Share

Can Obama Stop Israeli Settlements?

by: Steve Weissman, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Reflections on a TV screen in a shop near Jerusalem's Old city as President Barack Obama's speaks to the Muslim world in Cairo. (Photo: AP)

    Now comes the heavy lifting. Barack Obama has spoken in Cairo, calling for a new beginning between the U.S. and the world's one billion Muslims. All the major players have offered their initial reactions, and everyone from Israeli Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu to the incredibly shrinking Osama bin Laden is asking the same question: Can Obama deliver?

    The first and most obvious test will be Israeli settlements on the occupied West Bank. In his speech, Obama drew a rather modest line in the sand. "The United States does not accept the legitimacy of continued Israeli settlements," he said. "This construction violates previous agreements and undermines efforts to achieve peace. It is time for these settlements to stop."

    Obama did not call for a withdrawal of existing settlements, the tearing down of the separation wall, or the opening of the Israeli-only highways that carve up the Palestinian land and make a viable state impossible. He left these and other life-and-death issues to future negotiations between the Israelis and Palestinians.

    Even so, Netanyahu and his Likkud-led government said no. "Israel will not heed President Barack Obama's powerful appeal to halt all settlement activity on lands the Palestinians claim for a future state, officials said Friday, a position that looks sure to cause a policy clash with its most powerful ally," the Associated Press reported.

    "The government plans to allow construction inside existing West Bank settlements to accommodate for growing families, said the officials."

    Columnist Charles Krauthammer and America's whatever-Israel-wants crowd dutifully repeated the "natural growth" argument, finding a humanitarian necessity in helping Israeli families grow and prosper on Palestinian land.

    In their eagerness to avoid any suggestion of "moral equivalence" in the suffering of Palestinians and Jews, the American Likkudniks urged Obama to hold off on the settlements until he stopped the Iranian nuclear program, the build-up of Hamas missiles in Gaza, and the threat posed by a newly-strengthened Hezbollah in Lebanon.

    And, no surprise, the same voices somehow managed to overlook the Fourth Geneva Convention, which makes it a crime in international law for any country to colonize land it has conquered in war.

    One could be forgiven for beginning to see a pattern here.

    Obama, in the meantime, soared above the fray. Having brilliantly used his speech to redefine the game, he deftly passed the ball to Bibi, suggesting that the Israeli leader might well become the Nixon of the Middle East.

    "There's the famous example of Richard Nixon going to China," Obama told a small group of reporters, according to ABC News. "A Democrat couldn't have gone to China. A liberal couldn't have gone to China. But a big anti-communist like Richard Nixon could open that door. Now, it's conceivable that Prime Minister Netanyahu can play that same role."

    Obama then flew off to the Nazi concentration camp at Buchenwald, where he repeated his condemnation of Iranian President Ahmadinejad and others who deny the reality of the Holocaust. Neither Netanyahu nor his American allies will get away with smearing this president as an enemy of either the Jewish people or the State of Israel.

    All the while, the White House and State Department played solid defense, insisting that Obama was simply continuing the long-standing American opposition to Israeli settlements. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton even rejected the claims made by former Israeli officials that the administration of George W. Bush had secretly agreed to expanding Jewish settlements on the West Bank within their existing boundaries.

    "There is no memorialization of any informal and oral agreements," she told a news conference, as reported by the Israeli daily Haaretz. "If they did occur, which of course people say they did, they did not become part of the official position of the United States government."

    Will Obama make his opposition to the settlements stick where earlier administrations failed? He will definitely try, and the reason has nothing to do with whatever compassion he might feel for the Palestinians.

    As Obama and his advisors see the issue, American interests in reigning in nuclear proliferation, reducing terrorism, and protecting sources of oil and natural gas in Muslim countries require ending the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians, or at least being seen trying our best to do so. This is where the "foreign policy realism" of the first George Bush meets "Change We Can Believe In," and Obama's speech in Cairo and meetings with Egypt's Hosni Mubarak and Saudi King Abdullah set in motion a process that will push Washington in that direction.

    Newsweek's current interview with Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Saud al-Faisal makes the point. His message: The US should cut off aid if Israel does not end the occupation.

    "The United States has the means to persuade the Israelis to work for a peaceful settlement," said the Saudi prince. "It needs to tell them that if it is going to continue to help them, they must be reasonable and make reasonable concessions."

    The White House and Congress remain a long way from cutting off aid to Israel. But Obama has opened the door to increasing pressure on himself, and that will translate into increasing pressure on the Israelis.

  

»


A veteran of the Berkeley Free Speech Movement and the New Left monthly Ramparts, Steve Weissman lived for many years in London, working as a magazine writer and television producer. He now lives and works in France.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

The Saudi price is right.

The Saudi price is right. One hiccup in the cash flow and they'd decide settlements aren't so important.

Can Obama Stop Israeli

Can Obama Stop Israeli Settlements? NO!

Obama has said, " we should

Obama has said, " we should forge partnerships as opposed to simply dictating solutions." America will "start by listening, because all too often the United States starts by dictating." Except with regards to Israel, to whom Obama starts by dictating. It is illogical to say a visit to Buchenwald means Obama is not an enemy of the Jewish state. Most citizens of Israel believe that's exactly what he is.

exract: the American

exract: the American Likkudniks urged Obama to hold off on the settlements until he stopped the Iranian nuclear program, the build-up of Hamas missiles in Gaza,.... did you mean missiles OR rockets? hamas fires rockets, never missiles israel fires missiles, never rockets

Now, more than ever, our

Now, more than ever, our President needs American Jews that are against the Settlements to speak up for freedom, democracy and WORLD PEACE.

What visible website exists

What visible website exists for Worldwide Jewry to voice their support opposition to settlement construction?

Re the settlements: Build

Re the settlements: Build up, not out. Answer might lie in high rise apartments

Now is the moment when we'll

Now is the moment when we'll find out if Americans run our policy toward the Middle East or whether the real boss is in Tel Aviv. Obama will have to get tough, or everybody loses.

Enscription in tomb 1000 BC:

Enscription in tomb 1000 BC: The peace talks between the Isralis and the Palestinians are moving along. I've been following this conflict for 50 years. You would hope something would give...

"Can [President] Obama stop

"Can [President] Obama stop Israeli settlements?" - Of course he can. If we stopped sending American tax dollars to Israel tomorrow, the Israeli government would kick the so called "settlers" out themselves. We don't need a carrot AND a stick to pursue this policy. The threat of removing the carrot alone would be enough to wake Israel up. Who knows. Maybe we could re-allocate those billions to helping RE-settle some American cities. NAH!

Re: this comment Sun,

Re: this comment Sun, 06/07/2009 - 20:46 β€” Anonymous (not verified) What visible website exists for Worldwide Jewry to voice their support opposition to settlement construction? Check out: jewishvoiceforpeace.org

With respect to the

With respect to the question: "What visible website exists for Worldwide Jewry to voice their support opposition to settlement construction?" Specifically for U.S. citizens, take a look at the website of Brit Tzedek v'Shalom (the Jewish Alliance for Justice and Peace) at http://www.btvshalom.org/.

Can Obama Stop Israeli

Can Obama Stop Israeli Settlements? He'd better. Israel can no longer use the "national security" card to increase its ILLEGAL settlements--no matter what secret deal they made with GW Bush.

The settlements are probably

The settlements are probably the major reason why the entire Muslim world believes the Israelis, and by their continued condoning of the situation, the Americans, are not serious about creating a just and lasting peace in the area. Israel does not need to build houses on land they conquered out in the desert, inhabited by ultra-religious Jews who think they have a God-given right to re-populate their "holy land", and then have to use their Army to defend them against inevitable attacks from the people the land has been stolen from. I believe that a majority of Jewish people world-wide would favor dismantling ALL the settlements if it meant that terrorist attacks would stop and peace could take hold in the region. But that means these "super-Jews" have to be reigned in... by pressure from the US and also the moderate Israelis that want a rational solution.

The Israelis should continue

The Israelis should continue to build settlements. If a Palestinian state is formed and the Jewish settlements are inside the new borders, they can be Jewish citizens of the new Palestinian State. Israel proper is 20% Arab/Muslim. Why can't Jews live in the new Palestinian state?

Many, if not most Jews in

Many, if not most Jews in the U.S. and their families and others in Israel, reject the policies of their militaristic, hawkish, leadership. Continuing the occupation of Palestinian land, and building walls that create tremendous hardship will never move them toward peace. These have made it impossible to have harmony between the people there. "J Street" is a Jewish organization working to change these destructive attitudes and they have an excellent website promoting real answers for true peace.

Anonymous said, "Can Obama

Anonymous said, "Can Obama Stop Israeli Settlements? NO! " But if Obama is pressured by the American people, he can and should begin cutting aid until Israel stops building settlements. Let's face it, without the USA being complicit by its funding, Israel would have sought a solution a long time ago.

Israel is its own worst

Israel is its own worst enemy.

Stop u.s. aid to israel

Stop u.s. aid to israel until the settlements are gone,right of return applies to palestinians,israel gets out of u.s. congress,etc.israel is the biggest albatross around the world's neck and needs to be brought down to earth now.AND remember june 7,1967 when the u.s.s. ;liberty was attacked mercilessly by the israeli military for over 2 hours killing 34,wounding 170 out of a crew of 300.

Can Obama Stop Israeli

Can Obama Stop Israeli Settlements? He'll do better than that. His ongoing efforts will see the formalisation of a two State agreement which will be fully ratified during his second term. This will result in a de-escalation of hostilities across the Mid-East.

"The USS Liberty incident

"The USS Liberty incident was an attack on a neutral United States Navy technical research ship, USS Liberty, by Israeli jet fighter planes and motor torpedo boats on June 8, 1967, during the Six-Day War. The combined air and sea attack killed 34 crewmembers (naval officers, seamen, two Marines, and a civilian), wounded 171 crew members, and damaged the ship severely. The ship was in international waters north of the Sinai Peninsula, about 25.5 nautical miles (47.2 km) northwest from the Egyptian city of Arish. ..." by: Wikipedia (The Free 'non-corporate' Encyclopedia)

Israel only recognizes

Israel only recognizes might,whether it be force or cash. Obama is on the right track.

Israel's game plan: the

Israel's game plan: the creeping erasure of the Palestinian people. Obama's game plan for Middle East: I'm too nice a guy to push any particular agenda. (Read: maintain status quo). Also ,his game plan health care change.

It is amazing how a people

It is amazing how a people who had such a horror perpetrated on them just turn around and do the same thing to others.

I have to agree with

I have to agree with previous posts. Stop shoveling aid to Israel. Are we going to float that country for eternity? The US is the only country keeping Israel from going under. Pull back on the foreign aid and they'll step into line. Of course you run the risk of being called anti-Semitic, Israel's ace in the hole.

Can Obama stop the

Can Obama stop the settlements? A better question is: does he want to?

The irony is - the American

The irony is - the American taxpayers don't have the money to 'donate' to Israel for their so-called aid, now or forever, - they are borrowing it from China, Japan and a long list of Arab oil countries, so Israel can build their settlements and the apartheid wall. and not to forget , so that Israel can maintain the fifth-largest military power in the world!

Cut the dole! Stop sending

Cut the dole! Stop sending our money to support the hypocritical crooks, criminals and colonizers who continue wailing about what happened to some of their ancestors all the while doing the same thing to the Palestinians in the concentration camps the "victims" have created. They should reflect on the example of the mad dog: if you taunt and beat and starve the animal long enough it will turn on you. If you taunt and beat and destroy the homes and livelihoods of a people long enough, as the Israelis have done to the Palestinians, you shouldn't wonder why they turn on you - and you shouldn't run to the neighbor who has been giving you aid and ask for even more help. God's Chosen people, indeed!