Share

Prison Blues: States Slimming Down Inmate Meals

by: Shannon McCaffrey  |  The Associated Press

photo
Georgia prisoners line up outside of their cafeteria. (Photo: Derek Bell / National Geographic)

    The recession is hitting home for inmates, too: Some cash-strapped states are taking aim at prison menus.

    Georgia prisoners already didn't get lunch on the weekends, and the Department of Corrections recently eliminated the midday meal on Fridays, too. Ohio may drop weekend breakfasts and offer brunch instead. Other states are cutting back on milk and fresh fruit.

    Officials say prisoners are still getting enough calories, but family members and critics say the changes could make prisoners irritable and food a valuable commodity, increasing the possibility of violence.

    In Georgia, inmates are still getting the same number of daily calories: 2,800 for men and 2,300 for women. The portions at breakfast and dinner are bigger on days only two meals are served.

    Almost 5 percent of the state's 58,295 prisoners still get three meals every day because they are diabetic, pregnant or have other special health needs.

    Barbara Helie, whose 25-year-old son Nicholas is serving time for armed robbery in Valdosta State Prison, said he would go hungry without the roughly $60 a week she puts into his account to buy instant soups, cheese, beef sticks and other snacks at the prison commissary.

    "I don't know how the guys who don't have someone on the outside helping out handle it," Helie said. "Food has been an ongoing issue for him ... He's hungry a lot."

    Georgia's fast-growing prison system - the fifth-largest in the nation - has been hit hard by the same budget woes plaguing other states. For the current fiscal year, the state has slashed almost 10 percent from the state Department of Corrections' $1.1 billion budget.

    Friday lunches were a casualty of the department's decision to save money on gas and other costs by scaling back the prisoner work week from five eight-hour days to four 10-hour days, said Calvin Brown, Georgia Department of Corrections Deputy Director of Facility Operations. He couldn't say how much the state is saving.

    For years now, Georgia prisoners have received only two meals a day on weekends because they don't work, so now the same holds true on Fridays. They get three meals on work days because they are exerting themselves on road crews and litter pick up.

    There are no federal minimum caloric standards for state prison systems, though they are encouraged to adhere to guidelines established by the Institute of Medicine of the National Academies Food and Nutrition Board. Georgia officials say they follow those guidelines, and Brown said there have been some complaints from inmates and family members but no lawsuits.

    In Ohio, prisons director Terry Collins said eliminating breakfast on the weekends and replacing it with brunch "could save us some real dollars when it comes to staffing and food costs."

    He said the move would not upset prisoners because it would not sacrifice quality.

    "I don't expect them to be as good as mom's home cooking, but the food should be cooked and presented properly," Collins said.

    Other states have kept three meals but are scaling back menus. Earlier this month, Alabama reduced the milk and fresh fruit it serves to save $700,000. Alabama inmates now receive an apple or an orange once a week, down from twice a week. Milk has been reduced from seven servings per week to three. Tennessee has also cut back on milk portions for men - from two servings a day to one - to save $600,000.

    Gordon Crews, a professor at Marshall University in West Virginia, wrote a book looking at correctional violence and said historically there have been links between food and problems behind bars. He pointed to a February riot at the Reeves County Detention Center in Texas caused in part by poor food quality.

    "A lot of prisoners will see something like that as some kind of retribution against them or some kind of mistreatment," Crews said. "It'll be something that the correctional staff will pay the price for ... another reason (for inmates) to argue and fight back."

    In Georgia, reports of inmate assaults - on both staff and other inmates - are up substantially for fiscal year 2009 over the year before, according to data obtained by The Associated Press through an open records request.

    Prison officials deny the increase has anything to do with the shrinking menu but didn't provide an explanation.

    Sara Totonchi, of the Southern Center for Human Rights, called the elimination of Friday lunch part of a troubling trend of budget cuts in Georgia's correctional system.

    "We don't think this is a good idea," she said. "It destabilizes things inside the prison and that is not good for any of the inmates or staff."

    -------

    On the Web:

    Georgia Department of Corrections: http://www.dcor.state.ga.us

    American Civil Liberties Union National Prison Project: http://www.aclu.org/prison

    National Institute of Corrections: http://www.nicic.org

    -------

    Associated Press writers Phillip Rawls in Montgomery, Alabama, and Erik Schelzig in Nashville, Tennessee, contributed to this report.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

here's an idea, instead of

here's an idea, instead of cutting meals and starving inmates how about we have a fundamental change in our jails and quit jailing thousands upon thousands of non-violent drug offenders, especially those on marijuana charges. that ought to save some money

Take it one step further:

Take it one step further: legalize marijuana and tax it. Decrease the prison population and increase revenue in one fell swoop. Not to mention removing the truly compelling question, "why is it that people in this 'free country' can be arrested and sent to prison for growing a plant?"

I definitely agree that the

I definitely agree that the way to save money on prisons is to legalize marijuana and release thousands of non-violent prisoners, rather than starving them. Also, if there are any riots that result from this , any money saved- and probably prisoners' and staff members' lives- would be lost, and then some.

I definitely agree with the

I definitely agree with the other posters here, reducing the population of our prisons - especially of non-violent offenders - is the answer. In the mean time this "short term" solution is playing with dynomite.

Ever had a low-blood sugar "episode"? Besides causing severe physical pain, panic atttacks, and a host of other symptoms it makes you meaner than a nest of PO'd hornets! Lets make these folks with no place to go and no one else but each other or the guards to vent it on violent, right? Not to mention all the other health problems it leads to.

What a stupid, short-sighted "cure" for the problem.

But here we sit, myself included, typing away and doing nothing with our outrage.

Let's get off our hineys, and type to our reps in government, pick up the phone and call them, or most importantly, use our votes to tell them "we're mad as hell and we're not going to take it anymoe!"

I agree about the non

I agree about the non violent criminals being released. I also think we need to give the power of sentencing back to the judges by removing mandatory sentencing. The time has come.

Every time I read more about

Every time I read more about the massive expense/problems the U.S. has in housing and feeding inmates, I just sigh and wonder why we have to lock up everybody and anybody for every little thing. It says something really horrible about living in one country that imprisons 25% of the entire penal population on the planet. Besides, it's hard for me to feel too much sympathy for their hardships when so many children are doing without meals daily. A lot of homeless kids won't eat other than the school lunch and sometimes breakfast served to them. I've read that there are homeless children who only attend school for the food. They fall asleep at their desks after having spent the night sleepless in fear. A family member teaches school in Phoenix where teachers are really concerned about the situation. But you don't hear much about it, do you?

Legalizing marijuana would

Legalizing marijuana would not solve all problems, though: how are you going to find the chain-gangs you need to fix the roads if the prisons are empty? Stop loss has some limits. Also the revenue for these chain gangs should offset the price of the meals. So what? Another guest worker program to replace inmate slave work with immigrant slave work?

Re: Brunches instead of

Re: Brunches instead of Breakfast and lunch. If the brunches are "all you can eat," and they carry enough protein, they are following a pattern many of us take. We as a family of two, husband and wife, often eat brunch instead of breakfast and lunch on week-ends and on days off during the week. We simply eat our brunch as 8:30 AM or as late as 10:00 AM instead of 6:30-7:00 AM. Have been doing so for 20+ years. I don't see the harm, there. Many people by choice eat only two meals a day.

somehow i doubt very much

somehow i doubt very much that the brunches are of the "all you can eat" variety. from A sample Friday menu for prisoners in Georgia, who are now getting only two meals that day as the state tries to save money: (parenthetical notes mine) Breakfast: Scrambled eggs (I would assume powdered eggs) Grits Corn Muffins Bran cereal Pineapple beverage Margarine Coffee Milk (as the article points out, some states are cutting back on milk, in Alabama inmates get milk three times a week) Dinner: Chicken and biscuits (I'm guessing this is probably a drumstick and thigh and one, possibly two biscuit) Turnip greens Tossed salad (insert your own joke here) Vinegar and oil dressing Mashed potatoes Spice cake Iced tea I'm not saying prisoners should be eating like kings or anything, but since this is the menu released by the Georgia prison system I'm guessing this is as good as it get for inmates there. I imagine the menu in the privately run prisons is considerably worse.

I as a business man for 33

I as a business man for 33 years worked 12 hours a day , 6 days a week . In the morning I would have 2 or 3 cups of coffee and sometimes a bowl of cereal . I rarely had any lunch , I was too busy to take the time . Evenings at about 8:00 P.M. I would have a fairly large meal . I am now over 70 years old and am slim and trim compared to many of my friends and am in GOOD health. Generally speaking people stuff themselves which is not healthy.