Share

Rural Medical Camp Tackles Health Care Gaps

by: Howard Berkes  |  NPR

photo
A crowd gathers in the early morning at Wise County Fairgrounds in Virginia to receive medical care at a makeshift field hospital providing free care for those in need. (Photo: Becky Lettenberger / NPR)

    It was a Third World scene with an American setting. Hundreds of tired and desperate people crowded around an aid worker with a bullhorn, straining to hear the instructions and worried they might be left out.

    Some had arrived at the Wise County Fairgrounds in Wise, Virginia, two days before. They slept in cars, tents and the beds of pickup trucks, hoping to be among the first in line when the gate opened Friday before dawn. They drove in from 16 states, anxious to relieve pain, diagnose aches and see and hear better.

    "I came here because of health care - being able to get things that we can't afford to have ordinarily," explained 52-year-old Otis Reece of Gate City, Va., as he waited in a wheelchair beside his red F-150 pickup. "Being on a fixed income, this is a fantastic situation to have things done we ordinarily would put off."

Also see:     
Whistleblower Tells of America's Hidden Health Nightmare for Its Sick Poor    β€’

    For the past 10 years, during late weekends in July, the fairgrounds in Wise have been transformed into a mobile and makeshift field hospital providing free care for those in need. Sanitized horse stalls become draped examination rooms. A poultry barn is fixed with optometry equipment. And a vast, open-air pavilion is crammed with dozens of portable dental chairs and lamps.

    A converted 18-wheeler with a mobile X-ray room makes chest X-rays possible. Technicians grind hundreds of lenses for new eyeglasses in two massive trailers. At a concession stand, dentures are molded and sculpted.

    Desperate for Health Care

    The 2009 Remote Area Medical (RAM) Expedition comes to the Virginia Appalachian mountains as Congress and President Obama wrestle with a health care overhaul. The event graphically illustrates gaps in the existing health care system.

    "We're willing to sleep in pickup trucks or cars and deal with the elements to at least get some kind of health care," Reece adds. He earned a six-figure income working for an international industrial supply firm until an accident five years ago left him disabled. Joining him for dental, vision and medical checks are his wife, daughter, son-in-law and three grandchildren.

    "Tomorrow, I'm going to see the doctor to get my ear and my nose fixed!" grandson Jacob shouts excitedly. His nose appears battered and his ear has an oozing scab.

    Before the gate opened, Loretta Miller, 41, of Honaker, Va., got four hours' sleep behind the wheel of her parked minivan. She was No. 39 in line for her eighth RAM expedition. Her visit last year saved her life.

    "They done an ultrasound and told me that my gallbladder was enlarged and was ready to burst and it could kill me," Miller recalls. "They told me if I hadn't got help when I did, literally I could have died."

    Medical, dental and vision help is often elusive for the 2,700 people seeking treatment during the three-day RAM event. Just over half of the people attending this year have no insurance at all, according to a survey of the patients conducted by RAM. Forty-seven percent could be considered underinsured, given unaffordable copays or gaps in coverage provided by Medicare, Medicaid and conventional insurance plans. Only 11 patients have dental insurance, and just seven have vision coverage.

    "There's no doubt about it. There is a Third World right here in the United States," concludes Stan Brock, RAM's founder. Brock has organized similar medical expeditions in Asia, Africa and South America. "Here in the world's richest country, you have this vast number of people, some say 47 million, 49 million, that don't have access to the system and that's why [this] is necessary."

    About 1,800 volunteers provide the medical, dental and logistical help, including hundreds of doctors, dentists, nurses, assistants and technicians.

    Almost 4,000 Teeth

    Miller is ecstatic when her number is called. The divorced hairdresser and mother of two is uninsured and in pain. But she had taken the time, even with little sleep, to put on makeup, braid her blond hair and dress in a white lace tunic. She walked briskly through the gate for what would turn out to be five hours in dental chairs, given the extraction of an abscessed tooth, three fillings and a root canal.

    More than half of those seeking help sign up for dental exams and procedures. They fill the more than 70 dental chairs while hundreds wait their turn under tents nearby. Hundreds more out in the grassy parking lot hope they'll get their teeth cleaned and fixed before the event ends.

    Dental health greatly affects general health, says Dr. Terry Dickinson, who directs the Virginia Dental Association and the RAM dental effort at the Wise fairgrounds.

    "The infection in the mouth certainly has been shown to have an effect on systemic diseases," Dickinson explains. "So it's really critical that these folks be able to get infected teeth out and infection treated in the mouth because it's going to help them with their overall health."

    The extent of infections is staggering. Dickinson and his team pull 3,857 teeth in 30 hours of work spread over 2 1/2 days. Some patients lose all their teeth. A 4-year-old had cavities filled in every tooth.

    Who Is Responsible for Health Care?

    Terrible teeth, obesity, smoking, high blood pressure and diabetes are common among the people seeking help here. That raises an important question. Are they at fault for their poor health?

    "There's enough blame to go around for everybody. I think patients certainly have to have personal responsibility for what they're putting in their mouth, but we are also trying to create a better access care system. How are you going to get providers, whether it be dentists or physicians or anybody else, into these areas where economically these communities are struggling?" Dickinson asks.

    That's a reference to the costs of medical and dental schools and the debts that graduates incur, which can be $100,000 and more. There's pressure to practice in more lucrative places beyond rural regions like Appalachia.

    "There are areas of the country, and certainly Wise County is one of them, where there just aren't [enough] physicians," says Dr. Susan Kirk, an endocrinologist and diabetes specialist with the University of Virginia Health System, which provides specialists for the Wise RAM event. "We provide indigent care at the University of Virginia, but that's six hours away."

    RAM founder Stan Brock is impatient with those who suggest the people seeking help in Wise are somehow at fault and unworthy of care given poor health habits.

    "The rest of the population is not exactly in the best of shape themselves," Brock asserts. "They're eating well and, therefore, they're putting on weight and, therefore, they've got heart disease and the rate of diabetes in this country is going up. But, in the case of the well-to-do and the well-insured, they can afford to take care of it."

    At the end of her long day with dentists, Loretta Miller was still numb with Novocain but grateful for the care she could not otherwise afford.

    "It's well worth the drive and the wait," Miller said, close to 12 hours after her number was called. "You get tired and stuff. But you think about all the trips and the money it would have cost to have all this done. I couldn't have had it done."

    She then laughs about standing in line again at 5 a.m. the next day so she can get eyeglasses to "see what they've done."

    RAM organizers say they spent about $250,000 providing care worth about $1.5 million. In 10 years in southwest Virginia, they say, they've treated more than 25,000 people. They have eight more expeditions planned this year, from Virginia to California.

------------------    

    By the Numbers

    A survey of RAM attendees by the event's organizers provides some insight into who is left out of conventional medical, dental and vision care.

    What: Health care providers saw 2,715 patients and performed 2,671 medical exams, 1,088 eye tests and 1,850 dental exams. They extracted 3,857 teeth and put in 1,628 fillings.

    Who: Patients came from 16 different states; 30 percent were repeat patients.

    Of the patients, 51 percent are uninsured, 40.3 percent are on Medicaid or Medicare, and just 7.3 percent have employer or private insurance. Fewer than 1 percent of patients have dental or vision insurance.

    Twenty-six percent of the people are employed, 40.6 are unemployed, 4.7 percent are retired and 4.8 percent are children.

    Cost: The organizers paid about $250,000 out of pocket to run the event, and they provided an estimated $1.5 million worth of care.

All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.

  

»


Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

Wow- the first time I ever

Wow- the first time I ever saw a health care article in which the journalist actually mentions that most of these people have caused their own health problems by eating junk food, poor dental hygiene, not exercising, living a trashy lifestyle, having too many kids, spending their money on toys instead of being thrifty, etc. Most health care articles on liberal websites make it look like the government (taxpayers) are obligated to pick up the tab for every illness, birth, or mishap, regardless of who is at fault. It's bad that America has no health care system that takes care of people, but what's worse is that people live unhealthy lifestyles, make themselves obese, diabetic, heart diseased, etc. and then expect everybody else to bail them out. Great article!!

I'd be curious to find out

I'd be curious to find out how many of these folks are against government health care. I bet plenty of them, which would be a testament to the Republican propaganda machine.

How do we measure progress

How do we measure progress in a country? Is the worry of a market that keeps us sleepless? Are guns more important than health? Are warriors and sportsmen our true and only heroes? These men and women that are providing this heath care services can answer.

Interesting article, with a

Interesting article, with a careful balance - it brings up the issue of preventative care. True, people do have some degree of responsibility for unhealthy lifestyles, but this is true not just for the have nots, but also for the haves. It is just that the haves can pay into a system that will address their health issues in a way that some of the haves can literally "afford" to live an unhealthy lifestyle with proper medications, procedures and also surgery and importantly, access to good health care professionals. The have nots will do without the medications, and care that will make a difference in the quality, productivity and longevity of their lives. A cornerstone of a national health care policy must include preventative care and access to healthy foods so that all people can have lifestyles that are healthy. Importantly this may reduce overall costs to the system.

"I think patients... have...

"I think patients... have... a... responsability for what they're puttung in their mouth".Agreed but have you ever tried to eat healthy on a budget? One has to be quite wealthy to afford a reasonably balanced diet let alone 'Health Foods'.When you are hungry and have kids that are hungry you buy the most to feed them. And that means buying the industrial slop that is mass fabricated and pushed on T.V. It all very good and well intentioned to suggest selectivity in nourishment but you have to be in an economic positoion to have that CHOICE!

All that stuff about how its

All that stuff about how its really their fault because they make unhealthy personal choices is really dumb. The issue here is really very simple. Every industrialized country in the world – except the US – has a single payer health insurance program that provides better health care for less money. Why does the US not go this rout? 1. The health insurance companies don't want it and they are very powerful. 2. We feel that we need to continue to be at the head of a world Empire, even though we are literally bankrupt, and that doesn't leave money for us to be civilized country at home. 3. The media is dominated by big money and has been delivering very sophisticated propaganda for decades now. We need a single payer health insurance program like all the other developed countries in the world. That part is a no-brainer. But who is going to bell the cat (the big money people who have a strangle hold on this country)? That's the hard question.

Fox and Friends did not

Fox and Friends did not mention this. I don't think the Associated Press did either. Oh, that's right, the AP was busy reporting Fox's Glen Beck calling Obama some names. Now THAT is news worthy! Cheesh.

One poster commented on the

One poster commented on the self inflicted health problems these people suffer. And that is to the benefit of the current health care system in a good economy. It guarantees surgeries and pill popping, both of which have huge profits attached. In a non-profit single payer universal health insurance plan, these scenes don't happen. There would also be the impetus to promote preventive care, because lacking the profit motive, any payout, despite how cheap the insurance is because of risk pool size, becomes a cost. Better health equates to lower costs. Remember that the junk food market is heavily involved in big oil. Takes lots of oil to grow one bushel of corn force fed to cows in feed lots and turned into high fructose corn syrup. And cows prefer grazing and grass, so the much needed antibiotics, also using oil to make, brings Big Pharma into the food industry picture. So health care reform is about taking on the oil, food, and phamaceutical industries which are intertwined. Or we can just continue with third world scenery.

MAny of the politicians and

MAny of the politicians and pundits who are guarding so strenuously against a single payor system or a public component are getting caught in their arguments. Sen Gregg this morning was caught addressing the question of do you want to get rid of Medicare. His response was that Medicare doesn't pay the total cost. I would ask him which payor does anymore. answer, none. Bill Krystal said the military health care was excellent, but asked why he doesn't want the whole country to have it, he squirmed. The protection of insurance companies is so obvious. I would like such protection by so many senators.

Note the first comment from

Note the first comment from a right winger. Always the Republican point of view, that those living "beneath" you are entirely responsible for their own misery, being lazy, irresponsible and dependent upon government largesse for their well being. It's a comforting, simpleminded belief, enabling extreme selfishness and indifference toward those living in misery and poverty. That they did it to themselves. Life is far more complicated than that, and the economy is not strong enough to enable everyone to succeed no matter how hard they work and how talented they are. We don't have enough GDP to go around, and there will always be millions of losers who work hard and play by the rules. The problem is exacerbated at the top, where the ultra-rich have the power to siphon off far more than what they actually contribute to society. The American Dream is just that - a dream, not a reality.

Wow-millionth time I ever

Wow-millionth time I ever saw right wing views that actually mention and display the same thing: hypocrisy, ignorance and hostility towards large sectors of the population. Why are you here? I thought most right wingers had talking points beamed into their surgically implanted chips via Fox news to parrot endlessly. β€˜Poor people are lazy, careless and destroyed the economy with their crafty ways. Rich people are bold entrepreneurs who worked hard (ignore the reality of the bush clan) and deserve all the privilege and money they can steal.’ What is the percentage of illiteracy among republicans? Although they can be literate, they often prefer to be intentionally illiterate; much like their leader W chose to be deliberately stupid. Why bother with all that book-larnin’ when you got yours. The article makes very clear that well-to-do people have the same problems as poor people, but they have medical care, so they are treated and problems are dealt with instead of being left to the so-called free market to ignore. Probable response: BZZZT! BZZZT! Talking points downloaded. Socialism! Fascism! Mercury Dime proves it all! Obey your corporate master! Sure, some people are lazy fat slobs that do not take care of themselves or brush their teeth, but here is the thing that right wingers deliberately ignore: a health care system with a government option that could cover all Americans like in Europe would be far less expensive than the sick for-profit system we have now. Simple logic, experience and thinking ahead show how flawed the American system is, but most right wingers eschew such treasonous things. Hey right-winger, when your doctor tells you have a congenital heart defect, take heart and remember its all your own fault as you state β€˜It's bad that America has no health care system that takes care of people, but what's worse is that people live unhealthy lifestyles, make themselves obese, diabetic, heart diseased, etc. and then expect everybody else to bail them out.’ Stop heart diseasing yourself!

Next time my kids complain

Next time my kids complain when they go to the doctor or dentist l will tell them to appreciate the fact that they Have this service,---others in countries like the USA do not have this privilege and how lucky they are to live here in Europe.

It stands to reason that a

It stands to reason that a healthy person is more of a strain on the system than an unhealthy one. Healthy people live longer and will use the system more over a lifetime. Unhealthy people die younger and will use it less. Don't blame it all on lifestyle, because it is the opposite of what it appears to be.

The MSM never mentions that

The MSM never mentions that there may be other reasons besides weight for increased rates of diabetes: exposure to TCDD (a most toxic variety of dioxin). Veterans exposed to Agent Orange have demonstrated a far greater rate of diabetes than is expected. Plenty of people in the US have been exposed to Agent Orange (used as an herbicide in national forests throughout the 1970's) and via the waste in rivers from pulp & paper mills that use a chlorine bleaching process. That is several regions in the US, including the south. Nothing to do with lifestyle. Increased rates of cancer(s) & birth defects from substances like PCBs--which are still around, not just in soil, etc., but in transformers (original use)--the transformers are replaced as they wear out w/transformers using non-PCB lubricants. But an old transformer near you, if it leaks any of its lubricant, could be exposing those nearby to PCBs. It's not just lifestyle. In urban areas, polluting industries, etc., are more likely to be sited in the poorer parts of the city. Thus exposing low income children to more toxins. Children living within 150 feet of a busy street or highway are more likely to have asthma--and it's low income children who are more likely to be living close to highways. Single payer national health care might at least insure that children get better care for the conditions that their POVERTY and our culture--that is so obsessed with the combustion engine & using fossil fuels--expose them too. And their parents. And everyone gets exposed to some toxins. And I can only reiterate what another commenter said (and someone quoted in the article) that it's not just the poor who are putting on weight, who lead unnecessarily sedentary lives (i.e., avoid exercise) and who don't eat well. Just walk into a restaurant in the mid-range for cost & look at what people are eating.

Women need gynecological

Women need gynecological exams. A festering abdomen is also something that will affect overall health, and many women, not just the poor, are neglected in this area. My boss's mother died from necrotic intestines; which had died in her abdomen because the blood supply was cut off, by scar tissue caused by a common gynecological problem. (Endometriosis causes scarring all over the abdomen, and scars in the abdomen are not flat, but webs of tissue that tighten and strangle other organs.) But let's get to the junk food problem: If you go to any section of the grocery store except the organic section, and often even there, somewhere on the ingredient list is corn syrup. I eat very healthy organic food all the time, and read all the labels, but I pay dearly for it, and even so, I have all sorts of health conditions that the previous generations didn't have, because of additives and pollution. There are people who can only afford a bag of rice and a bag of beans. These people are more likely to serve wild meats. They are used to finding foods that are affordable; if the only affordable food (other than wild caught) is junk food, does this say that they don't take care of themselves, or that the government has subsidized junk food while the cost of healthy food skyrockets? It is not the poor, but the rich who have caused all the pollution and put all the corn syrup into all the junk food. Corn syrup is not even a natural derivative of corn. It is the rich, not the poor, who own the tobacco companies. But do these rich people help pay for the health care of the poor? And one wonders, why more health fairs such as this one aren't being funded by charity.

I am reasonably healthy. I

I am reasonably healthy. I have friends ranging from a dietician, to a diabetic, to one whose been on dialysis for 8 years. All these individuals are by necessity concerned with the nutrients in the foods they eat. Nutrition is an extremely complicated science, and one not readily evident in packaged, prepared, processed foods found on the shelves of every grocery store. Greed and unparalleled profits is the motivator, not health. Sugar content, fats, hydrogenated oils, bleached foods...consumers are not responsible for what is made readily available to them. Profiteers are, and profiteers at the top of the pyramid are not motivated by humanistic concerns generally. Stop blaming the poor for their lack of choice in life. They have what the wealtlhy profiteers make available to them.

It terrifies me to think

It terrifies me to think about all those people who needed glasses driving on our roads. Now, think about all the people who need vision correction who DIDN'T get to the free clinic! BTW, my Dad retired from a large corporation, but had his health insurance terminated because he reached his 'lifetime cap.' He WAS a wealthy Republican, now he's a Medicare 'freeloader' who's going through his remaing funds at a staggering rate, just paying for his prescriptions and the 20% Medicare doesn't cover. Personally, I have no fear of government-run health care, having served in the Army for 11 years and lived in Europe for 6. It works, and you don't have to choose between sending your kid to college and buying expensive insurance policies.

We should all send this

We should all send this story to as many media outlets as possible, and cram their mailboxes just to shame them into possibly covering it. I bet anything that if we had universal/single payer/public option healthcare, doctors might want to move to the area because they would be assured of getting paid. This is also a perfect example that because people can't afford to go get care, they will be sicker and need more services because they waited too long such as having to have their teeth pulled instead of getting fillings. The insurance companies are spending $1.2 Million a week on scare ads right now and lining the pockets of our Reps so that we might not get even the public option and/or it will be so diluted that the insurance companies will still control us. If this isn't the perfect time for everyone of us to call our Reps and DEMAND that they support the healthcare reform, I don't when it is.

With advertisements and junk

With advertisements and junk food in schools children are being inculcated with unhealthy lifestyles. I was fortunate to have worked most of my life and my doctors continue to provide the care for which I previously had coverage. It takes money to eat healthily. Eating is not optional. Preventative care depends on the patient's knowledge. The US no longer inspects food for safety. China for instance has two production lines- one for the EU the other for the US. Abstinence only "education" has increased the population and the burden on the planet.

Even Costa Rica can afford

Even Costa Rica can afford to provide universal health care for all of its people. It is not that the US government cannot do the same but that our representatives have sold out to the health care industry and allowed them to turn health into something one has to buy instead of a service that the government provides. And the members of the US Congress don't have to worry as they have special privileges when it comes to their health care as they are the supplicants of the country's wealthy and pampered elite.