News

Bailout Vote Underscores US Leadership Crisis

»

by: Steven Thomma, McClatchy Newspapers

photo
The bailout deadlock demonstrates that no definitive leadership exists in Washington - least of all in the White House. (Photo: Ezra Shaw / Getty Images AsiaPac)

    Columbus, Ohio - The failure of a proposed Wall Street bailout Monday underscored that America is suffering not just from a financial crisis, but also from a crisis of political leadership.

    "This has been a bad day for Washington and a bad day for American politics," said Harold Ford, a former Democratic congressman from Tennessee. "What happened today was an embarrassment for the country."

    None of the country's political leaders, Republican or Democrat, has proved able to navigate the treacherous politics of the moment and secure an agreement to bail out the country's financial system and restore confidence in the marketplace.

    President Bush is a largely discredited lame duck. He's not trusted by his own party and was unable to bend the Congress to his will even as he warned of a catastrophe if lawmakers rebelled.

    Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama and his party's congressional leaders control the Congress and agreed with Bush's urgency, but they couldn't deliver a majority, either.

    Still, they came closer than did Republican John McCain and his party's leaders in the House of Representatives, who delivered only 30 percent of the GOP votes for the compromise, while Democrats delivered some 60 percent of their members.

    Leaders of both parties vowed to seek bipartisan cooperation toward drafting a compromise that could pass, but with their own elections five weeks away, they couldn't stop themselves from partisan attacks, which make the goal of bipartisan agreement even more difficult to reach.

    Nowhere is the crisis more evident than it is in the White House.

    Bush limps toward the end of his second term with among the lowest job-approval ratings in history - a recent Gallup poll found just 27 percent approving and 69 percent disapproving.

    Worse, he's lost credibility in Congress, notably for leading the country into war in Iraq on false claims that Iraq had ties to al Qaida and weapons of mass destruction. When he dispatched Vice President Dick Cheney to lobby House Republicans to support the Wall Street bailout, the closed-door session grew heated, and some members reportedly reminded Cheney that they'd trusted him on Iraq.

    Bush also is paying a price for years of strong-arming Congress, particularly when he counted on then-House Majority Leader Tom DeLay, R-Texas, to "hammer" proposals such as a costly expansion of Medicare past skeptical conservatives.

    "There's no question the rank-and-file are carrying some grudges from the past," said Dan Schnur, the director of the Unruh Institute of Politics at the University of Southern California.

    Democrats, who won control of both the House and Senate in 2006, also couldn't deliver. Congress's approval rating is even lower than Bush's, at around 18 percent.

    When Obama, the party's new leader, learned of the plan's rejection, he spoke about Washington almost as if he weren't a member of Congress.

    "Democrats and Republicans in Washington have a responsibility to make sure that an emergency rescue package is put forward that can at least stop the immediate problems we have so we can begin to plan for the future," he said.

    He didn't say how he might lead or what role he'd play. "Step up to the plate," he told Congress. "Get it done."

    His party's leaders in Congress also threw up their hands, as House Speaker Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and others bragged that they'd delivered a majority of the Democratic votes, even though that wasn't enough.

    "The Democratic side more than lived up to its side of the bargain," Pelosi said, lauding fellow Democratic leaders for "getting 60 percent of the House Democrats to support a bill which isn't our bill."

    Republican leaders in Congress were powerless as well to deliver the votes they'd promised, saying that they lost about 12 committed votes when some of their members got mad at Pelosi.

    "We could have gotten there today had it not been for this partisan speech that the speaker gave on the floor of the House," said House Republican Leader Rep. John Boehner, R-Ohio.

    McCain appeared as impotent as everyone else. He'd suspended his campaign briefly last week to rally support for the plan, and spent part of Saturday lobbying House Republicans by phone, but he couldn't deliver, either.

»


IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 U.S.C. SECTION 107, THIS MATERIAL IS DISTRIBUTED WITHOUT PROFIT TO THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED A PRIOR INTEREST IN RECEIVING THE INCLUDED INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES. TRUTHOUT HAS NO AFFILIATION WHATSOEVER WITH THE ORIGINATOR OF THIS ARTICLE NOR IS TRUTHOUT ENDORSED OR SPONSORED BY THE ORIGINATOR.

"VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS ARE PROVIDED AS A CONVENIENCE TO OUR READERS AND ALLOW FOR VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY. HOWEVER, AS ORIGINATING PAGES ARE OFTEN UPDATED BY THEIR ORIGINATING HOST SITES, THE VERSIONS POSTED ON TO MAY NOT MATCH THE VERSIONS OUR READERS VIEW WHEN CLICKING THE "VIEW SOURCE ARTICLE" LINKS.

Comments

This is a moderated forum.  It may take a little while for comments to go live.

The math doesn't add up.

The math doesn't add up. Howd-hee do it? By pushing the Republican anti-Constitutional and anti law thugs to become even bigger thugs, on-going felons, slacks, wastels and neredowells, At the worst moment in this crisis of power and upfront money laundering and during the bail out negotiations - did anyone notice that the Pentagon received 60 billion dollars from the Senate for the illegal war in Iraq and the cover up in Afghanistan? - not to mention the earmarks, more millions, and the fact that the military elite get a pay raise while the rest of us might loose our shirts? Add to that the millions, if not trillions which unmonitored independent mercenary contractors like Erik Prince of Blackwater also got "theirs" with the apparent ease in which this bill was passed and right under our bail out noses. While most americans were discussing this "bail-out" , the chrome glasses and weirdness of Palin,the winner of the debate and other such nonsense, we were robbed again by the bible, gun, flag, patriots, babies, social nationalists aka the neo- mercantile capitalists and their "company" shadow government have hidden away 2-3 trillion in missing funds from the Pentagon, trillions upon trillions were awarded to the Bush "company", his entire family - all their friends - especially the mad cow brained Enron Cheney and made their privatized cronyism and put all their and our money into the pocket of Rockefellar and the Chase Manhattan Bank who spread out like a cancer to 27 states in their kapo bravado efforts to force us all do to business with them. Some democracy! The Pentagon is a whirlwind arm of the secret services of bankers, always has been. But when a nation is unwilling to share in the profits WE made for this nation, we see everything crumble so their campaign to force democracy down the throats of all has only lead to tyranny and oppression. The Pentagon is who should be put on notice here. They consume the vast dollars of all Americans who are more than willing to allow for this so that we can feel comfortable, brain dead, and well fed citizens. It is the mandate of the Congress to oversee this military spending gone nuts and everyone - allowed this to happen without oversight.

the constituents you refer

the constituents you refer to are moronic, more interested in 'Dancing with the stars" than monetary policy. Then there is talk radio spouting one falsehood after another, No I would respect leadership over pandering any day. It is a REPUBLIC after all.

EVERY member of the House is

EVERY member of the House is up for re-election, so they damn well better listen to their constituents. No seat is "safe" this year. Even the Speaker can't count on re-election from the politically savvy and charged-up voters of SF. I can imagine the e-mails and calls that are expressing outrage at the Paulson Plot: "I can't pay my electric bill/fill my gas tank/take my kids to the dentist, and you want to give $700 billion to the incompetents who made all those bad investments?" There is no leadership. Maybe in January, but not now.

I read this title heading

I read this title heading and thought it a strange heading for a Truthout article. You mean, we have witnessed leadership somewhere? The reps who have read the bill, yes, a few have, the rest of the wimps in DC really do need take heed. Congress might be Republican again. This bill is just a giveaway. I say we demand a line by line account of just where all this money is going. LET IT DIE, AMEN.

The Senate is schedule to

The Senate is schedule to conduct a vote on the bailout legislation tomorrow. If you harbor strong sentiments concerning the Paulson Plan, I suggest notifying your representative and expressing your position prior to the vote.

Lack of leadership, yes.

Lack of leadership, yes. Maybe we can come up with a better plan...but the fact remains the majority of Democrats sucked in their guts and supported this Republican proposal, despite the fact that it was Republican-style lax regulations and oversight that was a key factor in the meltdown...and the majority of Republicans dumped on their President, their Treasury officials, and their Congressional leaders leading to the 777 drop on Wall Street. The problem remains and the even more important job of freeing and rebuilding confidence in the credit systems looms.

Everyone in Congress needs

Everyone in Congress needs to read "The Shock Doctrine" by Naomi Kleine. We have created financial crises all over the world time after time in order to do to their governments what is being done today to ours. Some examples - Chile/Pinochet - Argentina - several Eastern European countries - Indonesia/Suharto The exact same methods are being used here to shift the ownership of private property and individuals savings and financial resources (401K - Retirement funds etc) to the Corporatocracy. Read the book and be glad for the delay in the bailout

It is obvious that the

It is obvious that the writer does not understand the situation. This is typical of all the big party leaders on both sides of the aisle. " .. a bad day for American politics," and "... an embarrassment for the country." EXCUSE ME! The voice of the citizens was being heard by enough true representatives, to get past the greed of the leadership. This is a victory for the American People. The Bail out is the wrong way to handle it. When a business is run poorly, it should wither and go out of business. We the People do not need to subsidize poor management or greed. With out the bail out, YES it will be difficult, very difficult, however the American Can Do attitude will prevail, and the economy will eventually turn around with less pain and suffering, and in less time than with all the bail out money which we do not have. We have to borrow it and it will burden our children, grandchildren and great grandchildren. When all the dust settles, with NO Bailout, we will have weeded out the bad businesses and the strong will have survived. Our lessen to prevent this in the future is to not let the Federal Reserve have control. They caused the "Great Depression" and were a Key problem in this financial crises. Get the Dollar back on a firm basis, ie the Gold Standard. Remove all subsidies and controls on the market and let Free Markets exist again after being manipulated and controled by government for over 100 years. We can be The Republic again as invisioned by our Founding Fathers.

Why is everyone commenting

Why is everyone commenting as if there were only one possible Bailout plan? Part of the problem is that it's a lousy plan that gives little reason to believe will serve any other purpose than to enrich Wall St. It certainly offers nothing to guarantee any of the claims--including improving liquidity. The original 3-page Paulson proposal from which it grew is absolutely shocking and makes one doubt his sanity--grant him total authority, without oversight, free from legal ramifications on a $700 billion revolving account, just because he wants it???!! If anything does need to be done, how about a trickle-up/debt-rehab approach? Something like this: Issue every family a $2000/person voucher which must be used in one of the following ways, in this order. (If you can’t use if for #1, apply it to #2, etc.): 1) Apply it toward home mortgage principal. Aside from voiding pre-payment penalties, it wouldn’t change the original contract. It would improve everyone’s equity picture and put money directly in the hands of lenders (not hedge funds!). For those who need it, it would greatly expand refinancing options. That should slow foreclosures and damp the decline of housing prices. At worst, it would reduce lender losses on foreclosures. 2) Pay off credit-card balances more than, say, 90 days old and require card-holders’ limits be reduced by the same amount. 3) Pay off student loans. 4) Pay off auto and other loans. 5) If you have been prudent and have no debts, use it to buy a long-term CD (5 years maybe?). That would improve bank reserves and allow more lending, while giving prudent spenders something to look forward to. This should improve everyone’s financial picture and provide money--directly--for lending. If some of it should trickle up to derivative holders, more power to them. If not, all the better!

the quicker the cowboy

the quicker the cowboy leaves the building the better

Oh no! The "rank and file"

Oh no! The "rank and file" paid attention to what their constituents wanted instead of doing what they were told...how dare they!!!

Financial Scam!Watch Dennis

Financial Scam!Watch Dennis Kucinch on the Monday DemocracyNow show. He tells the truth. The bailout is a rip-off. There are plenty of other ways to fix the economy. Besides which, the economy is based on relentless human population/consumption growth. It's destroying the earth. It's time to realize that raw capitalism is a death machine. Why bail it out? Let it die. Americans are too rich, spoiled, obsese and materialist. Time to change the whole system, not spend billions of hastily-printed dollars to bandaid it. And the Democrats siding with Bush...that shows you we have an oligarchy. Pelosi is a sell-out, as is Reid. Watch the movie www.zeitgeistmovie.com. They tell you the real story about the bankers and their allies.