Share

The Mugging of the Common Good

by: Robert Borosage  |  The Campaign For America's Future

photo
Robert Borsage writes that over the next few months the president and the Congress will either, "step up to the reforms the country needs - or they will fail the nation in a time of peril." (Photo: Pete Souza / White House)

Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
....The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
Surely some revelation is at hand

- William Butler Yeats


    President Obama traveled to Wall Street on the anniversary of the collapse of Lehman Brothers that triggered the worst financial debacle since the Great Depression. His purpose was to challenge Wall Street's barons, telling them:

"We will not go back to the days of reckless behavior and unchecked excess ... where too many were motivated only by the appetite for quick kills and bloated bonuses"

    Those days are over, the president said. It's time for comprehensive legislation. Taxpayers won't cover your bets or your bonuses. And we know once more the threat that financial holdings can pose to the nation.

    The president invoked country and the common good. "Instead of learning the lessons ... of the crisis, [some in the financial industry] are choosing to ignore them. They do so not just at their own peril, but our nation's." Obama called on Wall Street to act on its own, to overhaul pay systems, to level with consumers, to join with him in defining reform, but his tone was almost wistful. As he knows all too well, for much of Wall Street, patriotism is for suckers. And in Washington, private interests are rolling over the common good.

    In the wake of the worst economic downturn since the 1930s, the president has called for fundamental reforms vital to the country's future. Put aside whether he's been too bold or too timid, whether he has pushed hard enough or too hard; there isn't any question he is calling the nation to its senses.

    Our health care system is broken and unsustainable. Comprehensive reform is unavoidable. We can't continue to rely on fossil fuels; sustainable energy is a security imperative, not a choice. We need to shackle Wall Street, to shrink the size and excess profits of finance, and force it away from its addiction to gambling and back to the essential business of investing in the real economy. We have to reduce the crony capitalist subsidies that get squandered on agribusiness and Cold War weapons systems and top-end tax cuts, and use that money to invest in education, in a modern infrastructure, in research and development vital to a vibrant, high-road economy.

    This really shouldn't be controversial. Yes, disagreements about how to get this done are to be expected, but the status quo is simply indefensible. Despite all the fantasies of the rabid right, Obama is moderate by temperament, creative at compromise. He is, as one of his White House staff members described him, a "raging minimalist." He really does believe you put everyone around a table, have a "civil conversation," find areas of agreement and move forward. He does believe that everyone - from billionaire hedge-fund operators to insurance company CEOS to conservative legislators - will in a crisis put the country first.

    But he and his reform program are getting mugged. He's taken on the most powerful private interests in America - Big Oil, Wall Street, the insurance and drug lobbies - and they are winning. Republicans, despite the shattering of their conservative shibboleths, have chosen, with lockstep unity, obstruction over compromise. And too many Democrats have shown themselves more beholden to the private interests that pay for their campaigns than the public interest the president of their own party invokes.

    We are witnessing a harrowing test of our democracy. America is a big, bustling and entrepreneurial country. We pursue our own passions and pursuits, are jealous of our freedoms, and begrudge governmental intrusions. But in a crisis - faced with depression or war, our history tells us many become one. We join together for the common good.

    Well, it is hard to imagine a greater crisis than the one this country has faced over the last years. A middle class that has suffered a lost decade. Two wars. The Great Recession. Gilded Age inequality. Catastrophic climate change accelerating faster than most predictions.

    Yet, we haven't come together. Wall Street lobbies against reform. Derivative traders will ante up hundreds of millions to block regulation of credit default swaps. Goldman Sachs is back to computerized gambling and billions in bonuses. The insurance companies are spending over a million-and-a-half dollars a day against comprehensive health-care reform.

    The president's preemptive compromises only feed their appetites. He offers polluters a good portion of the revenue generated by "cap and trade." They lobby to weaken the cap.

    He bails out banks rather than taking them over and reorganizing them. They lobby against his financial reforms. He doesn't try to push for Medicare for All, accepting the role of employment-based private insurance, and he's accused of a government takeover of health care.

    The teabaggers were in Washington this past weekend. Despite their racial furies and right-wing fantasies, they shouldn't be dismissed. Many are working people, losing ground in an economy that isn't working for them. They are angry at a government that seems to take their taxes to bail out billionaire bankers, while they are left to swim or sink. They have every good reason to believe Washington caters to the wealthy and the connected, and not to them. And it is all too easy to deflect that anger to "them" - illegal immigrants, poor minorities, foreign aid recipients.

    This is the test for Democrats. With the White House and majorities in both houses of Congress, Democrats have to produce. If they are too cautious or too compromised, they will feed what could be an ugly populist backlash.

    Take health care reform. Sen. Max Baucus has produced a draft for the Finance Committee, making concessions as far anyone can see not for Republican votes, but for insurance lobby approval. He's produced that lobby's dream bill, mandating coverage for everyone without subsidies to make it affordable. His bill would drive people to take the high-deductible, low-coverage plans that are the industry's cash cows. It is hard to imagine a greater disservice to the country or to the party. Take young Americans who vote Democratic in large numbers, force them to buy health insurance that they don't want and can't afford, make them pay for policies that don't cover their health-care costs - and reap the whirlwind that you deserve.

    These next months are the reckoning. The president and the Congress will step up to the reforms the country needs - or they will fail the nation in a time of peril. For citizens, now is the time to get engaged. The only way legislators in both parties will rise above partisan politics and private interests is if their constituents allow them no choice.

    Middle-income Americans lost income over the last decade, for the first time since we began keeping records. Financial speculation drove the economy off the cliff. Catastrophic climate change is already melting the ice caps. We cannot afford another lost decade. If reason cannot prevail, angry people will increasingly look for a strong man to get something done. And that could make the teabaggers look like a tea party.

  

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum. Β It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

Baucus has sold progressives

Baucus has sold progressives out, there is no doubt. He never had a hope of garnering any Republican votes... but yet that provided great cover for his fund raising operation with the Insurance industry. In that way he also sold out he republican counterparties as well by beating them to the funding fountain. All hope is now on Senator Rockefeller to fix this bill before it lands on the floor of the Senate

As accurately dire as this

As accurately dire as this article paints the picture, it doesn't admit what is the reality - the system is broken. A good voice of reason for the common good cannot be heard because no one will agree on what is the common good. The common good has been politicized along with everything else. We might as well be in another civil war because that is essentially what is happening in America. This "war" mentality seems to be the dysfunctional paradigm that plagues many Americans. The true "common good" can only live when we stop allowing greed to kill it.

What a clown! Either he has

What a clown! Either he has the largest ego in the world or the smallest brain. Government interference was the root cause of the financial collapse - not salaries and bonuses. If he wants to prevent another collapse, then he should stay the hell away from Wall Street!

Everyone loves to quote

Everyone loves to quote Yeats...especially "The Second Coming." Keep in mind that Yeats, though Irish, was Protestant, not Catholic. He was also very rich. "The Second Coming" is inspired by what he saw as the rabble-rousing travesty of the Irish Revolution (in addition to the spread of "mere anarchy" during World War One). He was a product of the aristocracy and he despised the way the turn of the century upset the old order of things. His poetry has no place in any kind of argument on behalf of modern liberalism. You might as well be quoting Machiavelli or Julius Caesar.

New Deal regulation of

New Deal regulation of finance = unprecedented prosperity and a vibrant middle class. Deregulation = trillions in bailouts and shrinking, desperate middle class. Anti-government zealots aside, this really isn't so hard to understand.

As my mother always said,

As my mother always said, the answers are right in front of us. In this case I would say "The love of money is the root of all evil" is perfect. I am an ex-pat living outside the U.S. I try not to return very often because I find the level of greed so absolutely appalling. Where are all my peers from the 60's that could hold a good protest and make themselves heard? Have they sold out to wall street and/or the insurance companies? I think the people had better wake up soon or are they just going to fiddle while the country burns???

It's too bad Obama is so

It's too bad Obama is so naive. He thinks he can talk sense into the players at Wall Street? They don't care about sense, they only care about their own millions and billions of dollars. He'll probably fail regulating Wall St. for the same reasons he is failing getting true healthcare reform. His advisors don't want reform, and the Republicans and corporate Democrats in Congress don't want reform. He'll sell out the true Democrats who do want real reform in order to "compromise" with those who don't and their Republican partners. Too bad....

Was not this the same

Was not this the same assumption Greenspan had:that the US leading financiers would REASONABLE & INTELLIGENTLY be led by morals before profits, understanding their responsibllities within the ec0n0mic system??

What is it really going to

What is it really going to take to change things? How can we possibly imagine tackling these issues as a people when the information we are presented with is so biased? We the people are barely even an idea any more...we are broken and distracted and ultimately controlled. Any suggestions?