Share

Pay to Play Is Washington's Sport of Kings

by: Michael Winship, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
(Photo: Getty)

    As we marvel over the depths of hypocrisy and greed currently plumbed in the health care reform debate, it may help to remember that even Honest Abe Lincoln had his share of tainted colleagues, one of the most notorious of whom was his first Secretary of War Simon Cameron.

    According to Doris Kearns Goodwin's "Team of Rivals," when Lincoln asked radical Republican Thaddeus Stevens how corrupt Cameron was, Stevens paused and replied, "I don't think he would steal a red hot stove." When Cameron objected, Stevens allowed that maybe he was wrong - implying that the cabinet secretary would steal a hot stove.

    Cameron resigned after less than a year in office, plagued by allegations of war profiteering and overall ineptitude. He's largely forgotten now, but something he supposedly said is immortalized in the lexicon of famous sayings about money and government. "An honest politician," he declared, "is one who when he is bought, stays bought."

    The giants of the health care industry fighting legitimate reform will soon discover whether all the money they've spent on lobbying has worked yet again and which of the politicians they have showered with campaign contributions will toe the line and stay bought, thwarting the desires of the majority of the American people.

    This week, the Center for Responsive Politics reported that in the second quarter of this year alone, the pharmaceuticals and health product industries spent $67,959,095 on lobbying, and the insurance industry $39,760,477. Another $25,552,088 was spent by lobbyists for hospitals and nursing homes. That's a total of $133,271,660 in just three months, and that's not even counting the lobbying money spent to fight health care reform by professional associations like the US Chamber of Commerce.

    Just to further roil your ire, comes news from McAllen, Texas, reported in the July 30 New York Times: "One of the largest sources of campaign contributions to Senate Democrats during this year's health care debate is a physician-owned hospital in one of the country's poorest regions that has sought to soften measures that could choke its rapid growth. The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee collected nearly $500,000 at a reception here on March 30, mostly from physicians and others affiliated with Doctors Hospital at Renaissance, financial disclosure records show."

    A June article in The New Yorker magazine painted a devastating portrait of the sky-high costs of physician-owned hospitals in the McAllen area and President Obama has cited it often. But money talks, and the Times notes, "Thus far, physician-owned hospitals have been insulated from some of the most onerous potential restrictions in the health care legislation moving through Congress."

    Business as usual amongst the dough-driven denizens of Washington, DC, where they may as well replace the national anthem with Randy Newman's "It's Money that I Love," and pay to play is the sport of kings.

    Anything and anybody are up for sale in the capital. You'll recall the story in early July about the intimate dinner party Washington Post publisher Katharine Weymouth was planning. Her soirée would have brought the paper's reporters and editors covering health care reform together with officials from the White House and members of Congress.

    But she also invited CEO's and lobbyists - at $25,000 a pop, or a quarter of a million if they wanted to underwrite a series of these intimate salons. The invitation offered, "An exclusive opportunity to participate in the health care reform debate among the select few who will actually get it done."

    The dinner was scrapped when The Washington Post invitation leaked to the press. But such exclusive events where the elite meet to eat - for a price - are standard operating procedure in DC. The Economist magazine and The Wall Street Journal have hosted intimate salons. Atlantic Media, publisher of The Atlantic magazine and National Journal, among other publications, has been holding off-the-record, get-togethers for the last six years, with such corporate sponsors as Microsoft, General Electric, Citigroup, Allstate Insurance and the health care giant AstraZeneca.

    Atlantic Media is now taking it one step further, moving their exclusive party to the Internet, where National Journal has announced a new "policy-oriented" web site called 3121, named after the phone extension for the US Capitol switchboard. It's exclusively for members of Congress and their staffs. Well, almost exclusively.

    I can't log onto it - and neither can you, assuming you're not a senator, representative, or somebody who works for one. But guess what? If you're a lobbyist, you can buy your way in. The web site's marketing kit promises that you'll be able to "build connections and start a valuable conversation with a targeted group of some of the most powerful people in the political world."

    Yes, ladies and gentlemen, for a mere $295,000, you can be 3121's "Premier Promotional" sponsor. That means you get, quote, "exclusive rights to all advertising on 3121 from site launch in September" through the end of the year. You'll also be invited to the web site's launch party and what they're calling "Innovation Happy Hours," so order your hats and noisemakers now.

    What's that you say? You can't afford nearly $300,000? Tell you what I'm gonna do. For a mere $95,000 you can buy what they're calling a "Research and Education" package that gives you a sneak preview of 3121 and access to Capitol Hill insiders helping out with the web design and learning how to use it.

    At least if you buy into 3121 you know the web site stays bought, like Simon Cameron's definition of an honest politician. For sheer, unmitigated chutzpah, I give you the American Conservative Union (ACU), prostituting its vaunted philosophical purity in pursuit of filthy lucre.

    It seems FedEx, the package delivery megacorporation, is facing a change in law that may hurt its competitive advantage over United Parcel Service. Legislation pending in Congress would level the playing field.

    As columnist Thomas Frank explained in The Wall Street Journal, "Employees of UPS are covered by one labor law - the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) - while employees of FedEx are governed by a different one, a law that makes it much harder for them to organize a union. Lots of UPS's employees are organized; few of FedEx's are."

    As Frank wrote, the idea that Congress might give FedEx employees "more of a chance to have a say about work conditions" ruffled the company's feathers. Enter the American Conservative Union - which seeks to be "the conservative voice in Washington," according to its web site - and which said it would back FedEx's opposition to the legislation with direct mail, email and phone campaigns, radio ads and the creation of op-ed and other articles by ACU president David Keene and members of its board.

    The ACU said it would only charge FedEx, oh, say, somewhere between two and three million dollars, maybe up to $3.4 million, for its services. FedEx refused to sign for the package. So without batting an eye, the ACU switched its allegiance to UPS, accusing FedEx of fighting dirty. How brave, how principled. How corrupt.

    Summer is no time to be in Washington, the sun and humidity so oppressive that someone once described the sensation as akin to living inside the mouth of a very large dog. But it's not the heat creating the rancid aroma rising from the city. It's the panting exhaust created by the pursuit of money, regardless of country or party or philosophy. It's money that they love, and nothing will change until we disable the ka-ching of the giant Washington cash register and use the money to buy the pay to players a one-way bus ticket out of town.

  

»


Michael Winship is senior writer of the weekly public affairs program Bill Moyers Journal, which airs Friday nights on PBS. Check local airtimes or comment at The Moyers Blog at www.pbs.org/moyers.

Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

We must get election

We must get election reform. It won't solve all the money problems in Washington but it would surely help. Mr. Moyers needs to do another show on getting the big money donors out and the electorate into the way we pay for elections. Go ahead each of us $10. I will gladly pay to play too. Perhaps we need to have new lobby regulation that for each dollar spent by any lobby they must give 5o cents to a fund for a regular- nobody-listens-to-us-anyway voter lobby. Sorry, I am just frustrated as most people are.

As an avid reader of these

As an avid reader of these pages, I can't help thinking that we expend too much energy pointing out and proving that the power elite are greedy, demonstrate hypocrisy, are only out for themselves, etc. I don't believe it advances anything, and I think it is a trap for us, a spinning wheel in the sand. We expend too much energy there, energy that is not productive. I think it is just as addictive and entraining for us, as eating up the right wing propoganda is for the masses of those who are taken by it (and therfore vote and march against their own interests) I think we are taken by this emotionally when we can see the evidence that proves the hypocrisy, etc. And we read and read on, documenting it, commenting on it, being aghast at it etc. It is part of the human condition. It is something we have not risen above. Why should we be surprised (or for that matter angered, morally outraged or anything else). I say, let's spend less time being upset with how corrupt, how disingenuous, how bought off our leaders are. The moral outrage we feel is fueling nothing. Lets fuel the creation of strategy's for change Lets accept already, once and for all, the nature of the beast. Humans can be bent easily by emotion, by identification with the us and banding together against the other. This is generally easy to exploit by those in power. Its the basic condition we operate in. So be it. Let's not keep bemoaning it. Lets do the long hard work of changing it. GS

"...nothing will change

"...nothing will change until we disable the ka-ching of the giant Washington cash register and use the money to buy the pay to players a one-way bus ticket out of town." And just exactly how can "We The People" accomplish this depressing and potentially impossible feat????

"...nothing will change

"...nothing will change until we disable the ka-ching of the giant Washington cash register..." Last I looked, this action can only be defined as "revolution." The American system of government has become a sick joke and it is time to change it. That is our duty as written into the Constitution. At this point in time, we are derelict in our duty.

I desire to move to the

I desire to move to the United States of America. Can anyone tell me where to find it?

Mr. Whiship, how dare you

Mr. Whiship, how dare you cast doubt on congress We have the best government money can buy.

It's absolutely obscene that

It's absolutely obscene that this is allowed to go on. That money would be better spent helping those that are down and out. The folks that run these corporations must have no heart, no conscience and no balls.

I underestimated our

I underestimated our congress. By delaying a vote for weeks while they go home they keep the money coming in. If they don't pass a bill this year, they can bring it up again, (or threaten to bring it up), next year and every year. By simply denying to the American people the representation they were hired for they have created a cash cow and they are not likely to let it die by passing an honest medical bill. We should be proud. We really do have the "Best congress money can buy".

And who among the so-called

And who among the so-called decision makers, pray tell, - if you can - were the recipients of those bounties ? Since they profess to believe in the free market ideology, they ought also to be proud to list the benefactors to whom they owe their successes. Perhaps the disburses of he loot would also be willing to tell whom and what they were buying and how successful they've ben ! After all, their mantra is, "Open covenants, openly arrived at".

We average Americans have no

We average Americans have no real understanding of how slimy all this really is. This stuff is not really happening, is it? Is our government REALLY up for sale? Unreal... Thank god we can still vote (and maybe those votes will actually be counted). The Royalty of our Governors is thoroughly disgusting.

It's been said many times

It's been said many times before that Congress is akin to a "house of prostitution." Until term limits are imposed on all elected officials, it'll be business as usual, whether the issue is health care reform, defense spending, illegal immigration..... And let's not forget a true, viable third party is needed to upset the status quo of the two-party system.

Corruption starts with the

Corruption starts with the first free cigar and grows into a total sellout of the People. We have a duty and an obligation to clean out Washington from time to time: the Constitution requires it of us -- where will this cleansing start? Failed People = Failed government

End corporate personhood,

End corporate personhood, require complete financial disclosure from Federal campaigns, publicly fund Federal campaigns, and restrict all lobbying to a public forum.

The corporate media, an

The corporate media, an institution that looks the other way when politicians sellout. In a survey last year by Media Matters most anchors felt it was their job to present information, not to point out information that they know is false, thus knowingly spreading propaganda, misinformation and lies to the public. With an attitude like that and the corporate owners considering news entertainment, politicians do not have to worry about investigative reporters digging up the truth about their activities that is not entertaining. Of course, the Democratic Party is highly suspect in its real agenda. We are always told they are the people's party. Yet, time after time, they cave to corporate interests. Why do democrats keep making conservatives head of important committees? Senator Max Baucus head of the Finance Committee along with a few of his conservative colleagues are destroying any chance of a health care public option. The best option single payer was DOA, never considered by Obama and the Democratic Congressional leadership. Baucus with his $2 million plus contributions from the insurance industry and high rating from the NRA is the perfect example of what is wrong with US Politics. Why would anyone that is a poster child for corporatism be in charge of any committee? Now, that the republicans are powerless, the well placed democratic conservatives are convenient excuses for the Democratic Party's caving to corporate interests at the expense of the people. The current system rewards the corrupt and unethical, while punishing those standing up for the people's interest. Our government does not work!

there is just way to much

there is just way to much money polluting the political process and the will of the people... we need reforms to address the amount of money non people [eg. organizations] can bring to bear and pay or buy elected representatives... they are elected of the people and are to represent their constituency, why do we have lobby money polluting the interests of elected representatives? Canada is sure looking good to me these days!

Why are we taxpayers paying

Why are we taxpayers paying salaries, health care and retirement for members of congress? Let's stop the pay for the corrupt ones and send them home empty-handed.

One of my favorite sayings:

One of my favorite sayings: If voting could change things, Congress would make it illegal.

How about this... Make

How about this... Make every elected official record every conversation he has with anyone outside his bedroom, and submit it for public review. Make every lobbyist record every conversation he has with anyone outside his bedroom, and submit it for public review. Make it against the law for them to go into their bedroom!

The porch lights at the

The porch lights at the front door of congress should be changed to red ones.

Gee, if they would pay even

Gee, if they would pay even 10% of that in taxes it sure would go far in paying off the debt.

The US needs constitutional

The US needs constitutional reform. "Representative" democracy just doesn't work. What about this: eliminate one branch of Congress; have the people vote directly on laws, maybe every couple of months. Create a parliamentary style of government, with a President who has very little power. A new group of checks and balances.