Share

EPA Delays Hundreds of Mountaintop Mining Permits

by: Dina Cappiello  |  The Associated Press

photo
Mountaintops in West Virginia that were decimated by coal mining. (Photo: Vivian Stockman / Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition)

    Washington - The Environmental Protection Agency put hundreds of mountaintop coal-mining permits on hold Tuesday to evaluate the projects' impact on streams and wetlands.

    The decision by EPA administrator Lisa Jackson targets a controversial practice that allows coal mining companies to dump waste from mountaintop mining into streams and wetlands.

    Between 150 and 200 applications for new or expanded surface coal mines, many mountaintop removal operations, are pending before the federal government. EPA spokeswoman Adora Andy said the agency does not expect problems with the overwhelming majority of permits.

    The permits are issued by the Army Corps of Engineers, an agency that has been criticized by environmental groups and has been sued for failing to thoroughly evaluate the environmental impact of mountaintop removal.

    Under the Clean Water Act, companies cannot discharge rock, dirt and other debris into streams unless they can show that it will not cause permanent damage to waterways or the fish and other wildlife that live in them.

    Last month, a three-judge appeals panel in Richmond, Va., overturned a lower court's ruling that would have required the Corps to conduct more extensive reviews. The appeals court decision cleared the way for a backlog of permits that had been delayed until the lawsuit was resolved.

    The EPA's action on Tuesday could leave those permit requests in limbo a little longer.

    Ginger Mullins, regulatory branch chief for the Corps' Huntington District, which covers portions of Kentucky, Ohio, West Virginia, Virginia and North Carolina, said the EPA reviews will delay approval of projects.

    "It will take more time," said Mullins.

    The EPA said in a statement that it would be actively involved in the review of the long list of permits awaiting approval by the Corps, a signal that the agency under the Obama administration will exercise its oversight.

    The EPA has the authority to review and veto any permit issued by the Corps under the Clean Water Act, but under the Bush administration it did that rarely.

    "If the EPA didn't step in and do something now, all those permits would go forward," said Joe Lovett, executive director for the Appalachian Center for the Economy and the Environment. "There are permits that will bury 200 miles of streams pending before the Corps."

    The EPA action stunned the coal industry, which had been breathing easily since the mid-February ruling by the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals.

    "It's almost like the EPA's trying to skirt the 4th Circuit appeals decision and do whatever they want to do," Kentucky Coal Association President Bill Caylor said. "We would lose half our production in east Kentucky."

    Carol Raulston, a spokeswoman for the National Mining Association, said further delays in the permits would cost the region high-paying jobs.

    "This is very troubling, not only for jobs in the region, but production of coal generally," said Raulston.

    Mountaintop mines in West Virginia, Virginia, Kentucky and Tennessee produce nearly 130 million tons of coal annually - about 14 percent of the nation's power-producing coal - which in turn generates electricity for 24.7 million U.S. customers, according to industry estimates.

    The low-sulfur, high-energy coal produced from those mines is not easily replaced. The industry has long maintained that eliminating mountaintop mining will lead to increased imports from countries that have far fewer environmental safeguards.

    The practice has a huge economic impact in Appalachia. Mountaintop mines employ some 14,000 people across the four states. Wages average about $62,000 - high pay for rural Appalachia - and states make millions in taxes.

    "It just absolutely puzzles me as to why the same federal government that's trying to straighten the economy out wants to dismantle the economy of another state, particularly as it relates to the workers at these sites," said West Virginia Coal Association President Bill Raney. West Virginia is the nation's second-largest coal producing state behind Wyoming.

    In a separate action, the EPA recommended denying permits the Army Corps of Engineers was planning to issue that would allow two companies to fill thousands of feet of streams with mining waste in West Virginia and Kentucky. The Corps of Engineers said Tuesday that it was weeks away from issuing both permits.

    But in letters sent Monday to the Corps' office in Huntington, W.Va., the EPA said that Central Appalachia Mining, a subsidiary of Lexington, Ky.-based Rhino Resources, and Highland Mining Co., a subsidiary of Richmond-based Massey Energy Co., have not done enough to avoid and minimize damage to water quality and stream channels.

    In the case of the Highland Mining's plans, which would fill in approximately 13,174 feet of stream in Logan County, W.Va., the agency said it believes the project "will result in substantial and unacceptable impacts to aquatic resources of national importance."

    Neither Massey Energy Co. nor Rhino Resources immediately responded to requests for comment.

    --------

    Associated Press business writer Tim Huber contributed to this report from Charleston, W.Va.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Let's hope the Obama

Let's hope the Obama Administration starts enforcing EPA regulations, These mountain top removals have been an environmental disaster. What the coal people don't mention is that they can still get the coal and people can still have their jobs and they can mitigate the environmental effects. They want to make obscene profits not decent profits, that's what this is all about.

MOUNTAIN-TOP

MOUNTAIN-TOP REMOVAL/VALLEY-FILL MINING (More recently known as Cross-Ridge Mining. Notice the euphemistic quality of the new "name.") Time to stand up and JUST SAY NO! There is NO reason good enough to blow up our mountains! Not here in the Appalachians and Cumberlands. Not out west. Not ANYWHERE! These mountains are my religion. I walk in their shadows, and they comfort my soul. They are my happiness and my enlightenment. They protect me from evil -- and even from a lot of bad weather, actually. They are my friends, and my music. I lie along their bubbling streams, next to their clear-water springs. I listen to their bird songs against the backdrop of their breeze-rustled leaves. I walk in their forests, pick flowers from their vines and eat their berries. I know no other source of such comfort. I have often had to live away from them. I have always come back. Now I am home for good. Is it really okay for Massey or National or any other damned coal company to BLOW THEM UP? This has to stop, people!

I hope the O Admin can make

I hope the O Admin can make the price of coal reflect its TRUE costs, including the costs to people's health, loss of diverse habitat. The price of coal also has to reflect the destruction of ALL the cities and towns that will end up under 300 feet of sea water, as well as the loss of all the cites and villages around the world that will no longer have glaciers to provide their water.Include ALL the costs of coal-burning toxins heating up the planet and releasing the glaciers and ice caps into the oceans as fresh water. No more passing on the costs to Everyone Else. We can't afford the total costs of coal as a fuel anywhere on the planet. The coal producers must pay for the consequences of their products.

It's about time! Please,

It's about time! Please, let's just stop this destructive industrial exploitation NOW! Those devastated valleys used to be beautiful and supported an abundance of wildlife.