Share

Food Inc: Michael Pollan and Friends Reveal the Food Industry's Darkest Secrets

by: Tara Lohan  |  AlterNet

photo
A scene from the documentary film "Food Inc." (Photo: Food Inc. / Magnolia Pictures)

    The new film "Food Inc." is a shocking look at the health, human rights and environmental nightmare that lands on our plate each meal.

    It turns out that figuring out the most simple thing - like what's on your dinner plate, and where it came from - is actually a pretty subversive act.

    That's what director Robert Kenner found out while spending six years putting together the amazing new documentary, "Food Inc.," which features prominent food writers Michael Pollan (The Omnivore's Dilemma) and Eric Schlosser (Fast Food Nation).

    Warning: "Food Inc." is not for the faint of heart. While its focus is not on the gory images of slaughterhouse floors and filthy feedlots, what it does show about the journey of our food from "farm" to plate is not pretty.

    The story's main narrative chronicles the consolidation of our vast food industry into the hands of a few powerful corporations that have worked to limit the public's understanding of where its food comes from, what's in it and how safe it may be.

    But it's also a larger story about the people that have gotten in the way of the stampeding corporate herd - like farmer Joel Salatin (also profiled in Pollan's Omnivore's Dilemma), who has bravely bucked the trend to go corporate.

    There's also Barbara Kowalcyk, who becomes a tireless food-safety advocate after her 2 1/2-year-old son Kevin died from eating an E. coli-tainted hamburger. And there is the economically strapped Orozco family, which is faced with the difficult decision of whether to save money by buying cheap processed food and spend more later on medical bills, or spring for the more expensive, but healthier food options that stretch its immediate income.

    There are also the farmers who appear with their faces blacked out on screen for fear of Monsanto, or the communities ravaged by Type 2 diabetes, or the undocumented workers at processing plants who are recruited from their NAFTA-screwed homelands, illegally brought over the border to work dangerous jobs for peanuts, only to be humiliatingly sacrificed in immigration raids that only criminalize workers and never the employers.

    It's really the people that make this film so riveting. If you've read Pollan's or Schlosser's important works, then you already know a lot - but the film is still eye-opening on so many levels. And sometimes, you really just have to see it to believe it.

    Both Pollan and Schlosser narrate the film, but it is the ordinary folks in the film that make you realize how critical these issues are to the future of food, health care, the environment and human rights in this country.

    If you care about what you eat, then you should see this film - and if you do, you'll likely never walk through the supermarket in the same way again. And that's a damn good thing.

    AlterNet recently had the chance to talk with Kenner about whether our food is really safe to eat, why the food industry doesn't want us to know what we're eating, and how we can fight back.

    Tara Lohan: So how did this film come about?

    Robert Kenner: I read Eric Schlosser's book, Fast Food Nation, and I was struck by the idea that with food, there could be so much we don't know about something we are as familiar with. I began to think about doing a film about how we eat and where the food comes from. Ultimately exploring the idea that - on one level we are spending less of our paycheck on food today than probably at any point in the history of the world - and at the same time, this inexpensive food is coming to us at a high cost that you don't see at the checkout counter.

    I thought by being able to talk about all the producers - from the [small farmer] Joe Salatins of the world to big agribusiness - it could be a very interesting conversation. Unfortunately, that conversation never took place [because the agribusiness companies wouldn't consent to be interviewed], so the movie kept transforming into something different. I was very disappointed in the wall and the veil that was placed between us and this conversation about our food.

    TL: What was your learning curve like - how much did you know about these issues going into this, and what did you learn along the way?

    RK: I'm still learning. I didn't come into this as a food activist, I came into this as a filmmaker who found it an interesting conversation. I didn't want to make a film for the converted, I didn't want to make a film for the true believers; I wanted to make a film for people who hadn't thought about the food they are eating. I thought it was most important to try and get people, not to turn their stomachs but to open their eyes.

    My previous film was called Two Days in October, and it was a story about Vietnam told from all different points of view, and I found I learned more from the people whose opinions were different than mine, and I thought that was great - unfortunately, this was the opposite. The people who were different wanted to put up a wall. I didn't realize how subversive the world of food was.

    I went to a hearing on whether we should label cloned meats. When the lady who represented the industry spoke and said, "I really think it is not in the consumer's interest to be given this information because it's too confusing," I got goosebumps and thought, "this is scary."

    Then I realized that this is happening time and time again, and I hadn't been aware of it - whether it's GMOs that these corporations say are really good and will save the world but then they'll fight like hell to make sure you don't know it's in your food.

    Then there is [food-safety advocate] Barb Kowalcyk, who can't tell me what she eats because of the veggie libel laws. And I'm thinking something is off. If you live in a free society and are going to have free trade, it has got to be based on information; and if we are being denied that information we can't make the right choices. I didn't realize I was making a film about First Amendment rights. There is a lot to the story about our food.

    TL: You mentioned not being able to have the conversation you wanted because there were so many corporations that wouldn't go on camera with you, but there were also ordinary people who were afraid to talk.

    RK: You know, if you talk, and you're involved in this world of food production, you do so at great peril. And you pay the price. It is amazing how vulnerable you can be if you step forward and enter this conversation.

    TL: One of the startling things in the film was the industry connections that so many of the people had who were in positions of power at the FDA and the USDA.

    RK: One thing we say in the film is that we are not opposed to people going from industry to government, that is OK. The problem is when they go from industry to government, rule on things they are involved in in industry and then go back to industry with great bonuses. That seems a conflict of interest.

    And it wasn't only in the Bush era. In a funny way this crosses boundaries between Democrats and Republicans. On some of the levels, Monsanto has gotten a free ride because people think they are going to save the world with GMOs and their seeds. It has cut across party lines. It feels like tobacco research. Unfortunately, the ag schools have been taken over by industry, and they are now publishing reports.

    I think the parallels to tobacco are really true. Eric [Schlosser] has a line that sums it up: that they are huge, powerful, rich corporations thoroughly connected to government issuing misleading statements about their products, saying they are not unhealthy - ultimately, there are real parallels, and I think as we start to see how unsafe this food is, like tobacco, we are going to change it.

    TL: Are you seeing any changes in the first few months of the Obama administration?

    RK: Well, I think this wasn't a high priority because, obviously, there are huge crisis situations that have to be solved, but I don't think you can solve health care without changing the food system, when 1 out of 3 Americans born after the year 2000 is going to get early-onset diabetes; it is going to bankrupt the health care system. And I think there is a direct connection between food and health.

    I don't think you can deal with the environment without dealing with the food system when 20-25 percent of your carbon footprint involves growing and transporting food.

    I think these issues are coming to the surface and are becoming more important, there has just been some movement on food safety where the FDA will have the power to recall food (which they do not have now), such as Nestle's cookie dough, which has E. coli in it.

    TL: So, right now, the FDA doesn't have the power to recall food?

    RK: The hamburger that killed Barb's son prompted her to help create Kevin's Law to get the USDA, which is in charge of meat, to be able to recall food. It's a complex situation - the USDA oversees meat, but if it's a cheeseburger, then it's the FDA, because it's dairy. But neither of them have the power to recall food. The hamburger that killed Barb's son sat on the shelves for 12 days after he died when they knew where it came from, but the government couldn't recall it - it was up to the corporation. Hopefully that one will start to be changed.

    But we are subsidizing food that is making us sick in an even bigger way than E. coli, and that's obesity and diabetes. And I think that we have to figure out a way to turn the farm bill into the food bill.

    TL: What does that mean?

    RK: To start representing eaters' interests, not agribusiness. Unfortunately, that bill doesn't come up again until 2012. When we screened the film for [USDA head Tom] Vilsack, he said "we need a movement to follow. If there is a movement, we can help follow, but we can't change farm subsidies without people demanding it." Because he's up against agribusiness, and they're very powerful.

    TL: To me one of the shocking numbers in the film were the figures for diabetes, which you mentioned - 1 in 3 Americans born after 2000 and 1 in 2 who are minorities - are there people in the health community who are drawing these connections?

    RK: Oh yeah, that's why we can't have health care reform without fixing that. Diabetes is going to be so expensive. I really hope that we battle this idea of elitism, that people say that the can only afford bad food. That's why I think that family in the film was so important, because we have people who have a hard time paying for healthier, less-processed food, but meanwhile, they are now paying for it in their health care costs. The invisible costs are becoming very real for them, and how many people in that community have diabetes is astounding. They could not believe I didn't know someone without Type 2 Diabetes.

    TL: So, based on everything you've learned in this film, do you think of our food as being safe to eat?

    RK: I try not to eat industrialized foods as much. What is the bigger danger, is the idea of how they figure out how to deliver salt, sugar and fat to us. Sixty-four percent of Americans are either overweight or obese. I think, like tobacco they are trying to figure out how to sell you a product that is a bit addicting, and they are using billions of dollars of advertising, and they are training kids to do it at an early age, and they are overwhelming taste buds. So that's the scary part.

    TL: One of the things I liked in the film was talking, not just about the environmental and health impacts of the food we are eating, but about the labor laws and the treatment of the workers in some of the processing plants.

    RK: For me, one of the shocks of making this film was that at every rural location we went to there were parts of towns that only spoke Spanish and that our food is grown and processed by illegal immigrants, and it is really this hypocritical world that we live in because we are depending on them to deliver this inexpensive food to the supermarket, but yet we also don't want them in our communities because people think it taxes communities - the health care and schools.

    But unfortunately, the people who get arrested are the workers who are working hard and doing their part, and the reason they are being hired is because they are doing difficult, dangerous, low-paying jobs, and only people without rights would want to do that work. And that for me was as important as talking about how the animals are mistreated - I tried not to even go there. But people are always shocked by animal mistreatment in the film, and I didn't think I even put it in.

    TL: I think there were some pretty gruesome scenes.

    RK: God, I was just talking with my editor, and we thought we took them out. What you don't see in this film, and I didn't even want to go there ... you see the chickens, but the fact is that pigs don't move except for the day they are executed, or cows just sit in their own excrement - you know thousands of them in these giant factory feedlots. We've created megafactories, and it's not just the meat, it is the tomatoes and all the way down the line - we've created a machine of great efficiency that produces the food rather inexpensively, but it comes with great consequence.

    TL: One of the lighter scenes in the film is where the Wal-Mart reps go out to this small organic dairy farm that is selling its milk to Stonyfield Farms.

    RK: Oh yes, this happened right at the end of the film, and we were trying to get Wal-Mart in, and all of a sudden they said yes, we'd like to come. Whoever was willing to appear in the film, I wanted to present them in the best possible light. It is very easy to say a lot of negative things about Wal-Mart, and we wouldn't be the first to do it, but I also thought that I wanted to use that section of the film to show that consumers have power and that we are not out to make a film about how terrible every corporation is, because I do think there is a role in corporations helping to change the system, and we have to talk about that.

    TL: What's so funny is when the farmer meets the Wal-Mart reps ...

    RK: Yeah, she says, "I've never been in your stores - we boycott you - and I've been doing it for so long, I can't even remember why." She was great.

    TL: It makes you realize how complex the food system is, when small organic farmers are also dependent on Wal-Mart to sell what they are producing. What do you think people should be doing - shopping locally and organically is good - but what else?

    RK: I think the big thing is that we're not going to be perfect, so if you can change one meal a day, you're going to have a huge impact. Go to takepart.com - that lists things we can be doing and organizations to get involved with to help make change.

    We say, we vote three times a day - breakfast, lunch and dinner - but we also vote with our vote. When it comes to our meals, there is local, which I think is the best, it affects things on so many levels. There is organic - I was in fields where people had to wear spacesuits, and I don't think we should be eating food when people need spacesuits to grow it. When you go to the supermarket, start to read labels. All those funny words are corn and soy, and they are going to not be good for you. And know you have power - talk to people, ask for things you want. But don't feel bad if you're not perfect.

    People think if they can't do it all the time they don't have to do anything. Change one meal. But then we have to stop subsidizing food that is making us sick, we have to change the national school-lunch program. If we supported local farms and got that to the school systems and spent a dollar there, we'd save a a fortune in medicine and train kids to eat right, and we'd have better communities.

    We have to vote with our votes and our forks. I am really optimistic that it's going to change. I feel a sense of real growth - it might not be quick, but it is going to change, there is a real growing movement. The question is when. This is an unsustainable system, it can't go on.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Now that you've heard from

Now that you've heard from the director, check out The Warren Report's interview with FOOD, INC.'s producer, Elise Pearlstein: http://thewarrenreport.com/?p=7553

Buy the best organic food

Buy the best organic food even if you have to eat less. Eating less makes you live longer.

We are lower income

We are lower income alternative types, but work at eating right, which means focusing on vegetables, fruits and nuts, grains, etc. We do eat meat, but try to buy a better quality and eat in smaller quantities. The interview, however, is first mention I've heard of cloned meat. Can anyone say why that is problematic? Recalling cloned animals at a science fair, what would make their meat any more hazardous to eat than other animals? Or is it just the mass production methods, as usual, whether cloned or not? It's interesting that the writer says we spend less on food than ever before. We struggle SO with our food budget, and I think back on the days when food seemed, rather, plentiful and generous on an everyday basis. Meals were filled with extra servings and different courses. Teenagers would go to each others' homes and freely finish off the refrigerator without questions from parents. I can't imagine offering as much, these days, to a teenager's friends. And we are much more meager in our portions, servings, and courses (though in some respects, more healthly-so). I'm apprehensive about seeing this film, but I'm sure I will at some point. I'm sure I'll be discussing it with others who have as well. I'm glad it mentions the school system, too. The school system, for all its lip service to nutrition, is one of my biggest foes, as a parent, ITO what it teaches children to like. Outside their influence (for example, summertime), I have no such struggles. One point I might add is where people have their money invested and why Americans are loathe to criticize these "giants". Or why one is so vulnerable when doing so. Thanks for a both interesting and concerning review. I'm glad there are food advocates out there.

As long as the Ca$h flow

As long as the Ca$h flow CONtinues, We Don't Need ta Know Nothin'! What Really happened with Oprah & her "Food Disparagement Act" Case?

E X C E L L E N T

E X C E L L E N T Article! (((3)))

"Soylent Green,... it's made

"Soylent Green,... it's made out of people!" "To Serve Man... It's a cook-book!" "Your new Amana Radar Range from the Dew Line to your kitchen table (have a walnetto)" "Archer Daniels Midland, Pork Barrel to the World" "Things go better with Coke!" "The Pillsbury DoughBoy - Food war is hell, ain't it!"

Honestly, can you think of

Honestly, can you think of any major American industry that isn't currently riddled with corruption? Is it possible that we are just a corrupt society and that corruption taints our food and everything else as well? Maybe this corruption is just a natural result of corporate consolidation. It seems that the bigger the corporation, the harder it is to imagine the product showing the same pride of workmanship that would be found comming from a smaller company. It does seem to me that more power is consolidated in the hands of fewer corporate power brokers than ever before, maybe even more than during the "guilded age". Maybe that's the problem here. Maybe issues with the quality of our food supply are just a symptom of a larger problem.

If you want to eat

If you want to eat responsible meat, try grass fed buffalo. Generally you cannot "farm" buffalo, you can only let them be what they are. They were part of the food chain on in North America before man came and so their waste is better absorbed by the environment and they also do not destroy the grass they feed on. In the time before 1492, it was believed that Man and Buffalo were tethered together and as long as man took care of buffalo, buffalo would keep man strong and healthy. We should return to that sacred circle. Also buy locally grown vegetables and buy them directly from the farmer at a local farmers market. Speak with your $$ and let it be heard

I am a retired over-the-road

I am a retired over-the-road trucker. The last job that I had was pulling a tanker. One day I delivered 3,000 gallons of artificial sugar to a Kraft Foods plant. I was amazed to see that no real food products - grain and other dry goods- were delivered to this plant. It was all chemicals. The place looked like a refinery. Needless to say, I stopped buying anything with the Kraft label. Even the noodles are artificial.

As a farmer and reading

As a farmer and reading these poor comments tells my soul that most could not even fend for themselves when the local grocery store runs out of FOOD! Buy Local. Do most here know WHAT local actually IS? Existing as a farmer and experiencing the puke about "go green, go vegetarian, do not eat animal!" makes ME sick. Most here do not have a clue of the HISTORY OF THE FARM. The Family Farm is what you all rejected. GET THIS EVERYONE, Walmart discount [imported] what ever you call what you most in the urban centers now 'consume' as food. Good Luck. I grow our own food. I feed my family. I will not be wealthy. We will be healthy. No hand outs here. You will have to work for your food!

Well Josh (and I am not

Well Josh (and I am not josh'n you Josh), the American Buffalo Council thanks you for your kind support. When we are electro-proddin' those poor buffalo doggies, it's great to know we got folks like you on our side. "Buffalo, it's the beefier beef!" , find it, hunt it down, gut it, package it and voila! well whre is Bobby Flay> let's get some chipotles on it!

We are Addicted to MSG and

We are Addicted to MSG and Sweeteners. We are now hooked on high free-glutamate foods now labeled with dozens of names, like autolyzed, hydrolyzed, isolate, yeast extract, believe it or not... "natural flavor" includes food compounds that are processed into high free glutamate foods and are neurotoxic and diabetes-causing. For decades, the food industry has hidden this secret: MSG is truly delicious and very toxic over time (some succumb immediately, though) and it is as addictive as a drug. MSG exposure in children causes diabetes later in life - this is how scientists make mice diabetic for testing diabetes drugs. Aspartame breaks down into Methanol and causes destruction of the optic nerve and blindness. These are National tragedies and someone you know is already damaged by it.

Modern courage on display is

Modern courage on display is my take on this movie. The people without heart or courage could only be talked about in absentia. The saddest story of all was that of the man who had an antique seed-cleaning operation for soy beans. He had lost his business and the people he had believed were friends. The threats, intimidation, and bullying are close to unbelievable. The debts of conscience accumulating on the people who cannot speak for the cameras is astonishing. When it all falls down, they will be physically ill. Our illness-care system will be called upon to tend to them. The longer the end is postponed, the harder they will fall.

I'm not with the buffalo

I'm not with the buffalo meat industry, but I sometimes get buffalo meat, too. I've heard the same things about how it's raised (and how it canNOT be raised); plus, it's lower in fat than other red meats. I did not find it as tasty as some better cuts of red meat -- but the quality was better than what they usually put out there on the shelves, and I had the impression it just takes some adaptation ITO cooking approach. We don't object to meat eating at all. Just use moderately, reasonable guidelines given by physicians if you're concerned with heart disease, and certain forms of cancer. While we eat less because we can't afford more (not because we're morally opposed to a big juicy steak), it just so happens it's healthier, too, which makes living with the cutbacks that much easier. We use a lot of non-fat dairy in our diet as well. We don't go for the organic there, it's too expensive. Lately, we've been relying though on yogurt vs milk, for example, for a less hormone tainted source of calcium and protein.

I work for a state-wide

I work for a state-wide organization which promotes agriculture in our schools. "Grants" are simply chunks of money thrown at us by large agribiz's to "write curriculum" about their commodities and propagandize masked as education. As a small farmer who has to work off farm to make ends meet, I thought this would be a great job. A year later I realize small farmers count for nothing in the big corporate scheme of things and our schools and teachers are getting hosed. I am a beekeeper and organic gardener who feeds several families with a small CSA. I might as well be a scab crossing a picket line, only, if I don't our family and the tradition of farming in our family would suffer. Bayer Agriscience, Monsanto, Syngentec, and the large commodity marketing campaigns rule the day. Hopefully this film will start a national conversation before the small family farmer becomes a footnote in history - which would please the hell out of Monsanto.

The urban American is only a

The urban American is only a few % points away from total starvation! The financial backers of the "Factory Farms", will move capital as fast as lightening, to Asian markets, or elsewhere, much as the backers of GM and Chrysler did, for a few more % points ROI, and don't you damn forget it, Yankee Doodle Dandy! Your ass is on a fine line of percentage points of gain in ROI at all times and your pocket book is filled - with debt and pink slips - the skin on your food supply-line is stretched tighter than a fat woman's bright pink pantie hose, and a disastrous expose is about to happen! One screwball weather sequence, one larger than normal poisoning outbreak, one corrupt greedy official, one bad week in the market-place, one tough union fight, and just like a spark plug fires, the whole house of Factory Farming can collapse! Doesn't happen in America? Go see GM, Chrysler and a large number of once reliable banks! Does so happen in America! Welcome to the downside of rampant, unregulated, economy stimulating, vulture capitalism, and its consequences!

ADM/Monsanto buys

ADM/Monsanto buys Pfizer/Fox Sometimes I wonder why ADM doesn't merge with Pfizer and Fox. Big agribusiness produces crap food (high fructose corn syrup), media advertises that as well as the crappy drugs they shovel into people to deal with the consequences of obesity. And physicians too often get in the loop becoming "key opinion leaders" to further push more crap drugs down people's throats, downplaying healthier lifestyles while getting paid to spin clinical studies that have been turned into little more than marketing tools, leaving genuine science and health outcomes in the dust of the profits of a softcore economic genocide that keeps many USEFUL drugs exorbitantly expensive so people with AIDS die in Africa by the millions in order to "protect patents" (read profits). That makes me feel like I should run out and see a psychiatrist so I can get a lot of crap meds to dull the mind, heart and soul.

Unfortunately, you seem to

Unfortunately, you seem to be proving the "lady in industry" right regarding her stance that the issue is too confusing. You linked cloned foods and GMO's. Do you know the difference?

I just watched a video on

I just watched a video on youtube.. about milk and Bovine Growth Hormone and the name Monsanto was mentioned :) and how fox news killed the story. Monsanto threatened with litigation if the story was aired. The reporters sewed fox news - because well fox wanted them to distort the facts. In court basically they found that it wasn't against the law to distort facts ? what the heck kind of thing is that ? Do Americans know the milk they are drinking is full of this growth hormone ? How in the heck did something like this get past the FDA ? I wonder if the people from Monsanto - drink this milk ?

I grew up in rural Colorado

I grew up in rural Colorado where we lived on a small farm. We grew our own everything, and visits to the grocery store were rare. In AZ the family farm is pretty extinct, so I have found locals who grow for themselves and I supplement their incomes - cheap. I buy beef by the half from a Utah farmer (also cheaper) who thinks unsprayed hay is a great diet, and process my own fruits and veggies from Colorado. Sugar is a rare addition to my diet, used sparingly. I don't really like it. My kids are unable to live this way and all 3 struggle with weight and health problems. I have a hard time expressing my feelings about what capitalism has done to destroy our country without using words like 'hate' and 'rage'. Maybe we need a little motivation from 'hate' and 'rage'.

As to why cloned meat is

As to why cloned meat is objectionable, there is as yet no evidence that I'm aware of that the meat itself is in any way nutritionally inferior. However, it doesn't appear to be good for the animals, as more of them have health problems at a young age.I edited some stories on this when I was at Bloomberg News. here's one excerpt: "Concern that eating products from such animals may be unsafe -- and that the animals themselves are needlessly exposed to more health problems -- increased after Dolly, suffering from an incurable lung disease, was euthanized at an early age." By Catherine Larkin and Beth Jinks from http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aqTf2NGww878&refer=home. Also, it may well change the dynamics of the industry in ways that further push the balance of power in favor of agribusiness and away from small farmers, who generally have a much better record of stewardship towards plants, animals, the land, the environment, than agribusiness. Why do we need to clone animals? Have they lost the ability to reproduce naturally? Only when human-controlled breeding has so distorted animal biology that they can't do it unassisted. Outside of the realm of livestock, I have read that certain dog breeds have heads so large the puppies must be delivered by Caesarean. A lot of livestock are inseminated artificially nowadays, not entirely sure why. Probably for human convenience and the safety of the females. Cloning is a step further down the slippery slope.

I was under so called

I was under so called 'doctors care' for years. I finally took my own health into my own hands. Did a simple diet change, and low and behold I need no doctors anymore. What this world needs is to return everyone to themselves and quit this lording over each other. If it's a national brand, it's a national garbage.

Dear

Dear Congressman/woman, H.R.2749, Food Safety Enhancement Act of 2009 (Introduced in the House), must be amended to eliminate the onerous fee and other unreasonable restrictions on small family farms. The real culprits are the factory farms where atrocious conditions and inhumane treatment of animals abound. The small family farm must be protected and nourished. Please help by properly amending this bill.

the problem here is that

the problem here is that holy grail of most Americans, CAPITALISM. No one is going to admit it, at least right away, but, that's the culprit. A little socialism, is what we need, even if the republicons have convinced you otherwise. think about the profit motive, it has no morals, and doesn't need you, it needs to exploit someone to make that profit, why not you ?