Share

Do You Know What It Means to Miss New Orleans?

by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t | Columnist

photo
New Orleans resident Robert Green Sr. stands where his mother's home once stood in the lower ninth ward. Green's mother died during the Hurricane. (Photo: Ted Jackson / The Times - Picayune)

    Do you know what it means to miss New Orleans,
    And miss it each night and day?
    I know I'm not wrong, the feeling's getting stronger,
    The longer I stay away ...

    - Louis Armstrong

    The city of New Orleans will be on the minds of many in the coming days and weeks. The four-year anniversary of the worst civil catastrophe in American history - one of the worst such catastrophes in all of human history - will soon be upon us. It was four years ago, the length of one presidential term, that a storm came, and the seas rose, and the levees fell and a city was, for all practical purposes, murdered right before our eyes.

    Four years ago, it happened like this.

    On August 23, 2005, Tropical Depression Twelve swallowed up the remains of Tropical Depression Ten over the Bahamas and Puerto Rico and began moving towards the United States. Two days later, the storm was designated a hurricane and named Katrina. It made landfall in Florida and swung to the south-southwest, gathering strength from the warm waters of the Gulf of Mexico. A day later, the storm's track was recalibrated by the National Hurricane Center, with the line pointing straight into the heart of the Mississippi Delta. Louisiana Gov. Kathleen Blanco declared a state of emergency, and the Louisiana National Guard was mobilized.

    By dawn the next day, Katrina had become a Category 3 hurricane. Evacuations, at first voluntary and later mandatory, were ordered in the parishes that lay across the path of the storm. New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin emphasized to residents of the Ninth Ward to get a head start on the evacuation. Ten truckloads of water and meals were delivered to the Superdome, enough to support 15,000 refugees for three days. That night, George W. Bush was briefed by National Hurricane Center Director Max Mayfield on the status of and potential danger posed by Katrina. Forty minutes after midnight, Katrina became a Category 4 hurricane.

    By 7:00 AM (CDT), Katrina had become a Category 5 hurricane, with maximum sustained winds of 175 mph and gusts up to 215 mph. The storm was expected to make landfall overnight, and New Orleans lay directly in its path. Mayor Nagin ordered the mandatory evacuation of the city, and close to 30,000 people poured into the Superdome seeking shelter. George W. Bush participated in a video conference with Max Mayfield and FEMA Director Michael Brown, who warned Mr. Bush that the storm was more severe than Andrew, was headed directly for New Orleans and the city's levees were in grave danger of collapse. Brown emphatically described Katrina as "the big one." Mr. Bush said exactly 40 words - one sentence promising support - and stayed mute for the rest of the meeting.

    That was Sunday, August 28, 2005, the last day the city of New Orleans would exist as we have known it. At 6:10 AM (CDT) the next day, Katrina made landfall in Louisiana.

    By the end of that Monday, virtually the entire city of New Orleans was under more than ten feet of water. Rooftops began to disappear under the incoming tide. Levee after levee failed, an event later blamed on the Louisiana Army Corps of Engineers, despite the fact that George W. Bush that same year had stripped more than $70 million in funding for the maintenance of those levees - virtually the entire Louisiana COE budget - to pay for his ongoing wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

    Like a slow-motion nightmare, Americans watched the steady annihilation of New Orleans unfold on television while Bush discussed immigration with Homeland Security Director Michael Chertoff, shared a birthday cake photo-op with Sen. John McCain, promoted his Medicare Drug Benefit plan in Arizona and California and went to bed without responding to Governor Blanco's urgent plea for assistance. "Mr. President, we need your help," read the message she had relayed to Bush that day. "We need everything you've got." There would be no reply that day.

    It was not until the middle of the next day that Director Chertoff became aware that the New Orleans levees had failed and that the city was in mortal peril. Mr. Bush played guitar on television with country star Mark Willis next to split-screen images of bodies floating in the floodwaters and scenes of residents "looting" stores, much of which was perpetrated by stranded citizens seeking food and shelter. It had been three days since tens of thousands of people had sought shelter in the Superdome, food and water were running out, sanitary conditions were execrable, the heat became overwhelming and people started dying like insects stuffed in a killing bottle by a cruel, sadistic child. Residents trying to flee across the bridge were turned back at gunpoint. The city of New Orleans finally collapsed into chaos and drowned in salt water on national television.

    A city still stands where New Orleans once was, and bears the same name, but it is not the same city, and never will be again. The death toll will never be known, because the river and the swamp and the sea took so many and kept them, because those who were lost were mostly the unnumbered poor who lacked the means to flee, because back in those days, we didn't do body counts. Thousands upon thousands of the city's residents are still gone four years later, either to the grave or to far-flung points on the compass, evacuees with no way to return home and, in many cases, no homes to return to. Most of the Ninth Ward still remains a sculpture of rubble and destruction to this day.

    What does it mean to miss New Orleans? It means knowing that one of the most golden citadels of our shared history - a cradle of multiculturalism, the birthplace of jazz, seed corn of so much that is America - was allowed to die of neglect, disdain, racism, greed and simple stupidity right before our eyes. A city stands where New Orleans once was, but it is not New Orleans, not really. All that was the city, all that it gave this country, and so many of the people who lived there, are gone forever.

    Do not forget, do not let your children forget, what it means to miss New Orleans.

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.

  

»


William Rivers Pitt is a New York Times and internationally bestselling author of two books: "War on Iraq: What Team Bush Doesn't Want You to Know" and "The Greatest Sedition Is Silence." His newest book, "House of Ill Repute: Reflections on War, Lies, and America's Ravaged Reputation," is now available from PoliPointPress.

Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

It was the events of

It was the events of Hurricane Katrina that sealed my decision to leave the US. If this could happen to American citizens, no one is safe.

When all the disasters are

When all the disasters are counted under Bush and his congress, it is impossible to beleive that these criminals are not being held accountable for their criminal actions! This lack of accountability in the US government, The Executive Branch and Congress included, is an indication of how corrupt the system has become. Despite the good intentions of President Obama, it looks like the "System" will prevail and America will fall by the wayside. More imperialist wars, more financial irresponsibility, higher deficits and less investment in the US infrastruce, i.e education, roads transportation etc. Many Americans, discontented with the future prospects, quality of life, and the lack of good medical care for everyone are moving to Canada and Europe. It appears that the "American Empire" is disintegrating slowly but surely. Other areas in Europe and the Far East are becoming more attractive as the US system fails.

The story was (overly?)

The story was (overly?) grim, and did not report on the areas relatively undamaged by flooding. No section of the city was spared the wind and it's damage but significant sections of the city did not flood. Visitors can see all the same sites they used to enjoy and also take a disaster/recovery tour and visit parts of the city that would not have been on their itinerary pre-Katrina. Devastated areas remain, shrinking with the aid of volunteers from everywhere.

Please "do not forget" to

Please "do not forget" to tell the truthout, the whole truthout and nothing but the truthout should you ever try to spin the Flood of New Orleans by the US Army Corps of Engineers. Their levees and flood walls failed in over 50 locations due to Their Own Engineering Malfeasance. Never attribute to Incompetence what can be explained by Greed. George Bush did not build those floodwalls wrong. The citizens of New Orleans did not build them wrong. Congress did not build them wrong. The various levee boards did not build them wrong. I did not build them wrong, however, I witnessed their failures in New Orleans on 8/29/05. The Corps of Engineers committed Negligent Homicide and you would give them a pass here in your piece 4 years after the crime. The Corps built those failed flood walls WRONG in the first place, tried to lie their way out of it in the 2nd place, and continues to place spinfiltraited articles and public relations pieces across the country trying to blame everyone else for the Corps Failures. You attempt here to misdirect with them. It was a "civil" disaster which was perpetrated by the "Worst CIVIL ENGINEERING Disaster in History" done by the US Army Corps of Engineers. You ruined everything after opening with that myth. You would have the unsuspecting reader look Everywhere BUT at the Corps for the failure of their Engineering. It was not Katrina. IT'S THE LEVEES STUPID.

The levees failed, sure.

The levees failed, sure. But the government failed in its response (rather non response) to the catastrophe once it happened. Even though Brownie did a" heck of a job."

New Orleans is my home away

New Orleans is my home away from home; and I have been there twice now since Katrina. The city is struggling in all areas - many for sale signs, quiet streets that once thrived and fear of walking even with a group of people after dark in previously benign areas of the city. It may eventually recover, but it may also wither away due to lack of interest and concern of the American public. We already have an example of a beautiful city that never recovered a catastrophe already - Detroit. Check out this fantastic photo essay: http://www.time.com/time/photogallery/0,29307,1882089_1850973,00.html. If US citizens have let this happen before, they will let it happen again. This country lost it's way a long time ago... I wonder if we'll ever thrive again?

I disagree that it's "gone

I disagree that it's "gone forever" and I think such a statement makes invisible those who are still there, still struggling to rebuild and heal in the only city they've ever known and continue to love deeply. Is this a time to mourn? Yes, absolutely but don't discount the spirit of the survivors. New Orleans is still alive.

There's plenty of blame go

There's plenty of blame go go around. There were warnings about the vulnerability of N.O. prior to the event. As Katrina was moving toward land, I had been out of the country for over a week and hadn't paid any attention to the weather in the U.S. The night before it made landfall I was reading a National Geographic article about the faulty levees and the Mississippi River Gulf Outlet. As I was boarding my plane to return home, I saw the graphics on the TVs at the gate--it was like a premonition come true. There was a web of incompetence that allowed the disaster to occur. You could consider the dredging of the wetlands around New Orleans going back decades as part of the web. There wasn't much to stop the wind and storm surge as a result of that. To ameliorate that damage, levees were built but not maintained and the Corp of Engineers will have to live with that one. State and local officials could have done a better job of preparing for the worst, but the big share blame has to go to the Bush administration for sheer incompetence and apathy. A decade earlier Hurricane Andrew ripped through Florida and FEMA was there in force to relieve victims. Bush, with his naive belief that "government is the problem" seemed determined to make it a reality by cutting funds for FEMA and other sources of relief. Apparently voters got the message and voted in Democrats to Congress in '06, then again in '08 to Congress and the White House.

In the aftermath, the

In the aftermath, the neocons had a field day blaming everyone but the miscreant Bush, President codpiece who preferred to fund illegal and unnecessary wars rather than provide competent disaster relief and funding for flood protection. They would have had you believe it was Blanco didn't ask for help soon enough, or Nagin who didn't use all the school buses, or the Corps of Engineers who didn't know how to build levees, or those poor residents with no cars or money who didn't evacuate when they were told to, thus absolving the real perpetrator at the top of the U.S. government of all responsibility for their grotesque incompetence and cavalier attitude toward the suffering. I spent 4 years at Tulane and love New Orleans. Yes I know what it means to miss New Orleans and I'm sick at heart about all those people who were relocated from their ancestral homes never to be able to return. And I know who the hell to blame for it!

I just spent four of the

I just spent four of the happiest months of my life in that still-great, gorgeous, joyful, colorful, extraordinary city of N'Awlins. It is far from dead, it is alive with young people streaming in from all over the U.S. to party and make families and dedicate themselves to restoring the city. It is not dead, it is alive with people who live with passion and joy and appreciation of all the shabby/elegant beauty and music and FOOD that the city offers. Anyone who believes the city is dead needs to get them selves down there and get with Habitat for Humanity and learn to build, and help to heal. Yes, oh yes, a terrible tragedy occurred, but New Orleans is coming back.

I appreciate the desire and

I appreciate the desire and sadness of this piece, but I take issue with "A city stands where New Orleans once was, but it is not New Orleans, not really." It is New Orleans after the storm, just as San Francisco was after earthquakes, Detroit and Washington DC after the riots. Cities are social systems that evolve. If we deny this fact then ennui sets in and rebirth is that much more of a struggle. To say that New Orleans of July 2005 was the same as New Orleans July 1995 is a lie. Each Jazzfest, each Mardi Gras, each Bayou Classic is different with elements that remain constant. The cultural elements that make New Orleans remain. We are a generation that has not experienced real upheaval. I would argue, however, that the city's relationship to the United States and vice-versa has been forever changed. And, I'm OK with that. We are unique and we have choices. Let us create from what has been damaged.

Everybody laments New

Everybody laments New Orleans, but in Mississippi, where the eye actually hit, Hancock County, Waveland and Bay St. Louis, Pearlington and across the bay bridge, Pass Christian the devastation was total. The landscape was leveled and covered with mud left by 30 to 40 feet of flood waters that surged across our communities taking not just structures, but trees and everything living with it, first teddy bears, a great grandmother's cherished keepsake, our church, our job, our home, our way of life, never to come back, never. Changing our lives forever, forever, wonderful productive lives wiped out one morning, never to return. Of course there is rebuilding, but life for most everyone will never be the same, a thing most people will never even begin to understand. But the storm came, destroyed, and then left. Left us to rebuild, but left just the same. In countries torn by war, the storm comes and stays and that I held on to those first terrible days digging through the mud to find anything that could remind me of who I was. I could go on. I had choices. A luxury most people in the world are not lucky enough to have. I can only hope that those "poor, unnumbered" people who have not come back to New Orleans have made a better life for themselves somewhere else, somewhere where they have a chance to count for the first time in many of their lives.. The levy break devastated the city, but long before that it was already broken. It forgot most of its children unless you had money to afford a "private" school. It ignored thousands of people barely surviving each day. For these people the city was not a shining center of culture and entertainment, but a dangerous and cruel existence. Now they have new lives and it seems they were not so "expendable" after all. It seems they were the heart of the city. And going on without a heart is going to be a difficult thing.

They knew the levees were

They knew the levees were weak, and they could even tell you where they were going to fail. It was the lack of funding that destroyed New Orleans. If they had fixed the levees, there would have been no disaster. It was a criminal act to not fix the levees and prepare New Orleans for disaster they knew would come.

This was perhaps the

This was perhaps the greatest criminal act of the Bush Administration, and the Obama Administration has done nothing to ameliorate the situation and so shares fully in the criminal irresponsibility. "Yes, we can?" No, you can't!

There is much to be lamented

There is much to be lamented but more than that there is much to be done. In his zeal Mr. Pitt has written off New Orleans much like Mr. Bush, his cronies and most of the rest of the nation have: "What does it mean to miss New Orleans? It means knowing that one of the most golden citadels of our shared history - a cradle of multiculturalism, the ... Read Morebirthplace of jazz, seed corn of so much that is America - was allowed to die of neglect, disdain, racism, greed and simple stupidity right before our eyes. A city stands where New Orleans once was, but it is not New Orleans, not really. All that was the city, all that it gave this country, and so many of the people who lived there, are gone forever." New Orleans has a long history of destruction, always dying and always being reborn. It did not die and is not dead except to those who blithely say it is. Likely they do not know, do not live there and have no understanding of the brutal yet vital dynamics of this place. Unfortunately, Mr. Pitt inflicts even more harm than good by means of his essay. Instead he is writing off the city, the people, their resilience and abiding love of the city. There are many who struggle daily and are battling enormous odds on many fronts to heal it and make it right. Mr. Pitt would better serve New Orleans by understanding what needs to be done and encouraging people to help in the right ways with the ongoing efforts to make things better here.

William, I am a HUGE fan of

William, I am a HUGE fan of yours, and I agree that New Orleans could use more support, more attention from the federal government, but as a New Orleanian, I take issue with your statement that New Orleans not being New Orleans anymore. I moved here in the early 90s and instantly fell in love with the city's spirit, the people, the unique culture rich with second lines, jazz funerals, mardi gras indians, impromptu brass band performances by high school kids, and creole tomatoes, festivals every month of the year, the beautiful river and more. I lost my home and most of my possessions in Katrina, and lived in 4 different cities before deciding I had to come back. Why? Because no other city in America has what New Orleans had - or I would strongly argue - still has. This weekend we celebrated Louis Armstrong's birthday at the annual Satchmo Summerfest in the French Quarter (which was undamaged by Katrina). Local trumpeter/cultural ambassador Kermit Ruffins led the crowd at the end of the day Sunday with a heartwarming sing-a-long tribute of What a Wonderful World. Recently in City Park, 9 kids with brass instruments blew out an amazing performance for themselves and maybe 5 or 6 other lucky people who happened to be nearby. We have more restaurants - amazing ones at that - than we did before the storm. And most of my friends have returned - even those who lived in the 9th Ward and lost everything. I could go on and on about how New Orleans has triumphed in the face of adversity, corruption and neglect. We pulled this place back together on our own, without much help of the federal, state or local governments and we'll continue to do so, because there's no other place like it in the world. I'd love it if you could come on down and visit. As a fan of your work, I'd personally love to meet you and show you around the city.

Another nail for W's coffin:

Another nail for W's coffin: I went to just outside NO two weeks later to help and interviewed the Engineer in charge of the levee for District 9. During his de-traumatization he told between sobs, "After the storm passed I saw many soldiers going up on my (sic) levee so I went out to see what was up. It was the Army Corps or Engineers. Suddenly they began screaming 'Run, run!' and an explosion threw me to the ground. Then water began swarming in so I ran for my family..." Who gave the order for that explosion set off by the ACE?

If recent disasters in

If recent disasters in America is the subject, here are some observations. We got a clue to the Bush 43 mindset when the NYC Twin Towers were not replaced with all due haste. The terrorists changed New York City's skyline; they won. VP Cheney kept his "Energy Policy Meetings " secret, so we would be in the dark about Peak Oil, reason to revamp transport policy as prelude to getting off imported oil. Round two for the bad boys here & abroad.. Katrina cometh, and US Corps of Engineers, after the fact, proved unable to muster full logistic resources for cleanup, salvage and recovery. Round three for bad decisions made long before the storm appeared. Katrina demonstrated a few lessons, however. One thing, the rail connection to the port was fixed by the Railroad company, using some salvaged bridge wreckage, and private skills & initiative. Part of the Army's problem goes back a generation, to the abandonment of the Army National Guard Railroad Operating & Maintenance Battalions. Katrina's path still shows signs of the rail branchlines. Some with rail in place, these could have been used by the military rail units for cleanup. More than a passing fancy, the threat to America posed by future storms, homeland attack, and energy crisis invites recommissioned military rr units. US Army & National Guard unit office adjutants -with initiative- can obtain James A. Van Fleet's "Rail Transport And The Winning Of Wars", from the Association Of American Railroads librarian (202-639-2100). Others, not ready for train talk, see James Howard Kunstler's "The Long Emergency", and writings of Richard Heinberg.

Yes, I moved there in time

Yes, I moved there in time for Hurricane Betsy and left 2 years, 3 months later. Small cog in civil rights work. The AFTERMATH of Katrina was one more crime of the "W" administration, including levees, drainage, destroying good public housing, etc See writing by Bill Quigley, NOLA attorney, who was on the air by phone during aftermath, to DemocracyNow. Where's the change? in gov't policy.

Just after Katrina I marched

Just after Katrina I marched against the Bush administration and the wars and against the brutal and obvious genocide in New Orleans at a major protest in Washington, DC. Beside me marched a survivor from the 9th Ward and silently he held a crude, but not crude enough for the moment, sign, hand lettered in red upon what appeared to be a piece of a plank from a deluged front porch. It read simply: "Shame." That was something, as well as empathy, unknown to the Bush Administration. May its cruel history not be drowned like the poor of New Orleans. Remember Katrina and New Orleans before the "opportunity" changed it, and us, forever.

Dear William, Hi from New

Dear William, Hi from New Orleans! I'm at CC's on Esplanade, the cafe' under the oaks between the Quarter and NOMA, with a cool river breeze. And guess what! an internet connection! and my lovely little house, right down the street where it's been for 100+ years. Although I usually enjoy your work and I appreciate your continued concern, I really don't like your obituary. Yes we are still struggling, but we are not out. We are not dead. Some of our friends and loved ones are dead and dying, and that hurts. Why don't you write about Jindal closing NOAH while preparing to run for president? Some national attention on that issue would help us tremendously. New Orleans is not dead, yes it's changed but evolution is part of life everywhere. You are wrong to say all that was the city is gone forever. Like my buddy Jeremy, if you ever come to visit, send an email and we'll show you what it means to LIVE in New Orleans. Love, Amy

As a New Orleanian, I am in

As a New Orleanian, I am in complete agreement with the views expressed in Jeremy's comment. While I agree that the New Orleans of today is not identical to the New Orleans of 2005, 1880, 1950 or 1718. I agree that the trauma Katrina inflicted threatened and forever changed the New Orleans-that-was. It exposed all of the inequality that existed for so long and persists to this day. There are no words that can express the pain enduring by those who lost their lives or loved ones before, during, and after Katrina (to be honest, I feel queasy each time I type, hear or speak that name, and I think I always will). But the story of New Orleans--the story of the city itself and the people who are gone and those who remain--cannot be told in the form of a eulogy nor can it be composed like an epitaph engraved on a tomb. New Orleans is not dead. I was born and raised in New Orleans,and like my ancestors who came before me, I will continue to make New Orleans my home--I will share the struggle and the joy with those still living, and pay tribute to those who look down from above. Some people say that we are stubborn, naive or just plain crazy to live here, but those words don't capture our spirit in the slightest. "Love" is the only word that comes close. Love doesn't always feel carefree or look perfect, but Love endures with patience, passion and persistent effort--even in the face of disaster. Our Native Sons and Daughters, as well as those who come from far away to make this city their home, are survivors. We're still here. It is for those reasons that I think this story is incomplete--it lacks its other "half". I think that writing another part of the story examining what is happening now and what needs to happen next would be a step in the right direction.

New Orleanians are what

New Orleanians are what makes New Orleans great and over 60% of us have struggled to return home. It is a little different, but it is definitely still New Orleans. We had salt water up to the ceiling fan blades for weeks after the New Orleans outfall canal floodwalls collapsed long before even being overtopped by storm surge waters because of stupid engineering mistakes in the floodwall foundation designs by made by engineers employed by the US Army Corps of Engineers as reported in all three of the levee failure investigation reports. The Army may as well have carpet bombed our city. Normally, if an entity causes an innocent party damage, that entity is liable for those damages and it is appropriate for the damaged party to expect restitution from the damaging entity. But, not in New Orleans. Nope, the law of the land does not apply here. Had this happened anywhere else... Our man made disaster is ongoing and it would be nice if the current administration kept the unmet promises of the previous administration or at least do a third of the NOLA recovery related campaign promises by the current administration. Meanwhile, we are doing the best we can. Personally, we rebuilt on our same lot, but above the Katrina flood line. We're hurting. Ain't nothing easy here. Insurance, property taxes and utilities are through the roof. Nevertheless, we are delighted we are doing as well as we are. My family moved here in 1765 and its going to take a lot more than government negligence and floods to get rid of us.

To write off New Orleans is

To write off New Orleans is to write off the indomitable spirit of its inhabitants. I was privileged to spend the years from 2003-2005 working on a project at the Napoleon Avenue Container Terminal and came to think of New Orleans as the city of my heart. I have been to the city since Katrina. While the callous and criminal behavior of the Bush administration, contributed to its physical destruction, I have seen, firsthand, how the spirit of this extraordinary city could not be crushed. New Orleans will rise again. We can mourn the loss of the city that existed before Katrina, but we must also celebrate the city that can never completely be destroyed.

You would think that after

You would think that after four years, I wouldn't cry every time I read about the federal flood of 2005 but I still do. As we come upon the anniversary, I am just thrilled that not even a hint of a hurricane has dotted our door. All praise the the universe. I have only brought my mom home this weekβ€”on my own meager dimeβ€”because I feared she, like so many other elders, would die of the stress. Thanks for keeping the world mindful.

Sometimes, the most

Sometimes, the most interesting thing about articles are the comments they generate. Reading these comments, is like writing my own essay. So much to say, so little space to say it in. I do want to comment on two things: One, New Orleans lives. Two: As a native New Orleanian, I try to be conscious of the fact that the Gulf Coast suffered this disaster, that the physical storm of Katrina did not hit Louisiana (well, it did hit Grand Isle), it hit Mississippi. However, New Orleans is and most likely always will be America's unwanted stepchild because we refuse to be homogenized. Proud to be be a New Orleanian.

If the wisdom of the people

If the wisdom of the people has any validity nowadays (and it is always the wisest of all), New Orleans was actually the second, not the first American city wounded intentionally and terribly by the demonic duo of Bush and Chenney - New York City was the first on 9/11/01. It is a very damning precedent that Obama is setting for all of us by not bringing these monsters to trial and jail.

Reagan said government is

Reagan said government is not the solution it is the problem. Many people mistake what he meant. His statement was not an observation; it was a statement of direction for the neocons to do all that they could to create problems using government as the tool. And the success has been spectacular, in the sense that great cataclysms are spectacular. But the effect on the ground has been devastating.

'82-'83 I lived on London

'82-'83 I lived on London Ave between Leon C. Simon and R.E. Lee. Every morning as I walked down London Ave. on my way to the U of N.O., I noticed the potholes were full of water and would ponder, "Did it rain this morning?" Then I pondered the possibility of the the dike leaking. Never, in my wildest paranoia did I contemplate the absolute failure of everything.

How can nobody be held

How can nobody be held responsible for the failing of all the government agencies.? It seems as if the citizens of the US are just being ground down to accept however they are treated by an uncaring government, to be more ready for the next event.

I teach a course on the

I teach a course on the Holocaust and ask my students each semester to contemplate what it was that Germans voted for when the Nazi Party was legitimately elected to power. It wasn't the specific plans, but rather the rhetoric and the consequences I ask them to consider. Why should anyone be surprised that the government failed when for decades prior to this catastrophe Americans voted for politicians and parties that argued that government was the problem? That money should be taken out of so-called "entitlement" programs so that they (the voters) could pay less taxes. Having lived in New Orleans myself--and I too mourn the disaster and some aspects of the city it was-- I must also say that its voting citizens bought into short-term privilege like everyone else in the US. The scenes I witnessed with tears in my eyes on television told me not just about New Orleans, but about the national soul--which we sold for short-term gain. Please tell me Americans, that the last election signaled a conscience. Health-care reform simply can not be about our personal short-term gain, but about a proud country that has a conscience!

Mr. Karlsson: I ache for

Mr. Karlsson: I ache for N.O. and I, too, do not wish to write it off. If Rahm Emanuel could just get himself fired, a lot of the promised Obama improvements could be liberated.

How quickly the rightwingers

How quickly the rightwingers forgot that Cuba, itself in recovery from hurricane damage, sent a hospital ship into the Gulf to help with rescue and healing in Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas. . . and Bush refused to let them dock.