Share

Using the "T" Word

by: Editorial  |  The Baltimore Sun

photo
A detainee looks through a steel grate as guards pass at the US Naval Base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. The International Committee of the Red Cross interviewed Guantanamo detainees about what they were subjected to while they were held in CIA prisons. (Photo: Brennan Linsley / AP)

    A report by the International Committee of the Red Cross lifts the veil of secrecy from the torture of detainees in CIA prisons.

    Many Americans have long suspected the Bush administration wasn't being completely truthful about the interrogation techniques used to extract information from terrorist suspects captured in Iraq and Afghanistan. Officials conceded some methods were "harsh," but they insisted no detainees were tortured or seriously mistreated.

    Now a long-suppressed report by the International Committee of the Red Cross has surfaced to give the lie to those denials. The report's contents, presented to U.S. authorities in 2007 but made public only this week, describe in graphic detail officially sanctioned beatings, torture and abuse of prisoners in secret CIA prisons around the world that clearly violated U.S. and international law.

    The ICRC investigators, who interviewed 14 "high value" detainees at Guantanamo in 2006, cited cases in which prisoners were soaked with water and forced to stand naked in icy cells for days at a time, or confined in coffin-like wooden boxes too small to stand up in.

    Prisoners were deprived of sleep, food and medical care, punched, slapped or slammed into walls, and subjected to simulated drowning in a technique known as "waterboarding."

    "The ill-treatment to which [prisoners] were subjected while held in the CIA program, either singly or in combination, constituted torture," the ICRC stated flatly. Because the group is responsible for monitoring compliance with the Geneva Conventions, its findings, while confidential, have the force of law. Clearly, U.S. officials knew in 2007 that the outrages at Guantanamo constituted war crimes under international law.

    Who is to be held accountable for these acts committed in the name of the American people? Notwithstanding former Vice President Dick Cheney's disgusting attempt over the weekend to paper over CIA misdeeds as vital to national security, denial is not an option.

    President Barack Obama is understandably reluctant to launch a criminal investigation of the spy agency whose support he still badly needs, even after having repudiated the Bush administration's acquiescence in torture outlined in internal Justice Department memos released last week. But Sen. Patrick J. Leahy of Vermont, chairman of the Judiciary Committee, is vowing to get to the bottom of the matter in public hearings, and his inquiry need not turn into a partisan witch hunt if properly handled.

    President Obama has said his administration won't countenance the torture of prisoners. But finding out exactly how the nation went so wrong over the last eight years is an essential first step toward ensuring it won't happen again.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

A bit understated. I cried

A bit understated. I cried when I heard details on the WBAI evening news tonight: hanging from the ceiling by chains and chained at ankles, sleep deprivation in detail, so cold a prisoner was blue at the interview....This calls for more than a commission. Shame. I feel shame as an American. I want a special prosecutor and charges and prosecution for the CIA operatives on up to the highest office in the Bush Administration.

The Baltimore Sun (and the

The Baltimore Sun (and the corporate media in general), Leahy, and the Obama administration are still refusing to recognize the obvious. The US engaged in torture, and the orders to commit it were issued from the highest levels. This behavior reminiscent of the worst atrocities of the Nazis is a war crime, and warrants much more than "finding out exactly how the nation went so wrong". It warrants prosecution. Let's see how long and how well our new president and the lap-dog congress avoid their obligations and their oaths of office. This is the ultimate test in determining if we are a nation of laws or a nation of elite, privileged men. My money is on the latter.

Three ways we went wrong.

Three ways we went wrong. First we the voters elected a President who believed in the interests of the State over people, of business over the State, in unprecedented presidential powers, had a colonial attitude towards the rest of the world, and thought that because he talks to God he must be right. And then we elected him again. Second, we elected a Congress that is too meek, distracted, and disinterested to check our President. And third, we did not demand, with our voice nor our pocketbook, a press that is free, objective, and interested in anything more Britney's haircut or Laura's shoes.

Without a full disclosure

Without a full disclosure (which will probably not happen) you have to carry the shame like so many others that went to war before.

War Crimes. We cannot

War Crimes. We cannot directly grasp the circumstances, the effect, the consequences, or the aftermath of the experience of torture. It is beyond us. It is a crime nonetheless - of inconceivable violence. What we can conceive is that torture unmistakably violates The Convention Against Torture and the War Crimes Act. It also violates the Articles of the Bill of Rights thwarting the very intention of democracy and the US Constitution. We can understand that torture is the ultimate corruption of power. We can also deeply sense, therefore, that torture is treason to democratic government and Rule of Law. Yet, if we can be made to blink or shrug off torture as in any way acceptable in democratic society, sooner or later our voice to protest such matters will be irrelevant, the camps will be here among us, and we will be in them. Consider the history of the disappeared in Chile, Argentina and Nazi Germany. We cannot say it has not happened before. Therefore each of us must insist upon indictments and prosecutions. The chain of command is absolutely without ambiguity.

Is it any surprise that we

Is it any surprise that we support Israel's support of torture? It would seem that our US government is no longer representative of the majority... We, the citizens of this once-great country are to blame...We must take an active role or we will be continue to be dissed by our representatives...

Like NYCartist, I, too, want

Like NYCartist, I, too, want a Special Prosecutor, and a thorough-going, transparent, public investigation that gets at the source. Of course, we all already know who the sources were that authorized the torture -- they've openly bragged about it, and dared anyone to prosecute. I, for one, will take that dare. Senator Leahey's Truth & Reconciliation Commission idea, while well intentioned, won't cut it. It would end up glossing over the important parts, just like the 9/11 Commission and the Warren Commissi0n and numerous other "commissions" that were simply cover-ups for the culprits. There's no guarantee, of course, that a Special Prosecutor won't participate in a cover-up, but if there's enough pressure for transparency, perhaps that can be minimized. All Americans have been shamed by this sordid chapter in our imperial history, and we should all demand that restitution be made.

We take pride at being a

We take pride at being a country of laws. The large majority of the citizens are law abiding. The lawbreakers so far as the treatment of prisoners are concerned are in the government or retired from the government. When the government breaks the laws, we are in serious trouble. It behooves us to go after the lawbreakers regardless of where they are. We should remember the lessons of the Nuremberg trials.Aside from the legal and moral aspects we are also loosing our reputation for fair treatment of others. We must prosecute and punish the culprits regardless of their present or past standing. We must not become like our enemies.

The Courts in The Hague

The Courts in The Hague investigated and tried the Nazis responsible for the war crimes committed during WWII and the war crimes committed in Bosnia and Serbia. The Court of Inhumanity in Darmstadt, Germanyrecognised the claim of torture against Donald Rumsfield but agreed to delay the indictment upon the promise that the US would proceed with the case..which the US never did! Another empty promise! If the US does NOT investigate and proceed with these criminal cases against Cheney and Bush et al, then the US admits condoning such a policy and will continue to lose the respect of the free world and remain classified as another "terrorist and inhumane" nation! Frankly, I see very little difference between those crimes committed during WW II and Bosnia and the crimes committed by the US during the Iraqi occupation.