Share

Some Choice Words for "The Select Few"

by: Bill Moyers and Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
The green hue of money in Washington, DC. (Photo: Getty Images)

    If you want to know what really matters in Washington, don't go to Capitol Hill for one of those hearings, or pay attention to those staged White House "town meetings." They're just for show. What really happens - the serious business of Washington - happens in the shadows, out of sight, off the record. Only occasionally - and usually only because someone high up stumbles - do we get a glimpse of just how pervasive the corruption has become.

    Case in point: Katharine Weymouth, the publisher of The Washington Post - one of the most powerful people in DC - invited top officials from the White House, the Cabinet and Congress to her home for an intimate, off-the-record dinner to discuss health care reform with some of her reporters and editors covering the story.

    But CEOs and lobbyists from the health care industry were invited, too, provided they forked over $25,000 a head - or up to a quarter of a million if they want to sponsor a whole series of these cozy get-togethers. And what is the inducement offered? Nothing less, the invitation read, than "an exclusive opportunity to participate in the health-care reform debate among the select few who will get it done."

    The invitation reminds the CEO's and lobbyists that they will be buying access to "those powerful few in business and policy making who are forwarding, legislating and reporting on the issues …

    "Spirited? Yes. Confrontational? No." The invitation promises this private, intimate and off-the-record dinner is an extension "of The Washington Post brand of journalistic inquiry into the issues, a unique opportunity for stakeholders to hear and be heard."

    Let that sink in. In this case, the "stakeholders" in health care reform do not include the rabble - the folks across the country who actually need quality health care but can't afford it. If any of them showed up at the kitchen door on the night of this little soiree, the bouncer would drop kick them beyond the Beltway.

    No, before you can cross the threshold to reach "the select few who will actually get it done," you must first cross the palm of some outstretched hand. The Washington Post dinner was canceled after a copy of the invite was leaked to the web site Politico.com, by a health care lobbyist, of all people. The paper said it was a misunderstanding - the document was a draft that had been mailed out prematurely by its marketing department. There's noblesse oblige for you - blame it on the hired help.

    In any case, it was enough to give us a glimpse into how things really work in Washington - a clear insight into why there is such a great disconnect between democracy and government today, between Washington and the rest of the country.

    According to one poll after another, a majority of Americans not only want a public option in health care, they also think that growing inequality is bad for the country, that corporations have too much power over policy, that money in politics is the root of all evil, that working families and poor communities need and deserve public support if the market system fails to generate shared prosperity.

    But, when the insiders in Washington have finished tearing worthy intentions apart and devouring flesh from bone, none of these reforms happen. "Oh," they say, "it's all about compromise. All in the nature of the give-and-take-negotiating of a representative democracy."

    That, people, is bull - the basic nutrient of Washington's high and mighty.

    It's not about compromise. It's not about what the public wants. It's about money - the golden ticket to "the select few who actually get it done."

    When Congress passed the Helping Families Save Their Homes Act, "the select few" made sure it no longer contained the cramdown provision that would have allowed judges to readjust mortgages. The one provision that would have helped homeowners the most was removed in favor of an industry that pours hundreds of millions into political campaigns.

    So, too, with a bill designed to protect us from terrorist attacks on chemical plants. With "the select few" dictating marching orders, hundreds of factories are being exempted from measures that would make them spend money to prevent the release of toxic clouds that could kill hundreds of thousands.

    Everyone knows the credit ratings agencies were co-conspirators with Wall Street in the shameful wilding that brought on the financial meltdown. But when the Obama administration came up with new reforms to prevent another crisis, the credit ratings agencies were given a pass. They'd been excused by "the select few who actually get it done."

    And by the time an energy bill emerged from the House of Representatives the other day, "the select few who actually get it done" had given away billions of dollars worth of emission permits and offsets. As The New York Times reported, while the legislation worked its way to the House floor, "It grew fat with compromises, carve-outs, concessions and out-and-out gifts," expanding from 648 pages to 1,400 as it spread its largesse among big oil and gas, utility companies and agribusiness.

    This week, the public interest groups Common Cause and the Center for Responsive Politics reported that, "According to lobby disclosure reports, 34 energy companies registered in the first quarter of 2009 to lobby Congress around the American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009. This group of companies spent a total of $23.7 million - or $260,000 a day - lobbying members of Congress in January, February and March.

    "Many of these same companies also made large contributions to the members of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, which has jurisdiction over the legislation and held a hearing this week on the proposed 'cap and trade' system energy companies are fighting. Data shows oil and gas companies, mining companies and electric utilities combined have given more than $2 million just to the 19 members of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee since 2007, the start of the last full election cycle."

    It's happening to health care as well. Even the pro-business magazine The Economist says America has the worst system in the developed world, controlled by executives who are not held to account and investors whose primary goal is raising share price and increasing profit - while wasting $450 billion dollars in redundant administrative costs and leaving nearly 50 million uninsured.

    Enter "the select few who actually get it done." Three out of four of the big health care firms lobbying on Capitol Hill have former members of Congress or government staff members on the payroll - more than 350 of them - and they're all fighting hard to prevent a public option, at a rate in excess of $1.4 million a day.

    Health care policy has become insider heaven. Even Nancy-Ann DeParle, the White House health reform director, served on the boards of several major health care corporations.

    President Obama has pushed hard for a public option but many fear he's wavering, and just this week his chief of staff Rahm Emanuel - the insider di tutti insiders - indicated that a public plan just might be negotiable, ready for reengineering, no doubt, by "the select few who actually get it done."

    That's how it works. And it works that way because we let it. The game goes on and the insiders keep dealing themselves winning hands. Nothing will change - nothing - until the moneylenders are tossed out of the temple, the ATM's are wrested from the marble halls, and we tear down the sign they've placed on government - the one that reads, "For Sale."

  

»


Bill Moyers is managing editor and Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program, Bill Moyers Journal, which airs Friday nights on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

So, are we going to take

So, are we going to take back the power and get public financing for candidates, or are we just going to go, "Tsk, tsk" and "Oh dear, that's terrible!?"

Mr. Moyers and Mr. Winship,

Mr. Moyers and Mr. Winship, thank you from the bottom of my heart for lending your prestige to this issue. Our coin-operated congress is clearly the problem, not the solution to the problem, and it's been that way as long as I have memory. Unfortunately, history teaches us that this is an all too common phenomenon that is not easily overcome. Real solutions have always and will always involve real risk and real effort on the part of those most directly affected. Unfortunately, so far I have seen no sign of that level of patriotism. Our citizens seem to think that buying a yellow magnetic sign proclaiming "Support for the Troops" (made in China) is patriotism. And so now they are reaping the fruit from the seeds they have sown.

Thank you Bill Moyers

Thank you Bill Moyers Michael Winship, and Truthout. I believe that initially, the huge suppport and successful campaign of President Obama came from many many small contributors.

Wonderful, thanks, but what

Wonderful, thanks, but what else is new? Where was this sort of reporting one year ago, under Bush? And who will throw the money-lenders out of the temple? Not Mr. Obama, I wager. Only the people can do that - and the people have been carefully emasculated. Finally, if you tear down the 'For Sale' sign it usually means the property is no longer for sale - somebody has bought it. So even that option is no longer promising. Welcome to the future, folks. Pete Edler, Stockholm

Wow, that about says it all

Wow, that about says it all doesn't it. Bill Moyers is a great journalist, I guess that's why the right wing hates him, I hope he wears their hatred as a badge of honor.

Democracy bought out.

Democracy bought out.

Nance Ann DeParle did more

Nance Ann DeParle did more than serve on boards of health care companies. She was a private equity underwriter for CCMP Capital Partners, an investment firm specializing in health care acquisitions. She funded Legacy Hospital Partners, which turns nonprofit community hospitals into the for-profit variety. Two converted under her leadership.

Everyone knows that bribery

Everyone knows that bribery is improper- the Constitution says so- but only in the form of Pay-Per-Favor. Dispensing influence on the Prepaid Plan is apparently A-OK, and public officials spend much of their professional lives soliciting contributions. I would like to think that the public had had enough of this, and that polls that show Americans want a more balanced distribution of power would show up as an overwhelming mandate at the ballot box, but so far the public will has been weak.

Moyers and Winship are a

Moyers and Winship are a fantastic team. Much of what is printed here came out over TV last Friday (7/10/09)--but here in the SF Bay Area it came out on KQED at 10 p.m. ! The program (focused on successful strategies the health-care industry has developed for the defeat of reform) packed more truth in one program than, say, the NEWSHOUR WITH JIM LEHRER manages to air in a year. KQED should be ashamed of itself. If they were genuinely acting in the public's interest, they would drop the metronomic ping-pong nonsense of such shows as the NEWSHOUR (to which they give two hours of airing every weekday) and put Moyers front and center where he belongs.

How many times do we have to

How many times do we have to see things like this before we begin to see that the politicians are the hired help - and the CHEAP hired help at that. The amount of $$ that is spent to corrupt them is so incredibly small compared with the billions in profit these companies make, it almost insults everyone's intelligence. $2000 campaign contribution limit my eye! The ONLY solution is to make it illegal for politicians to accept ANY $$ from ANYONE for ANY reason, No exceptions. Minimal additional $ for travel and staff, that's it. A nice (and in my opinionincredibly necessary) addition to this would be a requirement that the elected official would have to be paid the mean or median salary of the constituents they represent, whichever was lower. You would see the laws of this country change so fast it would make your head spin... dave n nyc

When we have the will the

When we have the will the people can and will change this. We hired them with our votes, we pay them with our taxes, we can fire them with our votes and activism. We need the will to act in an organized manner. Thank you Bill Moyer for speaking the truth.

Money Talks, the poor can

Money Talks, the poor can walk (maybe, if they are able to). It is massively corrupt and how the media support the status quo is what is really disgusting about this whole mess.

Democracy is just another

Democracy is just another American myth.The mythology is so strong even those afflicted most swear by it. Unbridled capitalism is what it's all about. Living in NYC's financial district I'm appalled on a daily basis as the Temple of America with its disproportionate American flag is celebrated and saluted by those who have no understanding of how it manipulates their lives.The Temple is now surrounded by a concrete moat with SWAT teams, bollards, roadblocks, fences, gates, guards, bomb-sniffing dogs, pick up trucks and camera shooting tourists. Wall Street-yes, that's right, a walled street. Freedom, liberty, and blockaded streets-how free and democratic can one get?

Obama needs to be pressured.

Obama needs to be pressured. He can lead but only so far!

And nothing will change

And nothing will change still because we'd rather close the curtains than take to the streets. These people ("journalists", politicians and lobbyists) should be lining walls for a firing squad and they flaunt their lack of morality on national television. This country is on the verge of death.

Oxymoron - American Democracy

Oxymoron - American Democracy

If you think this is

If you think this is depressing, wait until the Supreme Court officially enshrines the right of businesses to spend freely on campaigns, despite overwhelming evidence of how badly corrupted the system is already.

This problem will not go

This problem will not go away until Congress enacts a law that repeals the 1868 Supreme Court ruling that granted "personhood" to corporations. Failing that, a group; perhaps the ACLU or MoveOn.org; could search for a case to reintroduce the issue to the Federal Court system. In 1864, former corporate lawyer Abraham Lincoln wrote, "Corporations have been enthroned and an era of corruption in high places will follow, and the money power of the country will endeavor to prolong its reign by working upon the prejudices of the people until all wealth is aggregated in a few hands and the Republic is destroyed." Remember this was 4 years before the actual decision was handed down. And if you read the history of this decision, there is evidence that a clerk inserted the language and that the Supreme Court itself never actually made the specific ruling. Perhaps a there was some skullduggery at work. However it happened; it's time to de-person the corporations.

The collapse will be good

The collapse will be good for the world. We must crash before the power can be wrested from the claws of the self serving gluttons who own us. Our last fight will be the fascists waiting in the wings to bring us "salvation."

R E V O L U T I O N. To the

R E V O L U T I O N. To the streets! History says it's the only cure. The only way freedom and democracy have ever been achieved is through bloody revolution. You can't vote fascism out of power. We all must fight for it, or forget it.

Amazing! Katharine Weymouth

Amazing! Katharine Weymouth is one those "who can get things done" for the Gordon Geckos of Wall Street. American capitalism truly is organized crime. When will the public finally get enough of this crap?

Given that Congress does not

Given that Congress does not have the will to end this travesty, and given that the United States Supreme Court persists in equating money with speech, thereby protecting the nefarious practice, there seems to be only one solution: A Constitutional Amendment. A daunting challenge in other times, the internet could make the process doable. Truthout would be just the ones to sponsor and coordinate the effort.

Lots of American citizens

Lots of American citizens hold stock in these egregious corporations. Many of us don't know we do, especially if we have money in, for example, enormous state pension funds. The question I would like to see discussed is this: Can the stock owning masses be mobilized to counteract the conduct of "the select few" and if so, how?

So.what did you expect?

So.what did you expect? Welcome to Texas no. 49 of 50 states in education and U S A no. 37 of 50 in world education, one step below Slovenia. Wonder what's on TV tonight, Sure am sorry I missed all the coverage of Michael, all the ball games and races games shows and such since Sept. 20 2oo1 the day the term boob tube became clear. Not that I paid much attention to it anyway.

Indeed, the only way to get

Indeed, the only way to get back to a system where elected representatives are responsive to the people and not the moneyed interests is to take money out of politics. Campaign finance reform is a big part of that, but there's more involved. Stifling the corruption will require our constant vigilance and probably a Federal agency dedicated to investigating crooks inside and outside the Beltway.

President Obama, please read

President Obama, please read this article and begin the change we hope for. Start with saying that you find it despicable that the publisher of one of the most influential newspapers in the world would facilitate a rendezvous between the select few of government and the lobbyists that seek to influence them. Just say it. We'll wait for the followthrough, but we really need to hear that you find this type of behavior disgusting and appalling.

The buck did more than just

The buck did more than just stop in DC. It THRIVED! It did so well that nowadays it both begins And ends there. Congress was bought and paid for right before our very eyes and we did nothing. Our nations justice system has become a Just Us system whereby the moneyed few have rigged the system of revolving doors to pay off better than any casino or lottery ever could. It's legal, all fairness set aside, only a gamble if you're not well-heeled. You don't hear much complaining because the biggest losers in that game end up wrongfully imprisoned, or worse. In short, you have to pay to play in America and if the big boys have their way, we'll all be handing over our lunch money for some time to come. Our foreign policy is only one horror story. There are many stories to be told in the land of the not so free.

$TOP WAR $TART UNIVERSAL,

$TOP WAR $TART UNIVERSAL, SINGLE-PAYER HEALTH CARE

If the people of the US will

If the people of the US will write and call their legislators, then the lobbyists will not have their way. But, it is difficult to convince people to make their opinions known to their legislators. Why? To each of you who read this comment, have you contacted your legislator? If not, why not?

And thanks, mainstream

And thanks, mainstream media. The news of the day reports that today the Democrats won something or lost something and the Republicans won something or lost something in, say, the health care debates. Do you ever remember when the news of the day reported whether the people won something or lost something that day?

Presuming the actual

Presuming the actual election voting system is not rigged, politicians should keep in mind it doesn't matter how much money these special interests contribute; in the end, "We the People" still hold the final word and should organize to vote these shysters OUT of office during the next elections!

Bill Moyers, I respect you

Bill Moyers, I respect you so much, and everything you say is right on the money. But exactly how do the people go about throwing the moneylenders out of the temple? How do we actually get around the "Select Few" and get it done ourselves? I am constantly emailing, calling, and petitioning my legislators and newspapers, marched, waved signs, and all the rest of it. Still nothing changes. I'm ready for torches and pitchforks. But how do we find out who the "Select Few" are? Whose hearts do we pound the stakes into?

Congress is bought Slow

Congress is bought Slow day Nothing to see here, move along!

How extraordinary, that

How extraordinary, that probably 75% of the people agree with you and we can't even get the Health Policies or the taxes on the rich we need to build a fair shake for everyone.... We even have a President who cares... It looks like it will take a leftist upheaval to get some action --or a congressional vote-in of new stuff to vote the policies in....This will take I'm afraid too long...So we shall reap the results according to history...Many will be changed for it...

Bill Moyers and Michael

Bill Moyers and Michael Winslip have nailed this one. I represent a small (poor) lobbying group representing 18.6 Million Retired Americans who earned their retiree healthcare benefit by agreeing to take less in their paycheck and fewer vacation days for 30 or more years in order to secure healthcare in retirement. They all thought, they had a CONTRACT with the corporation for healthcare insurance in retirement. Only it turns out Corporations had their legal fingers crossed and the Corporate Employment lawyers rigged the deal. Today, it is perfectly legal to take away retiree's healthcare benefit after retirement and the former employee has no legal recourse. (see Sprague vs. GM) H.R.1322, a bill currently in Congress with 50 Cosponsors would make it illegal for Corporations to take away that benefit after a loyal employee retired. I have been watching the new "proposed Healthcare insurance 'FIX' very closely. If the bill is passed as is, Corporations will be encouraged to dump all retiree healthcare insurance subsidies. Why? The Insurance Lobby and Corporate lobbyists who should be opposed to each other's agenda's are working together to keep any wording out of the new bill which would make it illegal to drop retired workers healthcare. Sad! Workers were given complete assurances all during their career that they would receive healthcare for life. Many decided to retire because they believed this big corporate lie. Employment law is the only law which allows those affected by contracts to not be able to read and sign that contract, yet have it determine their livelihood in retirement. Thanks to you Bill and Michael for again uncovering Capitol Hill flim flams. Jim Casey President ProtectSeniors.Org The only retiree organization trying to fix bad corporate law affecting retiree's earned healthcare.

We are the Chump-ions, my

We are the Chump-ions, my friend......And we'll keep on caving, 'til the end.....

To the 'Select Few' - we're

To the 'Select Few' - we're watching you. Part of the Declaration of Independence..."That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends (Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness), it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security. β€” Such has been the patient sufferance of these Colonies; and such is now the necessity which constrains them to alter their former Systems of Government."

I agree with the article's

I agree with the article's major lines of analysis. However, I do not agree that Obama has pushed hard for a public option. He is part of the corrupt Washington establishment and was already so before he was elected to the presidency. Nader is too old to run again, but the indignation of the American people needs to be channeled in a better way than supporting a diversionary Palin side show orchestrated by the corrupt captains of America, INC.

Bill Moyers may be hated by

Bill Moyers may be hated by the right wing propoganda mouthpieces. But he and Winship just gave voice to what everyone I know Repub and Dem alike believe - our gov't is for sale and it is being bought over and over again for fun and profit of the uber-rich. Washington Post, Bye-Bye!

Betrayal is the service for

Betrayal is the service for sale by our politicians. Keep this in mind the next time you vote, or spot any opportunity at all to foil their plans. Tell your friends. The recent 12 trillion these slime gave their "friends" in the financial institutions was money out of our pockets to the tune of $40,000 from every man, woman and child in this country. Men women and children who were betrayed, for profit. Get mad. You deserve it! It's the only thing with any hope of success.

I agree to a point. I'm a

I agree to a point. I'm a liberal Democrat but that does not mean that I think the answer to every problem is another Cabinet-level department or billion-dollar program. Thousands of lobbyists feed off the crumbs of nitwitted programs targeted at a handful of people. Once started most programs get tenure in no time. And Republicans piously claim to be against "pork" but they cut every ribbon they can because at that point it's about "jobs" -- if it's in a Democratic district it's a "boondoggle" of course. In the end nobody wants to suffer the cut, yet no one wants to pay the bill. The corporations do indeed run the show and that's obvious to all, but we average Joes and Janes love to eat our cake and have it too.

One question remains: 1.

One question remains: 1. What is to be done ? Are we left merely to know, to complain, but to DO NOTHING about what we know ? How can we tolerate the sale to the highest bidder of the people's sovereign power to obtain their just ends ? Who will at last take up the challenge to bring down the so-called "powers that be" and undo the dirty dealings ? It is not enough merely to know. To have any worth, knowledge must lead to consequential action. And so - what is to be done and by whom and how shall it be done ?

Moyers and Winship are gems.

Moyers and Winship are gems. They report the truth, something not done in mainline news. They, Seymor Hersh, Mike Taibbi, Mike Whitney and others act as a conduit of truth and a push against the infomercials of mainstream news. Bravo for a really outstanding article.

Your column just confirmed

Your column just confirmed what I concluded in the past few months despite Obama's election and my hopes... Health-insurance companies, Wall Street, Big Pharma, the oil industry, banking and other powerful, moneyed interests truly control this country. Until we revamp elections to full public financing with no exceptions, we'll never have a true democracy. Until then, our House and Senate are slaves to special interests...not the citizens of this country. I'm just not optimistic about real change for the middle class and millions of other Americans.

"Money doesn't talk, it

"Money doesn't talk, it swears." - Bob Dylan

This may be an

This may be an oversimplification; however, I believe everyone can agree that democracy, as defined, is a failed experiment. Democracy will never exist because greed (and fear) are part of the human condition. It's not good or bad - it just is. Not surprisingly, the system is set up to reward those who behave selfishly. Malfeasance is therefore to be expected among "The Select Few." Perhaps, as a race, too much is expected of people.

No easy answers to curing

No easy answers to curing the greed and depravity of these elected criminals....But, Term Limits would be a great start. Keep turning over the officeholders so it becomes too expensive for special interests to keep buying them. They SI's would need to spend a lot up front because they wouldn't be able to buy influence on the "time-payment plan", over the outrageously-long tenures of the Senators, Representatives, etc. It wouldn't give the SI's a very good payout. Plus, we might get more new ideas -- including some that are actually good ideas -- by bringing in new minds regularly. The country is obviously not benefiting from developing an entrenched, "political" class. Limit total time for one person, in all of their elected offices, to six years.

Dussault against big

Dussault against big lobby...wow, to have a name that would matter and to get invited to a dinner where the discussion was really going to matter...is there such a thing...not for the people...we have left our democracy in Honduras, or Iraq, or Iran...

I would have said I had

I would have said I had pretty good coverage. Six months after my brain surgery, I am starting to get denial of claim letters from my catastrophic insurance company. I am easily $50,000 in debt at this point. My mother would have told you she had good insurance. An automobile accident landed her in the emergency room and she was inpatient for two days. Less than a week after her admission, she started getting claim denial letters from her supplementary health insurance company. Will she lose everything? This article is an excellent plainspoken description of how "health insurance" operates today in America. Many of us are ready to storm the gates. Anybody got a game plan?

As usual, we are told what's

As usual, we are told what's wrong but not a word about how we ordinary citizens can change it. I've been hearing the same stuff from the Left for decades, and it is just so ineffectual, all this pissing and moaning without going to the trouble to make usable suggestions. Obviously, going to streets doesn't work when such displays are confined to some distant place where they are utterly useless. Obviously, voting doesn't work, or we'd have democracy now. What prevents democracy is capitalism, and our Dear Leader is a capitalist to the core. I admire Moyers, but pullease. All talk and no do isn't working.

I'm beginning to wonder if

I'm beginning to wonder if Obama is just a foil put forward to give the illusion of "change you can believe in". Or, maybe "change you can believe in" is, in reality, keeping things business as usual with just some fancy window-dressing.

Another great article on the

Another great article on the same subject: Matt Taibbi in Rolling Stone (Issue 1082) on seven decades of Goldman Sachs "getting things done" for itself by controlling financial & governmental levers.

The greedy few will have

The greedy few will have much to fear when the poor many have nothing left to lose.

Representational Democracy-

Representational Democracy- The best form of government, money can buy. These corporations fighting to stop the "public option" don't want healthy citizens. They want citizens who have to buy the corporation's products or services for their lifetimes. There is no money to be made with healthy people. The US has turned corruption into an art form. When the previous president said that the Wall Street corporations were to big to let fail, what he was really saying was that all of the small businesses facing hard times were to small to save. Thank you Bill Moyers and Michael Winship for your honest reporting. Is this a great country or what?

Things Just Aren't Bad

Things Just Aren't Bad Enough - Yet. It will require enough people choosing to participate in massive civil disobedience because they're out of good little worker-bee options. Think the 1930s. The vested interests presently have no fear of the people. The challenge will be leadership that constructively directs this action into forced legal reforms, such as strict public funding of political campaigns. If that doesn't work, then the Declaration rather than the Constitution may be the guiding light.

WHAT DO WE DO..?

WHAT DO WE DO..? CORPORATIONS HAVE TAKEN OVER OUR COUNTRY..!!!.... AMERICA IS OVER... And, as far as I can tell, about a third of the population complains about it in between doing other stuff, about a third is happy with it and swears this IS America as it should be and about a third just simply roll over for it because they have a couch, a fridge full of tasty calories, Cable TV, DVD, Internet, a Car and a Job.... and they don't want to make waves because they're afraid the cable will go off... or the stores will close.. or they'll lose their job... Now, if my little comment here is not a true little story about a CORPORATE coup d'Γ©tat, maybe you have a better one...

"According to one poll after

"According to one poll after another, a majority of Americans not only want a public option in health care, they also think that growing inequality is bad for the country, that corporations have too much power over policy, that money in politics is the root of all evil, ..." ## ...but apparently they don't want any of these things enough to keep from putting in office, year in and year out, precisely those people who will work to prevent these things from being realized.

anonymous at July 13, 00:41

anonymous at July 13, 00:41 asks for a game plan for 'storming the gates'. I re-iterate (all over again): We need to organize a 10 million patients march on Washington led by 100,000 people in wheel chairs. That should do it, and it is something of that magnitude which is needed and ASAP as they are already selling you down the river to Unwellpoint Medical Insurance Denial, INC. of New New Orleans. And that march needs to promulgate a clear goal: Universal, Comprehensive, Single-Payer health insurance for ALL.

The media and the government

The media and the government are manipulating Americans; we have become brainwashed sheep with a knee jerk reaction to believe anything. For example, Obama will help the people and the Democratic Party is the party of change. Meanwhile, Obama is morphing into Bush and the Democratic Party is becoming the new Republican Party. Progressive groups have to merge and organize demonstrations, instead of the ineffective contact your Rep drives. Get involved; scare the hell out of our corporatist government and its overlords with massive demonstrations in every major city until we get real change. Additionally, do not contribute to the Democratic Party. Regrettably, many of us were duped into contributing, directly or indirectly, to democrats that vote with republicans; a major cause of watered down bills that do nothing for the people. Furthermore, do not give the corporate robber barons your business. Help small business, use alternative energy and go without, when possible.

it's already over for

it's already over for america, this country and everyone in it has to be brought to it's knees... everyone has to lose it all, otherwise no real change will ever occur... america is capitalism masquerading as democracy... what a joke the government is... nothing but a bunch of greedy pathetic losers...

Once again I have to ask, if

Once again I have to ask, if its "off the record", why do journalists have to be there at all. They can offer no intellectual input to these meetings. Katherine Weymouth states, "its a Washington Post style of journalistic inquire into the issues...". Who cares? If the Washington Post journalists cannot print what goes on, it makes no difference how their "style" of inquire was thrown around the room. This is sick, disgusting and Weymouth should go to jail. Is this how the decisions of government are made? Print a list of all the elected officials who attended, then kick them out. Pay for play just doesn't do it for me. Yes indeed, the best government money can buy.

Can we expect a similar

Can we expect a similar expose of the similar if less subtle work of AIPIC? Or is AIPIC out of bounds,even for BM and PA programme?

"Government by the

"Government by the corporations, for the corporations and of the corporations". "We the corporations, in order to form a more perfect union...." (Who's got the White-Out??)

We all should read this. I

We all should read this. I agree with those who reason that money has corrupted our system. That can be corrected, but we don't do it. We love to whine but we don't act. Notice how few of us commenting on this great, informative piece are willing to be identified by name. Most are Anonymous. What could be harder than cleaning up our political system? Russia rooting our the mafia, maybe. Is it possible? I wish I could be optimistic.

Mr. Moyers, These are not

Mr. Moyers, These are not "high up" anythings. These are parasites who are at a far remove from the People's scrutiny. If they were honest they wouldn't need to hold their payola meetings out of the public view. Keep writing please. We can't know when the People will wake up and act to drive these dishonest botom feeders out of Washington.

"That's how it works. And it

"That's how it works. And it works that way because we let it." Though that's always a nice, ironic, and pithy way to end a tragicomedy, it is not true. The usurpation of America's freedoms, finances, and democratic experiment was accomplished behind closed doors in smoke-filled rooms ... since the days of the robber barons.

What amount of wealth does

What amount of wealth does it take for someone to lose their conscience? It's probably different for different people, but I'm amazed that so many people at the controls of wealth have no conscience.

Folks, it is time to take to

Folks, it is time to take to the streets. A general strike. Shut down the country until the representatives WE sent to Congress answer to us, for a change. Time to show the lobbyists to the door and push them down the Capitol steps. Then, there is Goldman Sachs. We give them bailout money because they were on the brink of disaster. Now, suddenly, they are making record profits while everyone else is starving to death. That company needs to be broken up. Any one who worked there should be barred from holding any public office that deals with economic policy. They are a cancer on our society because they take and take and give nothing back that is tangible. They rip us off so their top execs can make hundreds of millions in bonuses, yet leave the rest of the 299,999,000 of us citizens living in cardboard boxes and eating out of soup kitchens and food pantries.

Quick note here, 1.) the

Quick note here, 1.) the "mainstream media" IS corporate America. 2.) The biggest lie told Americans is that we own the airwaves. Many of you ask what can we do, what action can we take? My suggestion is to turn off your TV and keep it off and tell you "representatives" that you have. Will they keep spending you dough on advertising if your not watching? I would suggest that the "mainstream media" are simply the pushers of the drugs, and arms their corporate owners manufacture. Pay attention to what is advertised in the "mainstream media" One more question: Is there anyone who is watching, my favorite program, Jon Stewart's "Daily Show" who believes that the pills so abundantly advertised there are really going to make their "unit" bigger?

It seems that any health

It seems that any health care reform that is actually implemented will be doomed to the iron triangle conundrum just like all other major policy's created by congress. The insurance companies just want to mandate coverage on the young and healthy to help them pay for the cost of the aging baby-boomers, which will help them keep profits up at the expense of regular people. People need to wake up to the fact that fascism is upon us, and both major parties are nothing but enablers in the scam.

A brilliant commentary on

A brilliant commentary on the financial oligarchy that our democracy has become--government by the wealthy for the wealthy, with elections as the new 'opiate of the masses.' Wish I knew what to do about it.

I've read and agree with

I've read and agree with every previous comment. Does anyone remember that Franklin Roosevelt said in 1932 "Now that you've elected me you must build a coalition to make me do what I promised to do in my campaign." Also I want to add my puny words to the comment that said we need to end letting corporations behave like people. A corporation is NOT a person and should NOT have the rights of a person.

Bill Moyers, you have been

Bill Moyers, you have been speaking for me for 30 years or more, thank you! If it were not for you I would feel voiceless.

The "system" is required by

The "system" is required by the laws of nature to accomodate "mood of the country" whether it is 1. Wildly producing severer overpopulation or 2. In a state where the food has run out. or 3. Swarming out to find more food. (colonization)

Nice column, Bill. But you

Nice column, Bill. But you stop short at solutions, and here is a good one: use the FCC's power to limit broadcast political advertising, requiring that broadcasters supply equal time to candidates instead. That is perfectly legal under the FCC mandate to manage the broadcast spectrum in the public interest.

The 'developed world'? The

The 'developed world'? The U.S. is no longer a part of the 'developed world' in oh, so many ways. Look around you and compare our life situations with the actual 'developed world'. We've slipped far below that. I don't know how much more I can take of Washington. I feel helpless.

Forget healthcare.... just

Forget healthcare.... just take health in your own hands. Do yoga, eat off the market, lots of veggies, organic... and you will be healthy. forget relying on the man.

Don't I remember the

Don't I remember the suggestion that campaigns could be paid for by $10 from each of us? I believe Mr. Moyers made the suggestion once. Now that would be real campaign finance and make our elected officials more responsive to the people. What a sad state of affairs.

Damon Neal's comment re the

Damon Neal's comment re the legal status of corporations is an essential correction to be made. In addition to that, one step we can all take is to vote against every incumbent in every election. If we break the expectation of career continuity among the politician class, we also destroy their worth to the lobby class. No matter how good you think your local guy is, remember it is more important to prevent him/her from staying in DC long enough to get seriously corrupt, it takes away influence he/she may want to peddle, and it will naturally increase turnover in congress. it is the salient prerequisite to real reform.

The system is broken. An

The system is broken. An earlier commenter referred to the Supreme Court equating money with free speech in the election process, squashing the possibility of controlled campaign spending . (The Court needs a course in semantics.) Getting elected and re-elected to political office requires massive sums which have to be obtained from the corporations who have it. (Yes, Obama depends on Goldman Sachs' generosity to get in and remain in office.) Those who can fix the broken system are the benefactors of it - thus, no incentive to change. A progressive Supreme Court or a citizen's initiative for a constitutional amendment would seem to be the only non-violent hope of change. Attempts at legislatively allowing national citizen initiatives have never gotten out of committee for floor votes. Only 24 states now have that option. A profound grassroots effort would be required to advance this option... and you can expect billions to be spent to kill such initiatives. Waiting for that progressive Supreme Court might be too late to save the Empire. Maybe we're toast!

July 30, 2009 SINGLE PAYER

July 30, 2009 SINGLE PAYER DEMONSTRATION WASHINGTON, DC Medicare: Made In America Rally and Lobby Day Thursday, July 30th, 2009 | Washington, DC Celebrate Medicare's 44th Birthday by showing Congress and President Obama that unions, doctors, nurses, seniors, faith groups, and Americans of every stripe support national, single-payer healthcare.

It is very difficult to

It is very difficult to relate these problems to many Americans as they have no clue as to how this corrupt machine really works. Most are so dumbed down and programmed to believe whatever is televised as the truth whether it's from the Faux news network or ABC (already been communist). Washington D.C. (District of Corruption) is no better than the government of Mexico, Afganistan or Iraq or any of the other corrupt regimes in the world. Remove the corporations from being a person and yes , even destroy them if necessary. They are the evil among us.