Share

Top Officer Says US Bungling Muslim Outreach

by: Anne Gearan  |  The Associated Press

photo
In Afghanistan's Kunar Province, a resident observes a group of US soldiers. (Photo: Reuters)

    Washington - The U.S. military is bungling its outreach to the Muslim world and squandering good will by failing to live up to its promises, the nation's highest-ranking military officer wrote Friday.

    Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said there is too much emphasis on telling the U.S. story and not enough on building trust and credibility.

    "We hurt ourselves and the message we are trying to send when it appears we are doing something merely for the credit," Mullen wrote in an essay published in a military journal. "We hurt ourselves more when our words don't align with our actions."

    Mullen said he dislikes the military's focus on "strategic communications," which he said has become a cottage industry where the shaping of a message eclipses what that message says.

    "Most strategic communication problems are not communicatons problems at all," Mullen wrote. "They are policy and execution problems."

    Efforts to reach out to the Middle East and elsewhere in the Muslim world is a main priority of the vast communications and public relations machinery of the Defense Department. Mullen suggested that much of the effort is wasted, or at least misdirected.

    Public opinion in the Muslim world would seem to bear him out.

    A survey of two dozen nations conducted this spring found that positive public attitudes toward the United States have surged in many parts of the world since President Barack Obama's election, but not in most of the Arab and Muslim world.

    The poll registered continuing levels of profound distrust about U.S. influence and motives among Muslims, particularly in Turkey, Pakistan and the Palestinian territories. There, the report from the nonpartisan Pew Research Center said, animosity toward the United States "continues to run deep and unabated."

    U.S. intelligence considers Pakistan, a nuclear-armed Muslim country that Mullen has made a priority with nearly a dozen visits over the past 18 months, among the most profoundly anti-American places on Earth.

    Defense Secretary Robert Gates frequently remarks that the United States has let itself be "out-communicated by men living in caves," a wry reference to the skill with which al-Qaida uses the Internet to distribute its messages and capitalize on U.S. failings.

    Mullen noted one of those failings, the abuse of Iraqi detainees at the Abu Ghraib prison, but he said the problem isn't the skill of the communicators.

    "Our biggest problem isn't caves, it's credibility," Mullen wrote in the Joint Force Quarterly. "Our messages lack credibility because we haven't invested enough in building trust and relationships, and we haven't always delivered on promises."

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Actually the American

Actually the American problem is that it wants an empire. Our best message to the Muslim world would be to remove all US military personnel from anywhere in the world other than the US. Killing for peace does not work. Building bases around the world never brings peace. The only way to peace is to practice it. Disband the military industrial complex

After years of warfare in

After years of warfare in the Middle East, is there ANY emphasis on language instruction- at least Arabic- to members of the Armed Forces? The only thing likely to change opinions is the likelihood, in the minds of people in that region, that they are being heard by the nearest US "representative" in their vicinity... which is most likely to be a soldier. ^..^

Gen. Mullen is correct when

Gen. Mullen is correct when he states that credibility is the main issue. But credibility stems from integrity, not just earnest expressions. In this regard, Mullen is merely giving lip service. What effort has he made to truly investigate and expose wrongdoing at both the action and policy levels? A policy and practice of renditions and torture sanctioned at the highest levels is bound to create distrust and suspicion of US presence and intentions. Yet the Obama Administration continues to evade and suppress efforts to bring to light the mechanisms that made such activities formal US policy. Of course people like Cheney will oppose any effort to expose the hubris and lawlessness of his administration. How many convicted criminals still decry their "innocence" from the jail cells even in the face of overwhelming evidence of criminal actions? Criminals do not want to get caught or be held accountable! But in this case, failure to prosecute sends a clear "message" that the criminality and inhuman behavior is deemed acceptable by the US as a country. As long as that message is extant, building trust on the part of the Muslim world is but a pipe dream, no matter how many "spin doctors" are hired to tweak the "Message."

A government that protect

A government that protect criminals (The Bush and Cheney Gang) is also a criminal organisation. America is destroying freedom all over the world. Obama made big promisis during the election, it is five past twelve and I hope his consience will make him keep those promises. The whole world is holding his braith. Make the change you promissed, and stop the killings in the name of democracy.