Share

Balance

by: Laurent Joffrin   |  LibĂ©ration

photo
Laurent Joffrin reports that with respect to the French government's intention to authorize Sunday commerce, the majority of French citizens, "object to a one-dimensional society dedicated solely to consumption, in which ultimately commerce alone gives meaning to existence. They prefer to husband a little beach of time collectively chosen and free of monetary relations for the majority of citizens." (Artwork: Georges Seurat / The Art Institute of Chicago)

    A little lesson on capitalism. A number of consumers want to consume on Sunday; a number of workers agree or would agree to work that day: the freedom of economic agents leads to authorizing work on Sunday. Such is - beyond all the rhetoric about "the end of hypocrisy" or the "necessities of tourism" - the essence of the government's argument. Question: in a balanced society, must the freedom of economic agents overcome every other consideration? Those who have not learned the specific lesson of the economic crisis we are currently going through will answer in the affirmative. Others will demur. The market is not always right. When it is legitimate, the power of the government is based on seeing to it that collective values prevail. The majority of French citizens - our poll shows - do not want commercial activities to pervade the totality of life. They object to a one-dimensional society dedicated solely to consumption, in which ultimately commerce alone gives meaning to existence. They prefer to husband a little beach of time collectively chosen and free of monetary relations for the majority of citizens. Boutiques, department stores and supermarkets are not modern churches where one should have to ceaselessly sacrifice to the god of commerce. Once a week, we may suspend the cult of consumption and do something else. Focus on one's individual development, one's family, one's passions or whatever one desires. On life, that is ...

    --------

    Translation: Truthout French language editor Leslie Thatcher.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

The author claims that

The author claims that because the majority would prefer not to shop on Sunday, no one may be allowed to do so. Of course, those who prefer not to shop may simply refrain from doing so, - so that's not the real issue. They want to impose their religious preferences on the rest of society, who may not share them. The French government is right in opposing this form of religious imposition, regardless of the phony secular garb it's cloaked in

One family owned all of the

One family owned all of the Earth. The matriarch of the family said that the others were free to produce, trade and consume as they might, but with one stipulation: they would have to pay an "economic rent" for access to the natural resources and physical space that were the "private property" of the family. "Our economy is free market," she declared. And the people went along with that. When they all ended up enslaved to the one family, paying practically all their collective productive value in "rent", the people started to complain that the "free market system" didn't work. But they never saw that it was the privatized monopoly of mother earth that was the problem, not that the market was "free".

The author must be kidding!

The author must be kidding! Well, the Jewish faith does not do business on a Saturday. I do not do business on Wednesday. Happy Wednesday Everyone.

Lighten up! This is a good

Lighten up! This is a good message. The French have rightly chosen not to worship Mammon, and so what? YOU do your thing and they'll do theirs. Diversity (even of opinion) is the spice of life ...

The polls, the polls....I

The polls, the polls....I have one saying that 55% of the French wouldn't mind being able to shop on Sunday. And another saying that roughly the same number would NOT want to work on Sunday...The Unions are against working on sunday as is the Catholic Church...convergence in the only openly laic country around (I mean with REAL seperation of church and state written in the constituent laws). The one point to remember for the U.S. is that working on sunday over here is not like in the States : no overtime or time and a half, just another regular day at the bean counter. But any street poll would tell you a different story : if paid overtime a majority of the French would WANT to work on sunday. Remember Sarkosy got elected with the slogan :"more work for more pay".