Share

So Much Progress and Yet So Far to Go

by: Dr. Wilmer J. Leon III, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Alethea Wright, the executive director of Creative Steps Inc. day camp, speaks with the press about the racist actions of a swim club against youth attending her organization's summer camp. (Photo: Yong Kim / The Philadelphia Inquirer)

    On February 12, 2009, the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) marked its 100th anniversary. The NAACP is America's oldest, largest and most widely recognized grassroots-based civil rights organization.

    The NAACP is an organization with a unique vision and mission. As stated on their web site, its vision is to ensure a society in which all individuals have equal rights and there is no racial hatred or racial discrimination. Its mission is to ensure the political, educational, social and economic equality of rights of all persons and to eliminate racial hatred and racial discrimination.

    With the election of an African-American president, there are those who are asking if the NAACP is still relevant. In a "new America," a so-called "post racial" America, is the NAACP still needed? Since the founding of the NAACP on February 12, 1909, so much progress has been made and, yet, there is so far to go.

    Their literature states that in 1905 the NAACP's stated goal was to secure for all people the rights guaranteed in the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments to the United States Constitution, which promised an end to slavery, the equal protection of the law and universal adult male suffrage, respectively.

    Yes, slavery has ended in America; people of color can secure equal protection of the law and vote, but there are miles to go before we sleep. The main barrier for African-Americans, politically and otherwise, has always been and continues to be race and the manner in which race is used to define and diffuse issues. Yes, class is a factor as well, but race is still the dominant variable in the equation.

    The most recent evidence of this played itself out on June 29, at The Valley Swim Club, a private swim club in Huntington Valley, Pennsylvania. Creative Steps Day Camp, a Northeast Philadelphia children's day camp that services primarily the African-American and Latino communities, signed a contract with and paid The Valley Swim Club more than $1,900 for one day of swimming a week for the summer session.

    When the children arrived for their first day of swimming, they were not well-received. According to news reports, camper Dymire Baylor stated, "I heard one lady saying 'Why's there so many black kids here' cause she said she was afraid that we might do something to her child." NBC Philadelphia.com reported, "When the minority children got in the pool all of the Caucasian children immediately exited the pool," Horace Gibson, parent of a day camp child, wrote in an email. "The pool attendants came and told the black children that they did not allow minorities in the club and needed the children to leave immediately."

    Another camper, Jabriel Brown, said the he felt the tension all afternoon. He began to feel better when he recognized a familiar face - a teacher from his middle school. His sense of security was quickly dashed when he tried to say hello and the teacher just ignored him. Brown said, "It made me feel bad ... she used to be my math teacher."

    After the first day, Creative Steps's money was quickly refunded and the campers were told not to return. Several campers said they heard pool members making racial remarks during their time inside the club.

    In response to these events, club president John Duesler told a Philadelphia television station that several club members complained because the children fundamentally changed the "complexion" and "atmosphere" at the pool, but that the complaints didn't involve race. If not race than what? Duesler later claimed that the campers were removed for safety reasons. It is also important to note that the representatives of the swim club have not disputed the facts as stated, merely the reasons for the actions.

    The NAACP has requested the Human Relations Commission to investigate. The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission will immediately open an investigation into the actions of The Valley Swim Club. Chairman Stephen A. Glassman has said, "The rule of law in Pennsylvania is equal opportunity for all, regardless of race."

    W.E.B. DuBois, founder and general secretary of the Niagara movement and among the founders of the NAACP, wrote in 1952, "The problem of the twentieth century is the problem of the colour line." He was right then and is correct today. Who would have thought that in 2009 a swim club in the City of Brotherly Love would revert to the Jim Crow practices of the 30s, 40s and 50s simply because some white parents were misguided and afraid of what some black and Latino swimmers might do to their children?

    Do we need the NAACP? Is the NAACP still relevant?

    As long as African-American men are incarcerated at a rate of more than six times the rate of white men and the incarceration of black women continues to grow at record numbers, the answer is yes! As long as unemployment among African-American's is more than twice the rate of white Americans (four times in New York) and as long as studies show that a black family's income is a little more than half that of a similar white family's income, the answer is yes! As long as African-Americans continue to deal with "Driving While Black," excessive high school drop out rates and imbalances in health care, the answer is yes!

    Have we made racial progress in America? Yes, we have, but even with so much progress, we have yet so far to go. We still have miles to go before we sleep. Dr. Dubois, the problem of the twenty-first century is the problem of the color line.

  

»


Dr. Wilmer Leon is the producer/host of the nationally broadcast call-in talk radio program "On With Leon" and a Teaching Associate in the Department of Political Science at Howard University in Washington, DC. Go to www.wilmerleon.com or email wjl3us@yahoo.com.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

If we as a nation are so

If we as a nation are so special, that we hold ourselves up as an example to the rest of the world, then why do groups like the NAACP 'need' to exist. That is our shame.

What a sad day for

What a sad day for Huntington Valley, PA and their Valley Swim Club. I wonder how those people are going to explain their actions on Judgment Day?

This is outrageous and

This is outrageous and appalling. One can only hope the club receives at least a very, very stiff fine, and perhaps even has its charter revoked and then turned into a public institution. It would also be nice to see someone do some time in jail over this to send the message that this sort of thing will no longer be tolerated.

Sadder yet is idealism and

Sadder yet is idealism and zeal for justice misguided and misspent pretending that race is the evil that hides all others. The history of the NAACP in our generation is a testament to this failure, despite it's many successes. How can there remain a truly vast economic underclass [Whether, as you claim, too largely black? Or is it not-adaptably-neoliberal?] that remains immobile and--in fact--continues to decline? To even suggest that it is a matter of race in 2009 seems morally reprehensible! Like being lost in the battle to call a mass murder genocide without bothering to stop it. In a political and economic hierarchy where deceit and exploitation are mandatory, rapacious greed fundamental and cultural and human values literally anathema there will be a cruel "color-line" with or without race. When you talk about race, what are you really saying? What should you be saying? Now would be a good time! It's really time to face the music and dance.

To play devil's advocate to

To play devil's advocate to the extreme... per Obama's NAACP speech snippet so graciously provided by the mainstream media... some could ask whether Creative Steps should take responsibility for this. I think not.... Such snippets provide context for the sometime less than glowing reactions from the ranks of our civil rights leaders... Even if such statements are "taken out of context".

The NAACP is still very

The NAACP is still very relevant for people of color. I sometmes wonder if what is many times perceived as racial tension, isn't really just amplfied tension between economic classes. Would a group of inter-city white children, excited to be at a nice pool, have provoked the same rsponse from the more sedate white member children who swim there every day and know each other? My guess is yes.

It's an never ending battle

It's an never ending battle for the US to come to terms with it's racist past. The problem is with the judicial court system. They can discriminate at random and justify it with their decisions. As long as the Police can do anything without being accountable by the courts, the system of racism in the US is not going to end. Fundamental religions has to do a lot with the racism that is going on in the US. Also the News Media which thrives on hurling insults to minorities with being punished by the government. Change the court systems, hold the police accountable for it's racist actions and perhaps, just maybe the public will begin to see what racism really is.

Those who are interested in

Those who are interested in this issue should read either Tim Wise's book, "White Like Me" or George Lipsitz's "Possessive Investment in Whiteness". Lipsitz's book in particular is well researched. Both authors sometimes allow passion to overwhelm their arguments, but there is no arguing the data: white people have enjoyed an implicit form of affirmative action in this country for over 300 years. Even so-called "poor white trash" have it better than their non-white counterparts.

But, Fri, 07/17/2009 - 14:31

But, Fri, 07/17/2009 - 14:31 β€” WhiteDude, not even your "poor white trash" ever had as good as Nancy Pelosi or Lindsay Graham, Bernie Madoff or Larry Summer; will have less chance in the future and--most importantly--shouldn't have to waste their lives being what those people are to enter the elite. This endemically unjust, inhumane society will find someone to be "black," whether they are religious muslems, gun owners, the drug addicted, vaccination resisters, undocumented workers or those who refuse to work. The world doesn't need more generals Colin Powell.

I was pleased that Obama

I was pleased that Obama mentioned "our gay brothers and sisters" in his address to NAACP. It's not that being gay is like being black -- it's not -- but that minorities seeking justice should recognize each others' claims to justice, and to acknowledge the wrongs done to them as minorities even when those wrongs are not exactly the same. I would also put drug users, abortion doctors (and their patients), conscientious objectors, many immigrants (both legal and otherwise), the poor, and all minors in the category of persons to whom society tends to deny equal justice under the law. All these groups should all recognize each others' claims, even if they don't like each other very much. If you drink the "equal justice" Kool-Aid, you have to accept the implications of its universal application. By the way, the people who accept the universality of the rule of law are far more likely to support the ACLU than those who don't, That's one reason why the ACLU apparently "isn't for everybody".

Is the NAACP still relevant?

Is the NAACP still relevant? Should the NAACP respond to the decision to expel a group of young day campers from a swimming pool because of their "complexion"? Would a relevant NAACP respond to the outragious irony of Senators Jeff Sessions and Lindsey Graham's condescending interrogations of Judge Sonia Sotomayor on behalf of "white men"? A relevant NAACP would. An irrelevant NAACP might not. Because creative strategies a now used to perpetuate a racial hierarchy in the United States the NAACP should, through its presence, make itself more relevant.

It's true that racism still

It's true that racism still exists in the 21st Century. Some cases are overt like what happened at the Valley Swim Club and Jena, Louisiana. Mostly, it's more subtle. We still have higher penalties for possession of crack cocaine, used by minorities, than powder cocaine, used by whites and the well-to-do. A black kid can get 5 years in prison for the same crime committed by a white suburban kid who gets probation and community service. Don't forget what group of people were targeted by lenders for sub-prime loans; often they were people of color, sometimes even those who could qualify for prime loans. Then there is DWB and I could go on and on. I am going to be accused of racism for what I have to say next, but there are two sides to this issue. It is an inescapable fact that there are more blacks in jail because they commit more than their share of crimes. All one has to do is watch the evening news for the latest outrage. There is a sick subculture in the black community that tends to criminal activity. (The same sick subculture exists in the white community too, but as I've said, it's proportionately smaller.) Since we now have a president of African ancestry (who I gladly voted for), the old excuse of racism is no longer going to be sufficient to explain this away. If Obama can rise above it, then others can too. In fact, most people in the black community have already have risen above it, but more progress is needed (why are there so few black math and science professionals?). It's easy for whites like myself to say this is a black problem and to some extent it is. But sooner or later, what's cool in the black community (single parents raising families, for example) becomes cool in the white community. So "black" problems really affect us all.

The "glory" days of the

The "glory" days of the NAACP are long past. This formerly august organization has long struck me as old fashioned and ineffectual, more interested in having conventions, dinner dances, and invoking the name of Martin Luther King every five minutes than actually being a strong exponent for true change and progress in racial matters. They have reacted to this latest swim club incident with their typical knee jerk "outrage", but in the end the NAACP cannot change people's basic attitudes about anything. Having a Black president doesn't make things" ok", so what makes the NAACP think that what they say or do really matters?