Share

UN Report Says US Rendition Policy Broke International Law

by: Julie Sell  |  McClatchy Newspapers

photo
A military transport plane at Bagram Air Base. (Photo: Getty Images)

    London - A U.N. expert is accusing the United States and some of its allies of breaching international law for the so-called extraordinary renditions and subsequent alleged torture of terrorism suspects during the Bush administration's global war on terrorism, and is launching a probe into the detention of suspects.

    Martin Scheinin, a U.N. special rapporteur and expert on international law, issued his annual report to the U.N. Human Rights Council on Tuesday. While it identifies a U.S. role in masterminding a "comprehensive system" of rendition and detention of suspects as well as creating "an international web" of intelligence sharing, his report notes that it was possible only through collaboration with many other countries.

    Scheinin cites "consistent, credible reports" that countries involved in facilitating extraordinary renditions in various ways included Bosnia and Herzegovina, Britain, Canada, Croatia, Georgia, Indonesia, Kenya, Macedonia and Pakistan. Suspects then were transferred to "mostly unacknowledged" detention sites in Afghanistan, Egypt, Ethiopia, Jordan, Pakistan, Morocco, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Syria, Thailand, Uzbekistan "or to one of the CIA covert detention centers, often referred to as 'black sites,' " according to the human rights report.

    Rupert Colville, a spokesman for the U.N. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, said it was "a fairly major black mark" for any country to be targeted in such a report.

    Being on the list is particularly embarrassing for the British government, which already is stinging from charges of its collusion in the alleged torture of a former detainee at Guantanamo Bay. Officials from both key opposition parties in Britain are calling for an independent judicial inquiry on the matter after detailed accusations of collusion between MI5, a British intelligence agency, and the CIA were made in recent days by Binyam Mohamed, who was held at Guantanamo Bay for more than four years. He was flown back to Britain a few weeks ago after the Foreign Office pressed the Obama administration for his release.

    A spokesman for the Foreign Office said Tuesday that "there's nothing new" in Scheinin's claims of British involvement in extraordinary rendition. "When we hear of credible allegations, we'll follow them up," he added. It's the office's policy not to allow spokesmen to be named in news reports.

    In a speech to the Human Rights Council, which is meeting in Geneva, Scheinin said he planned to conduct a study on the secret detention program worldwide.

    "The United States has indicated that it wants to move forward and turn this dark page in its history, but in other countries this practice or permission of secret detentions - often of people who have been branded as terrorist suspects - is continuing," Scheinin said. "Before a page can be turned, we have to know what's on it, in order to move forward."

    Scheinin also reportedly hopes to interview detainees at the U.S. military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, when he visits the United States, although it isn't clear that he'll be granted authorization to do so.

    The U.N. report expresses concern about not only active but also passive involvement by state intelligence agencies in interrogations that might have involved torture. It also critiqued the broad powers given to such agencies to collect information on citizens and "compartmentalized oversight" of intelligence services.

    In Britain, Foreign Secretary David Miliband and Home Secretary Jacqui Smith, whose department oversees the security services, have refused requests to appear before Parliament's joint committee on human rights to discuss Britain's involvement in rendition and detention of terrorism suspects, citing an ongoing investigation by the Attorney General's Office.

    The Foreign Office spokesman said that the human rights committee didn't have the authority to require Miliband's attendance. Rather, he said, Parliament's intelligence and security committee is "the appropriate parliamentary body to be looking into these issues."

    Opposition politicians and human rights groups accuse the government of stonewalling.

    "Accountability is not the strong point of this government, particularly on foreign policy," said Tom Porteous, the director of Human Rights Watch in London, who noted that British admissions of complicity in America's war on terrorism have emerged slowly, in bits and pieces. With top politicians calling for independent inquiries in recent days, however, "we've built up a head of steam," he added.

    "The sum of it all is a very compelling case of U.K. connivance in counter-terrorism abuses," Porteus said.

    --------

    Sell is a McClatchy special correspondent.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Well, at least we know (and

Well, at least we know (and have always known and loudly proclaimed): it could never happen here.

One can only imagine the

One can only imagine the furore if some of the people moved around and tortured in this way had been American subjects. Just imagine the fuss if, say, a member of Blackwater's personnel had been captured, moved to a "black site" and tortured by a "terrorist" organisation. I ask yet again: Who are the terrorists?

Funny, but using the word

Funny, but using the word "masterminding" when referring to Bush is more than a bit humorous. "Inconsiderate" applies, since this former Chief Executive did not apparently spend a lot of time "considering" anything. May he rest in Jail -- hopefully the UN will show some spine and do things that our own government, here in the US, seems unwilling to actually do. We must have Special Prosecutors looking into the nefarious acts of the past administration and holding people accountable to what were supposed to be LAWS. They were not the unknown unknowns but the ignored KNOWNS that I personally thought were actually enforced, well for the average person... Bush certainly proved himself not to be average. Not even close to average.

I think the whole world

I think the whole world needs to access how all this happened. The Bush administration was able to corrupt the rest of the world in what seems very easy and really a short time, although 8 years seemed like a eternity. I do hope that the U.N. can bring charges against the whole criminal Bush Gang. We have been shamed.

If you're doing what the bad

If you're doing what the bad guys do, then that makes you a bad guy too. Perhaps these people like the 26 CIA people on trial in Italy for kidnapping, which the U.S. refuses to extradite, should themselves be abducted out of their comfortable hidey-holes in America & taken to Italy for justice. Or perhaps the International Community should hire some bounty hunters. Put prices on their heads, publish their locations & info on the internet. Do like the Americans do in Iraq, if you can't get them then take their families until they turn themselves in. Oh how the americans would scream if that which they have done unto others was done unto them.

Okay, Martin Scheinen,

Okay, Martin Scheinen, you're headed generally in the right direction. Now, if you investigate the U.S. military base at Diego Garcia in the Indian Ocean, then I'll believe that your investigation is substantial and you're doing more than just giving lip service to people's justifiable concerns about the use of torture by the U.S. My impression is that the U.N., along with all over the other organizations that people look to for global justice and concern about human rights, are asleep at the switch today and have been for years. There is no oversight, none. Nobody stands up to the U.S. today. If anybody could, then there would be an investigation on the use of torture at Diego Garcia. That's the canary in the mine.