Share

The Stimulus in Real Time

by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t | Columnist

photo
Rowes Warf on the South Boston waterfront. (Photo: castevens12 / flickr)

    It has been a rough economic year for the city of Boston. The most recent case in point: a flap has erupted between Gov. Deval Patrick and officials in charge of the Franklin Park and Stoneham zoos. Patrick, faced with daunting budget shortfalls due to the current recession, has been compelled to slash public funds almost across the board. The Franklin Park and Stoneham zoos, beloved by generations of city residents, announced the budget cuts would force them to close, and worse, would force them to euthanize many of the animals in their care.

    Patrick was obliged to release a statement saying no, no, we're not killing any animals, after the Boston Herald carried a front-page photograph of Little Joe, a gorilla housed at Franklin Park, beneath a gigantic block-lettered headline reading, "PLEASE DON'T KILL ME."

    Yeah, it's been that kind of year in Beantown.

    The city, ancient by American standards, has been plagued with a crumbling infrastructure and moldering façade for some time now, with huge swaths of the state budget given over to holding everything together with spit, bailing wire and used chewing gum. Just this past Monday, vibrations from trolley cars on Huntington Avenue caused slabs of concrete from a roof cornice to fall off a Northeastern University building and crash onto the sidewalk below.

    Miraculously, there were no injuries, but everyone in the city spent the following Tuesday looking up at the buildings around them to make sure nothing heavy was hurtling towards their heads. Add that to the massive graft and waste that comes with a city run by one of the oldest old-boy networks on the continent, combine it with the darkest recession we've seen in almost 100 years, and you've got a nifty little recipe for municipal blight on an epic scale.

    While Boston certainly has some unique difficulties along these lines due to its advanced age and incredible corruption, the problems being experienced here are happening to one degree or another in every city, town and hamlet in the country. Repairs to infrastructure on both a state and federal level have been neglected for a very long while now, and this grim new economic reality has left thousands of municipalities in a terrible bind: they don't have the money to fix all this stuff, but if this stuff doesn't get fixed, the economy will be damaged even further.

    But a funny thing started happening in Boston several weeks ago: The stimulus money kicked in.

    The Obama administration's American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, signed into law this past February, apportioned nearly a trillion dollars for national improvements in education, health care, unemployment benefits, tax relief and infrastructure. The Act was, and remains, a highly contentious subject for Republican opponents of President Obama. Lately, newspapers and news channels have been flooded with GOP spokespeople crowing their opinion that the stimulus was a failure, and this failure is proof positive that Obama cannot be trusted to govern responsibly.

    Kevin Hassett, an economist for the ultra-conservative American Enterprise Institute and former adviser for John McCain's failed 2008 presidential run, penned an article for Bloomberg this past week that was representative of this criticism. "While the president's favorite partisan economists held hands and chanted in unison from the Keynesian prayer book," wrote Hassett, "Warren Buffett captured the mood of the American people when he said that the first stimulus package 'was sort of like taking half a tablet of Viagra and then having also a bunch of candy mixed in.' The simple arithmetic of the February stimulus suggests that Buffett got it wrong. It wasn't half a tablet of Viagra with candy; it was a tiny dose of a mysterious herbal remedy, with a stick of sugarless gum ... That's a big reason why the economy still stinks."

    If Mr. Hassett took a walk around Boston, however, he might be forced to change his tune. There is construction work going on all over the city right now; one cannot walk two blocks without coming across cranes, pavers, diggers, hard hats and paint details. Virtually the entire city is undergoing a magnificent transformation: Roads that have been hellishly potholed for decades are being completely repaired, cracked and crumbling sidewalks are being ripped out and remade, everything is getting a new coat of paint, and a whole lot of blue-collar workers are drawing paychecks for the first time in a while.

    In short, the stimulus has come to Boston, big time.

    Recessions are tricky things. There are a zillion economic-textbook reasons why they come, why they stay and why they go. The most intangible factor in the depth and duration of any recession, however, cannot be quantified or predicted: mood. If people start to feel better about how things are going, whether or not their wallets actually show it, the economy improves. The recession that hit during G.H.W. Bush's administration, for example, started to lift almost immediately after the election of President Clinton. Clinton didn't do anything in particular besides win, but the arrival of a fresh face after 12 years of octogenarian conservatives in the Oval Office sparked an elevation of public optimism that became the beginning of the end of that recession.

    President Obama, it appears, understands this phenomenon quite well. People in Boston are going to see their elderly old town in a whole new, better light once these projects have been completed. The money paid to the workers is going to boost the economy, like it always has before. These repairs are going to dramatically diminish the state's municipal repairs budget, which will free up funds and ease its economic burdens.

    This grumpy old town is going to have a fresh new face before the snow flies, and people are going to feel better about the future because of it. The stimulus money may not yet be working this odd civic magic everywhere in the country, but it's coming. In Boston, it's happening right before our eyes, and it's a hell of a thing to see.

  

»


William Rivers Pitt is a New York Times and internationally bestselling author of two books: "War on Iraq: What Team Bush Doesn't Want You to Know" and "The Greatest Sedition Is Silence." His newest book, "House of Ill Repute: Reflections on War, Lies, and America's Ravaged Reputation," is now available from PoliPointPress.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

I volunteer at the stone

I volunteer at the stone zoo, mentioned in this article. My aim is to get a "paying" job with them (quotes are because anyone working at a zoo makes less than a vending machine). However this stimulus came with a mighty string attached for us: it was specifically forbidden to spend a cent of it on zoos. So the state is telling the zoos to trim budget money however they have to. Since the animals are already getting the bare minimum, we the workers are getting the shaft. People who have been there 20 years, making $12/hr at the highest levels of animal care, are probably going to see their health care slashed. Because of our lovely gun-to-the-head insurance law, these people cannot ditch coverage they can't use or need to afford frills like food and rent. The stimulus may be making superficial improvements around here but as usual, the bottom of the ladder is being told it's nothing but a stepping stool for the higher rungs. And we who shovel animal crap for what passes for a living really get a demonstration of what our elite lawmakers think of us.

I didn't read anything in

I didn't read anything in here about any transitioning to a more sustainable city. What's going on with that? Is it just a facelift or is there a real effort to support reducing the city's carbon footprint or assisting community gardens and other local food projects? Are there "Green Jobs" (the ones that are supposed to help those at the bottom rungs get a real leg up)? Aside from all this, it's unclear to me how the stimulus bill will help those who don't even have a foot on the bottom rung. Grinding poverty and starvation are happening right here in the US. Wouldn't it be great if all the dollars being dumped down the crapper into killing people in Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere could ALSO be put to use saving our cities and saving the planet?

Infrastructure repairs are

Infrastructure repairs are great, as long as too much isn't siphoned off by the same graft & corruption beneficiaries and every infrastructure repair isn't another Big Dig.

William, Good piece.

William, Good piece. However, you link to Stimulus Watch's page on Boston to demonstrate that a lot of stimulus money related projects are going on. I believe SW's site shows the wish list of projects submitted by cities, not the projects that have actually been funded. David

I'd be interested in the

I'd be interested in the names and stories of the contractors getting the stimulus. How will this affect corruption equations and their effects? Are prisons among the new projects? How is this affecting the drug trade/gentrification patterns? The incarceration rate? Who will be tracking this? The latest woman to try geo-tracking this sort of thing got severely punished. I'm quite interested in whether that means nobody will track these patterns in big, corrupt cities. Did Gary Webb tell the truth in vain?

Why and how is it we have

Why and how is it we have billions upon billions upon trillions upon mega-trillions of dollars for our military,pentagon and war budgets, but cry "broke" when it comes to helping our own states? What is going on here?

As long as "WE THE PEOPLE"

As long as "WE THE PEOPLE" continue with our delusion that WE matter or are in control, the SAME OLD S--- will continue. The CROOKS are in charge, folks, and it's time for WE THE PEOPLE" to get our heads out of the sand and stand up on our hind legs. There are a LOT MORE "HAVE NOTS" than "HAVES. Aren't you as sick of this as I am?????

(1) lipstick on a pig

(1) lipstick on a pig comes to mind (2) is it certain the makeover is, in fact, the result of stimulus money going to shovel ready projects? there is no specific statement of direct relationship in the piece. it would be good to have such a statement or doubting thomas has logical basis for doubt. (3) what if any of the jobs are sustainable at the end of the project life? (4) to what degree do the projects move the city forward to new paradigms in the areas reached or do they reinforce paradigms that are obsolete?

California is bankrupt- $21

California is bankrupt- $21 Billion in debt. And Obomba just forked over $30 Billion to Israel.

Graft and Waste of an Old

Graft and Waste of an Old Boy Network? Wait 'til you see the waste that comes from massive federal government spending. The icon of FDR's New Deal bringing the ailing economy back to life - as if that is how the Great Depression ended - is a fantasy. The Depression ended with the beginning of World War II. My guess is that some suitable disaster will ensue (within the year) to either camouflage the colossal failure of this hare brained wild extravagance, or create a war economy where a rising GDP distracts from a lower quality of life for most Americans (that would be the Real Economy that each of us feels, as opposed to the official numbers crafted to lie to us). Those still wandering around in the now fossilized 'Progressive vs. Conservative' paradigm will lead the charge into this black hole - err, Red is more apt - unless there is an awakening and an application of common sense with a critical analysis of economic history extrapolated from personal experience to Federal Policy. I don't expect Mr. Pitt to be leading us in this revelation, but hopefully he will surprise ud - or at least not blame the failure on whatever 'unforseen disruptive event' that comes along, right on schedule.

Hey, Can you do simple math?

Hey, Can you do simple math? (not verified) The New Deal was a great thing. Ever heard of Social Security or Medicare or any of the other "entitlement programs" that were started then? Why do people keep putting down the New Deal? It's because they have fallen for the Right Wind (Wing) media's claim that it didn't work. BUT It DID work!

Social Security is a Ponzi

Social Security is a Ponzi Scheme. It worked as long as the population was growing (baby boom) with more children supporting fewer adults - painless. Now, because the population is not growing so fast, those who paid into it will not get the same 'Deal' that their parents did. Simple Math. Meanwhile the Banks have looted us - that's where the money went. You want Right Wing? That would be the International Bankers who are now engineering all kinds of universal taxes worldwide all in the name of love. Time to Audit the Federal Reserve Bank - support HR 1207. Medicare would be great if the treatments it paid for weren't mostly bogus, wildly expensive, ineffective and dangerous due to the conflicts of interest at the FDA.