Share

Senate Adopts Slavery Apology Resolution

by: Greg Vadala and Edward Epstein  |  Congressional Quarterly

photo
(Image: The iPINIONS Journal)

    The Senate adopted a resolution Thursday offering a formal apology for slavery and the era of "separate but equal" Jim Crow laws that followed.

    After the clerk finished reading the resolution (S Con Res 26) in full, Iowa Democrat Tom Harkin, the measure's sponsor, noted that Congress has never before issued a formal apology for slavery.

    "It's long past due. A national apology by the representative body of the people is a necessary collective response to a past collective injustice," Harkin said. "So it is both appropriate and imperative that Congress fulfill its moral obligation and officially apologize for slavery and Jim Crow laws."

    The Senate action comes more than 40 years after the Civil Rights Act was passed, 146 years after President Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation, and in the same year Barack Obama was sworn in as the first African-American president.

    The non-binding resolution, which does not have the force of law, includes a disclaimer stating that the measure does not authorize or support reparations for the descendants of African slaves brought to the United States before the Civil War.

    The inclusion of the disclaimer in the Senate resolution has drawn sharp criticism from members of the Congressional Black Caucus.

    Soon after the Senate approved the measure on a voice vote, Rep. Maxine Waters, D-Calif., said the disclaimer is "unnecessary language."

    "If that is what it says, I don't support it," Waters said.

    House Judiciary Chairman John Conyers Jr., D-Mich., has for years made little headway with his proposals for the federal government to consider some form of reparations.

    But Rep. Artur Davis, D-Ala., who is trying to become the first black governor of his Deep South state, said he was glad about the Senate action, and added that the Congress is overdue in apologizing for slavery.

    Alabama approved an apology for slavery two years ago, following similar actions by legislatures in Maryland, Virginia and North Carolina.

    "The Republican legislature (in Alabama) adopted the resolution and the Republican governor signed it. If they can do it, it's probably not such a hard thing for Congress to do it," Davis said.

    Illinois Democratic Sen. Roland W. Burris, the lone African-American senator, took to the floor to praise the resolution.

    "Some in the black community will dismiss this resolution. Some will say that words don't matter — that the actions of our forefathers cannot be undone," Burris said. "But words do matter. They matter a great deal."

    Burris acknowledged that the reparations disclaimer concerned him. "I want to go on record making sure that that disclaimer in no way would eliminate future actions that may be brought before this body that may deal with reparations," he said.

    Rep. Steve Cohen D-Tenn., a white Democrat from Tennessee who represents a black majority district, sponsored a slavery apology resolution that was adopted by the House last year.

    Cohen, whose resolution was silent on reparations, said the House might act again this year.

    "The House may do a resolution similar to the Senate or just rest on the one we passed last year," said Cohen.

    "I think it's historic that the Senate passed a resolution," he said, adding that the Senate would not have acted if the House had not adopted his earlier resolution last year. Cohen said he would prefer a resolution that was silent on reparations, but said he understood why the disclaimer was needed for Senate passage.

    "I prefer my language but I am not a member of the Senate," said Cohen.

    Now that both chambers have acted, plans are in the works for a ceremony in the Capitol rotunda on July 7 to commemorate the action, he said.

    It isn't often that Congress offers a formal apology. In the Civil Liberties Act of 1988 (PL 100-383), Congress apologized to the Japanese who were forced to live in internment camps during World War II. During a debate on an Indian health bill last year, the Senate adopted an amendment apologizing for the U.S. legacy of brutality against Native Americans. And in 2005, the Senate adopted a resolution apologizing for its history of filibustering legislation designed to combat lynching of African Americans during the 19th and 20th centuries.

    -------

    Bennett Roth contributed to this story.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

WHAT IS RACISM? White

WHAT IS RACISM? White people need to ask themselves this question. WHAT IS ITS POLITICAL UTILILTY? WHY HAS IT BEEN PERPETUATED FOR GENERATIONS? WHAT DOES IT HAVE TO DO WITH CLASS STRATIFICATION? These are essential democratic questions. Until white people ask themselves these kind of questions token apologies will carry the taint of the disingenuous and will be meaningless.

Reparations, aside from

Reparations, aside from being superfluous in light of the over $1 trillion White-to-black wealth transfer effected by the last four decades of entitlement spending, are an administrative non-starter. Unlike the old USSR, ethnic classifications do not appear on official records. In addition, try convincing Hispanics and Asians to cough up cash for slavery reparations. BTW, Steve Cohen is not White, and has no right to speak for Whites.

Actions speak louder than

Actions speak louder than words, in particular louder than almost any words from our screwed up congressional circus of RepubliCrat clowns.

N I C E to see the senate do

N I C E to see the senate do 'some' good work :) Love "Light" and Energy _don

What do they mean, "...a

What do they mean, "...a national apology"? My family didn't own slaves ! My family didn't make the "Jim Crow" laws ! That blame goes to the rich and politicians of that era. I don't apologize for something me or my family didn't do !!

"A national apology" means

"A national apology" means recognizing the fact that, whether our ancestors owned slaves or not, Whites have benefitted collectively and substantially, and suffered morally, from the destructive institutions of the past. This was well understood at the time, as can be seen from the high moral tone of the anti-slavery movement. That some refuse to understand that connection today does not alter the basic facts. What's wrong with simply saying, "We regret this chapter in our history, and we're sorry that it happened"? That's not so hard, is it?

Enough with the talk that

Enough with the talk that cares no weight "non-binding resolution, which does not have the force of law". This country is in real trouble - stop talking the talk and start walking the walk. There is so much that needs doing and they spend their time on non-binding resolutions. Looks good -but does nothing.

So when will our government

So when will our government pay back the descendants of those that built this country by being slaves?

This apology is long overdue

This apology is long overdue because one important ingredient was missing: an African American preisdent. Rejecting this resolution would have been fatal to all the White democrats in the pearly seats. Personally, I may agree to some extent with Burris' statement that "words do matter", but they can only go so far. There's no mercurial shift in white politician's thinking if they believe words are sufficient. But, what also can be done? It's beenn too long since the end of slavery and the Jom Crow laws. What's the point of handing out reconciliation to a generation that's not suffered directly? Also the African American community shouldn't even be categorized, they're now hard-wokring, outstanding Americans. I believe the real and more avid problem is that of the Native American community. They're suffering endures and, even on that dreadful health bill, they just handed out neatly worded "appologies".

To acknowledge is step 1, to

To acknowledge is step 1, to apologize is step 2 and to make amends or to repair the damage done is step 3. Check kindergarten 101 if a reference is needed.