Share

The Toxic Residue of Torture

by: Deepak Chopra  |  The San Francisco Chronicle

photo
Razor wire lines at Guantanamo. The right continues to try to justify torture. (Photo: AP)

    It seems clear that the question of torture won't go away. It would be easier to talk about moving ahead. Images of Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo belong in nightmares. As a physician, my personal nightmare is of the doctors who stood by during torture sessions to monitor the victim's vital signs. This was supposed to be humane, but what about the Hippocratic oath, which says that a doctor shall do no harm? Is making sure that waterboarding doesn't cause a heart attack doing no harm? The whole rationale is grotesque.

    This is one of those moments when painful truth is the only way to heal.

    People don't want to hear about bad things from the past when the present is loaded down with more than enough bad things. But inconvenience and fatigue aren't good excuses. There is anger from the left - and not just the left - about an inexcusable Bush policy. There are demons in the closet, and shutting the door on them won't make them go away. Better to deal with it now, when a new president's idealism is still fresh. It will take idealism to face the torture issue. Otherwise, any truth commission will either turn into a vengeance squad or go the other way and sweep too much under the rug.

    The more the right wing tries to justify the torture policy, the worse they look. Using national security to justify torture is just a bald-faced attempt to hide the truth. What really went on was simple. The Bush administration felt that Al-Qaida could not be defeated while still preserving what America stands for.

    Now we have a President - and the world has a leader - who believes the opposite. Obama has stated that the terrorists can be defeated using methods that don't betray the core values of our country. I think he's right. He has to be. A country that resorts to torture has lost the battle to begin with. Not only was torture not effective (it yielded little that regular interrogation couldn't achieve) but even if it was effective, the damage done to America's standing in the world was far greater. What torture mainly does is provide a huge boost in recruitment for Al-Qaeda.

    If the truth sets you free, then let's have a truth commission as a first step. Lay everything out, however painful. The aim should not be punishment but detoxification. The toxic residue of Bush-era policies hasn't been cleansed; healing hasn't replaced bitter resentment. Not only should the right wing and the war-makers tell the truth, but so should those politicians, including Democrats, who passively went along with what their conscience told them was dead wrong.

    Then let's see where the truth leads us. There is no pro-torture side on this issue. "America does not torture" was the slogan of the Bush administration as well as the current administration. Now we need to expose how honest and sincere those words are. The road away from torture is the road back to America. Can we all agree on that?

    --------

    Deepak Chopra is the author of over 50 books on health, success, relationships and spirituality, including his most recent novel, "Jesus: A Story of Enlightenment," available now at www.deepakchopra.com.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

To use a worn-out argument,

To use a worn-out argument, would it be OK to torture a 3-year-old if we could save a huge city? Of course it's a false argument, but one many people are accepting. If torture is a practical American value, lets say so and take the consequences. If not, quit trying to rationalize it!

Yes we can all agree to the

Yes we can all agree to the fact that the truth will set us free. We must understand how this happened, how the law was manipulated and by whom. Only then will we know how to better avoid this from happening again.

Remember permissive

Remember permissive childhood? Instead of saying 'the right wing' let's be honest and say the church has been compromised by the government. There is never any excuse to torture, it gives false info if any at all. No city was saved through torture. And as I remember the bible, Jesus was not in the torture business. And business was not a part of his teaching. I never saw a picture of Him in a business suite. If we refuse to prosecute these moral offenders of humanity, then we can expect it to expand to the police and employers. How about a boss who tortures you to find out who stole the pens? The biggest problem here is that the new administration is an extension of the old one. The power behind Mr. Bush is the same one behind Mr. Obama. If we were indeed to take the country back, than we need to disempower the Oligarchy. And we need to ratchet down the federal powers. And maybe even return war powers to the congress.

I agree wholeheartedly with

I agree wholeheartedly with everything that you have said here, Mr. Chopra. Until the issue of torture is resolved, its toxic residue will be like getting tar on everything, ruining whatever we do.

It seems strange to me that

It seems strange to me that many of those who are taking a stand against the enhanced interrogation tactics used by the CIA don't seem to have any problem with abortion on demand. Both issues play to human morality and are thus subjective in nature. It seems to me that the torture issue is being used as tool to feed the fervor of those who truly hate the past administration and will stop at nothing in their quest for what they see as justice. This is all politics and it will only result in further division in an already broken society.

Victims hugging perps

Victims hugging perps occurred in South Africa. It's quite impossible for me to imagine a victim hugging Cheney, and I have an imagination. Nonetheless, whether the Cheney gang appears or not at a truth exploration, it is important for persons with credibility across cultures to do a truth exploration. Reconciliation may be a bit of a stretch in this country, filled as it is with so many harsh religions. As an evolutionary Christian (I don't believe other kinds want this territory), I would like to see a spiritual and scientific community volunteer to do the exploration. If people are paid to do it, it will suffer the ironic connotations of "public servant," a phrase I now take to mean "people who want a lot of attention and money so they can shop for assorted things they like and have their choices parade by conveniently, while the are on the phone conducting important business."

wrong wrong wrong. You can

wrong wrong wrong. You can not promote democracy and torture in the same breath. You are either for respect, dignity and human values or you stand for absolutism and repression of the oposition. Shame to all who did it. Execute the henchmen and forgive the lowranking helpers.

Any such article should

Any such article should mention the instances we know of where harsh treatment has led to death and should renew enquiree about the undisclosed deaths among the secret prisoners.

I recommend the short story

I recommend the short story "Those Who Walk Away from Omalas" by Ursula K. LeGuin on the subject of torturing the innocent to create utopia. Even in her utopia some people walk away.

I would like to recommend a

I would like to recommend a very instructive, cautionary book on the slippery slope of inhumanity. It's called ": The Nazi Doctors: Medical Killing and the Psychology of Genocide", Robert Jay Lifton: Books. The Medical Profession was the first to be subverted by the National Socialist Party in Germany.

Punishment is essential.

Punishment is essential. It's called justice. The torture victims did not receive the kind of consideration being given to the perpetrators. There is no justice without penalties for lawbreakers and those who inflict harm on others needlessly and there is no peace without justice. The country has sunken to a new low and this is perhaps the only chance to redeem it. Redemption is only possible when the truth is revealed and the consequences are dealt with. These must be consequences for these most horrible of acts, for all those involved in any way. There is plenty of evidence and the laws are clear. What is stopping this?

The ones who are making

The ones who are making excuses to justify torture, are harking back to 9-11. So I try to consider there position, we had just been attach, the first attach on the US soil since Pearl Harbor. Minutes after the attach the accused was identified, Osama Ben Lauden. Shortly we were seing our military to Afghanistan and then Iraq. I disagreed with the total approach. 9-11 should have been viewed as a police action, not a war. It should have been investigated and the perpetrators brought to the bar of justice. Instead we made war and eliminated the bar of justice. And we did not catch Osama. Go figure. We caught a lot of other people, people who have never been formally charged and we tortured. And we didn't catch Osama, we didn't end suicide bombings. What have we accomplished?

Count me in the numbers of

Count me in the numbers of the left who are still fuming about what the Bush Administration did and may get away with. When President Obama was inaugurated I felt a slight cleansed feeling but that is gradually fleeing as the forces that have to be overcome are still in place even if they are not living and working from the White House. The people have to demand and not let up on wanting investigations and indictments of all responsible for the chaos and embarrassment the Bush Gang was.