Share

Words and War

by: Norman Solomon, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
A July 2008 bombing outside the Indian Embassy in Kabul. (Photo: Getty Images)

    It takes at least tacit faith in massive violence to believe that after three decades of horrendous violence in Afghanistan, upping the violence there will improve the situation.

    Despite the pronouncements from high Washington places that the problems of Afghanistan can't be solved by military means, 90 percent of the spending for Afghanistan in the Obama administration's current supplemental bill is military.

    Often it seems that lofty words about war hopes are boilerplate efforts to make us feel better about an endless warfare state. Oratory and punditry laud the Pentagon's fallen as noble victims of war, while enveloping its other victims in a haze of ambiguity or virtual nonexistence.

    When last Sunday's edition of The Washington Post printed the routine headline, "Iraq War Deaths," the newspaper meant American deaths - to Washington's ultra-savvy, the deaths that really count. The only numbers and names under the headline were American.

    Ask for whom the bell tolls. That's the implicit message - from top journalists and politicians alike.

    A few weeks ago, some prominent US news stories did emerge about Pentagon air strikes that killed perhaps a hundred Afghan civilians. But much of the emphasis was that such deaths could undermine the US war effort. The most powerful media lenses do not correct the myopia when Uncle Sam's vision is impaired by solipsism and narcissism.

    Words focus our attention. The official words and the media words - routinely, more or less the same words - are ostensibly about war, but they convey little about actual war at the same time that they boost it. Words are one thing, and war is another.

    Yet words have potential to impede the wheels of war machinery. "And henceforth," Albert Camus wrote, "the only honorable course will be to stake everything on a formidable gamble: that words are more powerful than munitions."

    A very different type of gamble is routinely underway at the centers of political power, where words are propaganda munitions. In Washington, the default preference is to gamble with the lives of other people, far away.

    More than 40 years ago, Country Joe McDonald wrote a song, "An Untitled Protest," about war fighters: who "pound their feet into the sand of shores they've never seen / Delegates from the western land to join the death machine." Now, tens of thousands more of such delegates are on the way to Afghanistan.

    In pseudo-savvy Washington, "appearance is reality." Killing and maiming, fueled by appropriations and silence, are rendered as abstractions.

    The deaths of people unaligned with the Pentagon are the most abstract of all. No wonder The Washington Post is still printing headlines like "Iraq War Deaths." Why should Iraqis qualify for inclusion in Iraq war deaths?

    There's plenty more media invisibility and erasure ahead for Afghan people as the Pentagon ramps up its war effort in their country.

    War thrives on abstractions that pass for reality.

    There are facts about war in news media and in presidential speeches. For that matter, there are plenty of facts in the local phone book. How much do they tell you about the most important human realities?

    Millions of words and factual data pour out of the Pentagon every day. Human truth is another matter.

    My father, Morris Solomon, recently had his ninetieth birthday. He would be the first to tell you that his brain has lost a lot of capacity. He doesn't recall nearly as many facts as he used to. But a couple of days ago, he told me: "I know what war is. It's stupid. It's ruining humanity."

    That's not appearance. It's reality.

  

»


Norman Solomon is co-chair of the national Healthcare NOT Warfare campaign, launched by Progressive Democrats of America. He is the author of a dozen books including "War Made Easy: How Presidents and Pundits Keep Spinning Us to Death." For more information, go to: www.normansolomon.com.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Very moving. Your words are

Very moving. Your words are not only eloquently succinct, but a moving "picture show" of the way in which deceit continues unabated. I resonate with this message totally.

We live in a world created

We live in a world created for us by those who have gone before us -- and we continue in their stead ... it is a world that holds fear above all else and so it is no wonder that our current administration has no other location to funnel peacemaking funds than through the war-making arm of our government ... even so, as we look to creating the space for peace we must be careful as we proceed, and be honest with ourselves about the hell we continue to create ... then maybe, and only maybe we will find the courage to risk in new ways to give birth to peace ... and this not through violence ...

Norman, Perhaps you're

Norman, Perhaps you're correct in observing that "War thrives on abstractions that pass for reality." But another problem is lack of imagination. Our leaders, apparently, cannot envision an alternative to war in Afghanistan. I think it might help the administration and all of us if you would write a policy essay giving the specifics of an alternative plan. Just saying "No" to war is unlikely to stop the war. We need a positive vision that suggests practical steps we can--and should--take. Murray

And don't you love the

And don't you love the religious right's silence regarding all those unmentioned and unmentionable Iraqi deaths? They are not pro-life. They are pro-fetus.

Norman's & dad's surname is

Norman's & dad's surname is Solomon. Mr. Solomon, the elder and Howard Zinn are "agemates" (a few years apart) and know the same wisdom. Words are also used as propaganda by government. As Zinn says, "If you don't know history, it's like you were born yesterday and the government can tell you anything.". (From speech played on DemocracyNow, Jan. 3, 2009, given by Zinn shortly after the last Presidential election. His main other point, I think, is that government's interests and yours/mine/the people's interests ARE NOT THE SAME. Don't be fooled, folks. The war(s) is/are not being escalated for your benefit or mine...

Unless you're being

Unless you're being facetious, you must be confused as to why the u.s. and it's "allies" are waging war around the planet. This isn't about terrorism, at least not islamic terrorism. This is about world domination by the military/fossil-fuel/banking interests. They own Congress, they own Obama, they own the United Nations. Nothing will end this. Humanity's legacy: Profit before Life.

In South Asian countries,

In South Asian countries, 'appearances' are nightmares and dreams are apocalyptic. Time is rendered blurred by the violence of all sorts. Remember Norman, 'appearances' and 'dreams' together form 'reality'. Sometimes I think our lives as an inconclusive sentence growing and developing to make a complete ultimate sentence with any meaning..and this all is happening under certain grammatical rules. Syntax has its own rationality and logic. But think....when violence disrupts this process and perpetuates its own irrational, illogical 'reasoning'...when it interferes in side an evolving sentence...language itself is liquidated... That's the reason, we cry:'No more war!...no more violence..! Lets go to prayers...' and our cries don't carry any meaning because the language has been perished ... They are the 'powers' for whom the bell tolls..Certainly not for us, who have lost their abilities to form a complete sentence.. Norman, we are now deprived of any grammar. If we say 'PEACE' ...is there anyone who can comprehend it and translate it in their language.. Language of war, profits, trades and hegemony over others..?

Everyday fear is for sale in

Everyday fear is for sale in our media, and violence is peddled as the antidote to that poison. The first step toward peace will have to be either a reduction in the diet of fear and violence (which is unlikely given that there are fewer and fewer independent / privately owned media outlets) or adults will have to take matters into their own hands and unplugged the instrument of control (your corporate-programmed TV). PBS is a middle of the road solution but it is being squeezed by corporate money everyday. Globalization is the new colonialism and will reap a world of woe as the injustice and environmental devastation takes its toll in those hapless third world countries that seem happy to appease their teeming populations with 16 hour days at $0.35/ day. Someday, hopefully soon, 1st-World people will realize that it is all about lifestyles and economic justice. If we truly want peace then we must be about guarantying justice for all…justice that eliminates death by starvation for both food and an education for women and men everywhere.

Why is our current

Why is our current administration allowing this to happen when its professed view is one of change in all fronts?

There is a difference

There is a difference between a war in self defense and an unprovoked war. Our entire policy in the Mid-East rests on the pivot of the 911 attack. We must have the courage to do as the myriad of intelligence, military, aeronautic, architectural and engineering professionals who have stuck their necks out to demand, and launch an independent investigation of the attack, as we only have one small piece of the story and indications are that it contains many serious inaccuracies. Visit http://www1.ae911truth.org/

The wars in Afghanistan,

The wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, and now Pakistan were only possible because of the anger and fear generated by the 9/11 incident. The fake "attacks" by alleged al Qaida operatives on a mission planned and orchestrated by the cave-dwelling legendary fanatic Osama bin Laden gave the leaders of the U.S. war machine the excuse they needed to invade Afghanistan and Iraq. Islamic terrorists suddenly replaced the Soviet communists as our national "enemy." The media was enthusiastically selling endless war against a chimerical enemy that shape-shifted across borders and, like the Viet Cong, were fighters at night and average citizens by day. However, the pundits and captive media now remain silent in the face of incontrovertible evidence that the "official" story of 9/11 event was a lie. To this day, any assertion that the "attacks" were not actually carried out by CIA asset Osama bin Laden and 19 Arab patsies shepherded into position by the CIA and others, is ignored by the media despite the fact that this is the biggest story of the century. The media and their controllers, of course, have a vested interest in concealing the fact that rogue elements within our own government murdered nearly 3000 U.S. citizens for propaganda purposes. Read THE ROAD TO 9/11 by Peter Dale Scott and see if you still believe the official story.

War IS a peace-process,

War IS a peace-process, perhaps the only peace process America understands, with its winner-take-all mentality. War is a sport, played for fun & gain, & uses an inter-changeable vocabulary. The Israel/ Palestinian conflict is an ongoing "peace-process" with a lot of dead people. When America is involved, "peace-process" is rarely a PEACEFUL process but usually includes violence or the threat of violence. Like the schoolyard bully, motivated out of fear & insecurity (or selfish sadism, it's hard to tell which), resorts to intimidation & violence, the U.S. is the first & loudest to cry 'foul' if a victim resists or, heaven forbid, fights back...run home to mommy NATO or UN & come back with a bigger stick & a moral justification.. Afghanistan is the proof that an individually armed citizenry has little need for a national army to defend itself & does not need outside help to govern itself...it's been doing that for centuries. They need no lessons in democracy...village elders, ward bosses & with no more nor less corruption than we have. They have always had a functioning grass-roots democracy (that is until the Russians nearly destroyed it by murdering anyone with any local authority). And, with the appointment Gen. McTyranny, it looks like America is about loose its SPETZNAZ death-squads. Differentiations like armed fighter, civilian, woman, child, Pushtu, Baluch..are all irrelevant when making war on an entire indigenous people. There are only two distinction the military makes...hostile (which includes unknown), & friendly. As in Viet-Nam, the Af/Pac war started when we arrived & will end only when we inevitably leave. Unfortunately, we rarely leave until we are beaten & thrown out. If the object is to get rid of all foreign soldiers, then what is there to negotiate about? Let the "peace-process" continue.

Out of House and Out of

Out of House and Out of Home The only way to stop U.S. Imperialism is through retaliatory resistance. When the United States Government destroys a village, and murders innocent civilians, revenge takes on a life force beyond intelligence. The only thing the American people are going to truly understand is great suffering. America is spending itself to death, out of house and out of home. Mike Hastie U.S. Army Medic Vietnam 1970-71