Share

Afghan War's Blowback for India's Children?

by: J. Sri Raman, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
Children in the Punjab are increasingly born with birth defects. The phenomenon may well be due to depleted uranium carried over by wind currents from Afghanistan. (Photo: Money Sharma / EPA)

    Children born with abnormally enlarged or small heads, disproportionately short arms and legs, cerebral palsy, Down syndrome, and other complications. Increasing instances of infertility among women. A spurt in cases of lung cancer and intestinal ulcer.

    Punjab, a state in India bordering Pakistan, has reason to be concerned about this scary picture emerging from surveys recently carried out in some of its areas. Not only Punjab, however.

    According to a section of the researchers particularly concerned with the cases of birth deformities, Punjab may be paying with the health of its people for the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.

    More precisely, depleted uranium reportedly used in wars in these countries may be the cause of the deformities and disorders on the rise in India's northwestern state, according to a team based in the city of Faridkot.

    Winds from Afghanistan may have carried to the state a large quantity of highly toxic uranium, which has contaminated water and increased uranium in bodies to dangerous levels. This apprehension was raised at least five months ago by the team of the Baba Farid Center for Special Children, a nongovernmental organization (NGO), where some of the affected kids have been undergoing treatment.

    In what would appear to be a scandalously successful cover-up, the question raised by the team has been kept away from major headlines in the Indian and international media, with New Delhi seeing no need even to take cognizance of it.

    In a downplayed report, which the most prominent media did not consider deserving of better display, Dr. Pritpal Singh, in charge of the Faridkot clinic, said the number of affected children had risen "dramatically in the past six or seven years." Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan was launched on October 7, 2001.

    The use of DU weapons in the Iraq war, started on March 20, 2003, may also have contributed to the tragic drama in Punjab, according to the team. The radioactive uranium, released in such cases, gets mixed in soil, air and water within a large radius. Areas within 1,000 miles from the place where the uranium is released can get affected. Parts of Iraq close to Iran fall within that distance. Afghanistan is just over 330 miles away from India's Punjab.

    Evidently, children of Pakistan, which occupies this distance, have also been exposed to the same danger. So are their counterparts in areas India adjoining Punjab.

    DU - defined as uranium containing a smaller percentage of uranium-235 than the 0.7 percent found in natural uranium - has found several military uses. Because of its high density, it is used in tank armor, sandwiched between sheets of steel armor plate. It is also used in armor-piercing, incendiary ammunition. It has also been used, above all, to destroy bunkers and tanks.

    According to US radiation specialist Leuren Moret, "DU weaponry largely meets the definition of a weapon of mass destruction (WMD)." In a newspaper article in 2005, she wrote: "Since 1991, the US has released the radioactive atomicity (through DU weapons) equivalent of at least 400,000 Nagasaki bombs into the global atmosphere. That is 10 times the amount released during atmospheric testing which was the equivalent of 40,000 Hiroshima bombs. The US has permanently contaminated the global atmosphere with radioactive pollution having a half-life of 2.5 billion years." She also described DU weapons as "dirty bombs, dirty missiles and dirty bullets."

    Experts estimate that 1,000 tonnes of uranium is already present in the Iraq-Iran region and Afghanistan. People from these areas have been found to have 100 times more uranium in their urine compared to those from other areas.

    The Faridkot center sent hair samples of 149 children - 116 below the age of 12 - to the laboratory of the Micro Trace Minerals in Germany in June 2008. The results came back in February 2009. The samples of children below 12 years revealed 82 percent of uranium and those of the rest, 87 percent. Singh found the results "astonishing as there is no atomic plant near Punjab."

    An investigation team of the Observer (London) has just days ago confirmed the "dramatic rise in birth defects, physical and mental abnormalities, and cancers" in the state. The team, however, has linked the uranium contamination to ash from the region's coal-fired power stations.

    In a phone call with Truthout, Singh stressed that the matter called for a "scientific inquiry," which the Observer investigation was not claimed to be. He pointed out that there were complaints of such consequences from the DU weapons in other places.

    On May 1, 2008, the One Planet program of the BBC World Service quoted doctors in Kabul and Kandahar saying that the incidence of birth defects, including premature births and malformations, had doubled in under two years. Among the malformations were "neural tube defects and malformation of limbs; for example, the head is smaller than normal, or the head is larger than normal, or there is a big mass on the back of the baby."

    Though the George Bush regime protested innocence, the program cited the Canada-based Uranium Medical Research Center (UMRC) as saying that the cause might be depleted uranium. In 2002 and 2003, the center carried out analyses of urine from Afghans. In some, it found levels of uranium hundreds of times greater than in Gulf War veterans.

    As for Iraq, shockwaves were sent across the world by disclosures of a large-scale rise in children's deformities and deaths in Fallujah after two massive bombing campaigns in 2004. In November 2005, the Pentagon was forced to admit the use of white phosphorous and DU ammunition during these campaigns.

    Deafening is the silence of New Delhi on the possible consequences of the use of DU weapons in a war at India's doorstep. Does the Bush-built "strategic partnership" on South Asia demand callous indifference to the plight of deformed and dying children in Punjab?

  

»


A freelance journalist and a peace activist in India, J. Sri Raman is the author of "Flashpoint" (Common Courage Press, USA). He is a regular contributor to Truthout.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

An increase in birth

An increase in birth defects, the use of depleted uranium in Iraq and elsewhere: a causal effect? Maybe, but it seems unlikely. You would have to demonstrate that contamination by depleted uranium reaches levels thought to cause harm. You would have to connect the timing of the rise in birth defects with the actual use of depleted uranium in the War. Instead of creating a category of "birth defects", you need to set up more nuanced, better defined categories that connect to possible scientific study. Too scientific an analysis? Maybe, but why not model scientific thinking rather than stir up passions? This story rests on pretty shaky ground. Better to say, "There has been an increase in birth defects in the Punjab region. Possible explanations include environmental pollution and depleted uranium used in the Iraq War." Not as eye-catching, but more truthful.

Any scientific study to

Any scientific study to prove DU causes birth defects in humans is completely and utterly immoral and unethical. There is plenty evidence in animal and other sources to indicate what is happening in Iraq. The US military has killed more civilians than any other force on earth. It brings death, disease and destruction to where every it goes. A force for good must rise up to take its place or the human race is domed.

It would appear that

It would appear that referring to the U.S. as "The Great Satan" is not as ridiculous as it first sounded back in the '70's. For who else would be callous enough to invent and utilize such large-scale technologies of death upon the world's people? And eventually upon its OWN people as well, for do we not all live on this same little ball of dust?

More seem like something

More seem like something else. Isn't it amazing? PAKISTAN doesn't seem to have cases like that more often, but INDIA did.

The long-lasting and

The long-lasting and devastating effects of DU exposure are thoroughly evinced and documented in many, very saddening cases from post-First Gulf War Iraq. So, too, are the effects revealed in the myriad illnesses and birth defects endured by US military personnel who were deployed in the First Gulf War and their families. In the early nineties, we were naive to the side effects of DU to those in theatre and even further afield and the price for this naivete was paid by our servicemen and servicewomen and their offspring. Yes, they will pay the price again for our ignorance and the numbers sickened and the scope of their illnesses will be staggering. This is an immense tragedy. My mind reels. My heart breaks.

Drosera - such skepticism is

Drosera - such skepticism is unfounded. The higher incidence of birth defects and the outbreak of war is established by the authorities quoted in the article. Though unfounded, such unwillingness to accept this causality is not surprising: the US mainstream media has always done a thorough job of suppressing reports of the ravenous effects of DU on public health in Iraq; meanwhile, the VA here at home cooperates in this cover up by not explicitly diagnosing certain ailing Gulf War veterans as having been exposed to toxic materials as a result of their deployment (where applicable). And if anyone needs convincing that toxic materials in Country A can have adverse effects on the health in Country B and Country C, read about Chernobyl. Don't look at this like it's a new phenomenon or an untested theory. It ain't.

If you think this is bad...

If you think this is bad... just wait.

How can they separate the

How can they separate the vast and ever increasing amount of pollution generated by India from that caused by war in other countries in the region? India is not only one of the highest polluters on the planet, they refuse to curtail it in any way. And to whom are they looking for health care? The outstanding systems in the UK or Canada? The socialized systems in France, Holland, or Sweden? The government controlled systems in Italy or Spain? No, they are looking to the "broken" system in the US to provide solutions. They better hurry, though, before the Obamunists fix it!

Oh my gosh...it wasn't

Oh my gosh...it wasn't Padilla at all...we're the dirty bomber. Guess you have to do something with all that depleted uranium besides dump it on Native American land. The US has to stop polluting the world with our munitions and our might.

The trouble with this theory

The trouble with this theory is that it does not explain the variations in levels of uranium contamination within Punjab, nor does it explain how the DU is supposed to have reached the area, given that the monsoon winds are blowing the wrong way - either from the north east or the south west. The writer also fails to mention that Leuren Moret, the "citizen scientist" [her words] who is usually cited in connection with DU, believes that its alleged spread across the region is part of an evil Zionist plan by a secret cabal of bankers, politicians and royalty to depopulat e the region, thus allowing US agricultural companies and the Rothschilds to move in and take over all farming there. This is a quote from an earlier interview with her: "The Queen of Britain and the Rockefellers (US) own most of the uranium, and the city of London bankers control world uranium supplies and prices. Nice partnership, isn't it? Through her mother (maiden name Roche), Princess Diana was actually a Rothschild (city of London bankers). Many people believe that Prince Charles married Diana for her Stuart bloodline, which made her more royal than Charles. But when Prince William becomes king, England will have a Rothschild on the throne… that is the bloodline wanted from Princess Diana. " This is hardly the basis for a serious scientific case...