Share

Torture: An Author and a Resister

by: Ann Wright, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
The funeral for Army Spc. Alyssa Peterson, Flagstaff, Arizona. (Photo: Jill Torrance / Getty Images)

    As a Bush administration political appointee Assistant Attorney General in the Office of Legal Counsel of the Department of Justice, Jay Bybee, a Mormon, wrote one of four torture memos released last month. Bybee's August 1, 2002, 20-page memorandum laid out in excruciating detail the interrogation techniques he was authorizing the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) to use on al-Qaeda operative Abu Zubaydah.

    Bybee authorized ten "enhanced interrogation techniques" to encourage Abu Zubaydah to disclose "crucial information regarding terrorist networks in the United States or in Saudi Arabia and information regarding plans to conduct attacks within the United States or against US interests overseas." The torture techniques authorized were (1) attention grasp, (2) walling, (3) facial hold, (4) facial slap, (5) cramped confinement, (6) wall standing, (7) stress position, (8) sleep deprivation, (9) insects placed in a confinement box and (10) waterboarding.

    The current Attorney General of the United States Eric Holder has stated that waterboarding is torture, while the previous Attorney General Judge Mukasey refused to comment on whether waterboarding is torture.

    From recently released CIA documents, we know the CIA waterboarded Abu Zubaydah 83 times and Khalid Sheikh Mohammed 183 times.

    But, we know that from March through June, 2002, according to FBI interrogator Ali Soufan in an op-ed to The New York Times on April 23, 2009, FBI interrogators had already gotten "actionable intelligence" from Zubaydah using traditional, nontorturing interrogation techniques, including that Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was the mastermind of 9/11 and that Jose Padilla was planning to be a "dirty bomber."

    Ninety of the 92 interrogation videotapes the CIA admits it destroyed were interrogations of Abu Zubaydah. Zubaydah's British attorney Brent Mickum, in the most detailed account the public has had of Zubaydah's life, states that after all the waterboarding and other torture methods used, the CIA finally recognized Zubaydah was not the senior al-Qaeda leader they had portrayed him to be. According to Mickum, the military commissions at Guantanamo are now "airbrushing" his name from the charge sheets of other Guantanamo prisoners. Mickum reveals Zubaydah was severely wounded in Afghanistan in 1992 while fighting communist insurgents after the withdrawal of Soviet forces. He has two pieces of shrapnel in his head, which have affected his memory to the extent that "he cannot remember his mother's name or face." Mickum states that Zubaydah was shot and severely wounded when he was picked up in Pakistan. His life was saved by a John Hopkins surgeon flown to the region. After being saved from death, he was almost tortured to death by CIA operatives. Mickum says that Zubaydah is a stateless Palestinian with no country to argue on his behalf and a United States government now embarrassed at being caught in its own illegal conduct.

    We know that combinations of the other nine techniques authorized by Jay Bybee can be classified as torture, as the Convening Authority of the Military Commissions at Guantanamo Susan Crawford declared when she dismissed the charges against Guantanamo prisoner Mohammed al-Qahtani, in January, 2009, in the last days of the Bush administration.

    Crawford said that for 160 days al-Qahtani's only contact was with the interrogators and that 48 of 54 consecutive days he was subjected to 18- to 20-hour interrogations. He was strip searched and had to stand naked in front of a female agent. Al-Qahtani was forced to wear a woman's bra and had a thong placed on his head during the course of his interrogation and was told that his mother and sister were whores. With a leash tied to his chains, he was led around the room "and forced to perform a series of dog tricks." He was threatened with a military working dog named Zeus. The interrogations were so severe that twice al-Qahtani had to be hospitalized at Guantanamo with bradycardia, a condition in which the heart rate falls below 60 beats a minute and which, in extreme cases, can lead to heart failure and death. At one point, al-Qahtani's heart rate dropped to 35 beats per minute, the interrogation records showed.

    The torture techniques Jay Bybee authorized in 2002 migrated to Iraq in 2003. Maj. Gen. Geoffrey Miller traveled to Iraq from Guantanamo to demonstrate to soldiers in Iraq the techniques the military and CIA were using in Guantanamo.

    In September 2003, another Mormon, a woman soldier, US Army Spc. Alyssa Peterson, said she refused to use the interrogation techniques that Bybee had authorized on Iraqi prisoners. An Arabic linguist with the US Army's 101st Airborne Division at Tal Afar base, Iraq, 27-year-old Peterson, refused to take part in interrogations in the "cage" where Iraqis were stripped naked in front of female soldiers, mocked and their manhood degraded and burned with cigarettes, among other things. Three days later, on September 15, 2003, Peterson was found dead of a gunshot wound at Tal Afar base. The Army has classified her death as suicide.

    Jay Bybee, in thanks for his being the loyal soldier to the Bush administration's policies of torture, was nominated and confirmed by the US Senate as a judge on the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, where he sits to this day in his lifetime appointment. Jay Bybee, an author of torture, reportedly has a placard in his home for his children that reads, "We don't hurt each other."

    Alyssa Peterson, for saying no to torture, is dead, perhaps by her own hand.

    To help Army Spc. Alyssa Peterson rest in peace, I say we should demand accountability from our officials and IMPEACH the torture judge, Jay Bybee.

  

»


Ann Wright is a 29-year US Army Reserves veteran who retired as a colonel. She was a US diplomat, who served in Nicaragua, Grenada, Somali, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Sierra Leone, Micronesia, Mongolia and Afghanistan, where she helped reopen the US Embassy in December 2001. She has traveled to Gaza twice in the past three months and will make her third trip in May 2009. She is the co-author of "Dissent: Voices of Conscience."

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Thank you for this brave

Thank you for this brave article. We must open our eyes to what torture is even though like mine, they will be weeping.

Thank you, Ann Wright, for

Thank you, Ann Wright, for being a person of integrity and conscience and for bringing these horrific details to light. Am so grateful that people like you continue to exist. You give me hope.

The U.S. is now a torture

The U.S. is now a torture nation with an imperial presidency: a dictatorship. That is who we are. Oh... we'll prosecute line staff and low ranking infantrymen and women. No problem. Ms. Petersen knew this. She was caught in a double- bind. Disobey orders to torture, and she is Court Marshalled for insubordination. Obey the orders and she becomes another Lindy England-- a pawn who fell into the same game who rots in prison. We chuckle and laugh at the underachiever: the grunt scapegoat. Suicide made sense. It is, and will be, the imperial presidency. Until Bush and his cronies are prosecuted, we are a dictatorial police state. No longer a nation of laws. Fascism has arrived: the final evolution of predatory capitalism. Bummer. Say, who wants a Playstation? Who won American Idol?

A very hearty "Right-On"

A very hearty "Right-On" from me, Colonel Wright (Retired)!!!!! I listened to you on Cindy Sheehan's Soapbox radio show a few weeks ago. Thank you so much for your very courageous stand, for speaking truth to power, for telling it like it is, for not prevaricating, apologizing or excusing ANY war crime conduct, and for calling for accountability for the extreme, habitual criminals who have authored and/or condoned, and/or continue to condone, anti-America, anti-human and inhuman crimes against humanity. You have become a true American patriot and hero. MANY kudos and much True Love to you, and keep up the great work!

Hi Ann, How can this man

Hi Ann, How can this man condone what he's done? Can't he see how much pain and suffering his consent has caused? Thank you for shedding more light on the ugliness of the Bush/Cheney years. Peace. Jes

...Oh, and I neglected to

...Oh, and I neglected to mention that Alyssa Peterson was obviously murdered for her very courageous and Truly Patriotic stand, unless she was put up to killing herself (and that is murder too). But I don't believe for a minute that she committed suicide, and I doubt any other reasonable person upon hearing that she died only three days after standing up against inhuman torture and/or interro(r)gation (sic) believe it either, unless Alyssa did so because of how atrocious what she witnessed was, and how much compassion she felt for human beings who, no matter what, should not be degraded and so-pressured to say anything their torturers and those at the top want(ed) to hear. Rest in peace, True American hero, Alyssa Peterson (said with overflowing tears in my eyes).

Did Alyssa Peterson really

Did Alyssa Peterson really commit suicide? Or, did they kill her because she wouldn't go along? We know that Tillman's death was reported incorrectly. We now know how completely degraded that administration was.

Jay Bybee MUST be impeached

Jay Bybee MUST be impeached and the other criminals from the previous administration MUST be prosecuted IF we are ever to be able to hold our heads up as equals among nations. We now represent the worst of the worst... hypocrites and torturers. That means ALL of us not just those who ordered it and those who carried it out. I feel no pride at all in being an American.

Thank you, Col. Wright, for

Thank you, Col. Wright, for your courage and patriotism, and for this article. Given what little I know about Mormonism, I doubt that Ms. Petersen committed suicide. Also given what I know about Mormonism, Bybee's rationalizations for his complicity in covering for the Bush/Cheney criminals is marginally understandable, though not excusable. Raised in an authoritarian environment, and likely becoming an authoritarian personality himself, if he had any reservations about what he participated in, those were suppressed in deference to the "authorities" that were demanding a "legal" rationale for doing what they wanted to do. AND, perhaps more important, providing a shield against later possible prosecution. They HAD to know what they were authorizing was illegal, so needed a CYA "legal" opinion...being a good authoritarian, Bybee, Yoo, et al, were only too happy to oblige. At the very least, Bybee must be impeached and, along with Yoo and the other "lawyers" disbarred.

Under the "Foreign Corrupt

Under the "Foreign Corrupt trade Practices Act" i tis the responsibility of the CEO, CFO and other high ranking individuals of a company to keep records available for governmtnt inspection even in the event of a complete computer failure and destruction of al computer based records. There ar e criminal penalties for failure to do so. But the CIA, gets to do what it wants and the leaders, including the president of the US, get away free after deliberate destruction fo information. Well, I guess it beats goiing to court for deliberate malfeasance. Some might call it TREASON. I DO.

Thank you, Colonel Wright,

Thank you, Colonel Wright, for keeping us informed about this shocking and horrifying chapter in recent American history. You are a true patriot. As an American I am appalled, saddened, and angry that these events occurred, sanctioned by those at the highest levels of government. As a former soldier, I am furious that military personnel were ordered to commit these criminal acts and that all members of our military are now in more danger of being tortured themselves in retaliation if they are captured. Bybee, Yoo, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Bush and all the other thugs in the last administration must be brought to justice for their unconscionable actions. We owe that to Spc. Alyssa Peterson and others like her who bore the burden of those actions.

Impeach Jay Bybee? His

Impeach Jay Bybee? His torture memos are a crime against humanity and he should be tried and sentenced. He failed to uphold the constitution, which is a violation of his oath of office. He advised Bush to violate the Geneva Convention, which is a crime. Impeach Jay Bybee? Why not indict Jay Bybee?

Thank you, Ann, for this

Thank you, Ann, for this information and analysis. Wasn't the protection of our own a major motivation for establishing international standards of how prisoners of war would be treated? In other words, weren't the Geneva conventions intended to protect our captured soldiers by setting humane rules for the treatment of POWs? Thus supporting our troops in a really meaningful way. Secondly, doesn't research show that confessions obtained under duress are often worthless? That is, that torture is not a very effective method of gaining good, actionable intelligence -- presumably because the victim will say what he or she thinks the interrogator wants to hear, in order to get the torture to stop. Given these two points, what the hell is going on with these torture practices? Is it just sadism unleashed, or is there some obscure political purpose at work here? It's evident that I have many more questions than answers. And the whole discussion disgusts me more than I can express. Call it karma, or "live by the sword, die by the sword" -- the U.S. is in big trouble for generations to come.

When polls show that

When polls show that 61% of Americans do not want torturers prosecuted, it puts the lie to Americans' specious and hypocritical claim of being the bastion of freedom, democracy, and law. America is actually the bastion of perceived exceptionalism: we feel entitled to do anything we wish, whether it is making horrific war on innocent women and children, or inflicting the most hideous torture on people defending their country.

(I am not sure how my post

(I am not sure how my post at 16:36 got so twisted. Could you replace it with these corrections? Thanks) Wright's reference to Bybee as a Mormon is something I find interesting. Coverage of Mitchell Jessen and Associates has referred to James Mitchell and Bruce Jessen has part of the Mormon Mafia. Mitchell Jessen is the Spokane-based company named after the two Mormon psychologists who reverse engineered SERE torture resistance training given to U.S. pilots, special forces, spies, and foreign operatives. Spokane, Washington is home to Fairchild Air Force Base (B-52s during Vietnam and K-135 refuelers during Iraq) but is also home to numerous companies associated with mercenaries and the CIA under U.S. government contracts who are up to their noses in this dirty torture business. Spokane as a community needs to ask itself at what cost it tolerates Fairchild, SERE, Mitchll Jessen and Associates, and other CIA/DOD/mercenary firms. Likewise Mormons--who have long been considered good "company" men in intelligence circles (i.e., CIA and State Department) -- need to scrutinize and challenge within their own community and religion.

There are several

There are several conscientious objectors of the Iraq occupation who are facing jail time and are the bravest in my mind for standing up to the authorities that put them in that position. I suffer along with them in my mind and I'm so in awe of people like Ehren Watada, or Augustin Aquayo and others. What if one was placed in a position to torture someone and then refused to follow those orders? Some people say that you are supposed to follow orders, but then again, following orders knowing that something is wrong or illegal puts one in a Catch 22 dilemma. Didn't we prosecuted people that followed Hitler's orders during the Holocaust or some Japanese soldiers that were just following orders and that was not an excuse? ALYSSA PETERSON IS A HERO. Statue anyone?