Share

Showdown in Honduras: The Rise and Uncertain Future of the Coup

by: Benjamin Dangl, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Supporters of Honduras's ousted President Manuel Zelaya protest in Tegucigalpa June 29, 2009. (Photo: Reuters)

    Worldwide condemnation has followed the coup that unseated President Manuel Zelaya of Honduras on Sunday, June 28. Nationwide mobilizations and a general strike demanding that Zelaya be returned to power are growing in spite of increased military repression. One protester outside the government palace in Honduras told reporters that if Roberto Micheletti, the leader installed by the coup, wants to enter the palace, "he had better do so by air" because if he goes by land "we will stop him."

    Early Sunday morning, approximately 100 soldiers entered the home of the left-leaning Zelaya, forcefully removed him and, while he was still in his pajamas, ushered him onto a plane to Costa Rica. The tension that led to the coup involved a struggle for power between left and right political factions in the country. Besides the brutal challenges facing the Honduran people, this political crisis is a test for regional solidarity and Washington-Latin American relations.

    Manuel Zelaya Takes a Left Turn

    When Manuel Zelaya was elected president on November 27, 2005, in a close victory, he became president of one of the poorest nations in the region, with approximately 70 percent of its population of 7.5 million living under the poverty line. Though siding himself with the region's left in recent years as a new member of the leftist trade bloc, Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas (ALBA), Zelaya did sign the Central American Free Trade Agreement in 2004.

    However, Zelaya has been criticizing and taking on the sweatshop and corporate media industry in his country, and he increased the minimum wage by 60 percent. He said the increase, which angered the country's elite but expanded his support among unions, would "force the business oligarchy to start paying what is fair."

    At a meeting of regional anti-drug officials, Zelaya spoke of an unconventional way to combat the drug trafficking and related violence that has been plaguing his country: "Instead of pursuing drug traffickers, societies should invest resources in educating drug addicts and curbing their demand."

    After his election, Zelaya's left-leaning policies began generating "resistance and anger among Liberal [party] leaders and lawmakers on the one hand, and attracting support from the opposition, civil society organizations and popular movements on the other," IPS reported.

    The social organization Via Campesina stated, "The government of President Zelaya has been characterized by its defense of workers and campesinos, it is a defender of the Bolivarian Alternative of the Americas (ALBA), and during his administration it has promoted actions that benefit Honduran campesinos."

    As his popularity rose over the years among these sectors of society, the right wing and elite of Honduras worked to undermine the leader, eventually resulting in the recent coup.

    Leading up to the Coup

    The key question leading up to the coup was whether or not to hold a referendum on Sunday, June 28 - as Zelaya wanted - on organizing an assembly to rewrite the country's constitution.

    As one media analyst pointed out, while many major news outlets in the US, including the Miami Herald, Wall Street Journal and Washington Post, said an impetus for the coup was specifically Zelaya's plans for a vote to allow him to extend his term in office, the actual ballot question was to be: "Do you agree that, during the general elections of November 2009 there should be a fourth ballot to decide whether to hold a Constituent National Assembly that will approve a new political constitution?"

    Nations across Latin America, including Venezuela, Bolivia and Ecuador, have recently rewritten their constitutions. In many aspects, the changes to these documents enshrined new rights for marginalized people and protected the nations' economies from the destabilizing effects of free trade and corporate looting.

    Leading up to the coup, on June 10, members of teacher, student, indigenous and union groups marched to demand that Congress back the referendum on the constitution, chanting, "The people, aware, defend the Constituent [Assembly]." The Honduran Front of Teachers Organizations [FOM], with some 48,000 members, also supported the referendum. FOM leader Eulogio Ch·vez asked teachers to organize the expected referendum this past Sunday in schools, according to the Weekly News Update on the Americas.

    The Supreme Court ruled that the referendum violated the constitution as it was taking place during an election year. When Honduran military Gen. Romeo Vasquez refused to distribute ballots to citizens and participate in the preparations for the Sunday referendum, Zelaya fired him on June 24. The Court called for the reinstatement of Vasquez, but Zelaya refused to recognize the reinstatement, and proceeded with the referendum, distributing the ballots and planning for the Sunday vote.

    Crackdown in Honduras

    Vasquez, a former student at the infamous School of the Americas, now known as Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation (WHINSEC), went on to be a key leader in the June 28 coup.

    After Zelaya had been taken to Costa Rica, a falsified resignation letter from Zelaya was presented to Congress, and former Parliament leader Roberto Micheletti was sworn in by Congress as the new president of the country. Micheletti immediately declared a curfew as protests and mobilizations continued nationwide.

    Since the coup took place, military planes and helicopters have been circling the city, the electricity and internet have been cut off, and only music is being played on the few radio stations that are still operating, according to IPS News.

    Telesur journalists, who have been reporting consistently throughout the conflict, were detained by the de facto government in Honduras. They were then released, thanks to international pressure.

    The ambassadors to Honduras from Cuba, Venezuela and Nicaragua were arrested. Patricia Rodas, the foreign minister of Honduras under Zelaya has also been arrested. Rodas recently presided over an OAS meeting in which Cuba was finally admitted into the organization.

    The military-installed government has issued arrest warrants for Honduran social leaders for the Popular Bloc Coordinating Committee, Via Campesina and the Civic Council of Grassroots and Indigenous Organizations of Honduras, according to the Weekly News Update on the Americas.

    Human rights activist Dr. Juan Almendares, reporting from Tegucigalpa, the capital of Honduras, told Democracy Now! that due to government crackdowns and the electrical blackout, there is "not really access to information, no freedom of the press." He said, "We have also a curfew, because after 9:00 you can be shot if you are on the streets. So we have a curfew from 9:00 to 6:00 a.m."

    In a statement on the coup, Via Campesina said, "We believe that these deeds are the desperate acts of the national oligarchy and the hardcore right to preserve the interests of capital, and in particular, of the large transnational corporations."

    Mobilizations and Strikes in Support of Zelaya

    Members of social, indigenous and labor organizations from around the country have concentrated in the city's capital, organizing barricades around the presidential palace, demanding Zelaya's return to power. "Thousands of Hondurans gathered outside the presidential palace singing the national hymn," Telesur reported. "While the battalions mobilized against protesters at the Presidential House, the TV channels did not report on the tense events." Bertha C·ceres, the leader of the Consejo CĂŚvico de Organizaciones Populares y IndĂŚgenas, said that the ethnic communities of the country are ready for resistance and do not recognize the Micheletti government.

    Dr. Almendares reported that in spite of massive repression on the part of the military leaders, "We have almost a national strike for workers, people, students and intellectuals, and they are organized in a popular resistance-run pacific movement against this violation of the democracy.... There are many sectors involved in this movement trying to restitute the constitutional rights, the human rights."

    Rafael AlegrĂŚa, a leader of Via Campesina in Honduras, told Telesur, "The resistance of the people continues and is growing, already in the western part of the country campesinos are taking over highways, and the military troops are impeding bus travel, which is why many people have decided to travel to Tegucigalpa on foot. The resistance continues in spite of the hostility of the military patrols."

    A general strike was also organized by various social and labor sectors in the country. Regarding the strike, AlegrĂŚa said it is happening across state institutions and "progressively in the private sector."

    The 4th Army Battalion from the Atl·ntida Department in Honduras, has declared that it will not respect orders from the Micheletti government, and the major highways of the country are blocked by protesters, according to a radio interview with AlegrĂŚa.

    The Civic Council of Popular and Indigenous Organizations of Honduras (COPINH), condemned the coup, media crackdowns and repression, saying in a statement: "[T]he Honduran people are carrying out large demonstrations, actions in their communities, in the municipalities; there are occupations of bridges, and a protest in front of the presidential residence, among others. From the lands of Lempira, Moraz·n and Visitaci'n Padilla, we call on the Honduran people in general to demonstrate in defense of their rights and of real and direct democracy for the people, to the fascists we say that they will NOT silence us, that this cowardly act will turn back on them, with great force."

    Washington Responds

    On Sunday, Obama spoke of the events in Honduras: "I am deeply concerned by reports coming out of Honduras regarding the detention and expulsion of President Mel Zelaya. As the Organization of American States did on Friday, I call on all political and social actors in Honduras to respect democratic norms, the rule of law and the tenets of the Inter-American Democratic Charter. Any existing tensions and disputes must be resolved peacefully through dialogue free from any outside interference."

    But the US hasn't actually called what's happened in Honduras a coup. Hillary Clinton said, "We are withholding any formal legal determination." And regarding whether or not the US is calling for Zelaya's return, Clinton said, "We haven't laid out any demands that we're insisting on, because we're working with others on behalf of our ultimate objectives."

    If the White House declares that what's happening in Honduras is a coup, they would have to block aid to the rogue Honduran government. A provision of US law regarding funds directed by the US Congress says that, "None of the funds appropriated or otherwise made available ... shall be obligated or expended to finance directly any assistance to the government of any country whose duly elected head of government is deposed by military coup or decree."

    "The State Department has requested $68.2 million in aid for fiscal year 2010 [for Honduras], which begins on October 1, up from $43.2 million in the current fiscal year and $40.5 million a year earlier," according to Reuters.

    The US military has a base in Soto Cano, Honduras, which, according to investigative journalist Eva Golinger, is home to approximately 500 troops and a number of air force planes and helicopters.

    Regarding US relations with the Honduran military, Latin American History professor and journalist Greg Grandin said on Democracy Now!: "The Honduran military is effectively a subsidiary of the United States government. Honduras, as a whole, if any Latin American country is fully owned by the United States, it's Honduras. Its economy is wholly based on trade, foreign aid and remittances. So if the US is opposed to this coup going forward, it won't go forward. Zelaya will return ..."

    The Regional Response

    The Organization of American States and the United Nations have condemned the coup. Condemnation of the coup has come in from major leaders across the globe, and all over Latin America, as reported by Reuters: the presidents of Venezuela, Ecuador, Bolivia and Cuba have been outspoken in their protests against the coup. The French Foreign Ministry said, "France firmly condemns the coup that has just taken place in Honduras." Argentine President Cristina Fernandez said, "I'm deeply worried about the situation in Honduras ... it reminds us of the worst years in Latin America's history."

    Even Augusto RamĂŚrez Ocampo, a former foreign minister of Colombia told the NY Times, "It is a legal obligation to defend democracy in Honduras."

    Only time will tell what the international and national support for Zelaya means for Honduras. Regional support for Bolivian President Evo Morales during an attempted coup in 2008 empowered his fight against right-wing destabilizing forces. Popular support in the streets proved vital during the attempted coup against Venezuelan President Chavez in 2002.

    Meanwhile, Zelaya supporters continue to convene at the government palace, yelling at the armed soldiers while tanks roam the streets.

    "We're defending our president," protester Umberto Guebara told a New York Times reporter. "I'm not afraid. I'd give my life for my country."

  

»


Benjamin Dangl is the author of the forthcoming book, "Dancing With Dynamite: Social Movements and States in Latin America," (AK Press, 2010). He edits TowardFreedom.com, a progressive perspective on world events. Email Bendangl@gmail.com.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Why isn't anyone focusing on

Why isn't anyone focusing on the facts? 1. He was violating their Constitution 2. He was attempting to re-write their Constitution 3. He defied and ignored their Congress 4. He defied and ignored their Supreme Court 5. He VIOLATED THEIR CONSTITUTIONAL LAWS To what goal? Set himself up as President/Dictator for life. WAKE UP PEOPLE and stop being sheep

He was not violating their

He was not violating their Constitution, he didn't violate their constitutional laws. The military just wants to preserve the oligarchy because then the military retains power and all continues "as usual". The key statement in the article is ""The Honduran military is effectively a subsidiary of the United States government. Honduras, as a whole, if any Latin American country is fully owned by the United States, it's Honduras. Its economy is wholly based on trade, foreign aid and remittances. So if the US is opposed to this coup going forward, it won't go forward. Zelaya will return ..."

To 23:58 — Anonymous: Why

To 23:58 — Anonymous: Why haven't YOU focused on the facts? Why didn't you read the article? How can you defend a military coup against a popular president by saying that he was threatening to become a dictator. Focus on the facts. 1. Look up the definition of dictator. 2. Look up the definition of referendum. 3. Focus on the fact that removing from power an elected and very popular president who has a mandate from his voters to enact reform, simply for doing what the voters want is anti-democratic. 4. Focus on the fact that using a military coup to set up a puppet dictatorship is not a good way to prevent a dictatorship, especially when you could just have him impeached if you really thought you had a case against him. 5. Focus on the fact that most of the readers you've insulted actually read the article and have been paying attention all along.

This is a close call in my

This is a close call in my opinion. Since none of us live there to comrehend these series of events, it's best to wait before making any judgment. The US obviously knew that there was going to be a coup, and they haven't come out in full support of Zelaya. He was violating the Constitution by initiating the proposal to change the Constitution. From waht I have read any proposed change has to emanate from Congress.

The fact that the WH has not

The fact that the WH has not already declared that a coup, fell in behind the ousted President should tell us something. That is, they knew about the planned overthrow, do not intend sanctions and do not intend to insist he be returned to office with fill protections. Honduras is a satellite state for the US and its interests will be protected at all costs. No one is going to be allowed to pull away from the US, and get away with it and it is very clear that was the path Zelaya was taking. Those who have taken power did so with the blessing of the WH. Clinton stated she was not happy with the way she was treated recently by Zelaya. Chavez is a supporter of Zelaya and he is no friend of the US. If for some reason he is returned to power, it will be because he made a deal with the US (Bribes and blackmailed or even threatened with assassination--Or all the above). The US is not going to allow this country to go its own way and everyone should keep that in mind. It is not about rule of law, human rights or democracy. Obama is no friend of any of that. When asked recently if the US was wrong in putting Pinochet in power, should the US apologize (A simple enough request and apologies often go a very long way toward reconciliation), he deferred, stating he wanted to look ahead, not back. He is no friend to the global community and not us as Americans either.

Excellent article by Ben

Excellent article by Ben Dangl. Some missing details are coming from live & rebroadcast news & interviews from TeleSURtv.org which has been broadcasting nearly around the clock on the Honduras situation, despite the fact that--as Dangl, the Washington Post, Boston Globe, BBC & others have reported-- their news team in Honduras has been harassed, threatened and detained. Four AP staff members were detained. CNN en Espanol had its broadcasts blocked. Independent Honduran TV, radios & papers have been prevented from doing their job. Among other points: 1) Some military units have sided with the Zelaya and the Honduran people and some military leaders are resigning rather than be involved in repression on the citizenry. 2) The military is blocking transportation into Tegucigalpa so large numbers of people are walking to the city. 3) The military has been beating protesters in the street as well as detaining, & in some cases, disappearing people from their homes. 4) The military has used red-tinted spray from water cannons to "mark" protesters in the streets of Honduras. 5) The detention & kidnapping for president Zelaya (who was dumped in Costa Rica after the presidential plane, flown by the military, entered Costa Rican airspace without permission) has some similarities to the kidnapping of Haiti president on 3/1/2004 by the U.S. 6) Other dimensions of the Honduran coup resemble the failed U.S. backed attempted coup on Hugo Chavez Chavez in April 2004, in particular the role of right-wing media in the country in blockading, manipulating, and falsifying information. 7) Twenty years ago, the New York Times (3/20/1988) reported on the U.S. backed Honduran Air Force bombing Nicaragua on behalf of the U.S. organized contras. How times have changed with the U.S. forced to at least give the appearance of supporting democracy in Honduras. I expect TeleSURtv.org will win awards in the near future for its fearless coverage of this coup & many other events in the hemisphere blocked out & distorted by ruling class media.

One of the best pieces right

One of the best pieces right now on Honduras, is the most recent SOAW (School of America's Watch) press release. It includes important information on the coup leaders. (quote) The coup leaders include several well-known human rights abusers, such as the retired Captain Billy Fernando Joya Amendola, who was a member of the CIA-trained 3-16 batallion from 1984-91, one of the most notorious battalions noted for human rights abuses during that time.. Bertha Olivar, of COFADEH, calls the coup advisers a line-up of the "Galley of Terror". Furthermore, two coup leaders, Air Force Commander General Luis Javier Prince Suazo and Army General Romeo Vasquez Velasquez, were trained at the Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation (WHINSEC, Formerly known as the School of the Americas--SOA), a US army school located in Fort Benning, GA, whose graduates have been linked to some of the largest human rights atrocities in Latin America's history. (end quote) In addition it reports on the refusal of military units to go along with coup. (quote) Notably, two army battalions have refused orders from the coup government. They are the Fourth Infantry Battalion in the city of Tela and the Tenth Infantry Battalion in La Ceiba (the second largest city in Honduras), both located in the state of Atlantida. (end quote) http://www.commondreams.org/newswire/2009/06/30-6

If the US didn't support the

If the US didn't support the coup, it would never even have been thought of in Honduras. I live in CA. I like the comment that says, "we don't know enough, so we should do nothing." Go, USA!... Try googling and maybe you can know something. If the US lets the coup stand, ALL of the shiny new legitimacy of the Obama regime is tossed out the door in the eyes of the rest of the world.