Share

Scandal at Treasury: Official Quits Amidst Fraud Scandal

by: Brian Ross, Justin Rood, and Joseph Rhee  |  ABC News

photo
Darrel Dochow, former Office of Thrift Supervision regional director who allowed IndyMac bank to hide its impending failure, has resigned from the federal government. IndyMac cost taxpayers over $9 billion in defaulted mortgages and subprime loans. (Photo: AFP / Getty Images)

    Darrel Dochow allowed IndyMac bank to cook its books, investigators say.

    The man at the center of a fraud scandal at the Treasury Department has been allowed to quietly quit and retire from his job as a government regulator, despite allegations that he allowed a bank to falsify financial records and amidst outcries from investigators who say the case shows how cozy government regulators have become with the banks and savings and loans they are supposed to be checking on.

    Darrel Dochow, the West Coast regional director at the Office of Thrift Supervision who investigators say allowed IndyMac to backdate its deposits to hide its ill health, quit last Friday. Prior to his leaving, Dochow was removed from his position but remained on the government payroll while the Inspector General's Office investigates the allegations against him.

    Treasury Department Inspector General Eric Thorson announced in November his office would probe how Dochow allowed the IndyMac bank to essentially cook its books, making it appear in government filings that the bank had more deposits than it really did. But Thorson's aides now say IndyMac wasn't the only institution to get such cozy assistance from the official who should have been the cop on the beat.

    Investigators say Dochow, who reportedly earned $230,000 a year, allowed IndyMac to register an $18 million capital injection it received in May in a report describing the bank's financial condition in the end of March.

    "They [IndyMac] were able to maintain their well-capitalized threshold and continue to use broker deposits to make loans," said Marla Freedman, an assistant Inspector General at Treasury. "Basically, while the institution was having financial difficulty, it kept the public from knowing earlier than it otherwise should have or would have."

    In at least one instance, investigators say, banking regulators actually approached the bank with the suggestion of falsifying deposit dates to satisfy banking rules - even if it disguised the bank's health to the public.

    The federal government took over IndyMac in July, after the bank's stock price plummeted to just pennies a share when it was revealed the bank had financial troubles due to defaulted mortgages and subprime loans, costing taxpayers over $9 billion.

    Critics Point to Cozy Relationship Between Banks and Regulators

    In order to backdate the filings, IndyMac sought and received permission from Dochow, according to Freedman.

    "That struck us as very unusual," said Freedman. "Typically transactions are to be recorded in the period in which they occur, not afterwards. So it was very unusual."

    One former regulator says Dochow's actions illustrate the cozy relationship between banks and government regulators.

    "He did nothing to protect taxpayers in losses," former federal bank regulator William Black told ABC News. "Instead of correcting it [Dochow] made it worse by increasing the accounting fraud."

    Meanwhile, IndyMac customers who lost their savings have launched their own website and are demanding answers from the government. They were further infuriated after learning Dochow was also the regulator in 1989 who oversaw the failed Lincoln Savings and Loan, a scandal that sent its CEO Charles Keating to prison.

    "He's the person that claimed that he looked into Charles Keating's eyes and knew that Charles Keating was a good guy and therefore ignored all of the professional staff that told him that Keating was a fraud, and he produced the worst failure of the Savings and Loan Crisis at $3.4 billion. Now he's managed more than triple that," said Black, now an economics professor at the University of Missouri in Kansas City, Missouri.

    Following the Lincoln scandal, Dochow was demoted and placed into a relatively obscure office, but later, inexplicably was brought back into the Office of Thrift Supervision.

    Dochow declined to answer questions from ABC News.

    IndyMac Customers Furious

    After Ronnie Lopez was killed in Iraq, his mother Elaine invested the life insurance proceeds at IndyMac. She lost $37,000 of it.

    While Dochow could end up losing his job, neither he nor his colleagues are expected to go to prison.

    "This is criminal with the small 'c'," said Black. "No one within the regulatory ranks may go to jail, but they have done the worst possible disservice to the taxpayers of America."

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

It IS criminal with a

It IS criminal with a Capital C. Dochow, the people who promoted him back into the Office of Thrift Supervision, and ALL other individual employees of the T. Department (e.g. those regulators who suggested IndyMac should cook their deposit dates) should have assets seized, retirement benefits pulled, and be mandated to lifelong probation for the rest of their lives to serve those they have harmed (the taxpayers and citizen investors). Come on! Why should employees of regulatory agencies be immune from the justice system, be above the law, be excused from the oath of US Government Ethics?

He should be indicted. Is

He should be indicted. Is he also receiving a pension?

For more comprehensive

For more comprehensive background coverage, see this article (which also points out that Dochow was appointed during the Bush Administration, which this article fails to mention): Regulator Let IndyMac Bank Falsify Report Agency Didn't Enforce Its Rules, Inquiry Finds By Binyamin Appelbaum and Ellen Nakashima Washington Post Staff Writers Tuesday, December 23, 2008; A01

"So?" as our immortal and

"So?" as our immortal and beloved leader, Vice President Cheney, would say. Isn't this an example of "little government" in action, as opposed to the nefarious "big government" promoted by the socialists in the Democratic Party? These types go back to the administration of our "immortal and unforgettable leader," Ronald Reagan, much idolized by Republican candidates during the Republican primaries. No, I am not a socialist, just a realist.

Hey, this is fraud of the

Hey, this is fraud of the highest order, bilking the taxpayers. This is not criminal with a small c, and not convicting the wrongdoers of fraud would be an even worse disservice to the taxpayers. These people shouldn't go to prison, they should pay off their debt to society with community services for the rest of their lives.

Dubya is looking for

Dubya is looking for his"legacy?" Here's a piece of it. The Culture of Corruption lives on.

These bankers (others who

These bankers (others who deceive) the public, need to go to JAIL. If you or I did this we would certainly be indicted.

Illuminating glimpse into

Illuminating glimpse into how so many corporations were allowed to - perhaps even encouraged - to lie by federal regulators. Depressing, yet very informative. keep it up!

Why should they not go to

Why should they not go to jail, this is the second time around and the gall of it all, the thief is put back in the same position when they thought not one was looking. This is a prime example of "the fox guarding the henhouse" the fox does not do a very good job either just look at the chickens they have eaten and now it falls on the taxpayers. Would not smaller fish go to jail. This is under the guise of what the Republician matra has been saying that smaller government is better. Sorry won't wash smaller government is called "A Dictatorship", I think that Bush would have liked to have been called King George.

Why should no one in the

Why should no one in the regulatory ranks go to jail?

Criminal with the small "C"?

Criminal with the small "C"? What is going on out there? Our government agencies, in place to protect us, appear to have become rotten to the core. Of course, that was Norquist's plan all along. Worked beautifully with the rich getting richer at the same time. Cleaning up the mess the Republicans have made is beginning to look like the Augean stables. At the same time, the Republicans made sure there was no money left to pay for the cleanup. And they can't understand why they are in such poor odor with the voters? If it wasn't so tragic, it would be laughable that all they can say is " Just let us keep on doing what we've been doing and everything will be fine". I hope they keep on saying that. And the corporate media is already trying to hang this mess around Obama's neck. Although it started in 2007, was ignored for a year and a half, and and Bush fiddled while the banks and economy collapsed, nevertheless the corporate media is pushing the idea that Obama's less than 7 week old presidency is responsible for the condition we are in. Hopefully they will end up discrediting themselves just as the Republicans are doing.

And this is why the whole

And this is why the whole world hates Americans now. We put people in prison for marijuana and let financial scum like this guy just retire into a sunset. Yes, we the people are to blame because we let that happen. We looked the other way when everything was peachy and now we are paying for our ignorance.

Just like any other person

Just like any other person of influence (wink) they take full advantage of being above ethics and law.

I have often wondered why

I have often wondered why there is almost never a mention of our former President's brother Neil. He was at the center of the failed Lincoln Savings and Loan Association as well. He has followed his Grandfather's model, and entered the business world as a member of the Board of Directors or the President of the Board of Director's to many companies. The 'patron' of the Bush Family was a funny little man who thought that it was OK to keep the interest paid to the money that was sent to some of the companies he represented. The Jews that tried to get their money back after the WWII didn't think it was so funny. The Nazi's that old Bush supported so well had a lot of funny games. I can't even suggest that Neil had anything to do with this scandal, but I have to say that this smells so bad that it almost has to be a Bush game. Too bad that I think so, but, I think so! Best wishes,

I'm speechless and my gut

I'm speechless and my gut hurts from disgust and anger. After the Lincoln savings fraud, Dochow should have only been given a job sweeping streets. I wish I knew for sure that there is retribution after death and people like this would be somewhere where they would suffer for eternity. I hope that the people that lost money get some retribution and their money back.

"Mother, should I trust the

"Mother, should I trust the government?" Pink Floyd

This is an outrage. His

This is an outrage. His actions have hurt people he was charged to protect. This Treasury official deserves an indictment on criminal fraud. (And he very probably got kickbacks or other material benefits from the execs at IndyMac for his pointed dereliction of duty.) But at the very least he should lose his large pension and valuable "lifetime" medical coverage --- all paid by the taxpayer who he cheated.

Note - so long as Dochow was

Note - so long as Dochow was a federal official, he was largely immune from prosecution without requiring a court of inquiry be set up that would likely be not only time consuming but also would prevent the prosecution of MUCH bigger fish. Dochow's a minnow. By resigning from the government, he is now in a position where he can in fact be the target of civil lawsuits, and Obama can work on sweating out the bigger fish.

Oh, those awful Communists

Oh, those awful Communists and Socialists! They put Bastards like this before a firing squad for defrauding thousands, if not millions, of their livelihood and savings. Murderers and common run-of the mill small 'c' criminals get 20 or 30 years breaking rocks, as the harm they do is on a truly small scale in comparison. We reward the thieves and scoundrels with lifetime immunity and huge pensions and full medical coverage. Bush and Cheney are just the tip of the iceberg, yet the public remains more afraid of 82 year old Fidel then of monsters like this. You'd think we'd get a clue, but not in my lifetime, I'm afraid!

So who does this guy know?

So who does this guy know? (or blow?) Bush himself? Somebody in the Fed? He absolutely MUST have a very good buddy in the federal gov't. Or knowledge about someone who is there. If this is not investigated and punished, we have no integrity as citizens. Our idea of justice and the underpinnings of our entire investment system are in question.

The buddy-buddy stuff (and

The buddy-buddy stuff (and secrecy) throughout the Bush administration for years, about every move favoring in some way big business, is what pretty much rotted our system of government, the welfare of our society, the earth's chances for survival, camaraderie among nations--you name it!

This is one more article on

This is one more article on how the "White Shirts" get by with any crap they wish to pull on the rest of us. This dredges up an old Carol King song which I have taken poetic license with.... "Doesn't anybody go to jail anymore? It'd be so nice to see your ass locked in jail, Lookin' really pale, but you're above the law, This is what we saw, You should be locked away-for many days- Please go away, don't want to hear anymore, You bankrupt my store, you should be put away- Put away....so far away!"

Well people, this is just

Well people, this is just politics as usual----one dirty hand washes the other and both come out clean. You may soon see this guy on your green and he smiles at you----greed wearing the mask of morality.

Try being black and walking

Try being black and walking into the 7-11 with an old, rusty .38 Special. For the fifty bucks you might get, they'll give you life. Then try being a fat, white bank regulator and helping steal a couple of billion. They'll give you a nice pension. With government health care.

I had nearly all my whole

I had nearly all my whole pension stolen, along with 3,500 Republic steelworkers, when the criminal Bush appointed his guy (Kandarian) over the PBGC and literally stole the pensions due those hard working folks. This was in '02 after RTI shut down for nightturn, called in the day turn, and stated that they were in bankruptcy. We EARNED those pensions, worked our whole lives for them, but Bush helps steal our pensions, at the same time that he appoints, and protects, filthy, stinking corporate thieves like this! It is time that the people get what's been stolen from! Parasitic thieves like this guy are just part of the huge corrupt, corporate structure that has lived in luxury, off what they've stolen from regular hard working folks. We've got to demand justice!

That's the problem with

That's the problem with government jobs! Incompetent people will not or can not get fired. Incompetent people should loose their jobs and they should not be protected by a union. Once this dilemma is solved things will work out!!!

Dubbya's legacy. This, for

Dubbya's legacy. This, for me, is the kind of example I would give, among others now numerous, to anyone challenging me why the U.S. of A. shoud be considered a world model for honesty, integrity, balanced society, rule of law (now known as Rule of Flaw), democratic society, and a reference for all other nations, somewhat primitives as we are not Americans. Have a great day.

Bulls "service" Cows.

Bulls "service" Cows. Governments "service" Citizens. Civil servants are just doing the jobs their paid to do. The is the way things are done in the Capitalist-Elitist USA, so why is everyone so shocked? Were you all so foolish as to believe in the Democracy that's advertised on TV every night? Sheeple one and ALL...Sad.

the OTS: worst regulator in

the OTS: worst regulator in the US gov. Either a bunch of stupid people or corrupt people. Look at the OTS legacy: WAMU, COUNTRYWIDE, INDYMAC, etc., etc., They are still burying the fraudulent loans these criminal banks made to over a million Americans?

I recall one of this

I recall one of this country’s founding principles which says that 'everyone be treated equally by the law', that 'nobody is above the law', and so on – citizens, government officials, police, military, ... Isn’t that one of the complaints in the Declaration of Independence – that the English King was 'above the law'? That he made the laws but was not subject to them? I think 'equal treatment' has taken much more of a beating over the years than the stuff Bush & Co. did to the Bill of Rights during the last 8 years. A lot of folks are upset about Bush's doings, but I rarely hear much about 'equal treatment' – it’s been customary for centuries that the ruling class can get away with anything. If you or I (ordinary citizens) robbed a bank of its customers’ deposits, how quickly would the Law be on our necks? How much time would we spend in jail if convicted? Then suppose you or I robbed the bank a second time? But Darrel Dochow can simply "resign". There may be an 'investigation' of some sort, but very probably nothing else will happen. It would be interesting to see citizens ‘take the law into their hands’ – conduct trials, determine sentences – compared to how things work now (the 'justice' system prosecuting the plebes while protecting the ruling class). John

"Why should employees of

"Why should employees of regulatory agencies be immune from the justice system, be above the law, be excused from the oath of US Government Ethics?" The answer is clear. The crooks are smarter and work harder to get what they want thean the rest of us do to get what they want. The result speaks for itself.

"If this is not investigated

"If this is not investigated and punished, we have no integrity as citizens." This is backwards. The reverse is more to the point: we have no integrity as citizens, therefore this shall not be investigated or punished.

I too do not understand why

I too do not understand why "neither he nor his colleagues are expected to go to prison." Failing to notice that a bank was cheating is one thing, authorizing a bank to cheat is another. Who is this guy, who incentivized him to do this, and how many others in similar positions are doing the same? We need better PRIVATE enforcement of bank regulations. Like shareholder scouts or something.

We spent how many years

We spent how many years investigating Whitewater, the Clintons, and Monica Lewinsky, but these robber barrons who have robbed millions of Americans, conducted themselves as nothing more than psychopathic thugs, go free. There's something drastically wrong with the priorities in our country.

COMPLIANT=word used in

COMPLIANT=word used in medical & its associated fields:should be used in regulation of ALL&ANY business[NOT just the SMALL ones] and industry, banking, education, government, legislation, education and everything else-the rationale here is the same as to why we enforce the speed and safety belt LAWS on our roads.

The crimes and corruption

The crimes and corruption are rampant. Every day I read more and more articles like this one that talk about how people have been bilked out their life savings. Trillions of dollars have been stolen - yet NOT ONE of the criminals has been arrested!!! I’m sorry but I am not buying into the bull that we’ve been told. Like Alan Greenspan who was an expert on market bubbles, yet he claims he could not have foreseen the housing bubble and “bubble junior”, Ben Bernanke an academic expert on the depression, yet he could not have foreseen the collapse of the economy. BULL!!! All the banks and Wall Street firms collapse – but not before the Execs all cash out, only later to be bailed out and rewarded with bonuses??? BULL!!! Then there’s Uncle Bernie sitting in his multi-million dollar penthouse who gets a plea bargain deal so we never learn the details about how he victimized his thousands of clients? Oh, and let’s not forget Sir Allen Stanford, the billionaire cricket impresario who stole billions yet was not even arrested??? The SEC and other authorities had evidence for years - yet they did nothing? What a joke and now this? Where will it end? Does anyone else see that there is a pattern being played out here?

This is a conspiracy to

This is a conspiracy to defraud America, and hardly anyone has been put in jail yet. Bernie Madoff still resides in his luxury penthouse, Bankers are still taking in record bonuses, and nobody knows where all the money went. Or do they? The people with the money know. Criminals who have destroyed the banking system, the economy, and thus the nation should be going to jail. 150 years is not enough for Madoff.

ARREST! PROSECUTE!!

ARREST! PROSECUTE!! INCARCERATE!!!

Ron Reagan told the

Ron Reagan told the government, upon entering the White House in 1981, the we [meaning the government] always have time for our friends. Friends in this case being political benefactors, donors, and fellow travelers. And routinely the bureaucracy was instructed put the interests of Reagan friends (FORs - friends of Ron, and FONs - friends of Nancy) before the needs of the American people. The result is the catastrophe that was the Reagan administration. Update to the 21st century Same motto - government for sale, just different conservatives running the store. And it just never ends. K Street, Savings and Loan, 17 Reagan execs indicted, Iraq, Afgan money scandals, no bid contracts. This is not coincidence.