Share

A Factory Like a City

by: David Bacon

Last month, Toyota announced it would close the New United Motor Manufacturing Inc. (NUMMI) plant in Fremont, California, after General Motors announced it was withdrawing from the partnership under which the plant has operated for over two decades. The plant employs 4,500 workers directly, and the jobs of another 30,000 throughout Northern California are dependent on its continued operation. Taking families into account, the threatened closure will eliminate the income of over 100,000 people.

Factory Worker

(Photo: David Bacon / Truthout)

People have spent their lives in the NUMMI plant in Fremont, probably more time with the compressed-air tools at their workstations than with their families at home. The plant is like a city, thousands of jobs and thousands of people working in a complicated dance where each one's contribution makes possible that of the next person down the line. And like a city, it supports the people who work in it.

Factory Worker

(Photo: David Bacon / Truthout)

A NUMMI job brings the paycheck that pays the mortgage and the (now astronomical) tuition for kids in college. A NUMMI job makes possible the friendships that grow over years laboring in the same workplace. Working at NUMMI means being part of the union, with all the frustrations and infighting, but also the ability to pull together to get the contract that makes an industrial job bearable, and ensures that a kid's visit to a doctor or dentist doesn't bottom out the family bank account.

Factory Worker

(Photo: David Bacon / Truthout)

General Motors used to run this plant by itself, back in the '60s and '70s, when it was GM Fremont. It was a feisty plant with a feisty union, and a linchpin for years in the movement to stop concessions in union bargaining. When GM closed the plant the first time, in the early '80s, many thought it was revenge. Afterwards, autoworkers from Fremont became migrants. Many lived a lonely existence in motels in Oklahoma City or Texas, trying to hold onto seniority in a union auto job, sending money back home to families in California. Others lost their homes, and worse. In the wave of plant closures of the early 1980s, the Department of Commerce even kept a statistic of how many people committed suicide for every thousand who lost jobs when their plant shut down. No one in Washington has the courage to face that number anymore.

Factory Worker

(Photo: David Bacon / Truthout)

When GM and Toyota announced their partnership to reopen the plant, desperation was so great that people agreed to a union contract outside the national pattern before the lines even started moving. Big concessions to the "Japanese style of management" often pitted workers against each other and against their union too. It took years to fight those problems out with management.

Factory Worker

(Photo: David Bacon / Truthout)

When General Motors withdrew from its partnership with Toyota, everyone knew that spelled trouble. What sense did it make for GM to withdraw from a plant that consistently made vehicles that sold well, at a profit? But the GM bailout put the company under managers with no concern for keeping people working and plants open. Making GM profitable again meant getting dividends and profits flowing to a tiny group of bankers and investors, who already have more money than they can spend. And keeping production going at low-cost plants outside the US will bring that profitability back, although at the cost of the jobs and welfare of tens of thousands of people. Whose interest was our government serving with such a bailout? Even in France the conservative Sarkozy told French automakers they had to keep the factories running if they wanted a government subsidy. But here in the US, who was bailed out and who wasn't?

Factory Worker

(Photo: David Bacon / Truthout)

Without a GM partner, Toyota is moving to close the only plant it owns in the US with a union. And they just got a big taxpayer-funded present too. More vehicles sold under the Cash for Clunkers program were Corollas made at the NUMMI plant than any other model. The administration and Congress voted to throw three billion dollars at Toyota and the other auto giants to reduce car prices and increase sales. But there was no requirement that the subsidy come with a commitment to keep the people working who made the cars they sold.

Factory Worker

(Photo: David Bacon / Truthout)

Look at the photographs of the people of NUMMI. These experienced and talented people could make anything. If Toyota doesn't want to make cars in Fremont, why not put the plant to use making buses or the railcars for BART and local transit systems (for which taxpayers have already agreed to give up billions of dollars)? And if Toyota and GM don't want to give up the plant or put it to that use, then a true government commitment would be to use its power of eminent domain to take it over and ensure that the abilities of its workers don't go to waste, and that their families and the others depending on continued production there aren't plunged into misery and despair.

Factory Worker

(Photo: David Bacon / Truthout)

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.

  

»


David Bacon is a writer and photographer. His new book, "Illegal People - How Globalization Creates Migration and Criminalizes Immigrants," was just published by Beacon Press. His photographs and stories can be found at http://dbacon.igc.org.

Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.

our family car is a geo

our family car is a geo prizm from 1995 that probably came off that assembly line. it has a union sticker that we are very happy to have on our windshield.

Good on you, David. This is

Good on you, David. This is an excellent and well-researched article on a topic that affects every American -- even the rich ones who don't have to worry about their jobs vanishing. The last paragraph is esceptionally pertinent, asking why the government that has bulldozed billions into bank vaults in an effort to revive the ailing economy doesn't take over this NUMMI plant and keep it churning out products that are needed -- if not cars, then solar panels, windmill blades, buses, railcars or whatever. Anything would be better than closing this plant and eliminating the income of 100,000 people at the stroke of a pen. Come on, President Obama and Congress. Save this plant and its jobs.

This is a beautifully

This is a beautifully written article with beautiful photographs to illustrate the point. It saddens us to hear, again, how bankers are destroying the heart and soul of our country. And also how our government reflects the interests of bankers over the people they represent in name only. It is the same in Health Insurance reform, so it has been for so long in Manufacturing.

"Jobless Recovery" is an

"Jobless Recovery" is an oxymoron. Corporate media, Wall Street, Big Insurance and HMOs are calling this a "recovery" because their comfortable lifestyles and retirements are not in jeopardy. There was a threat to them just a year ago as the entire house of cards seemed poised to collapse. Corporate media is the lapdog for Wall Street and the ruling oligarchy. Every evening they hint at the truth, enough to retain their claim of "credibility" but they won't draw any accurate conclusions. Two generations ago this was different when reporters like Walter Cronkite, Fred Graham, Bruce Morton and the CBS TV news division began to tell the truth about Vietnam and Watergate. Their courage and team effort wrought significant changes in world events: Withdrawal from Vietnam and Nixon's resignation. These events were cheered by most citizens but the corporate aristocracy got spooked big-time. Never again, they swore. By 1979, we had a national PR effort by the electronic media to end the Jimmy Carter administration and usher in the age of Ronald Reagan and the neocons. It's too hard to say just now if this era has ended with the Obama presidency. There are progressive factions among the financial class but the forces of reaction are still quite formidable. Much like the Valkyrie movie depiction of the plot against Hitler in 1944, a disgruntled faction might emerge to depose the decadent but it's too hard to know right now if they can succeed.

I can definitely say NUMMI

I can definitely say NUMMI built good cars. Our 1998 Corolla built there now has 177,000 trouble free miles on it. My thanks to the folks there for designing and building this fine vehicle. The costs and work ethic at Nummi probably doomed this plant due in part to it's California location. UAW plants also typically have very high absenteeism and many non work related diversions. This is my view as a retired engineer with experience in the automotive supply chain. This closure was avoidable!

Why is this plant not "too

Why is this plant not "too big too fail. No one, no corporation, no monopoly is too big to fail. When will we get it through to our government that we need to BREAK UP the GIANTS that we allowed to take over our economy, not coddle them. I am so depressed by this kind of nonsense. We need to BREAK THEM up into manageable companies, expect REASONABLE compensation for everyone from the CEO on down to the sweepers. It worked for ATT. Ma Bell made a bunch of baby bells, which grew ans merged and prospered. Time to do it again! If we want working people to be the backbone of this country, then they should be paid, respected, and secure.

This story does a good job

This story does a good job at illustrating the ripple effects that happen when large manufacturing plants are closed. Yes, it is devastating to the 30,000 people who rely on this plant directly or the 100,000 indirectly,I don't want to discount that, however one thing this article doesn't mention are the numerous closings and cutbacks occurring in Michigan and throughout the midwest. There are 5.4 million people living in the Detroit Metro area and ALL OF THEM are directly or indirectly affected by the closure or cutbacks at manufacturing plants owned by the big 3 as well as layoffs and cutbacks in the engineering, design, advertising and administrative jobs at the big 3. There are also comparable cutbacks at parts suppliers throughout the Midwest and across the country. One thing that I don't hear talked about is that most of the higher paying engineering and design jobs at foreign car companies are done in the country where the headquarters are located. Yes, Toyota, Honda and other foreign car companies have manufacturing plants in the US but where does the bulk of the companies payroll get cashed and spent? In their own countries.. One step we can take as Americans is to BUY AMERICAN CARS!! There is a HUGE awakening happening about buying local produce and food (I know you've heard "buy local, think global"). However I am yet to hear that same statement or comparison made in regards to buying local American made automobiles that keep more money circulating in the US economy where our very economic survival depends on it!!

MISSING THE POINT What we

MISSING THE POINT What we are witnessing is the end of the cheap-credit fueled consumer economy. No amount of stimulus can restart it, and in fact it is psychologically dead in the water as well. People are beginning to realize that the boom era was great while it lasted, but now it is over. Plant closings of all sorts are occurring daily as the old borrow-and-spend economy gives way to a new and still undefined form of economic transaction.

For further reading: Two

For further reading: Two books, "Wealth of Nations," Book II Chapter 3 on 'Productive v. Non-productive Labor and Capital,' and "Economic Crisis and Crisis Theory" by Paul Mattick, which is available online by searching for the author...t

I can't bear another

I can't bear another heartbreaking story about jobs lost. We're on a steep slide and it is too late now for a 'rescue'. This job-loss avalanche is beyond checking, and what we are headed for is grim. I wish Obama appeared to realize this. I wish he'd drop the doomed health care fight and redirect all money that the country can fabricate into green jobs, any jobs. Banks & Wall Street don't seem to understand that the time they will be throwing themselves off the roofs of the skyscrapers in New York is imminent. Or will that simply be the middle class? Even the naive news organizations don't seem to get it.

I am really surprised. I

I am really surprised. I thought bailing out auto companies was about keeping jobs.