Share

My State Legislature's Crazier than Yours. Oh Yeah?

by: Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
New York state Senators Dean G. Skelos, left, and Pedro Espada Jr. The New York Senate has seen a slew of shakeups in recent weeks. (Photo: Nathaniel Brooks / New York Times)

    California should just be done with it and rename the entire state "Neverland Ranch."

    This serves several useful purposes. It would: be the ultimate tribute to Michael Jackson, pleasing his most ardent and bereft fans; further validate the state's Cloud Cuckoo, fairy-tale reputation, thus probably promoting additional, revenue-generating tourism; and stand as an accurate metaphor for the state government's airheaded inability to cope with its current financial disaster.

    On Wednesday, Governor Schwarzenegger announced that California's deficit has grown to $26.3 billion and proposed billions of additional cuts to education. He declared a fiscal emergency, triggering an automatic 45-day deadline for the state legislature to come up with a plan to cover the shortfall and balance the budget. If that fails, they're banned from considering any other legislation until they come up with a solution.

    Arnold also signed an executive order forcing the state's 220,000 employees to take a third, unpaid furlough day every month. This, after weeks of failed proposals, threatened vetoes, political contortionism and suspended social programs - a fiscal train wreck of such proportions that on Thursday the state planned on starting to pay its bills with IOU's instead of cash.

    It's "an institutional breakdown," according to State Treasurer Bill Lockyer, a Democrat. Lockyer has called for professional mediation to unjam talks between legislators and Governor Terminator, and even a two-tiered budget system that would raise taxes and allot resources differently for different parts of the state.

    That may sound crazy, but this is California. Besides, we in New York State are in no position to cast stones. Our state Senate has degenerated into a slaphappy free-for-all that resembles a drunken demolition derby more than anything remotely like a deliberative body.

    On June 8, two Democratic state senators, both of whom are under investigation on an assortment of charges, defected to the other side of the aisle, giving the Republicans a 32-30 majority. Then, one of the Democrats changed what was left of his mind and went back, creating a 31-31 split and deadlock.

    Under normal circumstances, the lieutenant governor, who also serves as Senate president, could break a tie. But currently, we don't have one of those. David Paterson had the job until he was elevated to the top spot when Governor Eliot Spitzer was caught engaged in commercialized bedhopping and resigned.

    Last month's legislative coup has led to name-calling, accusations, general inertia and circumstances under which, among other assorted wackiness, the guy who the Republicans say is the current Senate president has claimed that because there is no lieutenant governor, he should have two votes.

    Because neither side can come up with the requisite 32 members for a quorum, the Senate disintegrated into a series of alternating, one-party sessions during which nothing could be accomplished. Although on Tuesday, when Democrats spotted Republican member Frank Padavan walking through the rear of the chamber, they seized on the moment, claiming a quorum, and started ramming through legislation, which the Republicans say was illegal. Padavan says he was just taking a shortcut for a cup of coffee.

    Imagine West Side Story meets Duck Soup, with the Marx Brothers playing the Sharks and Jets, using whoopee cushions instead of switchblades, and you get the general idea. With the backing of a court order, Governor Paterson is trying to force all 62 members into the chamber for daily "extraordinary" sessions at which he hopes a deal can be cut that will get the Senate up and running again. He says he'll keep them coming right through the Fourth of July weekend. Some are refusing to attend. Watch this space.

    Because, despite all the foolishness, as in California, this is serious stuff with potentially dire consequences. As The New York Times reports, June 30 "was the expiration date of more than a dozen statutes that authorize local governments to carry out their everyday duties, from planning budgets to collecting taxes. And as Democrats and Republicans in the Senate continued ... to argue fruitlessly over who controlled the chamber, officials around the state were left to ponder contingency plans that they never thought they would need."

    What's also infuriating is the way certain enabled individuals are consciously helping stymie any possible breakthrough. In California, it's Governor Schwarzenegger, whose veto threats, blocking of short-term loans, and refusal to raise any tax or virtually any fee have thrown additional wooden shoes into the works. In New York, it's not the governor, who has tried to break gridlock but whose efficacy is virtually nil and popularity is south of "get lost." It's upstate billionaire businessman Tom Golisano, a gadfly who, according to The Times, helped broker the defection of the two NY Senate Democrats that precipitated the current mess. Apparently, he did so out of pique over proposed tax hikes on the wealthy.

    It's all a nasty game that puts cronyism, partisan bickering, and corrupt, despicable self-interest above the needs of increasingly desperate citizens. It is especially abhorrent as we celebrate the country's independence and commemorate that long-ago struggle against abuses of power.

    At least Brooklyn Democratic Sen. John Sampson, when asked this week if he was embarrassed about the situation, had the grace to reply, "Embarrassed? That's an understatement. We're ashamed."

    Indeed.

  

»


Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program Bill Moyers Journal, which airs Friday nights on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

To some extent, we in New

To some extent, we in New York should fail safe. As I believe Molly Ivins once put it, "no one is safe when the legislature is in session."

And then the RI House left

And then the RI House left town without bothering to finish 90% of its business, so yes, it seems like way too many state legislatures are crazy.

Hey folks how many times do

Hey folks how many times do i have to say this?? Raise taxes on folks making over ONE MILLION DOLLARS A YEAR and exclude corporations that employ plain folks like us. Yes they might have to give up 1 or 2 mansions,yachts, or private planes ,but they will certainly have enough left for foolishness and monuments to themselves.

It is all just spiraling out

It is all just spiraling out of control. We are paying 9.75% in Los Angeles presently, during this economy, as our sales tax. They cut the summer school programs across the county (NO SUMMER SCHOOL) & now the Gover-nator threatens us with more education cuts? I WANT HIM OUT OF OFFICE!! IMPEACH this idiot!! California needs a level headed Governor who knows how to lead the legislature, not just say no, WATCHING OUT FOR HIS HOMIES & leaving a pattern of destruction in his wake. At least I know I didn't vote for him.

Man games. A sorry excuse

Man games. A sorry excuse for government.

What Winship failed to

What Winship failed to mention but is at the crux of the state's governance problems are 3 key factors unique to this state, a legislature where a 2/3 majority is required to approve a budget, rare in the USA, second the ability to change the state constitution through referendums and initiatives which puts many special interest driven provisions, like no increases effectively on property taxes paid by corporations that tend to hold property for decades, and lastly a Republican governor was elected thanks to massive corporate funding of first a recall and then a special election and this same "fiscal conservative" greatly increased the state's spending over the past 5 years. It would also be worthwhile to mention how effective the state's prison union has been in promoting life sentences for anyone convicted a third time, even for shoplifting and this has had a huge impact on the size of the prison population and the amount that needs to be spent to feed and house the prisoners - an amount far exceeding what it would cost to provide free college educations for everyone in the state. So there is a perfect storm that has been fueled by the corporate media and special interest groups in the state and by groups outside the state lobbying in California. But the bottom line is the greed of the elites who set government policy in California but also in the rest of the country. Anyone who laughs at California needs to examine the sanity of a country that sends hundreds of thousands of men and women to the Middle East at a cost of trillions of dollars to provide a few billion in profit to the oil companies. Better to just pay the corporate oil companies not to pump oil just as we pay corporate agri-business not to grow crops.

It isn't just the state

It isn't just the state workers who are hurting. What the California governor is doing is hurting most of the citizens in some way or another. Education is cut to the bone and schools are closing. California's portion of social security has been severely cut back. Health care for children and the poor has been curtailed. Welfare to work programs have been cut. I could go on and on. The only people who are safe are those, like the governor, who have a lot of money. He doesn't care that people are losing their jobs or their homes, or that we are struggling every day to put food on our family's table. Many companies are relocating to other states with lower costs and fewer regulations. Local governments are laying off police officers at the same time Arnold wants to let criminals out of prison as a way to save money. The only way out of this mess is more taxes. But the last thing Arnold wants to do is make himself or his friends pay more taxes on their millions. He has driven our state into a black hole that will take decades to dig out of once he has left office.

California's deficit has

California's deficit has grown to $26.3 billion...according to data from http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/06000.html the states 2008 population is 36,756,666 the simplest most direct and intelligent solution to end this fiasco would be to invoke a $25 per resident surcharge $15 being direct individual INVESTMENT in their state as $10/per head would end the empasse with some breathing room AHNALD JUSTHAS TO DO IT!

In NY, it is Business

In NY, it is Business interfering in government. Billionaire Tom Golisano from Pay Chex started the NY Senate debacle by convincing two of his Democratic lackeys to switch parties, giving republicans the majority because he had to pay more state taxes. Golisano and others continue to use the old tax myth; to raise taxes would be a hardship on business. On the contrary, the Bush administration’s GAO published the results of a ’06 corporate tax study, which found that the majority of corporations didn’t pay any income tax. Here in New York the wealthiest were paying the same tax rate as someone with an annual adjusted gross income of $20 thousand that is what billionaire Golisano is crying about. He is upset because the wealthy no longer pay the same rate as someone making $20 thousand, poor baby. Add to that a ramped national corporate welfare system. For example, the Destiny Mall in upstate NY received a 15-year tax exemption then was given another 30-year tax exemption for an expansion (45 years total), at a time when big malls are unpopular and expensive to run. The politically connected mall owner Congel never had to provide a list of new tenants needed to fill the expansion space. Another NY taxpayer rip-off called empire zones, which were originally intended as tax break incentives to start small businesses in urban areas. However, the corporate lackeys in office soon found a way to apply empire zone tax breaks in non-urban areas to the likes of Lockheed Martin the world's largest defense contractor, GEICO auto insurance company (caveman commercials, NY tax dollars at work) and many other profitable corporations. We need public financing of elections and a constitutional amendment, the separation of business and state, to keep the crazies out of office.

Hey Tommy G - how are your

Hey Tommy G - how are your kidneys holding up?

Thug is word of the

Thug is word of the week. Tom Galisano is a thug. The two defective dem defectors are thugs. One literally so, is indicted on felony assault and the other pinhead is under investigation for shady activities. I'd like to see some grubby senator get booted out by his/her constituents. A citizens vote of no-trust. ASAP. OK New Yorkers- time to mail these unworthy and EMPLOYED civil suckers pink slips. Deluge their Albany offices with envelopes holding pink paper. Enjoy.

How long until California

How long until California and New York start charging and exit tax like they do in Mexico? I'm afraid to visit. Maybe they can shake down tourists by doubling the hotel tax. They could take your drivers license at the border and charge a green tax if your car gets under 20 mpg! The only reason the state governments are going bankrupt is that they can't print up their own money like the Fed although Arnold has begun to figure it out with is Arnold Bucks. If I spend more than I make I can't hold my employer hostage and take more of their money like the state does to it's taxpayers. Get those socialist bloodsuckers out of office or move to a state that's solvent and values individual liberty!

Yes, raise taxes on

Yes, raise taxes on millionaires! And, yes, cut the higher ed budget, beginning with the community colleges which should NOT have all the frills and high-priced campuses. And recognize that NOT everyone should go to college. Training programs and apprenticeships are much better at preparing people who don't want all the theory anyway for jobs that need skills, not four years of fancy and over-priced "education." And then remember, for all time to come, that actors and businessmen don't usually make good governors.

C'mon, people. We have the

C'mon, people. We have the evangelical Mark Sanford, His Holiness as we know him, as governor (you know, "loose lips sink ships" guy) who a has been fighting his own Republican Legislature here on things like stimulus money for education and law enforcement, raising the cigarette tax up from $.07 a pack (hey, probably more than a buck in your state!), and all sorts of other things. But NOW, when all this stuff about his personal affairs comes out, they line up to SUPPORT the guy because how would it look if Republicans impeached a Republican that they will probably run for President of The United States of America. Heck, he and Palin will probably have some "affairs of state" to be remembered if they both get elected. C'mon, you guys aren't even close as to discomboobulated lawmakers. Heck, we even beat Mississippi on this one!!!

NY, Callie, you don't know

NY, Callie, you don't know jack about crazy legislatures. Try living in Oklahoma.

This makes me feel better

This makes me feel better about the crazy legislature that "serves" the state of Tennessee. The Republicans and Democrats in this state spend most of their time struggling for control, betraying their own party, and figuring out ways to get revenge for the betrayals. I can't complain about this though, because the state legislators are really crazy when they get it all worked out and start trying to pass laws. This past year they wanted to change state law to allow people to carry guns into bars. Having been to several taverns in Nashville, I know this cannot be a good idea. The governor vetoed the legislation, but they spent months on this pandering stupidity. My state senator was actually a good and decent person, so her own party worked tirelessly to get rid of her; she was a Democrat, and the Democratic party in Tennessee is the primary reason I cannot get involved with that party in any meaningful way. In Tennessee both the Democrats and the Republicans are crazy. It seems this is true in California, New York, North Carolina, and Oklahoma. Tennessee can be safely included in the list, if you're keeping count.

• “Then, one of the

• “Then, one of the Democrats changed what was left of his mind and went back, creating a 31-31 split and deadlock.” I had to laugh out loud at this, and that’s saying something. It’s exceedingly difficult for Californians to find ANYthing to chuckle about these days. Governor Terminator has indeed Terminated the life of our beautiful state.

No one has mentioned the

No one has mentioned the Lone Star state yet, and I admit that our Legislature has probably been too hung over this year to reach its normal level of pathological ineptitude, but, if governors are taken into consideration, don't forget on this July 4th that we have one who wants to secede. "O Say does that star-spangled banner yet wave. . .?"

The state with roughly the

The state with roughly the sixth largest economy in the WORLD is in a terrible budget crisis, states all over are having serious problems in one of the world's wealthiest nations, and citizens all over seem are complaining about their local legislatures, and all the while the rich get richer and the poor get poorer during another world wide financial crisis.....wasn't this country supposedly founded in revolt against corruption and tyranny and excess and all that? what happened with that? Oh yeah the banks bought that too. Investigate those who control and manipulate money and we just might have a new date to celebrate a whole new level of independence. happy 4th everyone!

Somebody's arithmetic is a

Somebody's arithmetic is a "bit" off. For California, it would take a $715 per person assessment to meet the deficit, not $10 or $25. One does have to laugh out loud at the craziness of some state legislatures, but it's pretty scary to be a citizen of a state which has to pass out IOUs!

Uppity Woman: Ditto for

Uppity Woman: Ditto for your neighbor to the south--Alabama!

Arnold may be a problem but

Arnold may be a problem but he's not THE problem. The real problem is that the California legislature requires a 2/3 majority to pass a budget. This puts the whole process at the mercy of the wingnuts...

We get the governments we

We get the governments we deserve. Our fundamental problem is our unwillingness to accept accountability for the governments we elect. It seems that most of us are quite content to elect representatives who are going to fight dirty and bend the rules in our favour, as long as *we* aren't held to account for their actions. When they are caught, we point our fingers in feigned disgust as if we had nothing to do with it. The quality of any democratic government ultimately reflects the quality of the people who elect that government. Our problem is a deeply entrenched culture of personal non-accountability, thanks in great measure to prevailing interpretations of the American Constitution that fail to balance personal rights against personal responsibilities. The freedom your nation's forefathers fought so hard for was the freedom to be responsible for one's personal affairs - to be in control of one's own life. They did not fight for freedom FROM responsibility or accountability, which is what most Americans seem to be fighting for these days.

At what point do the

At what point do the politicians finally stand up and admit the real cost of illegals? Included in costs would be medical education, police, No wonder California is broke when states wth few illegals are not.

Holy crapcakes, its crazy

Holy crapcakes, its crazy everywhere apparently! I laughed out loud at the very apt statement, West Side Story meets Duck Soup! Priceless! Here in California it just keeps getting weirder and weirder...um, does anyone out there know how to do basic math??? Just wondering...

To Floresta - perhaps the

To Floresta - perhaps the reason why people can't do math very well is because of the cuts to the education budget. It is time that society holds its leaders up to the standards that they should be held up to. It is time for the reforms that are long overdue. It is time for change. And by change, I mean not just the cosmetic changes that Obama has put into place, but real, genuine change.

Governor Arnold sounds like

Governor Arnold sounds like the Governor of SC. Didn't Arnold oust the Governor before him and get into office because of budget problems? Didn't Arnold promise to fix the problems?