Share

Swine Flu Outbreak Could Be Linked to Smithfield Factory Farms

by: Tom Philpott  |  Grist

photo
There are allegations that Smithfield Foods, the world's largest pork packer and hog producer, is linked to the swine flu outbreak. (Photo: Lee Sang-hack / AP)

    The outbreak of a new flu strain-a nasty mash-up of swine, avian, and human viruses-has infected 1,000 people in Mexico and the U.S., killing 68. The World Health Organization warned Saturday that the outbreak could reach global pandemic levels.

    Is Smithfield Foods, the world's largest pork packer and hog producer, linked to the outbreak? Smithfield operates massive hog-raising operations Perote, Mexico, in the state of Vera Cruz, where the outbreak originated. The operations, grouped under a Smithfield subsidiary called Granjas Carroll, raise 950,000 hogs per year, according to the company Web site.

    On Friday, the U.S. disease-tracking blog Biosurveillance published a timeline of the outbreak containing this nugget, dated April 6 (major tip of the hat to Paula Hay, who alerted me to the Smithfield link on the Comfood listserv and has written about it on her blog, Peak Oil Entrepreneur):

    Residents [of Perote] believed the outbreak had been caused by contamination from pig breeding farms located in the area. They believed that the farms, operated by Granjas Carroll, polluted the atmosphere and local water bodies, which in turn led to the disease outbreak. According to residents, the company denied responsibility for the outbreak and attributed the cases to "flu." However, a municipal health official stated that preliminary investigations indicated that the disease vector was a type of fly that reproduces in pig waste and that the outbreak was linked to the pig farms. It was unclear whether health officials had identified a suspected pathogen responsible for this outbreak.

    From what I can tell, the possible link to Smithfield has not been reported in the U.S. press. Searches of Google News and the websites of the New York Times, Washington Post, and Wall Street Journal all came up empty. The link is being made in the Mexican media, however. "Granjas Carroll, causa de epidemia en La Gloria," declared a headline in the Vera Cruz-based paper La Marcha. No need to translate that, except to point out that La Gloria is the village where the outbreak seems to have started. Judging from the article, Mexican authorities treat hog CAFOs with just as much if not more indulgence than their peers north of the border, to the detriment of surrounding communities and the general public health. Get this:

    De acuerdo con uno de los habitantes de la comunidad, Eli Ferrer CortĂ©s, los desechos fecales y orgánicos que produce Granjas Carroll no son tratados adecuadamente, lo que genera contaminaciĂłn del agua y del viento en la region.

    My rough translation: According to one community resident, the organic and fecal waste produced by Granjas Carrol isn't adequately treated, creating water and air pollution in the region. I witnessed-and smelled -the same thing in Hardin County, Iowa, a couple of years ago, another area marked by intensive industrial hog production. The article goes on to say that area residents have long complained of "fetid odors" in the air and water, and swarms of flies hovering around waste lagoons. Like their counterparts who live in CAFO-heavy U.S. areas, they also complain of respiratory ailments. Now, with 30 percent of the area's residents now infected with the virulent flu bug, people are demanding that state and federal authorities inspect hog operations there. So far, reports La Marcha, the response has been: nada.

    The Mexico City daily La Jornada has also made the link. According to the newspaper, the Mexican health agency IMSS has acknowledged that the orginal carrier for the flu could be the "clouds of flies" that multiply in the Smithfield subsidiary's manure lagoons.

    I'll be in touch with contacts in Mexico as this story develops -and I'll be curious to see whether the U.S. media explores the link with Smithfield's Mexico operation.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

This is another GREAT reason

This is another GREAT reason for small, sustainable agriculture! Small farms can be managed more easily. From breeding to manure management, small farmers do it best. But the consumer must also be involved with this and seek out local, small farmers and be willing to eat less meat and pay a higher price for that meat. It's time to support your local farmers!

Sanitation, sanitation,

Sanitation, sanitation, sanitation. Stop the diseases before they start. Public health. Humans need to stop the fouling of their environment. That's what rules and regulations are for.

Clearly it's time to buy

Clearly it's time to buy local, and long overdue to boost food import safety laws.

Is this another side benefit

Is this another side benefit from NAFTA? That is, does this "treaty" help create these unsanitary conditions?

...Pork is the dirtiest meat

...Pork is the dirtiest meat in the world anyway...why not just stop eating this schmeg altogether and lower the demand for it? Oh, but we porkish Amoricans can't give up our bacon now, can we...? Unbelievable...

Our family decided years ago

Our family decided years ago to stop buying any Smithfield product because of the company's blatant pollution of Virginia rivers. Ostensibly this has been halted, but Smithfield fought regulation every step of the way. Many supermarkets in our area carry only Smithfield pork and ham, so there are no alternatives. And even if there appear to be, a person can get fooled. Smithfield products often carry labels that do not say Smithfield. This giant company.like so many factory farms — wirnwaa the huge chieken industries on Maryland''s Eastern Shore and elsewhre — care more about profit than environmental health, and if the natural environment isn't healthy, all the living creaatures that depend on it are at risk. Including us humans.

Another great reason to go

Another great reason to go vegan.

I am hoping for a tsunami of

I am hoping for a tsunami of regulations aimed at all big farm operations. If it's too big to stay healthy....see 'dinosaur'.

When I first read a similar

When I first read a similar Associated Press story 0n yahoo news on Monday, they named Smithfield Foods, but about am hour later and the same story had the company name removed! They also remove a line in the story quoting the Mexico Agriculture Department saying that no infected pigs had been found anywhere in Mexico.

another link to Smithfield

another link to Smithfield story. Also makes me wonder if this after the fact reporting is to cover up the use of a genetically engineered bioweapon: www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20090428/flu_mexico_090428/20090428?hub=Health “A top scientist for the United Nations, who has examined the outbreak of the deadly Ebola virus in Africa, as well as HIV/AIDS victims, concluded that H1N1 possesses certain transmission “vectors” that suggest that the new flu strain has been genetically-manufactured as a military biological warfare weapon."

It doesn't take a genius to

It doesn't take a genius to see the obvious does it? The concentration camp conditions of factory farming are the perfect environment for fostering the evolution of dangerous pathogens. It is time to ban completely all factory farming of animals. I suggest that everyone send a text similar to the following to their congressional representatives: Dear Rep. X, The concentration camp conditions of factory livestock production are a direct cause of the emergence of dangerous pathogens. Factory livestock production is a serious public health hazard. Factory livestock farming should be completely outlawed.

Going vegan isnt gonna stop

Going vegan isnt gonna stop you from becoming infected with a "new flu strain-a nasty mash-up of swine, avian, and human virus".... Or other genetic anomalies either man made through rouge science as a biochem weapon or an "accidental nasty mash up"... Sorry... being vegan doesnt exclude you from viral contaminates it only means your hard earned cash doesn't go to the coffers of pig farming corporate profits, instead it goes to their subsidiaries in medicine. Another win win for corporate profiteering... Meds and Pork skyrocket.... (See salmonella vs. tomatoes)

Just one more reason to kill

Just one more reason to kill NAFTA. With NAFTA even the cursory oversight of the USDA is eliminated with hogs raised in Mexico and shipped into the USA along with their pathogens. Time to ban any hog or pork products coming into the country from Mexico but doubt that Congress has the backbone to act in the best interests of the country.

These factory farms have to

These factory farms have to be broken up. The unsanitary conditions they keep their hordes of animals in requires constant dosing with antibiotics, and probably antivirals, too. In the USA, 70% of our massive antibiotic use is for factory farm animals... which makes them cauldrons of drug-resistant disease. Only the strong disease organisms survive...and go on to infect us. CAFOs = Pandemic Breeders Manure lagoons put global warming gases into the air, rather than recycling it into the soil for plant crops. CAFOs = Climate Change Engines We're very much in need of regulation that supports public health and planet health instead of profits for the few.

Seems you have never been

Seems you have never been around hogs being raised. NO I'm not a large scale producer of pork, just a country boy that enjoys raising my own beef, pork and vegetables when I can. Pigs given the chance will only eat clean food. They will not eat near their own excrement. Thats done in only one corner of the pen away from their food. True, commercially raised pigs don't always have the choice. Chickens are, to my feelings, much dirtier animal. They well eat their own or any other animals excrement just because it's there. ..Pork is the dirtiest meat in the world anyway...why not just stop eating this schmeg altogether and lower the demand for it? Oh, but we porkish Amoricans can't give up our bacon now, can we...? Unbelievable...

Watch out for the "Food

Watch out for the "Food Safety Act". Monsanto has written several bills: HR 875: "Food Safety Modernization Act of 2009."(Sponsor Rep. Rosa DeLauro, (D, CT) husband has ties to Monsanto) S 425: "Food Safety and Tracking Improving Act." HR 814: "Trace Act of 2009."HR 759: "Food and Drug Administration Globalization Act of 2009." These bills pretend to make food safe, but actually create a huge burden on small family/organic farms. If this flu came from a big farm, hurting the small/organic farms will only make things worse. Watch out of Big (Business) Government laws promoted by our zombie congress!

Makes one wonder about the

Makes one wonder about the massive pig farms in NC and other states, where their political contributions makes them essentially untouchable by local authorities and you all know how well the Bush Administration did in inspecting pig farms and banking institutions...

Doesn`t anybody find it just

Doesn`t anybody find it just a little curious that Rumsfeld bought all the tamiflu vaccine only to have Asian Countries virtually contain bird flu followed by ICE raids at Smithfield Farms & now we are on the verge of a pandemic generated from a combined mutant strain of swine & avian virus!?!

A man made virus in the labs

A man made virus in the labs and released to the masses. Now the worldwide media panic is on. DONT have a flu jab.

When we Americans export our

When we Americans export our poison it will come back to haunt us: DDT laced produce, antibiotic-laden meat, infections such as "swine 'flu". We must fight back against the stranglehold that Big Ag, Big Pharma, Big Coal and others have over Congress. Watch how they vote. If they don't vote with a conscience, VOTE 'EM OUT! It's the only way....

Only one sample from one boy

Only one sample from one boy near the farm was taken and kept around February, though over a hundred were sickened. When analyzed recently (last few weeks), it was a match with the current pandemic. I'll try to find a source.

The Guardian (UK) April

The Guardian (UK) April 27th: A Mexican village whose inhabitants were overwhelmed by an outbreak of respiratory illness starting in February has emerged as a possible source of the swine flu outbreak which has now spread across the world. The state government of Veracruz in eastern Mexico has confirmed one case of swine flu in the village of La Gloria with the sufferer named locally as a four-year-old boy, Edgar Hernández Hernández. The federal government said tonight that he tested positive for the same strain of the virus which has claimed lives in Mexico. The boy's case earlier this month came amid an outbreak of respiratory illness in the area in which around 400 people requested medical help. The boy was treated in hospital and survived. But two babies from the same village died during the outbreak. Sufferers complained of symptoms including fever, severe cough, and large amounts of phlegm. "The symptoms were exactly like the ones they talk about now [with swine flu]," said a local resident. "High fevers, pain in the muscles and the joints, terrible headaches, some vomiting and diarrhoea. The illness came on very quickly and whole families were laid up."

Link the the guardian

Link the the guardian article: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/apr/27/swine-flu-search-outbreak-source

I still remember Senator

I still remember Senator Paul Sarbanes' speech when NAFTA was being considered for approval. He said that it lacked the environmental and economic protections for workers and ordinary citizens necessary to make such a treaty acceptable. He would not vote for it. Oh, was he right. The corporate abuses continue. They have done terrible harm, particularly in Mexico where laws are lacking to protect the environment and citizens. It is all a part of moving the wealth up to the top and leaving poverty, illness and death in its wake. GREED.

I have no sympathy for pork

I have no sympathy for pork eaters who are now fearing swine flu. We know the consequences of intensive agriculture. It's polluting our environment, contributing to global warming, wrecking the usefulness of our antibiotics, and straining water resources in local communities. While I agree that corporate farms should be following the (mostly toothless) law when it comes to disposing of animal waste and contaminants, only when people stop eating animals will we no longer have to worry about these problems. Small-scale farming and local organic farms are all well and good, but let's face it--they simply can't produce enough flesh to meet the current demand, and they still contribute to global gas emissions, pollution, and other environmental ills. Animal agriculture on any scale is damaging and unsustainable. A meat-centered diet is a dead end when it comes to conserving our planet. The facts are already out there for those who want to know and have the courage to walk the walk when it comes to living sustainably. If you truly care about disease outbreaks, the environment, and our dwindling natural resources, you'll stop eating animal products.

Re: Sarbanes - Why the

Re: Sarbanes - Why the outrage over Nafta? As a Marylander, I largely appreciated his liberal politics, but I do find it disingenuous that he hails from (and presumably retired to) MD's Eastern shore, cradle to the notorious factory chicken farms that to this day callously and flagrantly participate in the ruinous pollution of the Chesapeake Bay, (formerly known as the world's most productive estuary). I don't recall any hard work or public outrage, on his part, over the existence of and the downright coddling of these factory farms. Interesting that he would be so concerned about the impact of Nafta at the same time. Woulda been nice if he had helped reign in the major polluters in his own back yard. Wouldn't have been politically expedient, I suppose.

I believe there already are

I believe there already are a number of religions that ban the consumption of meat. Why do we need another?

remember the million tractor

remember the million tractor march on the White House? That was when the big farm was stealing the family farms. No one stood up to them. Now we sow what we reap. Let it be a lesson for us all to stand up to the government and demand they return to being servants, not kings.