Share

Senate Panel Reaches Terms for Probe of CIA Detentions

by: Joby Warrick  |  The Washington Post

photo
Leon Panetta, CIA director, talks with California Senator Dianne Feinstein, Chair of Senate Select Intelligence Committee. (Photo: Reuters)

    The Senate intelligence committee reached an agreement yesterday on the framework of a wide-ranging review of the CIA's past treatment of terrorism detainees, even as members acknowledged that the bulk of the panel's work will be conducted in secret.

    The committee's Democratic and Republican leaders settled on a blueprint for a year-long probe that will examine the agency's detention and interrogation of about 100 suspected al-Qaeda operatives held in secret overseas prisons between 2002 and 2006. Panel members last week confirmed their intention to conduct such an inquiry.

    The scope of the bipartisan review will include the CIA's use of harsh interrogation tactics, including waterboarding, or simulated drowning, and whether such methods actually produced significant intelligence, as the Bush administration claimed, the panel said in a prepared statement.

    But how much of their findings will be made public remained unclear. Since nearly all aspects of the CIA's program were secret, key witnesses and documents will be examined in closed session, congressional officials confirmed. It is not yet known whether the panel's review will produce an unclassified report.

    The Senate inquiry will run parallel to a separate White House review of Bush administration detention and interrogation practices. Neither review is expected to result in recommendations for criminal charges.

    CIA Director Leon E. Panetta said yesterday that he will cooperate with the committee, calling the inquiry an "exercise in legitimate oversight."

    "What I will not support is an inquiry designed to punish those who acted in accord with guidance from the Department of Justice," Panetta said in a statement addressed to CIA employees.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Ultimate Corruptions. It is

Ultimate Corruptions. It is repellent and infuriating to again see planted phrases aimed at distorting and soft-selling torture. To the extent that torture has been sold to the gullible, it has been done with the same grotesque distortions of language displayed in this article by the Washington Post. “Water-boarding”? “Harsh interrogation tactics?” “Simulated drowning?” REALITY CHECK: Forced drowning doesn't “simulate” anything. “Water-board torture” is attempted murder, repeated, with the aim of keeping the victim alive. It is infuriating sophistry to see bromides and palliatives used to make tyrannical and sadistic behavior by our government acceptable. We are told this “Probe” of “Detentions” is secret. Secrecy is especially egregious in this instance. It is contemptuous of democratic processes, our Constitution, the public’s safety and its right to know. Torture, Kidnapping, and Murder based on suspicions, without charges, Due Process, or uniform standards of proof are War Crimes. They express the ultimate corruptions of power through inconceivable violence. Yet, the language used to describe this “investigation” allows for no faith in its processes. One sees no attempt to establish accountability for the most horrific of crimes. It is incumbent upon this committee to be open and to express and acknowledge the gravity of these crimes and policies and to hold its perpetrators accountable. Nothing less is acceptable.