Share

Republicans, Religion and the Triumph of Unreason

by: Johann Hari  |  The Independent UK

photo
Barack Obama's presidency has spurred an onslaught of bizarre reactions from the right wing. (Photo: Reuters)

    How do they train themselves to be so impervious to reality?

    Something strange has happened in America in the nine months since Barack Obama was elected. It has best been summarised by the comedian Bill Maher: "The Democrats have moved to the right, and the Republicans have moved to a mental hospital."

    The election of Obama - a black man with an anti-conservative message - as a successor to George W. Bush has scrambled the core American right's view of their country. In their gut, they saw the US as a white-skinned, right-wing nation forever shaped like Sarah Palin.

    When this image was repudiated by a majority of Americans in a massive landslide, it simply didn't compute. How could this have happened? How could the cry of "Drill, baby, drill" have been beaten by a supposedly big government black guy? So a streak that has always been there in the American right's world-view - to deny reality, and argue against a demonic phantasm of their own creation - has swollen. Now it is all they can see.

    Since Obama's rise, the US right has been skipping frantically from one fantasy to another, like a person in the throes of a mental breakdown. It started when they claimed he was a secret Muslim, and - at the same time - that he was a member of a black nationalist church that hated white people. Then, once these arguments were rejected and Obama won, they began to argue that he was born in Kenya and secretly smuggled into the United States as a baby, and the Hawaiian authorities conspired to fake his US birth certificate. So he is ineligible to rule and the office of President should pass to... the Republican runner-up, John McCain.

    These aren't fringe phenomena: a Research 200 poll found that a majority of Republicans and Southerners say Obama wasn't born in the US, or aren't sure. A steady steam of Republican congressmen have been jabbering that Obama has "questions to answer". No amount of hard evidence - here's his birth certificate, here's a picture of his mother heavily pregnant in Hawaii, here's the announcement of his birth in the local Hawaiian paper - can pierce this conviction.

    This trend has reached its apotheosis this summer with the Republican Party now claiming en masse that Obama wants to set up "death panels" to euthanise the old and disabled. Yes: Sarah Palin really has claimed - with a straight face - that Barack Obama wants to kill her baby.

    You have to admire the audacity of the right. Here's what's actually happening. The US is the only major industrialised country that does not provide regular healthcare to all its citizens. Instead, they are required to provide for themselves - and 50 million people can't afford the insurance. As a result, 18,000 US citizens die every year needlessly, because they can't access the care they require. That's equivalent to six 9/11s, every year, year on year. Yet the Republicans have accused the Democrats who are trying to stop all this death by extending healthcare of being "killers" - and they have successfully managed to put them on the defensive.

    The Republicans want to defend the existing system, not least because they are given massive sums of money by the private medical firms who benefit from the deadly status quo. But they can't do so honestly: some 70 per cent of Americans say it is "immoral" to retain a medical system that doesn't cover all citizens. So they have to invent lies to make any life-saving extension of healthcare sound depraved.

    A few months ago, a recent board member for several private health corporations called Betsy McCaughey reportedly noticed a clause in the proposed healthcare legislation that would pay for old people to see a doctor and write a living will. They could stipulate when (if at all) they would like care to be withdrawn. It's totally voluntary. Many people want it: I know I wouldn't want to be kept alive for a few extra months if I was only going to be in agony and unable to speak. But McCaughey started the rumour that this was a form of euthanasia, where old people would be forced to agree to death. This was then stretched to include the disabled, like Palin's youngest child, who she claimed would have to "justify" his existence. It was flatly untrue - but the right had their talking-point, Palin declared the non-existent proposals "downright evil", and they were off.

    It's been amazingly successful. Now, every conversation about healthcare has to begin with a Democrat explaining at great length that, no, they are not in favour of killing the elderly - while Republicans get away with defending a status quo that kills 18,000 people a year. The hypocrisy was startling: when Sarah Palin was Governor of Alaska, she encouraged citizens there to take out living wills. Almost all the Republicans leading the charge against "death panels" have voted for living wills in the past. But the lie has done its work: a confetti of distractions has been thrown up, and support is leaking away from the plan that would save lives.

    These increasingly frenzied claims have become so detached from reality that they often seem like black comedy. The right-wing magazine US Investors' Daily claimed that if Stephen Hawking had been British, he would have been allowed to die at birth by its "socialist" healthcare system. Hawking responded with a polite cough that he is British, and "I wouldn't be here without the NHS".

    This tendency to simply deny inconvenient facts and invent a fantasy world isn't new; it's only becoming more heightened. It ran through the Bush years like a dash of bourbon in water. When it became clear that Saddam Hussein had no weapons of mass destruction, the US right simply claimed they had been shipped to Syria. When the scientific evidence for man-made global warming became unanswerable, they claimed - as one Republican congressman put it - that it was "the greatest hoax in human history", and that all the world's climatologists were "liars". The American media then presents itself as an umpire between "the rival sides", as if they both had evidence behind them.

    It's a shame, because there are some areas in which a conservative philosophy - reminding us of the limits of grand human schemes, and advising caution - could be a useful corrective. But that's not what these so-called "conservatives" are providing: instead, they are pumping up a hysterical fantasy that serves as a thin skin covering some raw economic interests and base prejudices.

    For many of the people at the top of the party, this is merely cynical manipulation. One of Bush's former advisers, David Kuo, has said the President and Karl Rove would mock evangelicals as "nuts" as soon as they left the Oval Office. But the ordinary Republican base believe this stuff. They are being tricked into opposing their own interests through false fears and invented demons. Last week, one of the Republicans sent to disrupt a healthcare town hall started a fight and was injured - and then complained he had no health insurance. I didn't laugh; I wanted to weep.

    How do they train themselves to be so impervious to reality? It begins, I suspect, with religion. They are taught from a young age that it is good to have "faith" - which is, by definition, a belief without any evidence to back it up. You don't have "faith" that Australia exists, or that fire burns: you have evidence. You only need "faith" to believe the untrue or unprovable. Indeed, they are taught that faith is the highest aspiration and most noble cause. Is it any surprise this then percolates into their political views? Faith-based thinking spreads and contaminates the rational.

    Up to now, Obama has not responded well to this onslaught of unreason. He has had a two-pronged strategy: conciliate the elite economic interests, and joke about the fanatical fringe they are stirring up. He has (shamefully) assured the pharmaceutical companies that an expanded healthcare system will not use the power of government as a purchaser to bargain down drug prices, while wryly saying in public that he "doesn't want to kill Grandma". Rather than challenging these hard interests and bizarre fantasies aggressively, he has tried to flatter and soothe them.

    This kind of mania can't be co-opted: it can only be overruled. Sometimes in politics you will have enemies, and they must be democratically defeated. The political system cannot be gummed up by a need to reach out to the maddest people or the greediest constituencies. There is no way to expand healthcare without angering Big Pharma and the Republicaloons. So be it. As Arianna Huffington put it, "It is as though, at the height of the civil rights movement, you thought you had to bring together Martin Luther King and George Wallace and make them agree. It's not how change happens."

    However strange it seems, the Republican Party really is spinning off into a bizarre cult who believe Barack Obama is a baby-killer plotting to build death panels for the grannies of America. Their new slogan could be - shrill, baby, shrill.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

This kind of essay--as smart

This kind of essay--as smart and compelling as it is--will make no difference. That's because it is directed to those who already agree with its premise and the supporting details. To the degree that Mr. Hari seeks change--and not just analysis--he should find a way to talk to the masses of folks who believe all those lies. For example, he should send a simplified version of this piece to newspapers in the south. Better, he should present his ideas on YouTube. Even better, he should take a tour of the South and address the "true believers" face to face--in their churches, in their town halls, on the public square. Or how about working with a popular country and western group whose music might get past the blinders that the religionists and know-nothingists wear? Maybe I'm limited in my imagination. But until we figure out a way to engage those who oppose science and progress and making sure everyone has the basics (housing, healthcare, education), nothing will change. As for me, I regularly post on right-wing blogs and send letters to Southern newspapers. Is this making a difference? Maybe not. But I know that the problem isn't with the folks who read Truthout. Murray Suid Marin, California

Great story, thanks!

Great story, thanks!

"The election of Obama - a

"The election of Obama - a black man with an anti-conservative message - as a successor to George W. Bush has scrambled the core American right's view of their country. In their gut, they saw the US as a white-skinned, right-wing nation forever shaped like Sarah Palin." Look deeper my friends in the U.K. Obama is a pro-death penality, neo-liberal. All the appointees on the Senate Finance Committee (Baucus and the other RIGHT WING DEMOCRATS) could easily be replaced by REID per Obama's orders. Obama's public option is just a show.

A wonderful analysis. The

A wonderful analysis. The U.S. seems destined to become a second rate power because of the greed and narrow-mindedness of so many American citizens. One needs to be reminded, too, of the significance of hardcore fundamentalists in our military establishment to see the extent of this cancerous trend in our society.

We are a nation of sheep.

We are a nation of sheep. Spread the word.

Better make that 18,001.

Better make that 18,001. Don't forget the young lady that needed a liver transplant. She had insurance, but the insurer wouldn't pay for it until a hue and cry in the media by then it was too late. How many people die even though they had coverage and were denied life saving operations by their insurance companies? That might be a eye opener. Ed

This is a wonderful article

This is a wonderful article and should be shared with as many as possible. Email it to your friends.

Absolutely true. But the

Absolutely true. But the Left is just as hysterically blind in its own fashion. They believed the campaign promises of a machine-trained politician. They believed that the Constitution is inviolable and will easily returned to whatever they think it was. They believe, just like the Right, that "justice" is on their side, and must therefor prevail. They simply don't understand why and can't really believe that half of America was fooled twice, and almost a third time, into trusting G.W. Bush. It must have been a trick. Well folks, it's ALL a trick. We_won't_get universal single-payer, not because Rahm and the Blue Dogs are mean people, but because those issues don't have a deep-pocket constituency (like Pharma, Insurance, and the AMA). And the Dems have been out of power so long they no longer know how to use it. Rahm is Obama's junk-yard dog, making things work and keeping the troops in line. But Obama has no clue about the realities of the poor and the unorganized, and so doesn't know how to point Rahm in the right (left) direction. There's so much more, but this is a good hint.

this guy is absolutely

this guy is absolutely correct. Republicans are nutcakes NOT believing that the government can and should do everything for everyone because the peons do not have the mental capability to think and do for themselves. It's unfortunate that only a select group has the knowledge, compassion and initiative to be able to know what's best for the peons. Only Democrats don't want to kill poor old granny, only Democrats are reasonable, and no Democrat ever believed that Saddam had any weapons of mass destruction, no Democrat voted to go to Iraq. and on and on.

Nice writing. I get the

Nice writing. I get the sense that Barack Obama is banking on the understated approach so as not to aggravate forces that could bring a skinny upstart black guy down and out. JFK wasn't even skinny or black, but down and out he went. So, I can imagine Obama senses he's on delicate turf. There's something about American individualism that just doesn't feel all that chummy about the idea of togetherness. There's still a great swoon for individual achievement, going it alone, each to their own efforts, hands off, no help to the slouches, fend for yourself, great riches come to those who do the hard work to achieve greatness, and everyone who doesn't is lazy or some Darwinian proof of naturally being selected out of doing very well in life. The consensus is still this frenzy to guard and protect one's own coconuts, and not let anyone else get their greedy little hands on one's own hard won assets. And bully for me for how far I've gotten on my own. But all that feels petty now. It probably worked when the frontier spirits had everyone so spread out and having to go it alone for long stretches. But the US has grown to be hundreds of millions of people within much closer proximity. The effects we have on each other are much more immediate. And the inequities much more glaring and unsettling. What is the common good when everyone's busy being an individual looking out for their own singular gain? What profit a man (and I think this is gender related, though not absolutely so) if they gain great advantage for themselves to the disadvantage of those around him? What if profit were extended to include the well being of the whole society and not just one's own exclusive gain? Short of a cultural shift like that, we can expect more money grubbing and exclusive power grabbing and compromising others for individual advantage in the name of preserving the Constitution and defending all that America stands for.

An excellent take on our

An excellent take on our political posture, but not going that last unpleasant step: 99.9% of Obama's detractors are white. The never dreamed that McCain could actually lose. Their feedback loop (other whites) confirmed that daily. Obama did not, in fact win the white vote; hispanics and blacks put him in office. Whites feel cheated of an easy victory by forces that turn their world-view upside down. Whites see their dominance slipping away and it scares them. They are fighting back by the only means offered them, discrediting the victor and the victory. Frankly, I'm not sure these people can ever be brought on board; it may just be a bridge too far for them. The Obama train has left the station though; get on board or get left at the station shaking your fist. I think I know which they will do. ttommyunger-twitter

Please, the many tirades

Please, the many tirades against the right only add fuel to the fire. As long as the left/right bashing continues there can be no reasonable national discussion on any topic. Over the previous 3 presidential terms I have seen the bickering become more feverish. From Clinton's affair, through the many ups and downs of the Bush years, and now with Obama one cannot escape from wild theories and shameless bashing of political and social celebrities. It is time to move past the left/right distraction and instead fight national ignorance and corruption with truth, reason, and a careful balance of passion and self-control.

Not much different from -

Not much different from - shill baby shill, just louder.

They didn't expect it. They

They didn't expect it. They thought all Americans were as ignorant and arrogant, if not downright stupid, like themselves. They assumed most Americans were bigots, racists, nationalist socialists (fascists or Nazis) brain-washed fundamental bible thumping flag waving white southern bred hypocrites. The best thing of all is, they will never get over it. The best they can do is yell, shout, cuss and scream bloody murder, communists, leftist, internationalists, and just about every nasty word they can come out with. All that is a virtue for them. They do not know know the meaning of what truth, much less reality, is. They have self-destruct to the point that they will never be normal again, as if they were normal at all! They have become the most stupid class of people on the planet. I love it!

So, what will we do about

So, what will we do about it? Rant, rave, wring our hands? Or will we get into the streets and onto the airwaves and Internet and insist that America come home to herself? Probably not - It's easier to carp from the sidelines.

Much of the right-wing

Much of the right-wing histrionics and hysteria generation is simply psychological warfare. And it owes much of its effectiveness to its ability to monopolize the stage- abetted, incidentally, by the major American news media, who persist in giving it top billing in the headlines, for weeks on end. That emphasis pushes other perspectives out of public notice. And that's the most successful aspect of rightw-ing demonization of Obama- since it puts him in the position of being the embodiment of the American Left. Once that premise is given credence, anyone criticizing Obama from a viewpoint further to the Left must necessarily represent the lunatic fringe- and hence not even worth allowing air time. Perhaps the most warped thing about the character of the present "two-party system" is the difference in how the two teams play. The Republicans get their game face on, and begin from a position so extreme and intractable that, simply through inertial force, it draws the discourse to the right. The hardline opening position also provides considerable room for "concessions" that can only be considered so in the relative sense, i.e., in relation to the original extremism of the stance. An example of how that works: Ann Coulter suddenly starts getting praised for representing the voice of sober and respectable conservatism, simply because she's voiced her disdain of the "birther" allegations. That's all tht's required for the punditocracy to recast her public image into a moderate, ccntrist voice of reason. The Republicans game plan is that the best defense is a good offense. The Democratic leadership doesn't even seem capable of playing offense when they have the ball. Please, everyone- support Instant Runoff Voting. It's an absolutely necessary precondition for building new parties and alternative political movements with impact at the ballot box in this country.

There are a lot of confused

There are a lot of confused people who don't have any health-care, or have very inferior coverage. If you are already at rock bottom, the only place to go is up as you have nothing to lose and everything to gain, yet they drink the Kool-Aid. How dumb is that?

Please, let's not engage in

Please, let's not engage in name calloing- one of the problems Obama faces is his inexperience, not just in the Presidency, but in the Senate. Instead of running around the country calling town meetings, he should be button-holing Congresspeople and Senators, telling them what he wants, not what he'll settle for (you don't negotiate from your bottom position) insisting they get out the votes of the rest of the Democratic Senate and House, and stop trying to get a consensus with the opposition. No more pussy-footing around, trying to get agreement, no more watering down public option. The best way to get medical coverage for everyone is to expand Medicare to everyone. The system is set up, the way is paved- now GET ON IT!

I went to a town hall

I went to a town hall meeting this morning and it was a parade of stupidity equal to any of the others I've seen videos of (though without the guns, happily). Most of the questions were idiotic and the answers (from our Congressman Sylvestre Reyes) weren't much better. Reyes' office had prepared a very good handout debunking the false claims about the reform bill, but it seemed he himself hadn't even read it. He seemed more interested in campaigning than answering people's questions, and thus just fed the right-wing wackos' suspicions that the whole thing is a socialist scam. Of course, of any of them would READ they'd have a clue about what is and isn't being proposed. If people are that gullible that they can be brought out to agitate against their own interests, I guess they don't deserve any better.

Sad fact: as a recent poll

Sad fact: as a recent poll showed, they are winning this propaganda war. Obama's poll numbers have dropped dramatically and unless health care with a public option is passed this year, the government will again end up in the hands of these vile creatures in 2010. In discussions of the law, ignorance is no excuse, but in politics it is a given in political strategy that if you can get a small, vocal group yelling in a crowd, you can control the crowd and ignorance of the facts helps feed the people doing the yelling. Many a politician, including Barney Frank this week, have tried to ignore this fact, and have failed to quell the rising tide of insanity. There is, however, a way to stop a bully - you stand up to him/her and hold your ground. This is what the President should be doing, not following the advice of the likes of Harry Reid, Nancy Pelosi, or Rahm Emanuel, all of whom have corporate/lobbyist ties so deep that they could be considered liable of conflict of interest charges. The President wanted to hear when he was screwing up, so write, phone, e-mail and fax the White House and the President if you are dissatisfied. Go to town hall meetings and stand up quietly ask your question, and if someone tries to drown you out, walk up to the stage and ask your question without a microphone, then turn and face the person who is shouting and stare him/her down, never saying a word, just staring. It worked when you were a child, and it will work now because you are still dealing with a child. It is time to take back the public discourse from the corporations, the dupes, and the Republicans. We do it now, or we lose it and our country forever.

I'm really hoping that Obama

I'm really hoping that Obama figures out soon that this is like high school politics...where lies, innuendo and plain evil will win the day if the perps are not publicly exposed and humiliated. Obama must take off his gloves, expose the liars for what they are, make it a social embarrassment to be a part of the right wing. If he capitulates to these puppet masters and their puppets, all will be lost. He will lose the support of those who still believe in this country.

It drives me crazy that

It drives me crazy that people talk about living wills, etc. and seeing a doctor about it. I have end of life documents - my lawyer prepared them. I have no idea who will be my doctor when my end of life arrives.

What we are witness to are

What we are witness to are these days are closely related to existing ongoing facts...... or fiction..? Fact or Fiction..? America is almost completely owned, operated and exploited by GLOBAL Corporations... and WE the People have become merely WE the American Consumer... Fact or Fiction..? American Media is almost completely owned, operated and exploited by just a few gigantic GLOBAL Corporations..? Fact or Fiction..? This all occurred over recent Republican Decades under the 'Flim Flam' foisting of 'Less Government'.. which really meant-- Less Government Regulation of Corporations... Fact or Fiction..?... American Education now ranks quite low in the Industrial world.. (after years under the 'Less Government Regime)..and has for long enough now that what we see on TV in the Insane Healthcare NONDEBATE is the obvious outcome when Global Corporate Media meets the rubber band brains of millions of overworked, under educated, I-got-mine-screw-you crowd easily led to act against their own best interests with passion because Wealthy Talking Head Pundits of National Division For Profit told them too in between laughing all the way to the Bank... :-D

JUST SAY, "GET OVER IT":

JUST SAY, "GET OVER IT": It's very simple what we need to say to them when we meet up with these whiners. Remind youself what they said to us when we were even more angry (although more patriotic in how we dealt with it) after george II stole the election. They told us to just "get over it". Now it's their turn to do the same. I have family members who act like this, and I just EGG THEM ON until a vein pops and their eyes bulge out. Then I laugh and laugh and do a victory dance. If you do this they'll actually calm down. You know why? For the same reason spoiled children stop throwing temper tantrums once they realize they don't work. When they see their spoiled efforts are a waste of time they'll go in the corner and cry. It should all be familiar territory for them. It's just that they're not used to "the other shoe". Politics is full of two types of people: THE WINNERS and THE WHINERS. I've always said, "every time a republican cries an angel gets its wings". The President needs to be reminded of this as well: WE WON. GET OVER IT. - george II didn't NEED to be reminded. Now, isn't it time for the people WHO WERE ELECTED to get some work done?!

Great insights, great essay,

Great insights, great essay, however, I don't really think that a "Faith" rational for Conservatives' denial explains its extreme nature. It's fed by american media propaganda--a word I use fully here. Cable media in this country is mostly propaganda, or insipid content that supports extremely superficial commercialism. Much like credit card commercials advertising the ability to buy us "priceless" moments, 24/7 news channels pretend to value and honor the important moments and sacrifices of our lives while twisting our immediate and relevant history into a reality show. FOX News is the most watched American news cycle program, and it has double the viewers of MSNBC and now more than double of CNN. Fiscal conservatives have also entered the loon barn, with their utopic dis-belief in any relationship between taxes and healthy societies. This "Faith" that roads, hospitals, their education, their universities, their food, their police, their gated communities, and the fire man, would happen without government regulations and funding is not in fact "Faith," it's brainwashing. Its a denial fed by propaganda. Their at the best house in Vegas, and they don't want to anti up. It's astonishing how many FOX news watchers can't correctly verify recent history. To them, we found WMDs, Saddam was behind 9/11, and the government doesn't run Medicare. They live in a different world, and the reality there does not have such a liberal bias.

This is a reasonable

This is a reasonable analysis, but it has a couple of shortcomings. First, these kinds of delusional behaviors are nothing new for the republicans. They go at least as far back as Nixon. Just look at their relentless attacks against Clinton (as a serial rapist, as a murderer, etc.) Second, although the democrats are to blame for their weakness, the real culprit is the media. The reason many right-wing lies take hold is because the media refuses to correct them (death panels, government takeovers, etc.). In addition, the media never provides information regarding policies - all they deal with are tactics and politics.

It's too bad that Obama

It's too bad that Obama wasted so much time trying to hold hands with his Republican rivals. We got Social Security in 1935 because FDR saw the need for it, had a study done, and in one year with the stroke of his pen did it , period. Medicare, proposed in 1945 by Truman, took 20 years because of the fears of "socialist" medicine that are still in force today, but LBJ implemented that in 1965. They didn't waste time pussy footing around trying to appease opponents to these plans. The Nice Guy approach doesn't work. I almost wish that Obama were more like Bush and would just do what he wanted, and leave the idiots dumbstruck with "shock and awe".

"In any given situation,

"In any given situation, there are more Stupid People than intelligent ones. - Ken Kesey "Against Stupidity, even God is helpless." - Goethe "If you want to influence the masses, appeal to the Least Intelligent." - Chicken Little What does it say about us (U.S.), that this level of public discourse WORKS ... and that the Republican party has turned appealing to the Moron level into an Art Form.

Strangely and uncomfortably

Strangely and uncomfortably enough, the general trend in social change in the US is toward right wing thinking, religious fundamentalisn, creationism, hostility and political stupidity, exactly the opposite of what is going on in Europe. The election of Barak Obama and his presidency are to be considered an interlude. The attacks on Health Care reform are masterminded by the same people who gave us George Dubbya Bush, Dick Cheney, Karl Rove, and they are relentless. Even Sarah Palin wants in ! Twits for Twitter, save America from Wit. The morons desperately want to be back in power at whatever cost. And they might very well succeed again.

At least 25% of American

At least 25% of American adults believed that the 2000 millennium would mean the end of the world according to polls in 1999. No wonder Republicans use scare tactics to goad the irrational and uneducated to do their bidding.

I am not as pessimistic as

I am not as pessimistic as the writer who says we are moving toward the right wing. I think those people are just the loudest and have the most money to get people out in mobs to shout down reason. I don't think this is an interlude. Gradually, slowly, I think we move, over the years, to more liberal stances. The people who want to get rid of Social Security are a loud minority. So are the people shouting about Medicare. I think most mainstream churches are slowly, gradually taking their own message seriously; the Lutherans just decided that gay ministers with partners could serve; the Episcopalians did that (not everyone agrees) a couple of years ago. I think mot people realize this country is going to go bankrupt if we don't have major changes in our health care. And most people think we should NOT be in Afghanistan. But the media doesn't bring these things up, and the rightwingnuts shout down the voices of reason. Without the Internet, we wouldn't know what's going on.

I recently heard a story on

I recently heard a story on NPR about correcting misperceptions that directly relates to this situation. Research shows that if someone thinks that "Obama is a Muslim", saying that "Obama is not a Muslim" not only fails to change it, but rather reinforces it. The NOT loses its intent and the receiver still hears "Obama is a Muslim" Obama's radio address today was a bunch of NOTs in a long list. He and we will have to get much more focused and listen to George Lakoff on how to frame our argument if we want to be heard. And the crazies on the right should be called out for what they are: racists.

Articles like these are

Articles like these are essentially preaching to the choir. The people who need to hear this message will never read this.

Do you really think that if

Do you really think that if the president was white, Republicans would be lining up to have the government take over health care? Claiming that all people who disagree with you are racist is just as crazy as anything the right wing comes up with. Of course, there are some anti-black racists. There are also pro-black racists. One is just as bad as the other, in my book.

although i agree with most

although i agree with most of this, i have to say one thing bothers me. Hari said says that Republicans are blinded by Faith. he says that you only need faith to believe in things untrue. I'm sure that you and i both have Faith that we are i loved. By our mothers, fathers, lovers, ext. I am a young man who has Faith in many things. one of Them is my Faith in a higher power. I do not believe that Faith is the real issue here. The real issue is blind Faith and flawed teachings. Unfortunately i have known southerners and conservatives to be infamous for both. The real teachings of the Bible support the Left side of our political spectrum. To the Right, i'm sorry to say this fact has not and never will change

Yes, well, 'tis true that

Yes, well, 'tis true that America has a ring in its nose, yes 'tis true, but 'tis true of you too, and just look out across your manche there and further to Latvia and Hungary where the nazis are marching openly again. It's a worldwide problem, the problem of building a just society in the face of evil. Nazis, Quaidists, RightWing U.S. Republicans, oh yes, and then there's Rupert, Dennis Potter was right about him!

"The Democrats have moved to

"The Democrats have moved to the right, and the Republicans have moved to a mental hospital."

So far, Republicans are beating Democrats bloody in the court of public opinion, so who are you calling crazy? It would seem that Republicans have a far superior grasp of America's bigotries, prejudices and hatreds than Democrats, so much so that they are able to wield them for convincing victories in public debate and, if things continue the way they are going now, on the legislative floor as well.

If Democrats during the Cheney interregnum had been as focused and well-disciplined as Republicans are now as the minority party, Democrats and not the Republicans would have ruled the eight years before Obama.

Moreover, rule of the country will continue elude Democrats so long as they remain as undisciplined and unfocused as they have been the last nine years.

Spot on! It never ceases to

Spot on! It never ceases to amaze me that bush (2) won with barely 51% and called it a mandate to appoint himself with the power of God to rain down death and destruction on helpless people. Yet Obama, who won with 60% of the vote and really does have a mandate, continues to make deals with the devil. I heard a caller on talk radio the other day say that instead of cowtowing to insurance companies, and speculative bankers, he needs to turn around and punch them in the face. Well, I think the same method might be very effective when dealing with hysterical crazy people. Perhaps his poll numbers are down because the folks that elected him to do the things he said he would do, are increasingly disillusioned as all those promises are reversed. He may be good at diplomacy but he's weak on psychology.

I have read the Mussolini

I have read the Mussolini once said that fascism should really be called "corporatism." If so, then we are now living in a fascist country. You doubt it? look who controls public discourse: insurance companies, Big Pharma, agri-business, the mainstream media, etc. Who has the most influence on the elected representatives: the corporations with the deepest pockets or the voters? Ever since the 1960s the powers that be have made a concerted effort to dumb down education in this country and have blamed it on the left's desire to be "politically correct" and their "being shamed of America." People have been fed twaddle in schools and on TV and movies for so many years they can no longer tell truth from fiction. Why has this happened and why does it continue? Just answer the question, "Cui bono? Who benefits?"

How is a bi-racial man

How is a bi-racial man black? He is bi-racial. When opinions continue to skew this information, untruth is released. Our President is bi-racial and multi-cultural. He understands both "worlds" of being black and being white. We have to begin to understand this and embrace it rather than just continue to image him as black. He is that and more.

Life expectancy in USA has

Life expectancy in USA has dropped to the 42nd rank in 2004 compared to the 11th rank 11 years before in 1993. Mainly because of high obesity rate, social disparities and of a high percentage of infant mortality. from: http://www.ilcusa.org/pages/media_items/life-expectancy-drops-for-u.s.-citizens83.php USSR also experienced a sharp drop in its life expectancy just before its fall in the '80s

"The American media then

"The American media then presents itself as an umpire between "the rival sides", as if they both had evidence behind them." This is the crux of the problem. So much of America is ignorant and ill-informed-- the problem is particularly bad with the right. The media fans the flames because it makes for good ratings. A seemingly hopeless situation-- does anybody have any good ideas?

The only way this will

The only way this will change is by not letting all the wealth go in the same few pockets. Those of the 1%. Because what they do with all that wealth coming without work is to organize propaganda by every means they can to get this situation not to change. When a group gives itself the power to pocket the economy, everybody else is in deep trouble.

While I recognize that the

While I recognize that the bickering is old between the two parties, we've seen what happens when the Left lets the Right get away with lie after lie after lie. Articles like this superbly crafted one help raise awareness among those with a few brain cells left firing that many on the Right are beyond control, lost in a sea of fallacies, half-truths and misrepresentations, and helps us all by exposing the real truths behind the actions of those on the Right. Thank you, Johann, for a sharply pointed stick with which we can jab others back into reality.

what is the source of the

what is the source of the 18,000 deaths statistic? The number and relating it to the number of deaths on 9/11 is a good talking point - just don't want to get ambushed later on where the number came from.

Yet another liberal author

Yet another liberal author with an incurable case of cranial/rectal inversion.

A major problem is lack of

A major problem is lack of knowledge of history - the most revealing book I ever read was one that described life one hundred years ago in the good old USA, before minimum wage, before workplace safety, before all kinds of laws and taxes that created the educated, protected, and well-off middle class. The problem today is that we have been living for several generations in reasonable comfort and hardly anyone knows why. So we invent explanations, mostly faith-based, that USians are blessed, superior, divine warriors, whatever. this is where faith is an issue, when it fills in gaps of knowledge. It really was laws and taxes that dirtributed some wealth away from the top dogs to society at large. This is governmentΒ΄s basic function, if we like the middle class and want to keep it. If we decide the middle class is now longer a desirable thing in the US, then letΒ΄s continue as we have been since the 80Β΄s, dismantling laws that protect against insider deals and exploitation, and weΒ΄ll return to where the country was a hundred years ago - a few obscenely rich families that run everything and the vast hordes of illiterate poor living in over-crowded slums with a life expectancy of 45, and a relatively small level of middle class government employees and preachers to terrorize the poor and assure them that their misery is all part of a divine plan beyond our reach or comprehension.

Re "cranial/rectal

Re "cranial/rectal inversion"- right! Attack the author, when there's no apparent weakness in his logic with which to take issue... & then try & demolish. ^..^

A mishmash of trite notions

A mishmash of trite notions containing a few bits of useful information and a small number of genuine insights. The most insightful of them, if it wasn't a glib tossoff, was the question in the subtitle: "How do they train themselves to be so impervious to reality?" The article's lame answer, a putdown of America's higher level of religiosity, is just standard modern western European anti-Americanism. And it doesn't apply to large numbers of grassroots conservatives who never were very religious, especially in places like California. I think Mike of AK is right, that "the media" are at least partially to blame. But it goes further. Grassroots (that is working, non-wealthy) conservatives very often work hard to use conservative media to indoctrinate themselves with conservative talking points. But the question that still needs to be answered is WHY grassroots conservatives do this? Why indeed is it so important for them to all march together saying the same (often false) things at the same time? If they are going to put that much effort into getting information from the media, why not just think about it and come to their own conclusions? Or is that too threatening because it would put them outside of the conservative concensus? Now if someone wrote an article accurately analyzing modern grassroots conservative psychology, rather than sneering at their seeming irrationality, THAT would be useful to people on the Left.

The Republicans have

The Republicans have successfully coordinated intolerance among their more ignorant followers, who have in turn harnessed hate of the unknown, as the momentum and thrust of their attack. The real problems begin when they start to believe their own rhetoric. Why? Because they need to whip themselves into a pseudo-state of frenzy and outrage. This is how they empower themselves. Reason and logic need not apply when the self-embittered are outraged. The issue is no longer important - just the (negative) energy that is required to do battle with the unknown. And shaping the unknown into an image they can attack is all they really know. -rts

Democrats never learned to

Democrats never learned to exercise power when they had the chance to do so. It is much easier for Republicans to rally ordinary folks behind the flag to promote their narrow interests than for Democrats to do what has to be done for the benefit of the common good. This disadvantage has to be acknowledged and Democrats have to finally learn to use power just as ruthlessly as Republicans do. President Obama! Make decisions with the Democratic leadership and ram it through Congress with a take no prisoners approach. This is how things happen and change materializes. Americans want a strong leader. There is no way that you can do more damage than G.W.Bush did. JUST DO IT! And your poll numbers will improve again! The most important agendas are Energy, Health Care, and Education. All need substantial improvements!!!

Look, the republicans did it

Look, the republicans did it to themselves when they nominated and elected a right wing conservative that wasn't very bright -- George Bush. We wound up with Bush as President because of the personal problems of Bill Clinton. Now we have a Black President because of the abuses of power during the Bush Administration and the complete mismanagement of the U.S, economy. The republicans have no one else to blame but themselves, so live with it, next time maybe you'll run someone that can give orders as compared to taking orders.

This article is so sad. It

This article is so sad. It attempts to argue that Barrack Obama is a black man. While I find it fruitless to make even further racial comments I will say this. Obama is many things but he is very far from being a black man. Almost 3/4 of his heritage is Arabian and Caucasian mix. The black part, as it is, comes from only one other person...his dad. Another sad thing about this is that the writer says that Bill Maher talks of how the ones against Obama's plans are racist freedom haters. To the contrary, the libertarian movement that has gone International is the foundation of free peoples against the Global Banking Cartel that is running the puppets around the World. $24 trillion stole so far the the banking elite. That is more than the cost of all of the wars, great and small, throughout the 20th century combined. Obama is a tool as much as Bush was and Clinton and Bush and Regan and Carter and Nixon. Oh why can't they tell they're the ones that are making it out to be a race thing. People are marching for jobs, wages, security, farmland...all the essentials that go first in a converting Fascist police state.

This is my hope: Republicans

This is my hope: Republicans will cross the limit of absurdity - they will continue to lie without shame; they will go on supporting corporate interests as opposed to the public welfare. But the silent majority of the people will not be fooled. They will vote for the Democrats again, much to the astonishment of the Republican mobsters. Am I being completely unrealistic?

Awesome, intelligent

Awesome, intelligent article. Needs to be widely read and retweeted. Thanx!

The 18,000 people you

The 18,000 people you mention die of disease not the lack of health care. True, many (perhaps all of them) don't have health insurance but they all have health care -- it's a law in this country that no one can be turned away from a public hospital for lack of coverage. The stories of people being turned away (which are VERY rare but nonetheless tragic) generally take place a private hospitals. Also by way of correction, to say that faith is only needed "to believe the untrue or unprovable" is silly. It's like saying the sky is blue because it's blue. And, I don't think anyone is taught that "faith is the highest aspiration and most noble cause." They may be taught that certain behaviors (honesty, charity, compassion) that are required by this so-called God are noble but not that faith in and of itself is noble.

BULLSEYE! Even the

BULLSEYE! Even the republican elite know there constituents are idiots. No one can save you from stupid, you have to save yourself. They don't have a leg to stand on yet the media tries to be balanced, tries to give each side merit. The republicans have only racism and fear. Its been the American formula since slavery. You want to get a reaction, tell them that brown people will be getting healthier, on white peoples dimes. Tell them that the big bad black president wants to kill your babies and grandmother. No facts are necessary, they want to believe that stuff because of the racial hate thats bubbling under the surface. "how come these brown people are doing better than me? This ain't america!" is really the match that lights that fuse. That same thinking Birthed the KKK after slavery and Jim Crow and any other racist theology, after ww1 and ww2. Blacks have been the canary that determines the satisfaction of the white underclass for years. Their lives are made valuable or less so depending on the comfort of the average African -American. And a Black president with a African name is pulling the mask off their real motivations, hate and division, and the return of the "good ole days" when you could whip folks behind woodsheds, if their reason was threatened by facts or common sense, even common decency.

jahf wrote: "So far,

jahf wrote: "So far, Republicans are beating Democrats bloody in the court of public opinion, so who are you calling crazy? It would seem that Republicans have a far superior grasp of America's bigotries, prejudices and hatreds than Democrats, so much so that they are able to wield them for convincing victories in public debate and, if things continue the way they are going now, on the legislative floor as well." Of course Republicans have a far superior grasp of America's bigotries, prejudices and hatreds. They're largely responsible for them so they very well should! The reason they're able to get "convincing victories" in public debate is because they have more resources (money) to get their message out there & the base they're pandering to typically buys the misinformation they're spreading without doing their own research so they can make their own informed decisions then shouts down any voice of reason that confronts them.

This article is partisan

This article is partisan rambling. It doesn't provide any logic or proof for anything. Bush was a BIG government statist with religion and terrorism as the moral justification for his unconstitutional and unethical actions. Obama is a BIG government statist with social/economic "justice" as the justification for his unconstitutional and unethical actions as well. As long as the American people elect devious people, we will be taxed and lectured and called "un-american" for disagreeing with the party in power, whether it's because you disagree with the Iraq War or you disagree with Health Care reform. Wake Up! Vote for libertarians like Ron Paul who actually care about this country and individual Americans. We need to stop labeling groups and see individuals.

I was right with Hari until

I was right with Hari until he got a little hostile with the faith metaphor and his view of Southerners. The Republican media machine's smear campaign is very upsetting, but it is wrong to fight it with more ugliness and unkindness. Obama is a great diplomat. If we want to support the leader of our nation, we should follow his example.

It not about left and right

It not about left and right anymore people. It's about the U.S. government going rogue and turning on the very people it's supposed to serve. If you think left and right are even an issue, you are blind. Take bake your country while you still can.

Many things cannot be proved

Many things cannot be proved or disproved. Daily life requires many acts of faith. Attacking faith is pointless ignorant prejudice. Contesting disinformation with facts, or arguing for an idea you believe is better is another matter. There are no blue humans or red humans or conservative humans or liberal humans. There are humans with different belief systems and those belief systems include varying types and amounts of disinformation. It doesn't require much to be against something. Johann Hari... what are you FOR.

True believers are necessary

True believers are necessary for evil to triumph whether it involves the supporters of Stalin or Mao or Bush. All it takes is repetition and a desire to believe to have any lie become gospel. The very last thing the elites want is an intelligent and informed democracy. But they cannot admit this publicly and so have to come up with plausible alternative views of reality to justify their actions, whether it is denying health care to people or killing millions of babies with bombs and lack of food and medicine as the US government has been doing for the past 18 years, effectively wiping out a generation of Iraqi's. But we are committing genocide much more effectively in Iraq than we did with the Native Americans, even if with much less efficiency. Inefficiency is great for business as witnessed by the profits of the health care industry and the military industrial complex.

"Yet another liberal author

"Yet another liberal author with an incurable case of cranial/rectal inversion." Here is the perfect example of where the discussed phenomenon leads. Right wingnuts have no truths and no moral compass remaining. They take the lead of Limbaugh and immediately descend into locker room mutterings about the lower digestive system and juvenile sarcasm.

"We had fed the heart on

"We had fed the heart on fantasies, The heart's grown brutal from such fare". W.B. Yeats, "The Stare's Nest by my Window"

This is a good article and

This is a good article and points out the insanity of the right wing loons. One mistake, though, is that its not 18,000 people a year who die due to lack of health care, it is 45,000 people a year as found in a recent Harvard study on the issue: http://www.cnn.com/2009/HEALTH/09/18/deaths.health.insurance/index.html