Share

Winter Soldiers Speak Out in Europe

by: Maya Schenwar, t r u t h o u t | Report

photo
US veterans march from Philadelphia to Valley Forge before the Winter Solider hearings last March. (Photo: Susie Husted)

    Last March, a group of soldiers and veterans gathered in Washington, DC, to recount their experiences in Iraq and Afghanistan. They spent three days testifying, confessing and mourning. They revealed atrocities never before spoken of - the brutal murders of civilians, the destruction of homes and villages, the rape and sexual assault of both civilians and US military women - and displayed photos and video footage to back up their claims. The event was titled "Winter Soldier," harkening back to the 1971 Winter Soldier Investigation, in which veterans gathered in Detroit to give testimony about war crimes they had committed or witnessed in Vietnam. Both Winter Soldiers zeroed in on the US military policy's devastating effects, straight from the mouths of those charged with carrying out that policy.

    On Saturday, March 14, a third Winter Soldier conference unfolded - this time, overseas. In the leadup to NATO's 60th summit next month in Strasbourg, France, Winter Soldier Europe took place in Freiburg, Germany. Iraq and Afghanistan veterans from Germany, the UK and the US testified, revealing the impact of the occupations on civilians and service members alike. The event was organized by the nonprofit Iraq Veterans Against the War (IVAW), in an effort to amplify the voices of soldiers - voices that are often drowned out by military leadership and political commentators, according to Zack Baddorf, one of Winter Soldier Europe's organizers.

    "We've all heard American generals on TV," Baddorf told Truthout. "We've all heard the talking heads. We've all heard the politicians. But by hearing voices of troops who were on the ground, who experienced the reality of combat, the event hopefully inspired resistance and true change. We've served our country by joining the military; now, we're serving our nation by opposing this war."

    For Chris Capps-Schubert, head of IVAW's Europe chapter and the originator of Winter Soldier Europe, the event represented an intertwining of the personal and political effects of the "war on terror." The testifiers' words issued a vivid warning to the leaders converging in Strasbourg in April, urging them to consider the human toll that inevitably follows militarized policy decisions. On a broader scale, the event called out to the international public, reminding them that even though the global economic crisis has shifted attention away from the "war on terror's" consequences, the bloodshed continues. And, on a personal level, Winter Soldier Europe allowed service members to bear witness to the shocking, sad, sometimes torturous experiences with which they wrestle long after returning home.

    Capps-Schubert served in the Army in Iraq from November 2005 to September 2006, then went AWOL, refusing to deploy to Afghanistan. He now lives in Germany and counsels prospective deserters.

    "The idea to have a Winter Soldier in Europe came about soon after I learned that President Obama would be visiting the French-German border region, and using the NATO meeting as a possible opportunity to pressure European allies in NATO to commit more troops to Afghanistan," Capps-Schubert told Truthout. "I couldn't easily accept that, and I thought it was very important for the public and hopefully world leaders to hear the truth of what is going on in the 'Global War on Terror' before they decide to commit more fully to it."

    Thus, the testimonies focused on eyewitness accounts: the intimate details of war that often go unnoticed by the general public, though they best convey its horror. Testifiers ranged from a former Guantanamo Bay prison guard, to an active-duty member of the German armed forces, to a clinical psychologist who specializes in post-traumatic stress disorder. American veteran Andre Shepherd, who worked as an Apache helicopter airframe mechanic near Tikrit, spoke of his agonizing deployment to Iraq, followed by a decision to go AWOL.

    "It is no secret that the Apache is a devastating weapon," Shepherd testified. "When I looked at the videos of suspected insurgents being shredded by machine guns or blown to bits by the missiles, I [saw] the results of my handiwork. After combining that with the damage to the infrastructure, widespread poverty and disease, accidental deaths and millions of refugees, I thought to myself, 'What have we done?' I do not believe that there is a worse feeling in the world than to believe what you were doing was the right thing, only to find out that you contributed to the spread of misery and destruction."

    Shepherd described his change of heart, and of consciousness, his realization that he could no longer continue to go about his "handiwork." Now, he speaks out against the war and has made his choice to leave the military a public example of the deserter's cause.

    "We set down our stakes, and proceeded to run the country like it was a colonial property even to this very day," Shepherd told Truthout. "We have killed, tortured and bombed the civilians into submission, so much so that many people have fled their homes. I made up my mind to never again support the evil mechanisms of our foolish leaders there, and in April 2007 I made good on that promise."

    Shepherd is currently seeking asylum in Germany, and is the first Iraq War veteran to apply for refugee status in Europe. His application cites Nuremberg Principle IV, which states that a person is not exempted from international law simply because he or she was following orders while committing crimes.

    Christian Neumann, a member of the German armed forces who served in Northern Afghanistan, testified about the German role in the war - a topic, he said, that few Germans know much about.

    "I will get new information from the testifiers to tell our German soldiers," he told Truthout previous to the event, pointing out that elections are coming up in Germany, and Winter Soldier Europe's revelations could prove eye-opening to German voters. "Although a majority of our inhabitants don't support violent military operations, our governments - European, federal and state - try strongly to keep the foreign military missions out of the election campaigns."

    Neumann mentioned that the German government hopes to legalize the use of security contractors like Pretoria, which he compared to Blackwater. Contrary to the wishes of the German people, prominent forces in the government hope to "involve the Germans more and more in the fight against an enemy, who we can't see," he said.

    The testimony of former Guantanamo Bay prison guard Chris Arendt, an American, touched on a similar theme of underinformation. Arendt testified that he and his fellow guards - mostly young, low-ranking officers, who'd received very little training - operated on the principle of dehumanizing the "enemy" as much as possible. He described the process used to "extract" prisoners from their cells for interrogations.

    "First they're going to get sprayed with ... an oil-based irritant, like Mace, but military grade," Arendt testified. "Then five men in riot gear storm into the cell, and are free to beat this detainee for however long they want to, however they please. This happens multiple times daily, this is something the soldiers in Guantanamo Bay oftentimes take pride [in]. This is something we mark on our helmets. This is something we talk about when we get home. This is something people look forward to - it's a sport; it's a score; it's a number; it's something that you've chalked up while you're down there. We didn't ever think that these people were human beings. We were told that Muslims wiped their asses with their left hands, so we shouldn't touch their left hands, and that was our cultural training for dealing with detainees."

    American Eddie Falcon, who served in the air force in Iraq and Afghanistan, described the dehumanization process further in his testimony, noting that diminishing Iraqis' and Afghans' humanity not only makes individual acts of violence more palatable; it also makes the war as a whole easier for soldiers - and the public - to digest.

    "If you don't identify with your enemy as a human, it makes it easier to kill them; it makes it easier to torture them; it makes it easier to raid their houses, to blow up their communities," Falcon testified. "People would be saying things like, 'These people are crazy around here; they're Muslims; they don't even have Jesus, you know.' They'd be saying, 'We should just blow the whole fucking place up.'"

    In exposing the distorted thought processes and misinformation that both governments and soldiers live by in the "war on terror," the Winter Soldier Europe testifiers challenged the official picture of a morally sound and strategically necessary mission. Their stories painted a scene of confusion and uncertainty, in which destruction happened in response to dehumanization and faceless orders, not out of patriotism or an overarching sense of purpose.

    As he relives his experience in the US Army and waits for the verdict on his asylum plea in Germany, Andre Shepherd hopes that Winter Soldier Europe's message will reach both of the populations he is tied to.

    "Too many people have the misconception that these conflicts are something noble and just, when the exact opposite is happening right under their noses," Shepherd said. "Our aim is to shatter those myths, tell the people what is really going on down there and to ask them to help stop this madness. I pray that our efforts will not be in vain."

  

»


Maya Schenwar is Executive Director of Truthout.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

The psychology of the US

The psychology of the US military system is fascist; probably more so than other Western armies. Testimony like this is a loud call for top to bottom reform, including weeding out right-wing elements. It's ironic that the same military that brags "we defeated fascism" has this mentality. Obviously, it's also a warning to Obama: leave Afghanistan.

To Anonymous "the

To Anonymous "the psychology..." - that may be so and a reform might be in order, however I doubt one can simply weed-out the right-wing element in any army. I have been a soldier myself and it seems to me that though there is undoubtedly right-wing tendencies they do not necessarily impede proper behavior. Just like teaching tends to attract more left-wing people, fighting appeals more to right-wing people. One could say that everyone needs to find a fitting place in the society. On the other hand the real question is whether the corps is reminded from time to time of the reality of who the average Joe is. Everyone goes through school, so the problem does not arise for the teachers; but if only right-wing people enlist, the military could be tempted to "show all those hippies how a country is to be managed". To me this is where the fascist risk lies. One way to ensure against such a risk is (and I can hear people howlering already) conscription. I was in the French army at a time where it was mandatory for every Frenchman to serve for one year, and I must say that the one major side-effet of that was to teach the hierarchy what "real" people were. This led to an all in all pretty humane officer corps. Not that there were no problems, and wasting a year is one - but their right-wing tendencies remained reasonable for the benefit of the whole society. Soldiers tend to be right-wing, well, so?

These brave people of the

These brave people of the IVAW are dissecting their own souls and these wars for the love of the world. We should bow in honor for what they do, here and now abroad. We, the rest of those of us who have thought and felt what our military is doing is not in our names, should take heed of their examples. Carry on, brave men and women!

The whole Winter Soldier

The whole Winter Soldier experience speaks volumes on the brutality and inhumanity of war. Wars shouldn't have either rules or invisibility, because there are no rules. I was brought up in the 50's to believe that Americans fought by the rules and that only the Germans and Japanese machine-gunned civilians or tortured prisoners. The Luftwaffe bombed hospitals, but we used 'precision bombing' to limit civilian casualties. It's not pleasant to find out different. When you're in a war you shoot people in the back, or use napalm or white phosphorous in the hope of staying alive yourself--that's the only rule. The sooner everyone learns that the sooner we'll realize what a godawful thing war really is and the sooner we'll stop making wars. Instead of an abstract convention on civilized murder and war crimes trials, we should require everyone, 2nd Looie to commander-in-chief, who gives orders resulting in the death of either friend or foe, to face a tribunal afterward to account for his or her actions. Not to punish or blame, but to clear the air for the soldier and so everyone--military and civilian-- realizes what a monstrous thing we do when we make war.

Jesus suggested offering the

Jesus suggested offering the other cheek when asked about defending ones self. The amount of people who have been maimed and killed since 9/11 for defense or revenge isn't countable. The urge to strike back is soooo seductive, and yet, what have we achieved? We've made more enemies.

Interesting to see what kind

Interesting to see what kind of play this year's winter soldier hearings will receive in Europe. You can bet that they will be blacked out in the US just like last year.

What's telling is this: Why

What's telling is this: Why is every single "Winter Soldier" hearing---going back to the first one in the early 70's---virtually censored in the media? Why won't they cover this? In fact, the little we know about it, ironically, often comes from the right-wing blogging community, where they're constantly trying to disprove these allegations, claiming "fraud" or something else. Perhaps this is the one area where the media has been successfully intimidated. They can't shatter a myth that is too firmly ingrained: The myth that "our soldiers" are always good and only the "other soldiers" are bad. The idea that "our boys" are human, just as the "other side" is human, is something most people can't begin to contemplate.

USA Today said that American

USA Today said that American support for the war in Afghanistan is the lowest it's ever been. And President Obama has even suggested, on occasion, that the people themselves must tell him what to do. Well here it is, here's the message, coming through the Winter Soldiers and reinforced by a majority of Americans. If you want to know exactly how to act in Afghanistan, President Obama, Secretary of State Clinton, Special Envoy Richard Holbrooke, and Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, read a book called THREE CUPS OF TEA, by Greg Mortenson and David Oliver Relin. Read it, each one of you. Unlike the previous administration, you each know how to read, think and speak intelligently, right? And if you want to know how not to act in Afghanistan, put the words Winter Soldier in any search engine, then hear and watch the testimony-- and THE FILMS! And if you want to be identified with the American subhumans who preceded you, just go ahead and build thousands of new helicopters and escalate, just as Dick Cheney or George W. Bush would do, not to mention what they did do.

We should not go to war

We should not go to war unless attacked. We have no business going to war unless attacked. The war in Iraq was started becaus our president wanted to be a war president. He even said so himself. There is nothing but suffering on both sides of warfare. But not for the culprits who are starting it. The other aspect is as usual "money". The famous industrial military complex. We are arming the whole world. For profit. I am ashamed of our government.

The reports of the Winter

The reports of the Winter Soldiers and the comments which follow only confirm what I have believed for some time: that it should be called The War OF terror. Guantanamo, Falluja, Haditha, Gaza, Abu Ghraib and other scenes of atrocities are the best recruiting agents for anti-West extremists - note that I did not say "terrorists".

To Patrick: it's interesting

To Patrick: it's interesting to read the perspective of a former European soldier. If you read military history, it seems true that many soldiers tend to be conservative. However, the right-wing attitude has become a problem in the US because it is too widespread and virulent. The US military has a huge "empire of bases" (Chalmers Johnson) and too large a piece of the federal budget; this magnifies the effect. The conscription argument has been made before, including on the political left. The civil-liberties argument is more compelling:no government has a right to draft anyone without a critical emergency (a direct invasion of US soil); probably it wouldn't be needed in such a case. A draft under current US conditions means more bodies for the military-corporate complex to exploit. A question: has anyone seen a dictatorship without a draft? Stiff congressional and public oversight and a reduced military would solve a lot of the problem.

After reading this article,

After reading this article, I was not really impressed with what the article had to say since there is no reel evidence that these things have happend. Another thing that I have to question is that if these things really happend then why hasn't this been reported all over the media? If this was such a big thing then why am I only hearing about this know. So before you come out with allegations of atrocities of war, show me the evidence that it took place.

Patton was right when he

Patton was right when he said the war is hell. PTSD is the leading cause of cease among soldiers returning from Iraq and Afghanistan. Similar to the the Vietnam War, the longer a war goes on the more likely there is to be atrocities on both sides.

A couple of people have said

A couple of people have said they don't expect the European Winter Soldier to be reported in the US. It didn't get reported in the UK either. I'm in the UK and I've just read it (a little late) in Truthout. No coverage on the BBC or the press. The US may think Europeans actually talk to each other across countries but we don't really, or not the UK; our governments have just relied on aping what our big brothers across the pond do. Blair as Bush's poodle, assorted ministers of defence as the poodle's fleas, now a prime minister (Brown) who not only signed the cheques for the war as Chancellor of the Exchequer to Blair but has always been openly admiring of American monetarist policies and out of step with continental Europe.