Share

Report: Bush Surveillance Program Was Massive

by: Pamela Hess  |  The Associated Press

photo
(Photo: AP)

    Washington - The Bush administration built an unprecedented surveillance operation to pull in mountains of information far beyond the warrantless wiretapping previously acknowledged, a team of federal inspectors general reported Friday, questioning the legal basis for the effort but shielding almost all details on grounds they're still too secret to reveal.

    The report, compiled by five inspectors general, refers to "unprecedented collection activities" by U.S. intelligence agencies under an executive order signed by President George W. Bush after the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks.

    Just what those activities involved remains classified, but the IGs pointedly say that any continued use of the secret programs must be "carefully monitored."

    The report says too few relevant officials knew of the size and depth of the program, let alone signed off on it. They particularly criticize John Yoo, a deputy assistant attorney general who wrote legal memos undergirding the policy. His boss, Attorney General John Ashcroft, was not aware until March 2004 of the exact nature of the intelligence operations beyond wiretapping that he had been approving for the previous two and a half years, the report says.

    Most of the intelligence leads generated under what was known as the "President's Surveillance Program" did not have any connection to terrorism, the report said. But FBI agents told the authors that the "mere possibility of the leads producing useful information made investigating the leads worthwhile."

    The inspectors general interviewed more than 200 people inside and outside the government, but five former Bush administration officials refused to be questioned. They were Ashcroft, Yoo, former CIA Director George Tenet, former White House Chief of Staff Andrew Card and David Addington, an aide to former Vice President Dick Cheney.

    According to the report, Addington could personally decide who in the administration was "read into" β€” allowed access to β€” the classified program.

    The only piece of the intelligence-gathering operation acknowledged by the Bush White House was the wiretapping-without-warrants effort. The administration admitted in 2005 that it had allowed the National Security Agency to intercept international communications that passed through U.S. cables without seeking court orders.

    Although the report documents Bush administration policies, its fallout could be a problem for the Obama administration if it inherited any or all of the still-classified operations.

    Bush brought the warrantless wiretapping program under the authority of a secret court in 2006, and Congress authorized most of the intercepts in a 2008 electronic surveillance law. The fate of the remaining and still classified aspects of the wider surveillance program is not clear from the report.

    The report's revelations came the same day that House Democrats said that CIA Director Leon Panetta had ordered one eight-year-old classified program shut down after learning lawmakers had never been apprised of its existence.

    The IG report said that President Bush signed off on both the warrantless wiretapping and other top-secret operations shortly after Sept. 11 in a single presidential authorization. All the programs were periodically reauthorized, but except for the acknowledged wiretapping, they "remain highly classified."

    The report says it's unclear how much valuable intelligence the program has yielded.

    The report, mandated by Congress last year, was delivered to lawmakers Friday.

    Rep. Jane Harman, D-Calif., told The Associated Press she was shocked to learn of the existence of other classified programs beyond the warrantless wiretapping.

    Former Bush Attorney General Alberto Gonzales made a terse reference to other classified programs in an August 2007 letter to Congress. But Harman said that when she had asked Gonzales two years earlier if the government was conducting any other undisclosed intelligence activities, he denied it.

    "He looked me in the eye and said 'no,'" she said Friday.

    Robert Bork Jr., Gonzales' spokesman, said, "It has clearly been determined that he did not intend to mislead anyone."

    In the wake of the new report, Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt, renewed his call Friday for a formal nonpartisan inquiry into the government's information-gathering programs.

    Former CIA Director Michael Hayden β€” the primary architect of the program_ told the report's authors that the surveillance was "extremely valuable" in preventing further al-Qaida attacks. Hayden said the operations amounted to an "early warning system" allowing top officials to make critical judgments and carefully allocate national security resources to counter threats.

    Information gathered by the secret program played a limited role in the FBI's overall counterterrorism efforts, according to the report. Very few CIA analysts even knew about the program and therefore were unable to fully exploit it in their counterrorism work, the report said.

    The report questioned the legal advice used by Bush to set up the program, pinpointing omissions and questionable legal memos written by Yoo, in the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel. The Justice Department withdrew the memos years ago.

    The report says Yoo's analysis approving the program ignored a law designed to restrict the government's authority to conduct electronic surveillance during wartime, and did so without fully notifying Congress. And it said flaws in Yoo's memos later presented "a serious impediment" to recertifying the program.

    Yoo insisted that the president's wiretapping program had only to comply with Fourth Amendment protections against search and seizure β€” but the report said Yoo ignored the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which had previously overseen federal national security surveillance.

    "The notion that basically one person at the Justice Department, John Yoo, and Hayden and the vice president's office were running a program around the laws that Congress passed, including a reinterpretation of the Fourth Amendment, is mind boggling," Harman said.

    House Democrats are pressing for legislation that would expand congressional access to secret intelligence briefings, but the White House has threatened to veto it.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

And I would bet it will

And I would bet it will continually be built upon.

I want and NEED to know just

I want and NEED to know just WHAT kind of surveillance was authorized that everyone is yapping about but NO ONE but NO ONE will tell the American public who pays these jokers' salaries just what in hell they are doing? What are the other invasions of privacy that Bush the Idiot and others around him sanctioned?

Every day brings the

Every day brings the revelation of MORE lies! And, every day reveals a greater and greater intrusion into and, disregard for, our basic freedoms! And, still NOTHING is done about it! . . .In fact, the Obamas have yet to even acknowledge, let alone do, anything about it! And, are, in fact, CONTINUING the "business as usual" surveillance undertaken by the Bushies! Bush and Cronies should be in jail! And, if the Obamas continue in the same vein, they should join them!

This was "free for all"

This was "free for all" spying. They spied on Bill Clinton and who knows how many million of us.

Footnote to my earlier note:

Footnote to my earlier note: The Bushies argued that FISA was "insufficient" for what they believed was necessary. . .Yet, they brought not a single case before the FISA court; nor did they even request authorization under FISA to undertake what they deemed necessary! The question then becomes "How do you if it won't work. . .IF YOU NEVER TRIED IT??!!"

These great patriots worked

These great patriots worked overtime to protect this country from its subversive Constitution.

Really, what's the point of

Really, what's the point of still discussing this? Obviously, many crimes were committed. Nobody in power seems to ever listen to us. This is why we need mandatory public financing. The Washington cowardice is deafening. What purpose do articles like this serve? Are they just to remind the citizens of this country how little say we still have? Maybe (I'm being unduly optimistic here), it’s a way to drum up a critical mass of support so cowardly politicians feel safe allowing justice to move forward. MAYBE! Otherwise, I'm at a loss why we keep hearing exhibits X, Y, and Z in a criminal case that's never going to happen. If they want public anger, can it compete with unfair unbalanced propaganda spewing from the right specifically to put a wrench in the works of our democracy through a concerted disinformation campaign? The only times I've seen people REALLY get involved enough in an issue have been when congress put a cap on cable profits in the 90s and when they discussed switching all TV to digital. What do these things have in common? Something tells me that if bush jr. caused a potato chip price hike people would take notice and he'd be in jail. It's like going after the mob by catching a kingpin on tax evasion. We have to catch him on some minor detail to make him pay for major crimes he committed that the general public doesn't care about. Most people don't realize the Iran/Contra scandal wasn’t just about Iran and the Contras. Meanwhile, the pentagon has admitted hiring numbskulls who act as web trolls spouting misinformation on high traffic websites like YouTube, etc. Oh well, more incriminating evidence. Maybe history will be less forgiving of these criminals - unless they continue controlling the textbooks.

So when do the prosecutions

So when do the prosecutions begin? It'll be a cold day in hell, for a country that pretty well meets Mussolini's definition of Fascism.Here's to open government and all that crap

"According to the report,

"According to the report, Addington could personally decide who in the administration was "read into" β€” allowed access to β€” the classified program. " Now, if this doesn't confirm exactly WHO was running this country, I don't know what would! Bush authorized whatever he was told to, or "conned" into. We had a president for eight long years who was an "empty headed puppet," donated by his royal family for allowing corporate fascists to run our government. Call it crazy if you will. I doubt it. I think it may be the closest thing to reality that you have read. Do we now have control back in the legislature and White House? Doesn't yet seem so, does it? HOWEVER a HUGE public mandate for the "change" demanded by electing Obama might actually help in that effort. We are STILL being ruled and stolen from by the corporate fascists, and nothing could better illustrate that than the second DISASTER of the Bush administration, yet to be addressed FOR We the People.

I simply have nothing new to

I simply have nothing new to say - except - how about a public investigation broadcast on CSPAN live? I'd love to see a few jail sentences.

EXTORTION. Citizens will

EXTORTION. Citizens will scarcely be able to conceive the uses to which this information will be put. Referencing Poindexter's "Total Information Awareness" program would be relevant. It is not for military intelligence only. It is, of course, political intelligence. This, in a word, is extortion. What we have unseen here is the largest extortion racket in history! Without prosecutions, I fear this is the end of democracy in the United States. Where are the true patriots who understand the value of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights? One thing is certain. Unchecked power serves tyranny. The people who have this power are unlikely to give it up. Sooner or later they will use it in the worst ways against US. There has never been a greater need for citizens activism to insist upon government transparency, a broad interpretation of Citizens Rights extended to electronic media, and Rule of Law.

The last sentence of this

The last sentence of this article is perhaps the most troubling of all.

Very early in the Bush

Very early in the Bush administration, Darth Cheney & his crew of thugs were ginning up justification for these surveillance tactics when Al Qaeda gave them a shortcut they could scarcely have hoped for by destroying the WTC on 9/11. No wonder W sat there stunned when he was informed of the attack; he simply couldn't believe his good luck. This was a golden opportunity to do exactly what he had been planning. Anyone who takes the time to look at Bush's pre-9/11 agenda will see that the biggest plans he had revolved around "reducing violent crime in America". In fact, violent crime statistics were sinking historically at the time. I have no doubt that, absent the terrorist threat, Bush/Cheney would have pressed ahead with their illegal wiretapping of Americans in order to create the Nazi-clone police state they had been wet-dreaming about from Day One.

And Obama will complete

And Obama will complete Bush's work, all the while claiming he is dismantling it, while actually refining and amplifying its scope.It may yet come to pass that Bush's unashamed directness, his very unapologetic barbarity, will come to be seen as preferable to Obama's disgusting hypocrisy. Obama is proving that running America like a 'hall of mirrors,' where nothing appears as it seems, is precisely what America wants.Orwell has many avatars, and Obama is the current heir incarnate of simply a differing variant of American corporate totalitarianism. –(Jill Bains)

DUH...Marc I wrote in 2004

DUH...Marc I wrote in 2004 telling you how they data mined my computer destroying records that were vital to medical malpractice against HCA FRISTCO & how my efforts to recover them hospitalized me for a week nearly causing amputation of a leg all for me being on Code Pink`s email list having expressed condolences to Cindy Sheehan for her son Casey`s murder at the hands of CARLYLE GROUP aka BUSHCO INC!

Massive, useless, and more

Massive, useless, and more than that, a setback for the country. Of course. These people didn't believe that government is effective, which they strove to demonstrate at every chance. At the same time they wanted to offend. Spoiled brats to the core.

THERE IS NO RULE OF LAW in

THERE IS NO RULE OF LAW in this Country. That is what must be repeated over and over until there are investigations. When the 'ruling class' can break the law and not be held to the same laws as everyone else then We DO NOT have a Democracy.

I remember; in Stalin's,

I remember; in Stalin's, day some apartment houses were build with clear plastic piping in the bathroom and kitchen drains so your downstairs neighbors could see if you flushed anti government papers . The resemblance between the Cheney administration and those of Hitler and Stalin become more apparent every day. This latest disclosure will not have any permanent effect on public policy. There will be no incentive for those in government to stop this buildup of a totalitarian, secret police state until the American people and their dimwitted representatives in Washington understand that this places each of us at risk. To understand, consider this: This enormous compilation of information is accessible to a chosen few. With modern sorting methods they can choose any name, a governor or congressman and discover personal and once"private information which could be used to trigger an investigation, knowing that the intent is to find something to destroy a leader of an opposition party. At the level of you and me: In business and family matters, we use attorneys, phone and internet communications. Here is a marvelous opportunity to steal or sell business and private secrets to the highest bidder or just use them for blackmail. Americans think this surveillance is just to protect them from bad guys till they become victims of their personal and business interests in the wrong hands. If credit card information is sold in great quantities, what protection will we have against those persons who secretly have total access to all our private and business lives?

DUH...Marc I wrote in 2004

DUH...Marc I wrote in 2004 telling you how they data mined my computer destroying records that were vital to medical malpractice against HCA FRISTCO & how my efforts to recover them hospitalized me for a week nearly causing amputation of a leg all for me being on Code Pink`s email list having expressed condolences to Cindy Sheehan for her son Casey`s murder at the hands of CARLYLE GROUP aka BUSHCO INC!

It All Started @ the TOP,

It All Started @ the TOP, the Very TOP. "The Plan" & "The Players" were In Place before the bush Installation." Totally Immune to Any & All Laws, (CONstitution Included) "They" ran Roughshod over All Things non republican! "They" Buried their Tracks before they made them! When Caught in a Lie, a Felony, & acts of Treason, they Lied about Those as well. Reich in front of our eyes! The Media Aided & Abetted them! The Sheep Heads just went along for "The Ride". (& voted for More!) When the Law Makers are pushed to the side, Not Informed, & Existing laws are reinterpreted & Secretly rewritten as a "Get Out Of Jail Free Card," it's now known as "Pulling a republican!" Now, step back, admire the Carnage, & Thank the Heavens that the "Party of God" has left its indelible Mark of The Beast Upon You!

So I gather this is the very

So I gather this is the very same John Yoo who also provided the legal cover for torture? I hear he is a tenured professor at UC Berkley too! Someone should check him out to make sure he wasn't paid by the North Koreans to subvert our freedoms!

The American people have

The American people have every right to know about this program, the kind of information that was being collected and on whom, for how long and whether it's on-going. If it is, we need to have public discussion about it.

Ah yes... another Bush era

Ah yes... another Bush era program -- like torture and war -- that the empty suit Obama and his boys can build on. I throw up every morning when I see the news and realize I worked to get that SOB elected!

What a tangled web the

What a tangled web the Bushies et al have woven and still continue to weave since first they practiced to deceive and control the world. Cover-up, obfuscation, misleading & throwing people off their trail. That's what this is all about. Not only are they scared, mortified & condemned, they will be hugely embarrassed when this all comes out. Pity the stupid, arrogant, violent, criminal warmongers who are just doing the best they can. Investigate 9/11. Hold them accountable. For example, they probably didn't want to go thru Fisa because there must have been some decent, honest people at Fisa, people they couldn't control and buy off, people they had no power over.

The criminals who put these

The criminals who put these programs in play need to be held accountable, from Cheney on down. This entire program originated in Cheney's office and, by design, left other arms of government completely in the dark. Isn't it funny we don't even know what they were monitoring because it's all still a huge secret. The people who refused to be interviewed by the inspectors general need to go to jail until they agree to cooperate...and I don't mean some white collar, country club jail. Who do they think they are?!

remember last summer during

remember last summer during the '08 elections when news disclosed that obama's passport file had been breached. then to make the disclosure sound harmless the spin was that some curious fan bureaucrat at State meant no harm? I never bought it.

How terribly disillusioning

How terribly disillusioning to see hypocricy in its worst form! The "holier than thou" attitude that comes from Obama in every country he visits these days and the call for "free thinking and the system of democracy in governance" sounds so hollow when one hears about the reluctance of his administration to expose the horrendous, absolutely illegal practices of the Bush administration. Why are totalitarian states of the world condemned, why are the "values" of our country held up as something precious or unique when these revelations do not put anybody in jail? Why do "we the people" have no power at all?Looks like being able to vote is all that our democracy comes down to..So do the people in Iran! (VOTE, I mean..)

Good reporting, but did you

Good reporting, but did you have run the smirking monkey picture with the article? I thought after 8 years of it, I was done having to look at him.

We still like to believe all

We still like to believe all this illegal eavesdropping somehow protects us from the "axis of evil". The destruction of the WTC on 9/11 was probably the work of our very own "axis of evil", one of whose purposes was to set the stage for this colossal violation of our remaining Constitutional rights and freedoms. Note that WTC 7 was detonated 5 hours later, and this managed to obliterate all the files on the Enron debacle. Isn't it comforting to know today that there's a well-paid bureaucrat in a windowless building in California who knows exactly what kind of toilet paper you wipe your ass with?

Bush 43 the Terrible was

Bush 43 the Terrible was able to put the final nail on our Democracy. The nails were placed one at a time starting with the assassination of JFK, then RFK, then Nixon happened to us, then Ford Pardoned Nixon, then they undermined whatever good Carter tried to do,then Reagan's Administration put three more nails in it, then they got away scot free with Iran-Contra, then Bush 41 was able to continue what he did under Reagan, then they polluted Clinton's Presidency. President Obama has, I fear learned that he can't make too many waves and has decided to stay alive. I went through in my mind the other candidates that could have made it and concluded and I don't believe that we would be that much happier with things. Try it and you'll see that really the problem is not who is in office anymore if you come to terms that the rulers of the country and the world are not who we elect. We have in essence a Corporatist State = Fascism. Corporations, banks, the industrial military complex (war profiteers), they rule, we lose.

I share a lot of the

I share a lot of the negative feeling many posters have expressed about the problems our so called democracy suffers, but I have to say a couple of weeks ago I was standing in line waiting for service at the local cable company. Several old men (including myself) got into a discussion about what was wrong with the country. We went at it for 20 minutes or so covering just about everything, when I happened to glance around noticed the looks on the faces of some obvious immigrants (likely Latinos as this is South Florida). I almost could read what was on their minds. They were thinking I was a crazy gringo who had no idea how good this country was compared to real dictatorships where individuals had no rights at all.

This investigation and

This investigation and report is a sham - we all knew Bush was breaking the law in Jan 2005. The FISA laws were enacted to prevent a repeat of Nixon's crookery - using intel apparatus to spy on political enemies. If Karl Rove was collecting dirt on high-level politicians for eight years, it makes sense why Pelosi, Reid, Hoyer and the Democratic leadership would give all Bush era criminals safe passage. Now Rahm Emanuel holds the keys to the illegal White House surveillance program. Lo and behold all the Republican bigwigs are dropping like flies - Sanford, Palin, Ensign and others. It's the people vs. the politicians, folks. Got power?

Go To Jail. Do Not Pass Go.

Go To Jail. Do Not Pass Go.

One 4 year term for ALL

One 4 year term for ALL elected officials. NO MORE RE-ELECTIONS FOR ANYONE. Only way to get them out of there. How to pull the power back to the local levels?

Check out this link:

Check out this link: http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090711/ap_on_bi_ge/us_chipping_america_iv/print;_ylt=AsaDFX3cW9OQ29RfPjuYpZxv24cA;_ylu=X3oDMTB1MjgxN2UzBHBvcwMxNARzZWMDdG9vbHMtdG9wBHNsawNwcmludA-- Not sure why Truthout didn't cover it. It's an example of how insidious these attempts to make 1984 a reality really are. The government I.D. cards they keep telling us would solve all of our problems are just a great way to make their job even easier. I think 20 years from now people will come to regret much of what they freely published about themselves on sites like facebook, classmates and myspace. If they can get us to willingly surrender as much (seemingly harmless) info as possible it makes their job all the easier making a profile of us that WILL be used against us in ways we cannot yet imagine. I will gladly wear the "paranoid conspiracy theorist" dunce hat if anyone can give me a reason to think their recent track record proves we should suddenly start trusting them. "In God we trust" should be changed to "trust us". At least it would be more truthful. If they deserved our trust they wouldn't be hiding in the shadows trying to spy on their own citizens. I'm tired of this copycat KGB behavior. We deserve better.

OK Democrats, do you NOW see

OK Democrats, do you NOW see why IMPEACHMENT was so important???

Read Bamford "The Shadow

Read Bamford "The Shadow Factory". Its all there and more. Everything: cable, cell phone, internet, everything electronic is scooped up. Hayden, Cheney, etc. Americans just don't inform themselves.

This all attests to the

This all attests to the necessity to keep these egregious bastards away from the helm. Like as not they are waiting the chance to return and use all programs they put into place which are extant but invisible to the present administration. Only Verizon and its ilk know for sure.

Anyone can see that the real

Anyone can see that the real reason for gathering all this 'information' was in fact to help them cover up every aspect of their own unending criminal operations.

Of course this spying was on

Of course this spying was on Bush Enemies, in other words Dems and journalists, especially those who opposed the Iraq Invasion- that's why it had to be secret. I waited and waithed for this to finally explode into lethal shrapnel for the neocon vermin... but the Repub Congress gave them blanket immunity without knowing what they did. Let's undo that immediately and prosecute these criminals.

The only groups that collect

The only groups that collect more information about us and control us better than these ulcers, are the Credit Agencies.

This entire article is

This entire article is disturbing as it gives no solution to the massive crimes of the entire Bush Administration--Crimes apparently still on-going (And expanded in some cases) by Obama. The last line is indeed frightening. It is clear the WH has set itself above the law and refuses to listen to Congress. Congress refuses to listen to the people so they are above the law and accountability as well. We, as voters and citizens, must remain frustrated at our inability to control our govt and elected officials. Reagan put us on this path to self destruction but the Bushites fire bombed us all.

I agree that Bush, Cheney,

I agree that Bush, Cheney, et. al did multiple horrible things - way worse than selling the homegrown pot that some folks sit in jail for - and if this were a fair and just world, should be severely punished by law. However, given all the damage they have created and all the work necessary to remedy these ills, I agree with Obama that the smart and practical use of our energies at the moment is to dig this country out of the many holes they left us in. We can't do everything all at once, and real health care reform, reversing global warming, protecting the wild lands we have left, cleaning up our air, water & food supply, economic reforms, these things that will make life better for Americans for generations to come, are just more important than punishment. Hell, these guys have to live with themselves... there's karmic punishment for ya. Once we've put out the fires, then we can go after these guys, but given the choice... I'm for clean air & water, permanent wilderness areas, and food that won't kill us.