Share

A President Breaks Hearts in Appalachia

by: Robert F. Kennedy Jr.  |  The Washington Post

photo
Mountaintop removal operation, Boone County, West Virginia (Photo: Vivian Stockman / Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition)

    Mountaintop removal coal mining is the worst environmental tragedy in American history. When will the Obama administration finally stop this Appalachian apocalypse?

    If ever an issue deserved President Obama's promise of change, this is it. Mining syndicates are detonating 2,500 tons of explosives each day - the equivalent of a Hiroshima bomb weekly - to blow up Appalachia's mountains and extract sub-surface coal seams. They have demolished 500 mountains - encompassing about a million acres - buried hundreds of valley streams under tons of rubble, poisoned and uprooted countless communities, and caused widespread contamination to the region's air and water. On this continent, only Appalachia's rich woodlands survived the Pleistocene ice ages that turned the rest of North America into a treeless tundra. King Coal is now accomplishing what the glaciers could not - obliterating the hemisphere's oldest, most biologically dense and diverse forests. Highly mechanized processes allow giant machines to flatten in months mountains older than the Himalayas - while employing fewer workers for far less time than other types of mining. The coal industry's promise to restore the desolate wastelands is a cruel joke, and the industry's fallback position, that the flattened landscapes will provide space for economic development, is the weak punchline. America adores its Adirondacks and reveres the Rockies, while the Appalachian Mountains - with their impoverished and alienated population - are dismantled by coal moguls who dominate state politics and have little to prevent them from blasting the physical landscape to smithereens.

    Obama promised science-based policies that would save what remains of Appalachia, but last month senior administration officials finally weighed in with a mixture of strong words and weak action that broke hearts across the region. The modest measures federal bureaucrats promised amount to little more than a tepid pledge of better enforcement of existing laws.

    And government claims of doing everything possible to halt the holocaust are simply not true. George Bush gutted Clean Water Act protections. Obama must restore them.

    First, the White House should fix the "fill" rule the Bush administration adopted in 2002 to allow coal companies to use streams as waste dumps. Under this perverse interpretation of the Clean Water Act, 2,000 miles of Appalachian streams have been interred under mining waste. Obama could reverse the "fill" rule to reflect its original meaning, which forbids waste matter from being dumped into waterways.

    Second, the Interior Department should strictly enforce the widely ignored "buffer zone" rule that forbids dumping waste within 100 feet of intermittent or perennial streams.

    Third, our laws require companies to restore mined areas to their original condition. The administration should end the absurd fiction that extraction pits filled with unconsolidated rocks and rubble where trees will never grow and streams will never flow are "reclaimed."

    Fourth, current law forbids the issuance of "fill" permits that will cause "significant degradation" to waterways. It is absurd for the Army Corps of Engineers to endorse the canard that filling miles of streams is not causing significant degradation. The president should require the Corps to deny and rescind permits where operations will cause downstream damage.

    Fifth, the Clean Water Act requires mining operators to prove that they can restore the "function and structure" of affected streams. Operators have never been compelled to make the functional or structural analyses of the aquatic ecosystem required by the act. Obama should order his officials to stop ignoring this requirement.

    Sixth, the administration should enforce the law requiring an environmental impact study for each permit when a mine "may have significant environmental impacts," individually or cumulatively. The Corps of Engineers routinely allows coal operators to escape this mandate - an illegal practice that should stop.

    Instead of acting to enforce these laws, administration officials indicated last month that they will allow more than 100 permits to go forward while they carefully review their regulatory options. If they act accordingly, the ruined landscapes of Appalachia will be Obama's legacy.

    President Obama should go to Appalachia and see mountaintop removal. My father visited Appalachia in 1966 and was so horrified by strip mining - then in its infancy - that he made it a key priority of his political agenda. He complained that Appalachia, with our nation's richest natural resources, was home to America's poorest populations, its worst education system, and its highest illiteracy and unemployment rates. These statistics are even grimmer today as mining saps state wealth. In 1966, 46,000 West Virginia miners were collecting salaries and pensions and reinvesting in their communities. Mechanization has shrunk that number to fewer than 11,000. They extract more coal annually, but virtually all the profits leave the state for Wall Street.

    The coal industry provides only 2 percent of the jobs in Central Appalachia. Wal-Mart employs more people than the coal companies in West Virginia. Last week a major study documented how coal imposes a net cost to Kentucky of more than $100 million per year. Coal is not an economic engine in the coalfields. It is an extraction engine.

    Obama has the authority to end mountaintop removal, without further action from Congress and without formal rulemaking. He just needs to make the coal barons obey the law.

    --------

    The writer is senior attorney for the Natural Resources Defense Council.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Thank You Bobby

Thank You Bobby Kennedy. People, Bobby Kennedy Jr. should be president instead of Obama or any other politician, with Kucinich as VP. If that was who we had in the White House, we wouldn't be seeing a Democratic president who has escalated wars, betrayed Appalachia, preserved CIA torture and torture sites, given billions to his banker contributors, and caved in on single payer. What Obama has done with Appalachian mountaintop destruction is the same as he has done with every other major issue. He has sold out. He is an articulate, better-looking, bought and sold elite who does what the corporate monsters tell him to. Bobby Kennedy Jr. on the other hand saved the Hudson River, risks his life to be in the public eye defying the Kennedy curse, and has trained a generation of tough environmental lawyers at Pace Law School. All of you who support Obama and the Democratic Party, get a clue, get a conscience. Until you back and elect only people like Bobby, Dennis Kucinich and Ralph Nader, you are only Liberal supporters of capitalism's death march on the earth!!

I'm so sorry, but as long as

I'm so sorry, but as long as congress and the president are for sale to the highest bidder the highest bidder will always be industry. Dumping waste into the backyards of the poor has become an American tradition by now and will not be corrected while money buys policies, as it most clearly does. The answer would be to get the money out of politics so that politicians had to manage instead of whore. Massive "campaign contributions" from corporations are clearly bribes, or they would be illegal. They would be illegal because they would violate the fiduciary responsibilities of "contributing" corporations by spending stockholder money "charitably," were they not clearly purchasing services. But this system is now so entrenched that it will take a revolution to overcome it. A revolution no doubt brought about by the complete collapse of our country from being systematically looted. Looted by our corporations and their coin-operated politicians.

I do apologize to readers here for my use of the term "whore" in conjunction with "politicians." But I am at a loss for a more descriptive term. Clearly, though, those persons selling sexual services that accrue the same title are far better and more honorable people than our politicians. Whores sell sex in a generally honest, if thoroughly demeaning, transaction. Our politicians sell betrayal for their money. A far worse practice from a moral standpoint, and a far more damaging practice from a societal standpoint. What words are there to adequately describe these despicable people?

Bobby is right. Obama is in

Bobby is right. Obama is in several binds. Unfortunately, he is following the status quo. If. on the other hand, there is no coal then the U.S. will either import more oil or go nuclear. Think again if you believe alternatives will take up the slack. China is expending 785 mega watts per day for the last three weeks in the Beijing region alone! Guess how? COAL!

Odd how the Obama

Odd how the Obama administration seeks to avoid enforcing the existing law against mountaintop coal removal companies, but still finds time to vigorously enforce laws he claims not to approve of (DOMA and DADT). Hope? Not anymore. The Audacity of Hypocrisy is more like it.

Here! Here! President Obama

Here! Here! President Obama is a fine fellow, but he does not have the benefit of an Al Gore as Vice President (much as I do esteem Mr. Biden) to put conservation and ecological pressure on these issues. Thus, it behooves the citizenry to do so. An excellent article, and I intend to make calls and send emails to the White House and my representatives on this subject. That's the least one can do, and frankly, the least is what I usually do!

Truth spoken by men of

Truth spoken by men of integrity is compelling and Mr. Kennedy's peerless presentation of facts is compelling and very disturbing. Why doesn't President Obama act in this matter? America the once beautiful and endlessly destructive!

It's not only the mining of

It's not only the mining of coal that is the tragedy. Coal produces the emissions that reign mercury down on the earth. Scientists have now let us know that the sea plants absorb the mercury and then the small fish eat the mercury laden plants and then the bigger fish eat those fish and finally we eat the fish with the mercury. Mercury is the most toxic substance known to man other that plutonium. It is now in our food and water supplies. Get it!!!! Burning of coal must stop.

Please see the new

Please see the new documentary "Coal County" by Akron, Ohio filmmaker Mari-Lynn Evans. It will come on in the next few weeks and be aired in November on PBS, like her last one, "The Appalachians" was. Likewise an Akron native, I along with my friends in PDA are working to organize a hometown premier at the historic Akron Civic Theater on Sept 12th. We of PDA will be organizing house parties around this superb documentary and will be looking for people to raise awareness as to the criminal devastation that is taking place daily in the poorest region of our nation. Of course, because it is the poorest region is the reason they are getting away with this. Can you imagine this going on in the Berkshires or in Maine's Acadia region? This is an issue that hits one in a visceral way, and one that clearly demonstrates the battle for who will rule our nation--the people or the corporations. We taken a lot of hits on the chin, but from this low point, engaged in issues like this, we can turn our nation around and put people at the control of how we shape our world and our democracy. Join our Global Warming and Environmental Issue Organizing Team now.

Very good article about a

Very good article about a terrible issue. Be sure and check out this new interview with Aviva Chomsky titled 'Appalachia and Colombia: The People Behind the Coal': http://upsidedownworld.org/main/content/view/1908/1/

Obama is actually a DINO

Obama is actually a DINO (Democrat In Name Only) He is actually a Republican and is Bush's 3rd term. Obama's actions speak so much louder than his hollow words. I'm glad I followed my instincts and did not vote for him--the first time in 32 yrs I didn't vote for the Democratic candidate. The millions of people who drank his kool-aid and didn't take the time to dig deep into his record, or lack thereof, you're getting what you voted for.

Please call it what it is,

Please call it what it is, Environmental Rape.

Absolutely! Have the Dems

Absolutely! Have the Dems done it again? Why does it appear as though Obama is dragging his feet? I know this is rocket science indeed but we need industry in this area fast! My ConEd bill is $200 a month in the summer and why even take a chance for the Republicans to walk us down their "See I told you so" road?? Why aren't the green energy jobs coming and where is the needed competition to monopolys like ConEd and Time Warner and the list goes on and on...

Following on words from

Following on words from Travis Smiley there is a lot of good in Obama but we have to watch him. I am so glad to see Bobby's words as this slashing off the tops of the land is wrong, wrong, wrong and wrong. President you must stop this hell on earth madness now, today, not tomorrow.

I must *echo* the comments

I must *echo* the comments that came before me."President Obama is a fine fellow, but he does not have the benefit of Al Gore as Vice President (yes, I, too feel Vice President Biden is a gentleman I so admire) If I maybe so bold to state...He is no "RFK & indeed he is not Robert Kennedy,Jr." I can only urge you to continue to speak out...Like the late Molly Ivins, stated in her last column, "WE ARE THE DECIDERS." We must help you in this critical issue to use our voice...I am here to use my voice & the desire to help in anyway.The issues you so rightly raise-are quite scary. And sadly so true. Great article!! Respectfully, Maureen Sullivan Stemberg Boston,MA.

Energy plan? 1-eliminate

Energy plan? 1-eliminate all coal power plants within the next 10 years. (Yes I know that’s more than 50 percent of our power) 2-mass market the all electric car (see ev-1) and mandate it’s intercity use within the next 10- 15 years. 3-mandate all green electric use for residential homes within next 25 years. (Residential homes will be taken off the grid at that point) 4-build one half as many high quality nuclear power plants to replace coal plants immediately to supply transportation, industrial, garage, small and large business only..... with the un-disputable mandate that all nuclear be eliminated by the end of the century and no new plants after 2060. Residential to be supplied from power plants only for the next 20- 25 years. This is an achievable plan that gives us @ 90 years of stability and green momentum/ improvement while we search for new energy solutions and come up with long term answers through research and honest debate of the facts. It is also a hugh step toward a green solution and acknowledges the failure of the coal and other highly polluting industries to the people and to the environment. In the meanwhile, those steps would put many many people to work, supply us with the energy we use today through the end of the century, and drastically reduces our dependence on oil (which eases many related problems). Your thoughts? I know... I don’t like the Nuclear part either, but we have no choice. And we can pull it off safely if we give safety priority over profits.

It's not as if we are

It's not as if we are running out of energy, and we NEED to get coal this way. This is pure greed on the part of the enrgy moguls who seem to have Jay Rockefeller in their pocket. Why he hasn't stepped in to stop this destructive process is a question only he can answer.

I guess it's all about coal

I guess it's all about coal and there ain't going to be a green revolution. We will all fry together as the Earth heats up. Mining uranium is just as bad as the companies only use one per cent of the ore and 99 per cent is left on the earth as radioactive waste blowing in the wind, all over America's Southwest. I emailed to to Obama.

And BTW ‘billyDoc’, you

And BTW ‘billyDoc’, you are ‘right on’. We will fix nothing in this country until we stop lobbying (bribery). And Obama could fix that with a stroke of his pen, the same way Bush rammed through many things. Does he want real change or not? That is the most obvious and practical start, an executive order making exchange of funds or favors for political or legislative influence, illegal. He could easily pull it off if his heart was in it. We will see who he really is soon. I’m still hoping he’s a good man, but have seen very little 'change' so far.

Can't help but agree with

Can't help but agree with David Parentia. I touted Kucinic as long as he was running, but voted for Obama. He's been a disappointment. Reading this piece on mountaintop coal mining puts a pain in my stomach. When will we ever learn?

Actually we do have an old

Actually we do have an old tried and true method of dealing with lobbyists. Tar and feathers and an old rusty rail. Why criticize the big 0 when it's always the damned lobbyists? He's just they're mouthpiece selling us whatever bill of goods load they're pockets. I have a great plan to reduce energy. Use less. Dump the useless IT toys and the power monger SUV's. Most people who own them can't drive worth a crap anyway. Get back to nature where our faithless rears belong in the first place. I for one do not feel holy when I turn on a light switch. I feel like a prisoner when I can't go out to pick berries and apples. And you gun toters should all go down to Peru and help the indians against these people who rape land.

I've grown too cynical for

I've grown too cynical for my own good. I just don't believe that one man, one president canNOT move mountains anymore. It is the people that have to give him the power to make the bold decisions RFK Jr wants him to make. President Obama is being confronted with so many problems that I fear he can't help but to not pay attention to some of the problems. This is an important issue, and I'm all on board, but how do we make these powerful coal companies, who were given free reign during the horrible Bush years, and turn them around and to stop them. What I'm hoping is that President Obama continues to support alternative energy to make these coal companies irrelevant. Mountain top removal is a sin and a raping of nature for the profit of a few corporatists. Thank you RFK Jr. for your involvement in this issue.

Only when the last tree is

Only when the last tree is cut down, the last river filled in, the last field paved over, will we realize that we can't eat money.

Dear people of America, you

Dear people of America, you used unprecedented energy and enthusiasm and 'people power' to get Obama elected. Can you not keep up the same level of pressure ---on him as President, but even more crucially on your elected representatives, especially the many wobbly Democrats--- to help him achieve the goals he set out? He has inherited a most dreadful set of problems, and needs all our support for decisive change. He has set out on a path of attempted consensus that I think is proving to be a bad mistake, in Afghanistan as well as in Appalachia and over other issues, and has to be reminded of his prime duty towards his voters, change in favour of ordinary people worldwide. If we/you let him fail, the next President could be someone like Cheney, a dread prospect for the world.

As Philip said "Energy plan?

As Philip said "Energy plan? 1-eliminate all coal power plants within the next 10 years. " The tragedy is that last thing we need is more coal! A swinging carbon tax is the answer (or tight cap with auctioned permits) all revenue returned to consumers equally per capita. Then Appalachia can be left in peace.

"Obama has the authority to

"Obama has the authority to end mountaintop removal, without further action from Congress and without formal rulemaking. He just needs to make the coal barons obey the law." Geez, Bobby -- I got some bad news for ya. Obomba IS the coal barons. He is owned and operated by coal, oil, banks and defense. Think of him as a robot programmed by elite psychopaths. They speak and act through him. Who he really is as a person is not at all important.

Thanks Bobby we should get

Thanks Bobby we should get the word out. I too am crushed by Obama's latest betrayal. The coal issue begins and ends with WATER With huge destruction of land, air and people's lives in the middle. As a wonderful Appalachian fighter reminded a group of people (make that present tense)that the little creeks and valleys at the bottom of these destroyed mountains constitute the head waters of the Ohio River which provides a very large amount of drinking water for the entire east coast of the U.S. Just as the coal that is mined in Wyoming, Montana, Illinois, everywhere else is conjoined with water. In Wyoming and Montana the whole region is called "The Powder River Basin". There are several Rivers in that region--the Tongue, the Big Horn (think Custer) the Yellowstone all of which eventually flow into the Missouri and on to the middle west. whole water sheds are at great risk. There is not one tiny ounce of coal that is as important as water. So if you are saying to yourself "those poor people! that destruction should not be allowed but what can I do? I wish them all well and a good fight..." remember your air and water are at stake. The struggle belongs to all of us.

There will be no stopping

There will be no stopping the MTR coal-train until it can be demonstrated that there exists a renewable and ECONOMIC substitute for the electricity that is produced by this resource. Any plan to "go green" by substituting EVs, etc., will require that MORE electricity be produced, not less. The worst thing that could be done would be to allow the nuclear cartel to work it's "wonders" on the situation. By allowing this, we would not only enslave ourselves to much higher electricity costs, but encourage other unstable nations to view the nuclear pathway as the "logical alternative" to fossil fuels. On the other hand, other types of renewables , such as wind and solar, currently being hyped, cannot penetrate the market fast enough to stop the "coal train" any time soon, due to their high initial costs and availability problems. An energy source has already been identified which can provide enough power to supply all of mankind's needs, and a means to harvest it has been proposed. http://vortexengine.ca The Atmospheric Vortex Engine is the "Plan B" which is needed to supply us with the energy we need without destroying nature or polluting the atmosphere. Bobby--take heed, and please do what you can to encourage the development of this inexpensive, and badly needed clean energy resource. It does not involve "rocket science", and can therefore employ existing components. It is the most direct and effective means we could have at our disposal to stop MTR dead in its tracks. All that is needed is more support.

We wouldn't have the

We wouldn't have the enviroonmental problems , endless wars, health care problems if we had Kucinich and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. in the White House. Dennis is a co-signer of H.R. 676; and Kennedy is an outstanding environmentalist. Obama is definitely a disappointment - pushing insurance company health care and a supporter of the death penalty.

I wonder if BIG COAL is

I wonder if BIG COAL is lobbying the White House and that's why they don't want us to see the visitors log. It all makes me so sad.

rfk jr is a wonderful

rfk jr is a wonderful fighter for progressive causes. but for the most part, his voice is largely excluded from the mainstream media. and his views are largely excluded from the democratic controlled congress. ironic, is it not? here we are, with a progressive president, a demcratic controlled congress, and most everything seems to be essentially the same when it comes to the gap between rhetoric and policy. obama is either going to get worse over time, or get better. but he cannot continue his status quo embrace of corporate american oligarchic control of the political process and preserve his reputation. i fear obama is becoming a clinton style presidency. his bailing out on the public insurance option for health care, together with his embrace of bush's foreign policy essentials, from torture and "extraordinary rendition" to occupying iraq and afghanistan and expanding deeper into pakistan, indicate that the neoliberals and the neoconservatives are really flip sides of the same ruling class. and now we are supposed to push forward with an economic policy where 10 percent official unemployment is the "new normal." without a mass movement in the streets rejecting imperialism and corporate global wage arbitrage as de facto economic policy, this country will become another latin american pseudo democracy, where gated communities are required for middle class security, a security available only to the fortunate few.

Oh Wishful

Oh Wishful Thinkers, Tradesmen and tinkers, To Rich men and Presidents Our humanity is in shambles, Of thorn and bramble, And still You kill The lilies of the field. It causes me ponder and worry and wonder Are any of us, really alive anymore?

President Obama has made me

President Obama has made me proud many times, and I have cut him a lot of slack as a result. But as another poster put it, we have to keep in touch with our new President, and remind him that CHANGE is what we were voting for, and not his dazzling smile. Coal is the enemy of our long-term survival. Clean Coal is the energy equivalent of the Hydrogen Automobile - a red herring. Mountain-top removal is environmental terrorism. There's no way to sugar-coat these pills and no excuse for delaying action on shutting down the despoilers of our country.

Mountaintop removal is one

Mountaintop removal is one of the most hiddious things that I have ever seen. So get your inner activist on, people! Nothing, not one damn thing changes without some serious noise from us. Check what Hightower has to say on that fine subject!

newsfrombelow: "...here we

newsfrombelow: "...here we are, with a progressive president..." Who? Obama??? A progressive???? Not even... Have you accidentally fallen in the rabbit hole from an alternate universe? Obama never was, is not now, nor ever will be a: PROGRESSIVE. Dennis Kucinich is a "progressive" and that's why HE isn't president.

We have to stop our dead end

We have to stop our dead end thinking that we can only elect a democRAT or a republiCANT to the White House. Green Party, get your motor running!

Where the hell is WVa

Where the hell is WVa Senator Jay Rockefeller, erstwhile Peace Corps guy, former liberal, and one time good guy?

Mountains dissapear

Mountains dissapear overnight.