Progressives Lack a Limbaugh-Like Voice
Sunday 19 April 2009
by: George Lakoff | The San Francisco Chronicle

Do Progressives need their own Rush Limbaugh? (Photo: AP)
You turn the AM on and there's Rush, or Savage, or another of the army of right-wing radio talk show hosts. You may not be listening hard, just working, driving, doing busywork or the laundry. Yet if you listen day after day, year after year, your brain will begin to change.
Words, even those heard casually and listened to incidentally, activate frames - structures of ideas that are physically realized in the brain. The more the words are heard, the more the frames are activated in the brain, and stronger their synapses get - until the frames are there permanently.
All this is normal. It is how words work. And the right-wing message machine has found a way to take advantage of it - activating, as it were, a conservative system of thought.
The problem is, those thoughts on the radio are hate city. Savage rails against what he calls "the weakening of the military" by "affirmative action," "illegal immigrants," and "Marxist politicians." What proves it? The submarine accident in the Gulf of Hormuz.
Tune in to Rush. On the one hand he's pitching "rugged individualism," "liberty," and the absolute free market against Obama's call to unity and a sense of national responsibility.
Then he's hammering the AIG bailout and its bonuses, not mentioning that it was the conservative destruction of reasonable regulation that lay behind our economic disaster.
One diatribe after another, the crucial facts left out or lied about, day after day, city after city. It has an effect.
Where are the progressives? Largely absent. Or talking issue by issue, not about general themes. We have some icons: Rachel Maddow, Jon Stewart, Stephen Colbert. But they only talk to us. They are not omnipresent.
Can President Obama overcome all this? He is by far the best communicator in politics today. But what we get of him are sound bites, an occasional major address, and a five-minute talk Saturdays on You Tube. Meanwhile, the reporting in the media is about positions on issues, not about general principles that get repeated.
The president does, indeed, think and talk using general principles: empathy (caring about others), responsibility for both oneself and others, and the ethic of excellence - working to make yourself, your community, the nation and the world better. He sees these as the basis of American democracy: Empathy is why we have principles like freedom and fairness, not just for ourselves but for everybody.
In the absence of nationwide media cover, the president has to go barnstorming. His former campaign organization has chosen to reactivate its ground game to try to get ordinary people to go door-to-door, speaking in their own words from their own experiences, to gain support for his policies. The idea is for ordinary people to say what they sincerely believe to their neighbors.
Can this strategy counter the right's message machine on the national level? We shall see.
In California, the absence of articulate Democratic leaders with media presence has been particularly disastrous.
Republican policies led to a $42 billion shortfall this year alone, and GOP lawmakers held up a state budget for nine months. Yet they did not get blamed for it.
Why? The right-wing message machine is alive and well throughout California. Republicans get media cover. Democrats don't get their message out.
Ideas matter. The words that express them matter. Communication matters. The Democrats don't need and shouldn't want their own Rush and Savage. But they could sure use an Obama in this state.
-------
George Lakoff is the author of "The Political Mind and Don't Think of an Elephant!" He is Goldman Distinguished Professor of Cognitive Science and Linguistics at UC Berkeley.


Comments
This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.
The president is not a true
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 14:57 β Chris L (not verified)I've been wondering what is
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 15:34 β Grandma Karen in Missouri (not verified)Progressives are taught the
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 15:34 β Anonarcmous (not verified)The axis of drivel like
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 16:14 β radline9 (not verified)There may be other
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 16:52 β Micki (not verified)Folks, Wait a minute. You
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 16:57 β Tom (not verified)First off, Limbaugh is not a
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 17:17 β pat H in Newberg (not verified)What Limbaugh appeals to is
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 17:20 β Bill (not verified)First, "Yet if you listen
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 17:43 β frank1569 (not verified)Yes we do. Ed Schulz does a
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 17:46 β Anonymous (not verified)And now we have
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 17:50 β FreddieVee (not verified)Gee, I could have told you
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 17:52 β Oracorf (not verified)Progressives do have a
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 17:54 β Mark in Portland (not verified)PS Jon Stewart is indeed
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 17:55 β Anonymous (not verified)Besides, it is fixing this
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 17:59 β Anonymous (not verified)Anyone, anyone, should think
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 18:21 β Anonymous (not verified)The FCC and the station
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 18:23 β Anonymous (not verified)Two words: Jon Stewart.
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 18:26 β Anonymous (not verified)Lakoff may be right but if
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 18:27 β coberly (not verified)This isn't about "getting
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 18:37 β Anonymous (not verified)What we need is a way to
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 18:40 β Anonymous (not verified)It might be useful to study
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 18:41 β Anonymous Dr Goebbels proved Lakoff's viewpoint. (not verified)What a horrible thought...to
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 18:48 β Bek (not verified)"The Democrats don't need
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 20:22 β SN (not verified)Hypnotic right wing
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 20:25 β Anonymous (not verified)All this self pity and
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 20:33 β Anonymous (not verified)The conservative mind bent
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 20:55 β Anonymous (not verified)I think America is catching
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 21:10 β lynne (not verified)It is not in "our" sense of
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 21:22 β herbR (not verified)Ideas matter. Progressive
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 21:47 β Susan R. (not verified)The issue is to ensure that
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 22:01 β Susan R. (not verified)The ultra-right-wing ranters
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 22:04 β Regina (not verified)I don't think Lakoff is
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 22:13 β Anonymous (not verified)Rush Limbaugh isn't the
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 22:31 β Bookworm (not verified)The problem is, as someone
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 23:02 β Anonymous (not verified)The problem is not that
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 23:26 β rjt (not verified)Why is there no big push to
Sun, 04/26/2009 - 23:53 β Anonymous (not verified)"Every contract, combination
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 00:08 β David Bell (not verified)That's because most
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 01:44 β Anonymous (not verified)Limbaugh and his
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 02:04 β Anonymous (not verified)Haven't any of you heard Ed
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 02:17 β greencastle (not verified)Now that Ed Schultz is on
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 02:37 β Thedes (not verified)George Lakoff has written
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 03:40 β ari (not verified)There are several great
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 04:13 β josh (not verified)The problem is bigger than
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 04:38 β Live Free (not verified)A FAIRNESS DOCTRINE IN MEDIA
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 04:53 β Anonymous (not verified)It's pretty funny hearing
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 05:02 β Anonymous (not verified)Keith Olbermann, but he is
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 06:24 β Anonymous (not verified)Support Mike Malloy! If
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 08:22 β Rick H. (not verified)'''It's pretty funny
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 14:09 β Anonymous (not verified)Another great intelligent
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 15:00 β Anonymous (not verified)Lakoff is correct about
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 15:23 β Pollyanna (not verified)I reject the suggestion that
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 15:47 β Gus W (not verified)Ok everyone start supporting
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 16:48 β Anonymous (not verified)California is a lot like
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 18:01 β Anonymous (not verified)To Anonymous 14:09: You
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 18:26 β Anonymous (not verified)Maybe we ought to ask the
Mon, 04/27/2009 - 20:27 β Anonymous (not verified)No, we don't want nor do we
Tue, 04/28/2009 - 20:12 β Anonymous Webfoot (not verified)Blame the corporate
Tue, 04/28/2009 - 21:16 β ZeeBruce (not verified)Progressives have for years
Wed, 04/29/2009 - 07:24 β Vegas Quixote (not verified)Mark Twain is generally
Wed, 04/29/2009 - 17:01 β Anonymous (not verified)The problem with California
Wed, 04/29/2009 - 23:29 β ZeeBruce (not verified)There's Ed Shultz and Thom
Thu, 04/30/2009 - 02:52 β L.D. Freitas (not verified)The problem is that both
Thu, 04/30/2009 - 22:47 β Shrapnel (not verified)Limbaugh, Saage and Hannity
Thu, 04/30/2009 - 23:48 β dm (not verified)The posters that take issue
Sat, 05/02/2009 - 19:05 β Garrett (not verified)