Truthout Original

Facebook DIGG

Welcome to Gilead, Governor Palin

by: Cynthia Boaz, t r u t h o u t | Perspective

photo
In Margaret Atwood's dystopian novel, "The Handmaid's Tale," women are confined to a few, limited, gender-based tasks. They are kept in submission by the "Aunts," who reassure them that their subjugation is right. The "Aunts," according to Cynthia Boaz, have a whole lot in common with Sarah Palin. (Photo: Spencer Platt / Getty Images)

    If you've ever read Margaret Atwood's dystopian novel, "The Handmaid's Tale," you will recall the key role that was played by the women assigned to be the "Aunts." The story revolves around a futuristic American society in which fundamentalist Christians install a gender-based caste system where each woman is assigned a specific societal function. It is a commentary on the dangerous erasing of the line between church and state in the contemporary United States. The merging of religion and government is carried out by a group of older, white male "commanders" whose propaganda demands that citizens be constantly terrorized into submission and obedience. The resulting regime is Atwood's vision of the worst-case scenario: an American police-state theocracy where every woman's identity is reduced to her sexual attributes, and each is assigned to a category based on her physical qualifications. Subtle references to racist philosophy are mixed into the literalist religious rhetoric.

    The attractive young women of reproductive age are the "handmaids"; the attractive but infertile middle-age women are the "wives"; the dark-skinned women of any age are domestic servants, and so on. All women are forbidden from reading or writing. The country is renamed the Republic of Gilead, a reference to the biblical homeland of the patriarchs. And the Aunts - who are middle-aged white women of some previous prestige and education - are especially sinister characters. The primary job of the Aunts is to keep the handmaids (the childbearers) subservient. They go about this by convincing the handmaids that they are powerless and can only contribute to society when they fulfill their God-given responsibility to serve the commanders. The Aunts' job, put simply, is to exploit other women by keeping them submissive and telling them that it's for the good of all (and even more insidiously, that in obeying, the handmaids "empower" themselves.) What makes the Aunts so remarkable is their collective failure to realize that they are simply being used by the commanders to keep other women in line, and their willingness - glee, even - at doing so is simultaneously sad and terrifying. So what compels the Aunts to become traitors to both their sex and their country? First, they believe that their contribution to the repressive social order is righteous, and second, they've found that under this rigid system of social control, they have the illusion of a tiny bit of power.

    Does any of this sound familiar? It should. Governor and Republican VP candidate Sarah Palin is the Gileadian "Aunt" manifested. Her sudden emergence onto the American political scene, accompanied by a burst of enthusiasm on the part of many American women, is a surreal example of life imitating art. Much of Palin's rhetoric, tactics and personal philosophy seem to be taken directly from the Auntie training manual. By accepting the position on the GOP ticket despite her astonishing lack of qualifications, Palin signaled that she was prepared to be used - on the basis of her sex alone - in exchange for the promise of status and power. Refer to Palin's RNC convention speech, which was mostly a fawning homage to McCain's patriotism and leadership, sprinkled with condescending references to Obama as "our opponent." Although the lines were delivered with Palin's own folksy vernacular and over-enunciation, it was not Palin, but McCain - or more accurately, the GOP elders at whose feet he finds himself on election eve - who wrote the speech and whose voice echoed through the hall that night in St. Paul. Women who find themselves drawn to Palin because they think she epitomizes the classic "woman who has it all" might want to take a closer look. Sarah Palin was picked for the ticket solely because of - not despite - the fact that she is female. By keeping her sequestered from the media, McCain has confirmed he does not have faith in an unscripted Palin's ability to represent the campaign to the world. By going along with it, Palin is telling us that she's perfectly fine with being controlled by her male superiors. And by portraying herself as the candidate of the empowered woman (while simultaneously promoting policy that is openly hostile to the interests of working and middle-class American women), she reveals the sad truth about how little progress we've actually made.

    Lest we think that Senator McCain is hesitant to keep pushing this stereotype in the face of abysmal performances by Palin in news interviews, the most recent reports reveal that his campaign intends to hype the expected wedding between Palin's pregnant daughter and her boyfriend, the date of which is apparently being set just prior to the November election - with McCain and Palin sitting in the front row. Is it possible that Sarah Palin is just blissfully un-self-aware, or is it that she so eager for any illusion of power that she'll allow herself to be marketed no matter what the cost to the dignity of all women? If Palin were truly an empowered woman, she would have refused to allow herself and her daughter to be used in this manner - to assist a party whose rhetoric and imagery promote the ideal woman as deferential to established norms rather than acting as an independent - or critical - thinker. If her selection was intended to signal to American women that empowerment is possible, why is Palin being kept under lock and key? Clearly, this is not an individual whose intelligence or perspective McCain respects, or else he would permit her to speak for herself. To continue pretending that Palin's selection was anything other than an attempt to manipulate the voting public on the basis of a straitjacketed view of sexual roles is a dangerous lie that no American of any gender can afford to abide.

    --------

    Cynthia Boaz is assistant professor of political science at Sonoma State University.

»


Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live. Be civil and on-topic, don't threaten or advocate violence, please keep it under 300 words. Thanks for participating.

As a woman Palin would never

As a woman Palin would never get my vote. My God she makes Quayle look like a genius.

Thank you for the truth! If

Thank you for the truth! If John & Abigail Adams were with us today..I can imagine what her letters to John might say!!!! I think the Palin deal is an insult to all REAL WOMEN!!

A fine analogy but I doubt

A fine analogy but I doubt Mrs. Palin is cognizant of her duality. Surely she sees herself as master of her own ship as reinforced by her political wins. She would not have the introspection nor the qualms to 'rock the boat'.

Thank you Cynthia Boaz! As

Thank you Cynthia Boaz! As an American man who is sickened by the role of gender in this campaign(and all previous campaigns) I am heartened to hear your views. I have read the Handmaid's Tale and was deeply affected by it. The comparison drawn here seems extraordinarily apt.

If it weren't so scary it

If it weren't so scary it would be pathetic.

I read the book "The

I read the book "The Handmaid's Tale" about 15 years ago. The prophecy of a right wing, christian take-over was horrifying. I am glad that someone else sees the parallel with Palin. This is an excellent article that expresses the harm done to all women (and all people) by Sarah Palin by accepting to be used by the good old boys whom she was supposed to tame. How easily they wrapped her up; she doesn't even know what happened yet. If they win, she will make an excellent rubber stamper for the good old boys. Again, the analogy with the aunts of the book is uncanny.

Rather Harsh, but couldn't

Rather Harsh, but couldn't be truer. I quite dislike "The Handmaid's Tale" - but cannot help feeling the analogy is apt.

Excellent analysis of a

Excellent analysis of a serious problem in our political system - the repeated use of stereotypes to manipulate public opinion. Cynthia Boaz has identified a key issue - thanks for the insights!

I'll bet she never thought

I'll bet she never thought of it that way. For one, she'd have to have actually read some books that didn't include a Jesus Stamp (tm).

She somehow has a "role" to

She somehow has a "role" to play. Is she an auntie in Gilead or rather the witch in C.S. Lewis's The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe"? Were she really a woman of ethical standards, she would keep her children out of the public eye, and she would respect other women and strive to be an advocate for them. With grave concerns for our democracy, I cannot respect her in any way, as being intelligent, ethical, or as an asset to our country. Rather I see her as vacuous, vicious, and at the least, an embarrassment to the nation.

"Identity politics" is

"Identity politics" is disempowering for everyone (including those in whose name "identity politics" is pursued) other than those who promote it as a vehicle for mere SELF-empowerment. The career generals never really care about those they would reduce to cannon fodder.

My wife immediately snagged

My wife immediately snagged a copy of "Handmaid's Tale" in reaction to the nomination -- this is a good time to re-read it. Visit your local book store.

Next time the Republican

Next time the Republican Palin-face candidate for VP shows up in SNL, it would be rather appropriate, I suppose -- as a telling metaphor -- to have her dressed in a two-thousand-dollar designer burka.

She's capable of anything.

She's capable of anything. Her birthday is a day from Lincoln, Quayle, and Edison. She's very masculine in her pursuits. She knows how to win. That is the troubling aspect of her. Just look where she is now...

Great analogy. Time to

Great analogy. Time to bring back that hymn "There is a Bomb in Gilead." Or was that 'Balm?'

A scary and very astute

A scary and very astute observation and thoughtful report!

The Palin Ploy is certainly

The Palin Ploy is certainly an affront to the nation, but is even more an affront to women. Sisters, we should storm the polling places and vote to let McCain and his college of cynics know that we're neither flattered nor fooled!

I started a blog on women's

I started a blog on women's issues in 2004. It's inspired by The Handmaid's Tale - handmaidstale.blogspot.com - and most recently Palin's terrifying rise has been one of its main themes. I'm doing what I can to prevent that dystopia from becoming a reality!

Everybody knows what a

Everybody knows what a "palindrome" is, right? For example the sentence "Madam I'm Adam" is one because it reads the same forwards and backwards. Comes from the Greek words "palin" or backwards and "dromos" a road, way or path. So obviously we are being signalled symbolically by the governor's very name that, if we elect her, we are taking a giant step backwards.

Sept. 30, I will never

Sept. 30, I will never forget the horror I felt reading Atwood's book almost 20 years ago. Now we have Palin being presented as perfection in womanhood. May our nation survive this offense to all women. Carole

Isn't "The Handmaid's Tale"

Isn't "The Handmaid's Tale" one of the books that Palin tried to have banned?

Au contraire, the thought

Au contraire, the thought that Sarah Palin is "masculine in her pursuits" is not the case as the pursuit of fame, money, influence, power, et al. is genderless. Nor is cynical disdain for any "other" limited to a specific group. What is remarkable is that such breathtaking narrow mindedness and poverty of intellect has been coupled with such a ruthless determination to dominate this country. That is a frightening scenario...surreal...but we are awake! To the barricades!

Palin thought the 700

Palin thought the 700 billion bailout was a " jobs creation program ". The best summary was that she sounded like a freshman in college who didnt read the material. What will happen if McCain wins and then kicks the bucket ! Scary thought...

Fine essay Cynthia and good

Fine essay Cynthia and good eye for the parallels. The very existence of the McCain/Palin ticket should be humiliating to all Americans, male or female. And yet the polls remain close. No one has been able to explain that to my satisfaction.

Ms Boaz could have used just

Ms Boaz could have used just a little deeper understanding of religious history, The Handmaid's Tale", and Sarah palin's Church. The parallels she writes of are not parallels at all, they are corollaries, substantially branches of a single tree. The Handmaids Tale is not a work of fantasy, it is an imaginative extension of personal experience with a particular variety of religious experience and belief into a dark future. That extension separated the book from the controvesy it would have met had it named names (and denominations) at the time it was written, and gained it a specialized audience of people who were prepared to imagine things that, had they been presented as fact, would have been unimaginable - though they were. Palin, her family, her church, come directly from that very religious tradition, system of belief, and religious experience. So the first issue is in treating the correspondence as if it were an accidental parallel, rather than a historically rooted correspondence. The second is to misinterpret the attitude of sumissionin the novel, and in Palin as "prepared to be used - on the basis of her sex alone - in exchange for the promise of status and power." That is too simple, it misses the point of Dominionist Pentecostal belief - that the woman, as men (reread Tom DeLay), "prepared to be used by God" in furtherance of the coming of the Dominion of God, in which those "used" assume total domion in the name of God. So "in exchange for status and power" is factually correct, but does not quite fully communicate the amount and character of the status and power the person "used" has a "God Given" right to exercise... Sarah has fully internalized this doctrine; the personal power people sense in her flows directly from a delusional psychosis induced since childhood and fully supported by her life experience, family, and religious community.

As someone (Gloria Steinem I

As someone (Gloria Steinem I think) said recently - the only thing we have in common is a chromosome. (I'm female. The similarity ends right there). I'm putting The Handmaid's Tale on hold at my local library now. Can't wait to see the VP "debate" on Thursday too. I'm sure Biden will do well even without trying. Pay special attention to how many times she uses the same vacuous scripted phrases over and over again, rather like a Stepford wife. (She's being coached now).

Have you seen her interviews

Have you seen her interviews with Katie Couric on uTube? Katie is noticeably wincing and trying not to throw any punches as Sarah skirts each question, it's pathetic, really awful. I guess she got out of her chains for that interview. You can hear how canned the answers are. We must prevent this election from being stolen! Great article by Cynthia Boaz.

Jim P- This article is for

Jim P- This article is for a general (albeit mostly progressive) audience, not for a theology journal. Way to nitpick! The point is still very valid. Ellie R.

Bravo, Cynthia Boaz! You

Bravo, Cynthia Boaz! You got it so right. It never hit me until now why Palin gives me the chilly shivers. She IS the Auntie! Brilliant article!

Such fun reading this. So

Such fun reading this. So perceptive and seemingly on target. Will Thursday morning's big news be Palin dropout?

Ah. This explains why I

Ah. This explains why I resent her so. Good job!

I'm glad to see I'm not

I'm glad to see I'm not the only one who cottoned to the idea that this was a scene right out of the book! Chilling novel, equally chilling movie. American women aren't the only ones who note this use of women by male powers. Read Rasna Warah's article in Daily Nation, Kenya. ..."Women like Palin Ensure that Men Remain on Top." http://www.nation.co.ke/oped/Opinion/-/440808/475516/-/3lv1jp/-/ Even third world women can see the way Palin's being used by the cynics in the McCain/GOP campaign to further their goals. Women's rights, our ideas, our needs, our point of view isn't really what they're interested in. They want to blur the edges of reality so that women voters are blind to their agenda, their past failures, their cynical 'mismanagement' of the world we live in. If the Grover Norquists of the world get their way and they shrink our nation's government into extinction, where will we turn for security? Where will we turn for community? Where will we turn for a collective ideal called democracy? Of course, even the men have been blinded by Palin's image. Funny how some McCain/Palin male supporters have tried to cast Obama as the anti-Christ. Wouldn't our governor be a better under-the-radar candidate for the old harridan? From the mountain top in Palmer, Alaska.

Many thanks for the

Many thanks for the reminders about "The Handmaid's Tale," which still has its space on my bookshelf. I will have to reread it in a new light. I dismissed Sarah Palin as stupid -- now I realize that SHE is sinister, not only the "operators" who arranged her nomination. I'm sure her inanities are the best she can offer, but her role in the Republican "base" manipulations is something else. Meanwhile, she is the antithesis of the contemporary professional/executive woman -- the deliberate anti-Hillary, selected with malice and placed on the slate in a conspiracy.

I purchased The Handmaid's

I purchased The Handmaid's Tale (1st Edition) a few months ago, and when I heard Palin was McCain's pick I read it straight through the night and have been convinced her religion preaches the precepts held in that novel. The intellectual interpretations of this Novel have been long debated and are dense as suggested above, but there is no doubt that Palin is AuntieOne in our world, very very frightening that we've come this far as women to suddenly be thrown back into the dark ages.

I am looking forward to the

I am looking forward to the debate on Thursday. I hope there will be someone checking Palin for wires and a listening device in her ear (remember the debate where it appeared Bush had a device under his suit jacket). Palin is a disgrace and a slap in the face to women who have worked so hard to overcome obstacles in our male dominated world.

Did we all miss the last

Did we all miss the last paragraph? Her poor daughter has to endure being flaunted for all to see?! Pregnant and getting married at such a tender age is hard enough without having an overbearing mother forcing her to parade for the entire world to watch! Anyone who has had this type of wedding in their family or a friend knows full well the risk of divorce is very high. These kids, who are starting a family so very young, have enough pressure without this happening. Can anyone here imagine having Sarah Palin as a mother, let alone a mother-in-law?!!! Without the public exposure, this marriage is already doomed to failure. So sad.

We see life badly imitate

We see life badly imitate art? Given her right wing leanings, if she were to be elected with McSmae and, if McSame would give out physically, we would have the exact type of Fascist response in our leadership from a President Palin. at in the Republic of New Gilead. This mirrors a conversation so closely of yesterday, I am both surprised, and truly pleased that someone has articulated this parallel so well. As Spencer Simrill, Dean at St Mark's Cathedral said in his first Easter Sermon "Brothers and Sister, what do we have to fear, this Easter Day?" Unfortunately, we Christians do not always "get it"! We think that evil does have or can have dominion over the world, when the truth of the matter is that love will conquer all fears if we put our faith in love rather than our fears -real or imagined. In this case, we see our fears driving the promotion of an apocalyptically based zealot candidate as a "would be savior" of moral values: this is very very scary. We can not let our fears of this endgame vision drive our politics. Peace and Agape,

"Country first", McCain?

"Country first", McCain? Yeah, if that country is Gilead!

This is about another 4 or 8

This is about another 4 or 8 years of the horrible last 8 + years. The neocons and republicans are NOT going to just give up with out a fight which will be and is using a lot of devious and nefarious methods to keep the presidency, from rigged voting machines, all the way to having another woman, a white one, in the race where there are high possibilities of her becoming president. Getting another woman to replace hillary gives the women someone to vote for instead of a black man, heavens forbid. I didn't realize that the shotgun wedding was going to take place, much less before the elections. Neocons will stoop to any such tricks at other human's expense to further their agendas. I didn't see in this post when but I would suspect that it will be on the Saturday before the elections for maximum effect. Where oh where did this country deserve this? Another thought, I wonder about the 'first dude's' part now in all this. I saw where he may have talked to ms. sarah about her interviews with couric and am curious what was discussed. And is he the arm twister that is making mr. independent-I-got-her-pregnant-but-she-didn't-complain show up and go through with this extravaganza? And last, I wonder who will divorce who if the election is not won or after the term(s) are over, dude dis sarah or sarah dis dude. And how long will little rebecca of sunny brook preggers last before she divorces?

"Anyone who has had this

"Anyone who has had this type of wedding in their family or a friend knows full well the risk of divorce is very high", especially to a boy who has publicly declared, via social networking sites, that he is not interested in marriage or children- a shotgun wedding indeed. How hypocritical- for Palin to support abstinence only sex education programs, when she couldn't get it to work in her own family- and then turn it into a lesson in "family values". There is a serious disconnect in reasoning here, that her supporters fail to see for some reason. That they don't see it scares the he!! out of me-that and the possibility that this person could be our next president.

America is filled with

America is filled with smart, successful women - so why aren't they screaming bloody murder right about now? Why so silent? ..........Pentecostal wives and daughters must be governed with a heavy hand to avoid the feminine pit of rebellion. Man’s obligation is to teach women obedience, love, honor God and love their husbands... A Pentecostal wife must address her husband as lord or "boss" and be subject to him until his death. He is to make all major decisions in the marriage partnership including limiting the wife’s credit... It is the woman's full time job to teach and care for her children and satisfy her husband sexually...

As anonymous says in the

As anonymous says in the 23:28 posting, there are also parallels to CS Lewis' story. . . the most important of which is NOT the White Witch in The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe, but rather the introduction of Queen Jardis of Charn (who later becomes the White Witch) in the prequel The Magician's Nephew. The Magician's Nephew seems to lay out the entire scenario now unfolding and the minute Sarah ascended the national stage I thought of Queen Jardis of Charn. I encourage everyone to read this short and compelling book, the scene where Jardis takes on London is worth the cost of the entire book and very reminiscent of Ms Sarah's style . . .

I hope someone can sneakily

I hope someone can sneakily run a metal detector/bug sniffer around that big ol' beehive 'do before the debate.

Isn't Gilead the name of the

Isn't Gilead the name of the biotech startup Rumsfeld sold for millions. just before he joined Bush's cabinet? It's amazing how all this nightmare stuff is interconnected. The above reference to Hieronymous Bosch is also very apt.

no most women do not support

no most women do not support Palin, a woman against women's rights, well the bimbos might fall for her. Natl Org of Women endorses Obama because Obama supports women's rights. I'm voting overseas ballot, sending it in by Fedex-- no way will I miss voting for Obama/Biden & against McCain/Palin--I've got my women's rights to think about, along with alternative energy, world peace, free health care, free education, free & enlightened society, transparency in govt & banking, and a future for the world without global warming!

"Shotgun wedding"?

"Shotgun wedding"? Naaaaaah...I'd look for Palin's daughter to suffer a "tragic miscarriage" some time shortly after the election, and her boyfriend to be whisked away to some sort of well-paid-for life of obscurity. One almost universal characteristic of the right-wing leadership is an apparently limitless capacity for hypocrisy.

Immediately after having

Immediately after having watched Sarah Palin's speech on the last night of the Republican convention, I turned off the TV feeling shocked and sickened. I then recalled having read Margaret Atwood's "The Handmaid's Tale" when it was first published. I was shocked and sickened then, too, but comforted by the thought that never in America... I was a naive idealist then. I am naive no longer. I think that what is happening and has been happening ever since the Republicans abandoned their principles to embrace the far right is terrifying. "The Handmaid's Tale" should be mandatory reading for every woman of voting age in America. Right now!

Thank you Cynthia Boaz for

Thank you Cynthia Boaz for your excellent essay re THE HANDMAIDEN'S TALE and Sarah Palain. I must reread the novel. It was scary when first I read it. It will be horrifying to read it with Palin in mind. I am amazed at how people can listen to her stumble in the interviews and still think she is qualified to be VP and possibly president. I want to state my agreement with l the responses printed. I see no redeeming virtues in her nomination for VP or in her as a human being. If Palin comes to power in this country, I can only weep for all women alive and all unborn female children in the future. The Women's Movement will be set back to the dark ages.

I read The Handmaid's Tale

I read The Handmaid's Tale about 18 years ago. I could not put it down all night, slept for about an hour, and then started to reread it again at 8AM. It filled me with horror! I quickly saw her, the stealth candidate, as the door for the powerful leaders of the Far Right to a Theocratic America, as Theocratic as a Fundamentalist Islamic state,and the long time goal of her religion. I am being told by people in my mainstream church that that would never happen. Their eyes are not open. I do not believe they have read this book!

and I couldn't agree more.

and I couldn't agree more. I will never understand how someone so completely out of her league could be so power hungry that she is blind to the fact that she has been used.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.