses as to who really controls the fate of the of America. Please read "The Creature From Jekyll Island" and "The True Story of The Builderberg Group". Your vote is irrelevant.

I would only disagree that

I would only disagree that this is a "glorious mess" Mr. Pitt. I'm a progressive democrat but, as an American, I find this mess not so glorious. Both parties are a joke and the fact that neither seems capable of working together for the actual interests of individual citizens in this country is just another sad example of the state of our country is in. I find no reason to laugh about this.

Speaking of laughter curves,

Speaking of laughter curves, here's a good one: Permanent Republican Majority... ha ha ha ha ha!

I agree with the first post.

I agree with the first post. True what Mr. Pitt says. The Dems won't lift a finger until one of the aforementioned pulls that particular string. One world government and one military presence. It doesn't matter who makes the laws. What matters is who owns the digits we now use as money. Digits that can be created at the flick of a button. Digits that flow in one direction... toward the central banks. We, all of us, everyone of us, even Obama, are slaves. Say good bye to the world we thought we knew. Because it hasn't been around for at least a hundred years.

Wow, there were a lot of

Wow, there were a lot of fatalists who commented on this piece! I'm thrilled that the majority of the American people were able to see through the lies and manipulations of the right-wingers and make their voices heard in the last election, in spite of a corrupt mainstream media and rigging of voting machines and other illegal actions orchestrated by Rove and company in the past five elections. The fact that we beat the bad guys this time gives me hope for our future. Our country, our world, will become what we create. Every day I work towards a just, fair, honest, and compassionate future. Might I suggest that we all do that, instead of lamenting that we are the powerless slaves of some vast financial machine? Even if that were true, which I doubt, I will choose hope and action over despair and giving up any day! Thank you, Mr. Pitt, for another insightful article.

The R's are history and

The R's are history and don't have to come back to life as the D's have taken over the center-right. We've been cleverly led to a one-party government. The only way out that I can see is reform of media rules. And who is going to lead that through the process??

We need to be very careful

We need to be very careful about how we laugh. Let's not get smug about the Democrats' victory. Let's work to keep things going in the correct direction--for the people, of the people, and by the people. It would be a dream come true to have a government that worked toward the highest good of all citizens and not just of a few well-heeled individuals. Don't get too happy. Get to work!

I know they will "be back".

I know they will "be back". But, it is such fun watching and listening to them.

WR Pitt: "the GOP is doing

WR Pitt: "the GOP is doing just fine dumping itself, and neither the Obama administration nor the Democrats need to lift a finger." Unfortunately this is the problem I have with a lot of the Democratic performance over the past 30 years, and this attitude is often on display on this site. Once the Democrats are in office, they feel that the nation's problems are now solved and thus feel no need to lift a finger. So we get "baby steps" towards health care, the Republican wars just keep on simmering in Iraq and Afghanistan, greenhouse gases keep going up, nobody has the guts to regulate the out-of-control financial industry, and on and on and on. What will be the lasting legacy of the Obama administration if Democrats spend a few more years smirking and not lifting a finger? It's too early to pass judgments, of course, but so far it's not looking good.

Hard to laugh with millions

Hard to laugh with millions dead and trillions spent on unnecessary wars and hundreds of thousands of disabled soldiers and the economy in the toilet. It took 8 years of Republican leadership and Democratic cowardice to bring us to this point in our country's history. Proud to be an American - hell no.

The D's are now as far right

The D's are now as far right as the R's were 30 years ago making the R's irrelevant and unnecessary and the two party system history. Now what? Scott

We ought to watch carefully

We ought to watch carefully as bills are crafted. Language can appear benign when enacted by an apparently benign administration. The same regulations in the hands of a less benign administration could be turned against us. I remind you of the "Clean Air and Clear Skies" initiatives that really supported the bad player corporations. Be careful! Don't assume we will be well taken care of by this administration--though it may appear to be so. A national or world bank could be devastating. Food safety bills could knock farmers' markets and family organic farms off the map. We must be careful and thoughtful, and pay attention!

Great comments all. But the

Great comments all. But the Government can keep track of all the money and interest loaned to Banks and interest, what would be wrong with the Government loaning it to us directly? Cut out the broke middleman. At the rate loaned to banks? It would be great for the economy and reduce the national debt also.

"The laughing man has not

"The laughing man has not yet heard the terrible news."

Wow! Just like the antics of

Wow! Just like the antics of the republicant party the bush leagers still can't except that the road they followed so blindly has led us all to ruin. All though the partying may have been intense and seemed very profitable for some. The party of "Me" can not stand and never will , for long. Only the party of we can actually make any head way towards peace and sanity. ....Oops I forgot the party of Me LIKES war. And sanity is not something they seem to be capable of. So , I suppose instead, the gloat and the glut the repubs have eaten and regurgitated for so long, is gone, now they will have to eat crow. And those are all the gloom and doom comments you'll see in answer to this column. Crow regurgitated.

Act Right Think Left Vote

Act Right Think Left Vote Green.

As long as the Democrats

As long as the Democrats don't actively study, critique, and perhaps even abolish the Federal Reserve they will not be fundamentally distinguishable from the Republicans. Our public monies are in the hands of a private banking cartel.

Responding to the comment

Responding to the comment from Tom Martin...... The Democrats do not need to magnify the wrongs committed by the Republicans. The wrongs are far too huge to magnify..and are far too evident to even the most ill-informed American. The Republicans continue to shoot themselves in the foot...almost as though they are unaware of the shift..or..unwilling to accept the turning tide that led tho their defeat. In other words...the Republicans need no assistance whatsoever in pointing out their obvious wrongdoings. The screeching snarling swarmy right-wing media nutbars (Fox News etc.) give them daily platforms in which to air their grievances...no matter how absurd.