Share

Conservative Democrats Break Ranks on Health Care

by: Erica Werner  |  The Associated Press

photo
Majority Leader Steny Hoyer with members of the Congressional Blue Dog Coalition. The Blue Dog Democrats released a list of demands that could delay legislation that was expected to be unvailed today in the House. (Photo: Getty Images)

    Washington - President Barack Obama on Friday acknowledged the tough going for his health care overhaul in Congress but rejected the notion the legislation is doomed if lawmakers fail to act by August. "I never believe anything is do or die," Obama said.

    "We're closer to that significant reform than at any time in recent history," Obama told reporters at a news conference in Italy. "That doesn't make it easy. It's hard. And we are having a whole series of constant negotiations."

    Conservative Democrats are demanding significant changes before they will support a sweeping health care overhaul, forcing the House to join the Senate in stalling Obama's top domestic priority.

    The "Blue Dog Democrats" group released a list of demands on the eve of House Democratic leaders' planned unveiling of their final bill Friday. The bill release was pushed back to next week and Democratic leaders spent part of Friday meeting with the fiscally conservative Blue Dogs to work through their concerns.

    "The message that was sent was heard loud and clear," Rep. Jason Altmire, D-Pa., a member of the group, said Friday. The group's concerns were the need for more cost containment measures, protections for small businesses and a focus on rural health care.

    "We cannot support a final product that fails to" address these issues, members of the group wrote to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Majority Leader Steny Hoyer. Opposition from the 52-member group could imperil House passage of a bill.

    Before Thursday, delays and internal Democratic disputes over taxes and the role of government had seemed mostly confined to the Senate. A bipartisan deal emerging in the Senate Finance Committee was threatened this week when Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., and other top Democrats indicated displeasure with the likely payment method, a new tax on health care benefits.

    That has left Finance Committee members scrambling for alternative taxes to replace the $320 billion the benefits tax would have raised over a decade. Democrats are considering raising taxes on wealthy investors instead, along with other options, according to officials who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss private negotiations. The proposal to extend the current 1.45 percent Medicare payroll tax to capital gains earned by high-income taxpayers would bring in an estimated $100 billion over 10 years.

    In the House, Democratic leaders had hoped to release an ambitious bill Friday that would achieve Obama's goals of holding down health care costs and extending insurance to the 50 million people who lack it. Insurers would have to cover all comers, employers would be required to offer insurance and individuals would be required to purchase it, with subsidies for the poor. The tax-writing Ways and Means Committee met throughout the day Thursday to try to finalize plans on how to pay for the plan, with an income surcharge on high-earners of some 3 percent or more emerging as the leading option.

    But the move by the Blue Dogs scrambled the equation. It was unclear whether Democratic leaders would be able to satisfy the group's demands since in some cases they're far apart from draft language produced by the three House committees writing health legislation.

    Also unclear was whether the setbacks would amount to anything more than a brief delay for a bill of enormous complexity and controversy.

    Hoyer sought to minimize the day's developments.

    "Let me make it very clear that everybody in that room thinks we ought to pass health care reform," the Maryland Democrat said after he and Pelosi met for more than two hours Thursday evening with Blue Dog members.

    But Hoyer said, "There's still some additional work that needs to be done."

    One conservative Democrat, Rep. Mike Ross, D-Ark., said he believes no House vote should take place until September.

    That is well past a midsummer informal deadline set by Pelosi, D-Calif.

    "I promised the president that we would have legislation out of the House before we went on an August break," she said earlier in the day. "That is still my goal."

    Among the Blue Dogs' concerns is the shape of a new public insurance plan that would compete with private insurers. House leaders envision making payment rates to providers in the plan some 5 percent higher than Medicare payment rates. Blue Dogs say they can't support any link to Medicare rates, which they say pays well below market rates and varies unfairly around the country.

    That puts House leaders in a tough spot since many liberal Democrats are insistent that a new public plan be linked to Medicare.

    --------

    Associated Press writers David Espo and Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar contributed to this report.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

The health insurance

The health insurance industry has bought our congress and we will never see affordable, nondiscriminatory, one payer health insurance. The poor and even the middle class will never have adequate health coverage. This country only gives socialism to the very wealthy. America only wants to subsidize the war profiteer industry to the tune of trillions of dollars, and poor sick people can go to hell.

If Congress only passes a

If Congress only passes a mandate to purchase health insurance from for-profit companies, that will be no reform at all. It would be, in essence, a government-sanctioned monopoly. Obama must promise to veto any bill without a strong public option.

The article mention that "

The article mention that " Among the Blue Dogs' concerns is the shape of a new public insurance plan that would compete with private insurers."Is there any surprise here? They are "honorables" doing their job. They have very clear to whom they accountable to and to whom they worship: God$$$.

i.e., Republican operatives

i.e., Republican operatives masquerading as Democrats.

What do you expect? The

What do you expect? The "make-nice" sham policies of Obama are nothing but a cover for the worst of Bushism and Clintonism. If you are a progressive , speak up, act up, oppose each and every "Democrat" who indulges fascist policies. This means opposing Baucus and similar immoderates! Let Obama know that from this day forward he will have ZERO support from progressives!

Well people, anyone have

Well people, anyone have ideas about who progressives should support in 2012? It cannot be McObush! Get cracking, start the campaign now, go to the bosom of every hollow in America, this is it, are we gonna get democracy back , or is it blade-runner-land for ever?

Even though I'd love to see

Even though I'd love to see universal healthcare in my lifetime, what's with the deadline? Sounds too "hurry up" to me. They need to get it right. . .and keep insurance companies out of the picture. Because if insurance corporations continue to have their say, people such as my aunt in a death mill, (sorry, "convalescent hospital") will continue to slowly have the noose tighten on their "healthcare" services because it is "not profitable"to their shareholders.