Share

That's No Angry Mob, It's a Movement

by: Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Excesses and failures in US companies and financial institutions spur protests in Los Angeles. (Photo: Reuters)

    A college friend of mine, after much quaffing from the keg, so to speak, would start singing a faux hymn that began, "We are sliding into sin - whee!"

    I've thought of his bleary tune from time to time as we all watched our financial institutions slide from thoughtless, wretched excess into calamity, aided and abetted by deregulation and bailouts, dragging the rest of us along on their speed bump-free ride.

    You'd think there would be a modicum of contrition but mostly it has been deny, deny, deny combined with shivers of revulsion as an angry citizenry freely expresses its opinion. Former Clinton SEC chairman Arthur Levitt sniffed to The Wall Street Journal this week, "It has reached extremes of incivility that are intolerable," and on Friday the Journal editorially wrung its hands over "political Torquemadas" who would dare to prosecute Wall Street executives.

    See here, you people, the seemingly dumfounded elite ask, why all this hollering? Well, it wasn't only those AIG bonuses that had folks mad as hell. For sure, they triggered the outburst last week. But then came an ABC News report that JPMorgan Chase - recipient of 25 billion in bailout bucks, courtesy of taxpayers - was pressing ahead with plans to spend $138 million dollars on two new corporate jets and a place to park them - a state of the art hangar with a "vegetated roof garden." Presumably, bank executives will use the vegetation to hide behind when the mob arrives with tar and feathers.

    And speaking of greenery, Wednesday's New York Times reported that last year 25 top hedge fund managers harvested salaries totaling 11.6 billion dollars. That's an awful lot of lettuce in these hungry times, especially when, as the Times calculates, hedge funds have lost an average 18 percent of their value.

    By Thursday, Treasury Secretary Geithner was talking tough to Congress. He called for a vast expansion of government authority, promising to crack down on Wall Street's reckless behavior, including the murky markets of hedge funds and derivatives. He proposed "comprehensive reform - not modest repairs at the margin, but new rules of the game."

    But veteran Washington journalist William Greider, who has covered government, politics and the economy for four decades, fears that what Geithner and the Obama administration are proposing may not create reform but simply perpetuate more of the same, and even lead to the creation of what he calls "a corporate state… a rather small but very powerful circle of financial institutions... Yes, watched closely by the Federal Reserve and others in government, but also protected by them. And that's a really insidious departure."

    He expressed his concern to my colleague Bill Moyers in an interview for the current edition of Bill Moyers Journal on PBS. Greider agrees with most experts that the Geithner plan will end up placing reform in the hands of the Federal Reserve Board.

    Twenty years ago, Greider wrote Secrets of the Temple: How the Federal Reserve Runs the Country, still considered the definitive account of the government bank. "One of the attractive qualities about the Fed is that it is this black box of technocratic expertise," he told Moyers. "And it knows things the rest of us don't know. And it's very expert at what it does… But it's a political institution. It makes public decisions for the rest of us. So to pretend that it's above all that is nonsense from the beginning...

    "They couldn't stop deregulation," he continued. "In fact, they supported it, because they knew their major constituencies in finance and banking were all very much for it... So to tell them now 'Wouldn't you like to just admit your mistake and put back some of the collateral lending functions into your control?' I don't trust them to do that."

    What we ought to be seeking, Greider believes, "is creating a new financial and banking system, of many more, thousands more, smaller, more diverse, regionally dispersed banks and investment firms. The first obligation is to serve the economy and serve society. Not the other way around."

    As for President Obama, "I understand his political dilemma. And I sympathize with it. But he's trying to govern by convincing people that we will be able to get the old good times back. And my view is that the good times ain't comin' back. For lots of reasons- including the ecological crisis and global warming and the weakness of our economy. This is the hard part. The sooner the country comes to terms with that, acknowledges it as fact, not just fear, then we can start this great era of reform and revitalizing the country and society."

    In his new book, Come Home, America: The Rise and Fall (and Redeeming Promise) of Our Country, William Greider sees the public's anger as good news for the country - "America the Possible," he calls it.

    "We're at a break point in our history," he said. "And it's not just the financial system, although that's front and center. It's the deteriorated economy, it's militarism looking out in the world, trying to find the next war. It's a lot of things coming at us, all at once. I believe, on the other side of all of these adversities, we can become a better country.

    But to make that happen, Greider thinks, "People at large, I don't care whether they're middle class or upper class or working poor or union, non-union, have to find ways to come together themselves, perhaps in very small groups at first, and talk about their own stuff. Their experiences, their ideas their convictions, their aspirations for the country, themselves, their families, and then broaden out a bit, laterally. And have more people in the discussion. They don't have to become a giant organization, but they have to convince themselves that they're citizens…

    "That's kind of the mystery of democracy. People get power if they believe they're entitled to power."

  

»


Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program Bill Moyers Journal, which airs Friday nights on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Why divide domestic &

Why divide domestic & foreign policy? This is a good article. I very much want movement in the movement. We have several kinds of movements, and we need coalitions joining, as keep happening. The corporate media shuts out a lot of news about protest and dissent. There's no point in repeating the great comments of readers on the recent articles about Afghanistan-Pakistan, as well as to Matt Taibbi's piece and Tom Engelhardt of TomDispatch (but it lets folks know to go there). The money "going out the door" (song so aptly words it)for war plus the dead and wounded need to be put with the domestic issues. Isn't that what got LBJ in so much trouble, in that he had to stop the Great Society/War on Poverty due to money for Vietnam? See Chalmers Johnson on empire, republic death and money in "Nemesis".

Protest and survive.

Protest and survive. President Obama appointed the same men who wrecked the economy to fix it. What is he thinking? OK keep your enemies close, but we the people voted for strong liberal policies. He has not brought Ralph Nader, Ron Paul, or Dennis Kucinich into his circle of advisers. I am willing to give him time and to participate, but he needs to show willing.

I just stopped off at the

I just stopped off at the Guardian online: home page, top story L column: 35,000 march at G20 meeting. www.guardian.co.uk France recently had a large national show of demonstrating and so did Guadaloupe in the Caribbean (see DemocracyNow yesterday) have a successful 6 week strike. www.democracynow.org

Welcome to the Fascist

Welcome to the Fascist States of Amerika!

My health does not permit me

My health does not permit me to be the organizer of a large demonstration, nor do I have the resources. But I would volunteer for such an organization with all I can spare. I have been saying for years that we are many, we are smart, we have the power to go and take the government back for ourselves. Sheer numbers alone can do it. These execs are walking around disdainfully abusing us because they are getting threats for what they're still doing to us. Where do they get that kind of arrogance! It's time for the French Revolution! I wanna eat cake! Off with their heads! It would be interesting to see what reaction a rumor of that kind of revolt in America would garner.

I agree with NYCartist re

I agree with NYCartist re we need to see -- and spread the word -- on Wall St. protests and dissent along with body bags and funerals for our troops 'coming home'. Shine a light on what our Corporate Media doesn't want us to see. Labor's protesting -- and blogging -- globally now in solidarity with one another. Alternative news organizations like Democracy Now! videocam these events -- and archive, so can easily be distributed(published) online, as does YouTube. Take to the streets with a camera & text-messaging -- and friends.

Time for the working classes

Time for the working classes to admit to themselves, and realize that the Ivy League overeducated Morons have taken over the democratic party for their own uses and financial gains. Bill and Hillary Clinton doubelcrossed us. Bill signed of on the regulation of the Banking industry along with Phil Gramm.. Clinton is hauling in money by the millions from the countries that he outsourced our industrial base to. Senator Dodd and his wife are in the pockets of AIG and the banking industry. Time for a million man march on Washington DC..and protest the takeover of the government by the banking industry..

Patience Folks. With or

Patience Folks. With or without Obama I think God is finally in history and working with us. Consumerism and wrong minded production overseen by war lords and politicians will not stop the revolution which has already started. When we all awaken to the reality that it is us who can say "enough" in our own personal lives, then grace will descend from above. What will happen is more leisure time ( cause we won't be worked to death and have our life savings robbed- there won't be any) we will have to find our pleasure in growing our own food, cooperating on regional and personal levels, find new and closer communities of support, to sustain our lives which might be the new heaven on earth. Otherwise, our shattered expectations and recent historical events might just move in the direction of communal rage and destruction. We do have the power to self manage and to manage this government. The people can save themselves by sharing and, as the writer suggests, finding creative, rather than violent, solutions to our present dilemna.

William Greider is one of

William Greider is one of the few rational voices: and history shows that rational people, people whose view of things turns out to be correct, are not listened to. Who knows why, but check out losers like William Kristol and Robert Kagan, two neo-con wild men who have been wrong for the past twenty years. They just junked their Project for the New American Century, as it, like AIG, has become a laughingstock, but already they've founded the same tired old wingnut factory under a new name, the Foreign Policy Initiative. Funding is secured, all the old PNAC "experts" (always wrong and proud of it) have their opinion pages and TV talking head gigs secured, and folks like Greider (been right on the issues since Jesus was a kid) are belittled as old and out of touch.

I encourage all to read Russ

I encourage all to read Russ Baker's "Family of Secrets" to get an idea of what we & Obama (for all his good intentions) are up against. Along with Greider's "Secrets of the Temple" the scope and contours of the evil that has ruled this nation for nigh onto 70 years (if not more) is truly frightening. Movement or no, any concerted effort to reclaim the social, economic and political promise of this great country will be met with fierce opposition, regretably not least, from some of our own countrymen/women who have drunk deeply of the KoolAid.

"What is the crime of

"What is the crime of robbing a bank compared with the crime of founding one."-- Bertolt Brecht But when the bankers run the government they get to say what is a crime and even who gets taxpayer money to add to their booty. This is nothing less than the continued looting of American workers' pensions and social security to profit the wealthy elite of the world. First it was the legalized looting of pension funds by corporations and now it is the looting of the US Treasury by corporations and their executives, not surprisingly being sanctioned and supervised by former heads of Wall Street investment firms.

Mr. Geithner was the

Mr. Geithner was the possibly worst choice President Obama could have made and he should never have been confirmed. Again, what was he thinking? While President Obama is an excellent orator and showed much promise, some of the problems he is tackling are not appropriate to tackle all at once, impossible given the financial state of the nation and throwing good money by printing it after bad reminds me of the Weimar Republic. We all know what followed.............. Thinking we would get new leadership we instead get much of the same only in a different package and equipped with a better vocabulary. Since Vietnam the country has not needed a movement more than it does NOW. I was part of that movement then and we succeeded. Americans today have become too complacent, rendered ignorant by the media mostly in the hands of very few - this is starting to look like the movie "Wag the Dog." How long will the people take the "let them eat cake" elite attitude before violence erupts on a large scale? America, land of the FREE has become an illusion perpetuated by massive flag-waving and the fact that we now have a President who is a person of color. That does not make him infallible. His zest and intentions may be very genuine but his choices for cabinet posts are very questionable indeed at a time like this. America can no longer afford being "policeman" of the world nor should it ever have assumed that role but the weapons sold in covert operations or on the open market are now pointing at the American citizen - do they realize that the enemy really lies within while the manufacturers and dealers of those weapons are cashing in bigger than ever????????????

Of course, we cannot depend

Of course, we cannot depend on Obama and the Democratic Party to do the right thing. Obama sold out to the rich and powerful right after he won the democratic primary. You can see the results of his back room dealings with the Clintons and corporate America. First, unlike his recent disapproval on constitutional grounds (pro-corporation) of the House's vote to impose a 90% tax on bonuses for Bailout CPUs and their lackeys, He had no constitutional reservations during the election about voting (pro-corporation) for retroactive immunity for the telecoms illegally spying on Americans and a weak FISA law, which ignores the fourth amendment. Second, during the election, he rushed into and even pushed for the $700 billion Wall Street Bailout (pro-corporation) with no strings attached, but now insists American auto company workers renegotiate their Union Contracts again (anti-worker). Their companies must have a restructure plan, which can and does include pay cuts, loss of benefits and massive layoffs (not required in Wall Street bailouts). Third, when taking office Obama surrounded himself with some of the very people that caused the economic meltdown (pro-Wall Street) and people responsible for the Bush Iraq policies (pro-defense contractor). The fruits, so far, of these choices are more money for Wall Street, with barely any strings attached and the decision not to leave Iraq until the end of 2011. In addition to, more troops for the Afghanistan quagmire. Fourth, the Democratic Majority Congress is not much better, with its two plus years of do nothing committee hearings and the Senate's phony 60 vote filibuster rule on every bill. Where the republicans just have to threaten to filibuster without really filibustering and Harry Reid gives them the win. We need a populist party, a corporatist Democratic Party is not much better than the corporatist Republican Party is.

Wow, do believe we hear some

Wow, do believe we hear some chains clanking loud and strong today. That's great! Let's not forget someone IS monitoring our every comment here and we still haven't got our most sacred constitutional rights back either. Thomas Jefferson should be rollin' over in his grave right about now. Amerika indeed!

COOPERATIVISM HAS DONE

COOPERATIVISM HAS DONE EVERYTHING THAT WINSHIP NOW RECOMMENDS...WHY IS IT THAT NOBODY SEEMS TO REMEMBER? Well, let me remind those who forgot: the Cooperative system is the most democratic form of economic and social organization the world ever knew, capable of taking on fast-track development wherever it’s needed. Moreover, it co-exists harmoniously with capitalist enterprise, since it is based on private enterprise, cooperatively owned. It can also flourish in a socialist state, since it is based on privately- owned enterprises with a commitment to community-development goals. Cooperativism has a long and successful history in the USA. A visit to the NCBA web page will help you remember: http://www.ncba.coop/about_hist.cfm

Obama made compromises with

Obama made compromises with the devil in order to obtain the nomination - and more compromises in order to live long enough to be elected. I believe the longer he is in office - the more powerful he will become. I think he is an honest man surrounded by knaves, thieves and agents of Israel. I think the guy is doing the best with what he was handed. Geithner, Paulson, Emanuel, Summers, Bernanke - these creeps came with the package.... Government is filled with evil. We cannot rid ourselves of these demons in one election cycle. The good men and women must hang in there until they garner the power to purge the place of the malignant tumors.

The root of the financial

The root of the financial crisis is really quite simple AND IT IS USURY, unlimited interest rates by and for the money changers, BANKERS. History as far back as 5,000 years ago warns of the significance of USURY, THAT IT CAN DESTROY A COUNTRY[S] and we, the world,is bearing the fruits of USURY. The implementation of usury really took hold in the 1980's when the top rate for credit cards, then 10%, was eliminated in favor of today's 30% interest rates. How did the elimination of interest rate limits destroy the world? Simple again, it made the financial sector more profitable than the creating of useful products for society. Example, more is made by financing a car than is made by producing a car. This makes paper more valuable than a car. This is a great distortion for a society because it makes finance disproportionately influential than its true importance. Its distortions are significant in that those capable of becoming engineers and/or scientists go into the parasitic financial industry which creates nothing but paper with ink. It creates laziness and scheming. Usury will never be eliminated because the industries which benefit from it have too much influence to bribe the politicians from reinstating usury laws. Last, The Christ's on ly act of violence was when he trashed the money changers[usury merchants] in the temple.

It's time to treat the Wall

It's time to treat the Wall Street criminals the same way ordinary citizen criminals are treated: arrest them, try them, and sentence them. Just because they have multiple homes, obscene paychecks, weekly manicures, boats and planes and fancy automobiles, and, of course, friends in high places, they have no more rights than the rest of us. To jail with them!!

Why all the hollering?

Why all the hollering? Geez, one could be working for little more than miminum wage in the 1950's and still afford to buy a house in some areas. Some other interesting facts: Y.A. Tittle, San Francisco 49ers quarterback in 1954 was the top paid athlete in the NFL at $20 grand per year, and Tom Watson, boss at IBM had a salary of $100 grand in 1959. So in the past fifty years, we've had an American Royalty, if you will, develop over time of overpaid bosses of corporations, overpaid professional athletes, overpaid no-talent musicians (as opposed to the good ones who don't get recording contracts), and film stars (of which some don't have much talent). Then there are those who inherit their wealth and demand the end to so-called "death taxes." Yeah, there is an angry mob, made up of pink-slipped teachers, laid off manufacturing workers, furloughed state employees of one department or another. Are there any left over guillotines in France?

It's time for a 21st Century

It's time for a 21st Century version of the White Rose Society! I have such a revolution in mind, but it can't be communicated here, on the net, or by cell phone, or by any post-modern means of communication. Big Bro is monitoring everything. Anyone have access to messenger pigeons???? Time to get serious folks. They've got us by the balls and are in the saddle and riding us hard...

the US public treasury has

the US public treasury has been looted so many times without any real consequences to the guilty parties that the talk of 'angry mobs' or 'movements' seems just that. the current transfer of public funds to private companies is staggering and without precedent and, in light of yet another meek public response, gives every indication of continuing. when the government is so clearly by and for the corporate elite, i'm beginning to wonder; is the American experiment over?

FDR once said something like

FDR once said something like you elected me now make me do my job. Obama says he cannot do it all by himself. I remember when there were voices telling us about the state of our government and those voices are being silenced one by one. Maybe it is time for people to start demonstrating to take back our government and the first step would be to get rid of some of the lobbyists for corporate america since they seem to control our government more than "We the People".

I'm too handicapped to lead

I'm too handicapped to lead the revolution, but I want to do all I can while I'm still alive and before the government goes bankrupt and stops my Social Security. We've been screwed by our own politicians for the last 25 years and it's getting worse. The only answer is insurrection and a whole lot of violence that hopefully scares them into doing something positive for the country. I want to see screaming mobs, burning bank headquarters, and barricaded CEOs.

Term limits for all elected

Term limits for all elected officials -- the first step. No one should get more than six years, total for all of their elected offices in their lifetime. Same for corporate boards of directors.

“Experience hath shewn,

“Experience hath shewn, that even under the best forms (of government) those entrusted with power have, in time, and by slow operations, perverted it into tyranny”

The capitalist economy is

The capitalist economy is fascist in construction. It will only serve the entities whom it benefits the most. It has never been egalitarian in anything other than the concepts, which are supposed to inspire us to do better than we have been doing in the past - keeping the majority pacified with stories of rags to riches success rather than the excess of the rich. We need to put our money on a different horse. Banks should operate like public utilities, nothing more, nothing less.

We certainly heard from the

We certainly heard from the People during G20 Summit, especially re global warming crisis, as we did about a month ago when a younger generation gathered, learned, and acted in DC at the "Power Shift". There's plenty to learn in the wake of these events, along with the courageous actions of Utah college student, Tim DeChristopher, who spontaneously disrupted BLM oil and gas auction by bidding up outrageously. While ultimately the land was saved,the non-violent eco-activist now faces a couple of felonies for this intervention. To learn how to join his crusade: www.bidder70.org We create movements by supporting one another's righteous risk for the public good-- or Commons!!