Share

Oh, What a Lovely Class War!

by: Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
"Security of the Family." (Artwork: Seymour Fogel)

    My goodness, how they howl when the proverbial shoe is on the proverbial other foot. You'd think the Red Army had just left Moscow and was preparing a frontal assault on the Federal Reserve.

    So what are conservatives, Wall Street and financial television commentators shouting? Socialists! That's right. Spread the word: Socialists are swarming over our nation's Capitol and making off with the means of production, otherwise known as campaign contributions and the federal budget. You got trouble, my friends.

    The hysteria started during the campaign, retreated a bit but was back full throttle by the day after the inauguration. President Obama's left hand was barely off Abraham Lincoln's Bible when South Carolina Sen. Jim DeMint told the January 21 edition of The Wall Street Journal, "What I'm looking to do as a conservative leader in the Senate is to identify those Republicans, and even some Democrats, and put together a consensus of people who can help stop this slide toward socialism."

    Newt Gingrich, resurrected yet again, proclaims his Contract on America has been canceled and replaced by Barack Obama's "European socialism." Josh Bolin, founder of the conservative web site Reagan.org is quoted in The New York Times saying, "Socialism is something new for us to hit Obama over the head with," and a panel at the recent Conservative Political Action Conference was titled, "Bailing Out Big Business: Are We All Socialists Now?"

    And what do all these pesky socialists coming out from the woodwork want? Why, class war, of course. Arise, ye workers from your slumbers, at least in time to watch early morning TV. On the "Today" show last week, CNBC's Jim Cramer alleged that President Obama was perpetrating 'an agenda in this country now that I would regard as being a radical agenda," adding, "This is the most, greatest wealth destruction I've seen by a president."

    Joan Walsh of Salon.com noted several hundred references to Obama and "class warfare" when she searched the words on Google News at the beginning of March and wondered "why are mainstream reporters pushing this storyline?"

    The truth is, there's nothing new about any of this. A famous New Deal-era cartoon in The New Yorker shows Manhattan swells in black tie urging neighbors to "Come along. We're going to the Trans-Lux to hiss Roosevelt." And as financial historian Charles Geisst told the Times, "To hear [FDR] referred to as Comrade Roosevelt during that period was not unusual."

    But although Obama embraces FDR analogies, in some respects he's a piker by comparison. The Columbia Journalism Review linked to a chart from the National Taxpayers Union and noted, "The top marginal rate of 39.6 percent that Obama is proposing is actually low by historical standards - he may be adopting FDR-style rhetoric, but his tax plan isn't in the same ballpark. And it wasn't only Roosevelt. Throughout the Eisenhower administration, top tax rates exceeded 90 percent. Under Nixon, they never dropped below 70 percent. Even for most of Ronald Reagan's term, they were at 50 percent. Those presidents aren't often thought of as 'class warriors.'"

    Nor did Democrats or progressives fire the first shots in any so-called class war. As the recently poorer multibillionaire Warren Buffet said a couple of years ago, "There's class warfare, all right, but it's my class, the rich class, that's making war, and we're winning."

    America wasn't founded as a nation where winner takes all, but over the last couple of decades that's the way it has turned out. The central vision of "We, the people" has been distorted and manipulated by the powerful and privileged doing their damnedest as they wage class war to sustain their way of life at the expense of everybody else, even in this current crisis.

    "Sold Out: How Wall Street and Washington Betrayed America," a report released last week by the nonprofit citizen's group Essential Information and the Consumer Education Foundation finds that "from 1998-2008, Wall Street investment firms, commercial banks, hedge funds, real estate companies and insurance conglomerates made $1.7 billion in political contributions and spent another $3.4 billion on lobbyists, a financial juggernaut aimed at undercutting federal regulation."

    According to Harvey Rosenfield, president of the Consumer Education Foundation, "Depression-era programs that would have prevented the financial meltdown that began last year were dismantled, and the warnings of those who foresaw disaster were drowned in an ocean of political money. Americans were betrayed, and we are paying a high price - trillions of dollars - for that betrayal."

    The truth of the matter may be that, as Nate Silver wrote at FiveThirtyEight.com, "The stock market is engaged in something of a pity party - the prevailing emotions being fear and loathing. It is concerned about policies which might be burdensome to equity holders in large corporations while perhaps nevertheless being boons to economic recovery."

    Add to that a heavy dose of petulance, arrogance and malice stirred further by any attempt at curtailing their rice pudding days. While the dives in the stock markets are real enough, the screams and rending of bespoke garments carry more than the hint of self-inflicted wounds, in the manner of spoiled kids saying, "I meant to do that," when they break a toy, even though this administration is seeking solutions by joining hands with the very financial institutions that got us into the jam in the first place - including private equity firms and hedge funds.

    Cries of Socialism! - with their insinuations of sedition and Bolsheviks under the bedstead - ring hollow, especially with the threat of global Communism 20 years past and many in the financial world opting for expediency over ideology. The basic truth is that there are no easy answers, no quick fixes, no kiss to the body politic that will make it all better.

    Nonetheless, they lash out, flailing madly, saddling up straw horses and conjuring memories of McCarthy-like witch hunts, desperate to point the finger at anyone but themselves.

  

»


Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program Bill Moyers Journal, which airs Friday nights on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Just one thought: would

Just one thought: would socialism really be that bad right now? I don't think so.

Why don't we start talking

Why don't we start talking about the REAL upper class, since the Federal Reserve is about as federal as Federal Express. It's important to keep in mind that those Zombie Banks we've been hearing about are the owners of The Federal Reserve. So we have the Zombie Banks who caused all these problems bailing out themselves through THEIR Federal Reserve with OUR money. I think we should nationalize the Fed and cancel all that interest debt we owe them. Why in the world do we need to pay interest to THEM when our government could print its' own money interest free. The United States of America can no longer afford this CRAZY arrangement that was crafted by Bankers.

Our country has been made

Our country has been made great by "socialism" and corporate wealth is enhanced by socialism. Without our road system built by socialism, how many cars would have been sold over the years? The federal government (the people, socialism) paid for the Louisiana Purchase which doubled the size of the country at the time, built the Erie Canal, funded the GI bill which gave the middle class the great boost in the 40's and 50's and brought great prosperity to our nation. Libraries, police, firemen, utilities, national parks, all socialism.

Whenever there is a sense of

Whenever there is a sense of loss, people look for someone to blame. If you lean left you blame Bush & Co, if you lean right you blame Obama or Pelosi. Maybe we should stop the blame and just fix the problems

As one looks at this

As one looks at this behaviour from across the pond, it is remarkable that they are so blatantly extreme in the level of immaturity they display. Throwing tantrums and humiliating themselves with the likes of rush limbaug...no surprise Like children who have been neglected and fed on fast food they are insatiable because fundamentally they have been programmed from the cradle and starved from any nurturing, upbringing, and nutrition. So what we, as a society , have bred , is a generation, (or 3) of gluttonous, ego centric sociopaths...we have drugged them with ritilin and cocaine, alcohol and antidepressants and dressed them in banana republic and Abercrombie , put them on the market and sold them to the highest bidder... whether it was Jerry Springer or Fox News..or worse we sent them to the slaughter where anything decent we may have been able to impart , gets brainwashed and annihilated beyond recognition...and then they ask us to support the Military... ugh... This whole picture is sick, with the most pathetic display of indulgence and complete disregard for these catastrophic consequences which were known certainties...the Maddoff's and Cheney's, the Addingtons and Yu's, architects of the axis of evil and evil personified....Henry Paulson, Greenspan, Bernacke... These people are responsible for war crimes against the American Economy which stabilizes the Global Economy !! Do you think for a moment they have any conscience for your child's college education??

We should all remember that

We should all remember that we are dealing with the successors of those on HUAC who considered a line in a movie written by Dalton Trumbo "share and share alike, that's democracy", Communist propaganda, who saw in the story and movie Robin Hood, Communist ideas of redistributing wealth, who lived and politically died by the dictum "every liberal is a socialist, every socialist is a Communist, every Communist is Moscow's spy.' All that has changed is that they don't have Moscow to kick around any more. Seriously, the Keynesian compensatory fiscal policies which the Obama administration is carrying forward may today as they did in the New Deal period, help to fund social progams which Communists and socialists campaigned for and in a number of instances originated but both in Keynesian theory and in U.S. political practice the purpose was to both save and reform the capitalist system by maintaining the mass purchasing power in the system to contain economic downturns, and secondarily, supporting trade unions and social subsidies for employment, housing, energy, transportation, and health care that would estabilsh both a higher level of social harmony and real social stability within the capitalist system. For Communists especially, such programs were in effect ways to empower workers, strengthen the organization, and as such were stepping stones on the road to socialism, which was and of course is a system based on publically owned planned economy where production of goods and services is for use and need, not for the profit of individuals, corporations, or the capitalist class. Norman Markowitz

Nationalizing the Fed is a

Nationalizing the Fed is a great idea! Lets all go back to square one by "canceling all the interest debt we owe" (Anonymous, above comment), stay at our jobs, stay in our homes, and get back to solving the real problems like education, energy, health, and advancement in science to make our world a better place to live in. Posturing and pointing fingers has become a habit in government. Habits are hard to break when you are old. How about getting rid of the old people in Congress and the House and getting new young, smart people to help Obama turn the country back into normalicy?

The banks are the Federal

The banks are the Federal Reserve as one poster wrote. Wake up fellow Americans. We have been owned by the wealthy who control the banks which they are propping up to maintain their power and money. Those bank investors/owners are now seeing their money disappear and are more dangerous than ever working to maintain the status quo. President Obama, has been in office what? 50 days? Jump and dump all over his plans to deflect what other evil deeds they are planning. Non of their hate speech would have been allowed or tolerated had Sen. McCain won the election and that is a fact. Don't let the loud mouth rich losers do anymore damage than they have the past several years.

My father, Norman B. Ture,

My father, Norman B. Ture, wrote the 1962 Kennedy tax cut, and 20 years later the Reagan tax cut. He was Reagan's Treasury undersecretary and as conservative as they get, slightly to the right of Genghis Khan. He said, and I quote: "This country has always had a mix of socialism and capitalism, since its founding. The public debate should be about that mix." My advice to all: take a deep breath and get to work. Most of us don't know what socialism means and don't recognize it when we see it.

It's all of a piece: the

It's all of a piece: the collapse of the USSR; "The Project for the New American Century;" the so-called "end of history." What was over was the dialectic between world communism and US/western European capitalism. As long as we had to compete with the Soviets for "hearts and minds," we did a lot of foreign aid and a lot of posturing about how "everybody wants to come to America." But as soon as the opposition crumbled, the US neo-cons went berserk on a foreign relations level giving us Iraq and the globalists went ballistic over "outsourcing" and driving the American standard of living down and the Wall St pirates went bonkers with ponzi schemes and "derivatives" etc. It's hugely ironic, the whole disaster pulled out of the exact moment of capitalism's biggest triumph. Not just unbounded greed, but hubris. And now it's nothing but bluster and denial and raising the shibboleth of "socialism" after the horses have fled the barn because they set fire to it!

to Bruce B It's really

to Bruce B It's really simple IT ISN'T ABOUT BLAME. It's about assessing responsibility. Without knowing how and why we got here, and who is responsible for the decisions that brought us to this sorry state, we cannot figure out how to get to where we want to go.

The U.S. needs a resurgent

The U.S. needs a resurgent socialist movement to keep Obama moving left.

It's actually both a class

It's actually both a class war and a race war, with the wealth of the White middle and working classes being redistributed upward to the rich, and downward to the "disadvantaged." The former dynamic may take a slight breather under The Great BO, but the latter, which has gone on for four decades to the tune of over a trillion dollars, will no doubt be ramped up a few notches.

I too recognize the

I too recognize the desperate need for and the constitutional right to print money... without paying private bankers interest. I heard that John Kennedy was assassinated three days after putting the printing of money back into the hands of government. Is this true?

Just one response to the

Just one response to the free capitalists! Capitalism is still the best system ever conceived and combined with some socialism it becomes social capitalism. The best of all worlds and an environment where a strong middle class can prosper and a strong middle class always carries a nation. Pure capitalism has one fatal flaw and it shows up after a few generations or in the US case after about 250 years. IN CAPITALISM WEALTH ALWAYS CONCENTRATES OVER TIME IN THE HANDS OF THE MOST CAPABLE AND/OR THE MOST RUTHLESS. Just think about it; only the state can solve the dilemma. When the concentration of wealth becomes extreme, then the system collapses and the already weak middle class gets wiped out. In old times revolutions or war followed. This is in the interest of nobody because even you pure capitalists need somebody to make money off. The better off the broad masses are, the more money YOU make. So stop whining by crying socialism and instead help to create and support a strong middle class. That's exactly what President Obama tries to do and for that he deserves your support, too!!

The patently

The patently unconstitutional Federal Reserve System needs to be dismantled. The valuation of money must be reclaimed by the people's representatives. Nowhere in the Constitution is it implied that the duties of any branch of government can be "outsourced" or "subcontracted" to privately run institutions, as has been done in the case of the Fed. The Congress alone is given the power to "coin money and regulate the value thereof". Allowing the bankers to run our monetary system is equivalent having a farmer let the foxes manage his hens.

Please, Euro-Socialism as

Please, Euro-Socialism as soon as possible.

Since when has socialism

Since when has socialism European style become a bad word? I moved to a socialist country and am quite happy to no longer be in a system that bankrupts you should you become ill, spies on it's own citizens, wages unjust wars and spends more money on weapons than the entire rest of the world. Let us not forget that the United States are a YOUNG country and now in the volatile teenage years so to speak, where instant gratification is demanded whether the bills can be paid for or not. Doesn't it remind us of a person who is so insecure with themselves that material possessions are required to prove ones existence and status? Didn't CAPITALISM ruin the country for the majority of people while enriching a few? I don't think I am wrong here and hearing from my own adult son that he is fearful of waking up some morning in a "socialist" country versus a "capitalist" one tells me of the media brainwashing, getting your news from TV because nobody reads critical and well-balanced newspapers any longer. He should be so lucky as to wake-up in a socialist society.............................his job is on the line!

Guess it all depends on

Guess it all depends on whose wealth is being lost, eh, Jim? Socialism is better than what the right wing lunatics are offering - that is an ISM starting with "F." "Heil, Limbaugh!" "...On the "Today" show last week, CNBC's Jim Cramer alleged that President Obama was perpetrating 'an agenda in this country now that I would regard as being a radical agenda," adding, "This is the most, greatest wealth destruction I've seen by a president..."

This is what bothers me the

This is what bothers me the most. The class that I am engaged in warring with rules our government, our funding, our jobs, our education, our benefits, the world. They have all the money and thus all the power. We've allowed these people to insinuate themselves into such a powerful position that civil war may be the only way to reclaim our country. We have been conquered, begging for basic sustenance. This time the middle class are the slaves, not just black America. The dumbing down of average Americans is almost complete, as is the helplessness of a people whose ability to provide basic sustenance for themselves has been destroyed. In Obama we have a champion, but can he actually succeed in changing the system and thus the world?

Social Capitalism . . .

Social Capitalism . . . Google and learn . . . is the two-tiered system we've been [increasingly] living with, where there's the rich and the poor and no in-between. Social democracy is the animal we seek . . .

Hannah 3/11 has it right -

Hannah 3/11 has it right - we already have "socialism" in the post office and mail system, roads, police, firemen, libraries, national parks, and education... we should do it wholeheartedly and better, for all, not for just the superrich capitalists who want taxpayer money but no responsibility. As for the CEOs who have bilked us all --- off with their heads!

Eilish, the truth can bring

Eilish, the truth can bring them down. They know this and do everything possible to stop or hide the truth. There's a lot of people who think like you do. Look for the truth about 9/11, the Federal Reserve and IMF. (www.journalof911studies.com)(read: Confessions of an economic hit man) Then tell as many people as you can about what you have learned.

Mr. Winship, you have my

Mr. Winship, you have my wholehearted approval for every word you've written. Let's take back the earth from the wealthiest people running it. They've shown their contempt for the "common" people, for governments, for systems of law and social order. They, these oligarchs (British royal family, Rothschilds, Rockefellers, Melons, the papacy, etc.) would engage us all in another world war, and they're using the U.S. military to start it. Why? They'll make money, and lots of it, on selling weapons to both sides... and even more, on financing the sales, just as the Carlyle Group has made its money and positioned itself to control more and more of the money in the world. Their greedy fingers reach everywhere, but its not just greed for money, its greed for control. They want to enslave the people so they're too poor and too oppressed, too occupied with just making a living to present any resistance to their plans... too afraid, their spirit too broken, too addicted to pain and pleasure and escape from reality. This is the world they're giving us because at heart, they are cold and merciless people

I, for one, am tired of the

I, for one, am tired of the class warfare the rich, along with their enablers in the Senate, Congress, and White House, have been waging on the working classes of America since the time I got out of college when Carter was president and was criticized for abolishing the three martini lunch tax break. I am also wondering when someone like Bernie Sanders gets TV face time on CSPAN, MSNBC, or even Fixed Noise to discuss how socialism isn't anything to be afraid of. We need more of it now than ever, especially regarding a need for nationalized health care for all Americans, the kind that Repug Senators warning of socialism get free! Can you imagine Social Security actually being the main source of an American's retirement, instead of relying on 401Ks and other privatized retirement investments? This Madoff Ripoff wouldn't have happened!

I guess the shoe hurts when

I guess the shoe hurts when it is on the other foot. The wealthy have been waging war on the lower and middle classes fo 30+ years, and most of us have been treading financial water for most of that time. Time we got some of our own back.

Blah, blah, blah, blah,

Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. It's all noise, noise, noise. A million voices crying out, and nothing ever gets done. Nothing ever will get done because this country has been run for decades upon decades now by the corporations. It's just so clearly evident now because of the internet, which by the way, whose days are numbered. And do you think anyone will do anything about it besides write posts? Ha!! Good-bye America, you were a great dream, but a dream nonetheless.

In 1978 the Republican

In 1978 the Republican Party's official unofficial model for America is Indonesia, a country with no government functions of any kind for its citizens who still pay taxes for nothing in return. The Republican Party Indonesia model has/is being implemented by the Republican Party instead of a dangerous European type model with health care, consumer protections and the like. Indonesia is rife with government corruption which is why the Republican Party likes it among other reasons. Same old Republicanism SOCIALISM FOR THE RICH and CAPITALISM FOR THE WORKING CLASSES.