Share

Made of Lies

by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t | Columnist

photo

    It began more than six years ago with a lie, followed by another lie, and another lie, and then two more, ten more, a hundred, a thousand, an avalanche of lies from heads of state and hatchet men and well-fed media types more interested in getting the interview than in getting the facts.

    It began with lies like this:

    "Simply stated, there is no doubt that Saddam Hussein now has weapons of mass destruction."

    - Dick Cheney, Vice President Speech to VFW National Convention 8/26/2002

    ... and this:

    "We don't want the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud."

    - Condoleezza Rice, US National Security Adviser CNN Late Edition 9/8/2002

    ... and this:

    "We know for a fact that there are weapons there."

    - Ari Fleischer, Press Secretary Press Briefing 1/9/2003

    ... and this:

    "We know that Saddam Hussein is determined to keep his weapons of mass destruction, is determined to make more."

    - Colin Powell, Secretary of State Remarks to the UN Security Council 2/5/2003

    ... and this:

    "We know where they are. They're in the area around Tikrit and Baghdad and east, west, south and north somewhat."

    - Donald Rumsfeld, Secretary of Defense ABC Interview 3/30/2003

    It began with George W. Bush standing before both houses of Congress and an international television audience for his January 2003 State of the Union address and stating that Iraq was in possession of 26,000 liters of anthrax, 38,000 liters of botulinum toxin, 500 tons - which is one million pounds - of sarin, mustard and VX nerve agent, 30,000 missiles to deliver the stuff, mobile biological weapons labs, al-Qaeda connections and uranium from Niger for use in a robust nuclear weapons program.

    Lies. All lies. 4,321 American soldiers have died in Iraq because of those lies, 101 during this year, including Sgt. Timothy A. David of Michigan, who was killed on June 28 when an improvised explosive device detonated near his vehicle. Four more soldiers were killed in Iraq on Tuesday in the midst of the withdrawal. Tens of thousands of American soldiers have been shredded and maimed because of those lies. Nobody knows how many innocent Iraqis have been killed and wounded because, to this day, we don't do body counts. Estimates range from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands to perhaps more than a million, depending on who you ask, all because of those lies.

    Now, more than six years later, a new president and a new policy has brought about one of the most dramatic and determinative days Iraq has seen since the initial invasion and occupation. "Six years and three months after the March 2003 invasion," reported The Washington Post on Tuesday, "the United States has withdrawn its remaining combat troops from Iraq's cities, the US commander here said, and is turning over security to Iraqi police and soldiers. While more than 130,000 U.S. troops remain in the country, patrols by heavily armed soldiers in hulking vehicles have largely disappeared from Baghdad, Mosul and Iraq's other urban centers. Iraqis danced in the streets and set off fireworks overnight in impromptu celebrations of a pivotal moment in their nation's troubled history. The government staged a military parade to mark the new national holiday of 'National Sovereignty Day,' and Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki made a triumphant, nationally televised address."

    Triumph comes in strange packages these days. The reality of the situation in Iraq has been best described by Robert Dreyfuss in a Nation article titled "Little to Celebrate in Iraq." Dreyfuss writes:

    As we pull back, we're leaving Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki in charge. Increasingly, Maliki is taking on the trappings of a dictator. He's established a network of security agencies that report directly to him. He's built a countrywide patronage system to bribe and pay off tribal allies, in anticipation of 2010 elections. He's shown no compunction against using the army, the police and the secret agencies he controls to eliminate rivals. He's used divide-and-conquer tactics to outflank the Sunni-led sahwa movement, known as the Awakening or the Sons of Iraq, driving some of them back into armed resistance and others into sullen resentment or fear for their lives.

    And Maliki, despite his protestations that he is a born-again "nationalist," has close ties to Iran. With Iran now revealed as a fundamentalist-run, naked military dictatorship, I expect Iran to act ruthlessly vis-a-vis Iraq, and if he wants to stay in power Maliki will pretty much have to go along.

    A prominent Sunni activist from northern Iraq told me Tuesday that anyone who thinks about opposing Maliki in Iraq has to fear for his or her life. The fact remains that despite the resurgence of secular nationalism in Iraq, as evidenced by the results of provincial elections last February, Maliki sits atop a conspiratorial little party called Al Dawa, a fundamentalist Islamist grouping, and he is reliant on a small, secretive clique that surrounds him. During the February election, in order to appeal to Iraqi voters, Maliki posed as a nationalist of sorts, but in fact he is dependent on two outside powers. First, he's dependent on the United States, for despite his bravado about the US withdrawal from Iraq's cities, Maliki desperately needs American backing to remain in power, to build up his armed forces. And second, Maliki is dependent on the good will of Iran, which could topple him instantly if he crossed Tehran.

    While Iraq's Shia population celebrated in the streets and Iraq's Sunni population crouched in fear, another group got right to business. "The long-awaited auction of licenses to develop Iraq's huge oil reserves began Tuesday amid unusual contentiousness," reported The New York Times on Tuesday, "as multinationals demanded far more revenue from every barrel of increased production than the authorities were willing to allow. Scores of Chinese, Russian, American and British oil executives, representing eight of the world's top 10 non-state oil companies, gathered in a hotel meeting room in the Green Zone. They listened closely on headphones to translations as bids for six oil fields and two natural gas fields were read out and then rushed into consultations."

    The more things change, the more they stay the same in an Iraq torn to pieces, covered in blood, and made of lies.

  

»


William Rivers Pitt is a New York Times and internationally bestselling author of two books: "War on Iraq: What Team Bush Doesn't Want You to Know" and "The Greatest Sedition Is Silence." His newest book, "House of Ill Repute: Reflections on War, Lies, and America's Ravaged Reputation," is now available from PoliPointPress.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

And so George W. Bush and

And so George W. Bush and Dick Cheney are closer than ever to achieving their original goal of securing Iraq's oil for the multinational oil companies who got them into the White House in the first place. Success is near, and all for the cost of a percent or so of one generation's young men and women, and a few trillion dollars.

Even though the media was

Even though the media was hamstrung somewhat by draconian "embedding" by the Bush administration, there was decidedly not nearly enough scrutiny on the build up hype that led this country into the Iraq War by the (humph) free press. Some have expressed regret, but that didn't help much. Now that Cheney has virtually admitted lying about his vicissitudes in this affair, why isn't he facing a court to testify regarding his patently treasonous actions?

Why is it that still today

Why is it that still today so few people in America care about the lies? Even our great new President cares not about the lies. Why is it that so few of us care about our dead soldiers? Why do so few of us care about the dead Iraqis? When will we ever learn that war is evil? All the Christians in this country must lay their weapons down and learn from our contentious history...there in lies the rub. Education. We are a country of morons.

They even used torture to

They even used torture to manufacture lies. It was one giant falsification factory that left their minions like Roberts and Alito to sanction their duplicitous products. Impeach the Supreme Court Justices installed by an illegal government on the way to meting our justice to all these nefarious public (corporate) servants.

War Crimes. Invasions.

War Crimes. Invasions. Murders. Torture. And none of these people should be held accountable for any of this? Where is the parade of Special Prosecutors for these and all the other illegal acts of the Monarchy that preceded Obama? Here, and in England. Where are the international courts?

George Orwell wrote a book

George Orwell wrote a book on the Spanish civil war called Homage to Catalonia in 1938. He served there for about six months in 1937. Reading this, I am reminded of his comments on the coverage by the press which fell wide of the mark on truth telling. As we re-read the lies put forth by the Bush Administration it strikes me that our much vaunted media bears responsibility for swallowing these lies so readily and regurgitating them to the public. Not all, but many.

So now more than ever it`s

So now more than ever it`s time to throw off the Exxon patent hold on the 500mpg carburator and yank the damn petroleum rug out from under all their money grubbing feet they have profited enough from this charade flat rate nickle a gallon and let OPEC embargo THAT!

A Long Line of Liars - We

A Long Line of Liars - We have had nothing but liars for presidents for some time now. Most recently, the campaign promises vs the immediate actions of giving the keys to the Treasury over to those who robbed us, starting another war, and leaving the vast majority of Bush's abominable signing statements creating dictatorial powers intact. Change? Show me some real change - restore the Bill of Rights, for a change, Mr. 'Constitutional Scholar'.

By the time Americans

By the time Americans finally leave all of Iraq, it will be fully clear to everyone that the last big lie told by Bush was also just that a big lie. Namely, getting rid of a brutal dictator (Hussein) was never even remotely an interest of the United States in Iraq. Instead, as your story remarks, our legacy to Iraq will simply be another murderous dictator, al-Maliki. The thousands of Americans who died there, the tens of thousands more wounded there, and the billions upon billions, yea, verily, even trillions, will all have been wasted for nothing -- except the neo-con macho idea that nations need to fight wars, so as to vet and bleed every generation, so that war will not die out from among the peoples of the world.

And here's the hilarious

And here's the hilarious part...America will NEVER leave Iraq, just as we never left Germany, or Japan, or Korea etc. Anyone looking for terrorists need look no further than the pentagon, the cia, the wto, the world bank, the imf, goldman-sachs, the "federal" reserve, or wall street. wars and occupation are for profit

Many lies and no

Many lies and no consequences for the liars.

So why was "Impeachment off

So why was "Impeachment off the table" by Pelosi? Why is there no prosecution now? Why do these scumbags go unprosecuted for the murder of so many American youngsters, and so many more Iraquis? Why is the World Court not prosecuting? And what lies are we being told now that allows Obama to do the same thing in Afghanistan? If Bush and company aren't held accountable, how can any future president be held accountable? what kind of government are we?

I hope there will soon be

I hope there will soon be coverage by TruthOut about Depleted Uranium and the systematic poisoning of the land and people of Iraq (and other countries) the US has engaged in for years now, shocking though it will be. The Bush administration's lies about the safety of DU is one of the vilest lies they've told, but the general public still knows virtually nothing about it. Our troops will be coming home with this poison in their bodies, their offspring will suffer high rates of birth defects, and the soldiers and their wives will suffer with abnormally high rates of cancer, though not as much as the Iraqis, of course. Their rates of birth defects and cancer are already over the top.

The average USer would

The average USer would rather die than admit that the USA is the most evil nation in the world.

The drill goes on . . . Why

The drill goes on . . . Why has the charade of 'leaders' of the past administration, and some of the current one---still parade in front of the American stage--like Pelosi and the esteemed John McCain, et al.? Because they have a stake in political non-speak 'protecting the perks' of office---so enthroned now in American politics. The Truth revealed--from before, during, and after 9/11 would throw this country into chaos---and they have all had a loud voice in the Silence. Again, the advice---read PNAC--Project For The New American Century. The blueprint is all there in black and white. And, what about the famous SHOCK and AWE, thee, hum . . 'stunning campaign' fashioned just for doing the quick Iraq War? A thorough reading of Shock And Awe, by Naomi Klein will take care of any yet lingering questions about why. Wake Up America. We are all pons on the chessboard of the 'king men," and their's is a deadly game. Our children need our action, or they will inherit oceans of our tears falling, as it were like rain, from beyond---where wisdom sees all and weeps. Gloria

When you have two parties

When you have two parties controlled by corporations, war is a business decision.

Let's see... The US,

Let's see... The US, trained Bin Laden, and put Taliban in control of Afghanistan. But wait, the Taliban were pretty horrible rulers huh and Bin Laden ? Who is Bin Laden, really ? Saddam - gosh he was horrible also, right..countries piled sanctions on the country about oil- he didn't suffer.. but the people of Iraq sure did. Did the people of Iraq benefit at all ? Name for me please, one Iraq citizen, who is delighted that the US military tore apart their society.. Just one, is all I'm asking for. Weapons of mass destruction- nothing but a smoke screen- to cause fear in people. Let the oil run free and everyone is suddenly happy. I have nothing but bitter contempt for Bush - he is a criminal along with the rest of hi s cronies. And to name what type of government we have - I would say we rapidly move to Fascism - how do you feel about that ? Do a little history research on Nazi Germany and then tell me please, what feelings run through your mind. Myself - I believe it took me 2 years of denial - before it really sank in.

I agree on the history. But

I agree on the history. But once the cat is out of the bag, you can't get it back in. What would happen if we simply walk away? My sick feeling when GWB invaded Iraq was, "We'll be there for 15 years." Nothing I've seen so far convinces me that I was wrong about that.

The fact that we have left

The fact that we have left the cities proves nothing. Bases were built outside the cities so it was a matter of relocation. Maliki needs the US for he is their puppet. He can call for US assistance anytime he needs and the military will come running and slaughtering, business as usual. We are not leaving Iraq: EVER. 60,000 Americans can die there and the US is not going to leave and that applies to Afghanistan as well. There is simply too much money to be made by mercenaries, contractors, the arms merchants, Big Oil, etc. Once Maliki is no longer viable for us, we will find another. It's the way the US conducts diplomacy and democracy.

We need to take to the

We need to take to the streets like the Iranian opposition. Let the whole world watch that. Unfortunately Americans are too complacent to stop watching tv and go out and do something. America - the land of apathy.

And the greatest deception

And the greatest deception of all - the belief in other.

Two million dead Iraqi

Two million dead Iraqi people, resources wasted and stolen, and Dick Cheney and the rest get million dollar plus contracts for books and other gigs. Go figure. It seems to pay to lie, cheat, rob, murder, than to do any noble actions. Forget faith in your fellow country men and women to dislodge themselves from their corn chips and mania for celebrity deaths while sitting in their overly comfortable sofas complaining about health care costs. Americans live on lies, gossip, and entertainment. No wonder we are where we are and the world dislikes us so much.

Well folks,we all know what

Well folks,we all know what we got, now the question is... What do we do about it?

Yeah - those lies were

Yeah - those lies were TERRIBLE! Now there's even worse ones like "We can spend our way out of debt", "We can afford universal health care" and "Cap and Trade will create jobs and save the economy". No matter which side of the fence you are on (R or D), you are being lied to and USED. Wake up - hold all governemnt officials responsible for their corrupt actions.

So if that's all true what

So if that's all true what is Truthout doing about it besides articles?

The Peaceful American

The Peaceful American Revolution is near. We’re burning daylight. It’s time to get off your ass’s and stick your neck out for a change. What is more important, your Country and your Children’s Freedom, or your credit rating? Where do I sign up?

And now the zinger of a

And now the zinger of a demouement to this little play. After spending trillions of dollar along with over 4,000 American lives and 1,000,000 Iraqi lives -- who wins the oil prize on the cheap? China! that's who. What a world. The wages of war goes not to those who win, but to those who gain the spoils without lifting a finger. See No Oil For Blood: http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/015/574iglgp.asp

First no re-elections for

First no re-elections for anyone....One term, you serve your country and out you go, back to the public sector. Start impeachment proceedings in our own states against those who have voted against the will of the people. Do you know ANYONE who wanted the bailout? I don't, and I keep asking. It must start at the local levels....local involvement. Groups hanging banners regularly over bypasses to inform the locals about the truth. Start up local meetings, gather, gather, gather. Get people together and get them talking. Bad stuff is coming our way and people need to ge prepared. Never think for a moment we aren't living in 1984. Read it if you haven't. America, the land of people living in a matrix.

Since it would have been

Since it would have been quite feasible to leave Saddam in place as our bad guy, well under control, and selling oil to us, and since he will apparently (and predictibly) be replaced by another strongman, why did we invade Iraq? It was not because of Saddam, not because of 9/11, and probably not to make it a democracy. It was not because of oil, because we could've bought that from Saddam. Therefore the only explanation is that we went to war to help the military industrial complex. But even that is a crude explanation. I'm still confused. Oh, and Mr Pitt, I get your point, and your need to be precise, but even if we don't know the exact number, it is important to cite the hundreds of thousands of Iraqi dead, and millions of refugees.

The point was not to take

The point was not to take the oil, it was to keep it off the market. These people never cared about how much we were spending for gas. They want the price high. The war was waged because Saddam was gonna increase his oil production. OPEC sets quotas for all the OPEC nations, and Saddam was about to defy them. Papa Bush said it, and the Washington Post printed it. If Saddam increases his oil production, the price of oil goes down, we don't want that. What else should we expect when we put an oil man in the White House.

Good article but it is

Good article but it is necessary to correct a lie by Robert Dreyfus: "With Iran now revealed as a fundamentalist-run, naked military dictatorship." THis is just not true. Iran has had elections that were more honest than those we've had in the US. Iran's weapons are purely defensive, not like those in the US, NATO, Israel. Iran has not invaded any nations. Iran has actually helped the US in both Iraq and Afghanistan. Lies are like fashions. Lies about Iraq's weapons and the crimes of Saddam are old news. Today's lies are about Iran. The but goal is the same -- demonize Iran and prepare the world for another "shock and awe." Dreyfus an Pitt should know better than this. But I fear that the coming Obama/democrat war against Iran will be much like the war against Yugoslavia in the 80s. All the liberals missed the truth of that war. It was naked aggression, just like in Iraq and Afhganistan but because it was stated by a democrat, the liberal media plugged it ears and covered its eyes. Now they are doing it about Iran.

Democrats and the media let

Democrats and the media let themselves be intimidated into not questioning the war and its premises. Look what happened to the Dixie Chicks. Unfortunately, the media (at least the islands of open-mindedness in the media) and especially the Democrats are still shell-shocked, have no backbone and are still walk in fear of the right-wing noise machine.

Re depleted uranium

Re depleted uranium ammunition: I second Anonymous' call for Truthout coverage of the effects of "d.u." For background, see the CBC archives at http://www.thewe.cc/contents/more/archive/june2003/depleted_uranium_the_silver_bullet_links.htm (thanks once again, Canada!) and Bill Mesler's article "The Gulf War's new casualties" in the July 14, 1997 issue of The Nation (issue no. 970).

We failed to included the

We failed to included the almost one million Iraqis that died as well. How little we really grasp the magnitude of this event. Just imagine if another country attacked us, killed ten's of thousands of our people and plundered our resources.

As long as people blindly

As long as people blindly vote the two party's, this kind of crap will go on forever. Now is the time to support a third party candidate and end this corporate canard for good! Vote for candidates who are not in the pockets of the corporations. Vote for Nader, Kucinich. Hell vote for Noam Chomsky! But stay away entirely from either of the main two party candidates. They are not on your side, my side or anyone's side beyond the corporate criminals who continue to turn this country into a police fascist state as they run it economically into the ground.

Looking backward, truth

Looking backward, truth begins to reveal itself when answers become evident to vital questions asked. It becomes obvious how all things are interconnected to either the truth or the lies of man. We see how Bush/Cheney developed "the grab" through an avalanche of media liars, an evil-hearted deception supported through a network of neo-Fascists hell-bent on ruling the planet by having new wars and other rivalries for their profit. The list of things done to and through Americans and the rest of the world during B/C that caused great harm to democracy, truth and higher ideals of mankind is mind-boggling! So much to destroy and so little time! The easiest way to change hearts and minds is through WAR. These evil-doing money-hungry death-dealing Fascists will NEVER STOP KILLING THE TRUTH AND ALL THOSE WHO STAND IN THE WAY OF THEIR GOALS. They are well-dressed criminals of the vilest kind! They would cut your heart out and then blame you for making them do it. TERROR IS MOSTLY ALIVE IN AMERICA. FASCISM HAS FOUND AMERICA A WILLING PARTNER. Nothing can stop them from their quest for total control of the masses until we refuse to believe their lies, refuse to accept their deceptions, boycott all that feeds their machine. Shouldn't we be pushing for justice to come to our aid, seek out the truth and put these murderers in prison? But we must always be willing to fight for truth and peace and justice, never complacent about it, always checking ourselves and stepping into the light for all to see.

Why should the

Why should the Republican-voting members of American Oil Industry corporate Boards of Directors care? They got theirs. Wall Street created billionaire cronies under G.W. Bush's watch, selling those lies to their stockholders that bought into those lies. It's all about money. Proof that greed, kills. Proof that the secretive hands of capitalist greed in the highest office in the land, creates wars that destroys their own national economy.... and for what I ask? This wasn't about making a profit, it was about making a killing. THOUSANDS OF OUR TROOPS DIED BECAUSE OF THIS LIE and those that come back still alive, tens of thousands are handicapped for life... and for what, I ask? JUST SO A FEW OIL INDUSTRY, REPUBLICAN-VOTING CEO'S IN AMERICA CAN BECOME RICHER THAN MIDAS? My sense of Christian morals directs me to never vote for another Republican, for as long as I live!!!

AMEN

AMEN

its just a matter of time

its just a matter of time before little georgie gets a seat on exxonmobil's board of directors as pay back for all the crimes and murders he committed on their and other oil companies advantage. to call him a coward and a mutt would be a major disservice to cowards and mutts!