Share

Spain Investigates What America Should

by: Marjorie Cohn  |  The San Francisco Chronicle

photo
Six former Bush administration officials are being investigated by Spain for their role in authorizing torture at Guantanamo. (Photo: AP)

    A Spanish court has initiated criminal proceedings against six former officials of the Bush administration. John Yoo, Jay Bybee, David Addington, Alberto Gonzales, William Haynes and Douglas Feith may face charges in Spain for authorizing torture at Guantánamo Bay.

    If arrest warrants are issued, Spain and any of the other 24 countries that are parties to European extradition conventions could arrest these six men when they travel abroad.

    Does Spain have the authority to prosecute Americans for crimes that didn't take place on Spanish soil?

    The answer is yes. It's called "universal jurisdiction." Universal jurisdiction is a well-established theory that countries, including the United States, have used for many years to investigate and prosecute foreign nationals for crimes that shock the conscience of the global community. It provides a critical legal tool to hold accountable those who commit crimes against the law of nations, including war crimes and crimes against humanity. Without universal jurisdiction, many of the most notorious criminals would go free. Countries that have used this as a basis to prosecute the most serious of crimes should be commended for their courage. They help to create a just world in which we all seek to live.

    Israel used universal jurisdiction to prosecute, convict and execute Adolph Eichmann for his crimes during the Holocaust, even they had no direct relationship with Israel.

    A federal court in Miami recently convicted Chuckie Taylor, son of the former Liberian president, of torture that occurred in Liberia. A U.S. court sentenced Taylor to 97 years in prison in January.

    Universal jurisdiction complements, but doesn't supersede, national prosecutions. So if the United States were investigating the Bush officials, other countries would refrain from doing so.

    When the United States ratified the Convention Against Torture, it promised to extradite or prosecute those who commit, or are complicit in, the commission of torture.

    President Obama, when asked whether he favored criminal investigations of Bush officials, replied, "My view is also that nobody's above the law and, if there are clear instances of wrongdoing, that people should be prosecuted just like any ordinary citizen."

    "But," he added, "generally speaking, I'm more interested in looking forward than I am in looking backward." Preoccupied with the economy and two wars, Obama reportedly wants to wait before considering prosecutions that would invariably anger the GOP.

    Evidence that Bush officials set a policy that led to the torture of prisoners at Guantánamo continues to emerge.

    According to ABC News, Gonzales met with other officials in the White House and authorized torture, including waterboarding.

    The Office of Professional Responsibility, which reports to the U.S. attorney general, drafted a report that excoriates Yoo and Bybee for writing the infamous torture memos. Haynes, Addington and Feith participated in decisions that led to torture. The release of additional graphic torture memos by the U.S. Department of Justice is imminent.

    It is the responsibility of the United States to investigate allegations of torture. Almost two-thirds of respondents to a USA Today/Gallup Poll favor investigations of the Bush team for torture and warrantless wiretapping. Nearly four in 10 support criminal investigations.

    Former Navy General Counsel Alberto Mora told Congress, "There are serving U.S. flag-rank officers who maintain that the first and second identifiable causes of U.S. combat deaths in Iraq - as judged by their effectiveness in recruiting insurgent fighters into combat - are, respectively the symbols of Abu Ghraib and Guantánamo." Providing impunity to those who ordered the torture will be the third recruiting tool.

    If the United States refuses to investigate now, it will be more likely that some future administration will repeat this scenario. The use of torture should be purged from our system, much like we eradicated slavery.

  

»


Marjorie Cohn is president of the National Lawyers Guild and a professor at Thomas Jefferson School of Law. She is the author of "Cowboy Republic: Six Ways the Bush Gang Has Defied the Law" and co-author of "Rules of Disengagement: The Politics and Honor of Military Dissent." Her anthology, "The United States of Torture: America's Past and Present Policy of Interrogation and Abuse," will be published next year by NYU Press. See www.marjoriecohn.com.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

I truly hope that members of

I truly hope that members of the Bush/Cheney Administration actually have the audacity of stupidity to travel to Europe and get detained, indicted, prosecuted, and found guilty. If they end up in a Spanish prison, that's great. What are we going to do about it? Attack Spain or NATO, our allies? Yeah, right! Regarding Spain, that's a country with a record of dictatorship for nearly forty years under a Fascist: Francisco Franco, responsible for having millions of Spanish people tortured during and after the Civil War there in the 1930's, an extreme nationalist who outlawed the Basque language, Catalan, and Gallego, and who reinstated the Catholic Church as the state religion. Just wanted to state that if anyone wants to compare Franco's and Bush's records, as there are some parallels.

It is sad to realize that we

It is sad to realize that we no longer seem to have a government representative of The People and the Constitution. The fact that even WAR crimes become politicized is a shame. We, the US, should be investigating all that has happened in the past 8 years to bring every thing in the open. The whole idea is to have transparency and a form of gov. in which the leaders are in fact accountable and subject to the same laws we enforce on anyone else, domestically or internationally. The lack of any investigation from the new administration is a sad political move which will allow the next presidents to get away with even more covert ops, lies and deceptions in the future.

Gee, would the gop get all

Gee, would the gop get all upset if the numerous high crimes and misdemeanors of Mr. Obama's predecessor were investigated and/or prosecuted? Remember 'get tough on crime?' Remember 'take responsibility for your own actions?' Funny how all that rhetoric evaporates when it's rich white guys on the hot seat. When they start talking about partisan witch hunts, let's remind them of their pathetic effort to oust Mr. Clinton for his tawdry affair. Remember: lying about an affair is a disgrace to the presidency and an impeachable offense, but lying to justify torture and mass murder is really quite profitable.

The Bush administration had

The Bush administration had no choice but to implement torture. Stop acting so surprised. There were no terrorists in Iraq. No Al Qaeda. Torture CREATED the blowback...the "terrorists"... they needed to sell 9/11, the Iraq War, the Afghan War (i.e. all the bogus fairytale b.s. stories) to all the comatose American zombies who legitimize these actions by their laziness and inaction. You did nothing when Bush stole the election in 2000. Are you surprised by how he spent his 8 illegitimate years? 8 years of one long crime spree...one lie after another...one big con job to rake in the trillions. Hundreds of thousands killed, a planet's path potentially derailed, and some of you are still preoccupied with these crumbs of the story.

If President Obama truly

If President Obama truly believes, "that nobody's above the law", should we really "wait before considering prosecutions that would invariably anger the GOP?" Gee, they seem pretty angry right now and they are certainly now working in collaboration with this new administration in any way that I can notice. There is Most Certainly plenty of evidence that Bush officials had a policy of torture of prisoners at Guantánamo. So, we let SPAIN take the initiative on all this???? And we leave Bush and Cheney off the list of those possibly involved? Special Prosecutors needed to address these evil doers. No question about it. If not now, When?

Justice must be served.

Justice must be served. A person, office or political party's status isn't above our laws. Bring forth the indictments. Show the people the evidence. Let the judges and juries decide in open courts. Let's not let this slide, though. Valerie Plame deserves her day in court, too. The fear that we're moving backward is fear of backlash. The ability to rule without fear is based on justice. We have the capacity, as a government built on the rule of law, to move forward in the meantime without fear.

YES.... Spain is willing to

YES.... Spain is willing to do what the US JUSTICE DEPARTMENT AND CONGRESS should be doing.... So--- Is Spain a Nation of Laws and Not of Men... While WE, The UNITED STATES, are not..?.. Perhaps the People of Spain have a better understanding of just how nasty living under a Fascist Government really is while WE here in the US are still living under the Corporate-owned Media delusion-illusion where everything '''BuSh and Cheney'' was ''Patriotic Necessity'' rather than the extremely UNPatriotic, UnConstitutional, Un-American, Fascist, Nonsensical, Self Agrandizing BS it was...

It would be interesting if

It would be interesting if some enterprising foreign CIA-like organization kidnapped Yoo, Bybee, et alii for public trial outside the U.S. The comparison to our CIA's actual behavior -- kidnapping people (in Italy, for example) and disappearing them into secret torture sites (in Egypt, for example) -- would be hard to ignore in such a case, and America would have little ground for complaint. It's quite possible for this to happen, and I hope Yoo, Bybee, Haynes, Gonzales, Condi Rice, and the rest are losing sleep over it. A *lot* of sleep. It would be so nice to hear Condi huff at her trial, "I do not recognize the jurisdiction of this court," and to see how her insistence on giving irrelevant lectures instead of answering questions serves her at her trial. (According to one eyewitness account, she chaired a committee inside the White House that gave detailed instructions to our nation's torture staff.)

So long as those with blood

So long as those with blood on their hands continue holding seats in the US Congress honor & justice shall remain contrary to The Constitution which Bush decried;"IS JUST A GODDAMN PIECE OF PAPER!" and for this every American Patriot`s name from those who signed The Declaration of Independence til now and forever will bare an asterisk* that is the Bush legacy

If we want to regain the

If we want to regain the "moral highground" and have the world look to us for moral and ethical leadership, we have to behave morally and ethically - that means investigating and prosecuting criminals - regardless of their title. We do it to "leaders" from other countries and say "see how great we are" well, ............................ its time to stop burying the dirty laundry, get it out in the open, and deal with it. Otherwise we are heading for 2nd rate world status

Although we perceive what

Although we perceive what Spain is doing as extraordinary, it really is not. They are acting as normal evolved human beings would. What is not normal is the depths to which we have sunk - a place so shameful in the annals of history that countries are beginning to pre-empt our sick justice system and to guide us like bad little boys towards a saner and more wholesome existence. I don't think, however, that we have shed enough arrogance and immorality to heed the examples.

Many years ago I broke the

Many years ago I broke the law and was taken before the court for what I had done. Yes, I was guilty and I have no regrets for the time I served in Federal prison for what I had done. It gave me the time to rethink my life and I have lived my life straight since that time. Politicians are no different. If they have broken the law, then let the courts decide if they deserve punishment. They too would benefit from serving some time for their wrongdoings and justice will have been served to the American People.

yes it is time, the

yes it is time, the supporters of torture are no different than the murderers of nazi-era france or germany, they make saddam 's crimes legitimate thru rationalization.Their M.O.: A web of lies to trash our Constitution. As a result we have cops arresting and detaining those who prefer different political candidates, or holding peace marchers from flying. If these criminals are not made to suffer and face justice, we will become an extra-judicial state with prison camps for thought crimes, oh, I forgot the halliburton detention camps are already built on our taxpayers dime, just waiting for Saddam Cheney's enemies, that is anyone who loves freedom and not a war of lies.

and what about the leaders

and what about the leaders of the pack?

Kind of a pity if Mr. John

Kind of a pity if Mr. John Yo should be intercepted by the Spanish police if he goes abroad. We are working hard to get him a professorate i North Korea and get him over there - as a One-way export.